Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treated like an alcoholic by midwife?

736 replies

MyMabel · 14/08/2021 17:45

Anyone else been in this situation?

Ok our telephone consultation appointment I was asked how much I drink prior to finding out I was pregnant - I said (honestly) I had about one or two gins every night, the occasion glass or two of wine instead. Couldn’t tell them in units as I have no idea.

I was never drunk, never drank until DP was home as we have a toddler DD so wanted to make sure if anything happened one of us can drive, plus I wouldn’t drink while solely responsible for her. - again, never drunk or even dizzy. Just a glass or two while watching telly before bed. I suppose with COVID and all I was just bored?

Anyway, was asked if I drank since finding out- said no, because I haven’t.

Come to my face to face appointment; Midwife explains that due to my alcohol intake before being pregnant I’ve been referred to speak to someone. I was in a bit of shock to ask questions and just said ok. But after I left I felt mortally embarrassed and now a bit worried they think I’ve got a drinking problem?!

Maybe I’m not BU in the sense that they could perhaps help someone who struggled with alcohol by doing this routinely.. but AIBU to think I really don’t need to speak to someone regarding what I drank in the evenings?

Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 06/12/2021 22:34

im talking 09 here but i had the opposite i was called a liar when i said im teetotal.

the same appointment we had an almighty row over something else that caused her to be suspended for unprofessional behaviour.

i was 29 at the time and he was my 2nd baby he was also a fertility treatment baby(if it makes a difference)i was on 4 years of clomid tablets to even get pregnant

at my first appointment all the usual questions asked and alcohol intake came up and i said zero when asked. she replied yeah yeah no
bullshit now how much?
me being me(i am my user name and more)i got really abrupt and said bloody zero im telling you ive been teetotal my whole life. who do you think your swearing at?

she put zero with a question mark next to it

goes then to last period.my reply never

her reply dont dick me about now miss*** when did you last see?

i blew at this point and said loudly and abruptly
"listen here you unprofessional bitch if you were competent enough to check any bloody files you could see i have severe pcos and never ever seen a period(still haven't and im 41) this baby was 4 years of the strongest strength clomid tablet that this bloody practice was prescribing ,i found i was pregnant at 2 and half weeks by taking weekly tests not due to a missed period as i dont bloody have them. dont you ever raise your voice to me ,call me a liar or ever speak to me in that manner.
you might speak to other patents this way but i wont stand for it"

the doctor came in at this point as he was room next door and heard most of the conversation and asked me to another room to find out what happened

i and my partner)explained what went on and his reply was thats it your the 3rd (clinic opened at 9am this was 10am)who complained today but they went to the receptionist to complain your the only one ive witnessed and heard, shes only been here 3 weeks and we have had enough"

i then goes on to say(nicely to the doc) "well im no push over mate she might get away will talking to others that way and they are to scared to say anything back, im not one of them, I will not be talked to like that by any one and especially not a professional. and the fact ive been called a liar twice in the space of 5 minutes is not bloody on.

i get asked to come back that afternoon for a appointment with the manager and senior doctor

i go and find out shes been suspended for unprofessional behaviour and intimidating actions as she tried to "persuade/bully" the girl before me to have an abortion(we know who he was talking about as we are a little welsh village in the south wales valleys and everyone knows everyone,) she was 15 and the midwife didnt agree with underage pregnancies and tried to bully her in to it.
(she kept the baby is roughly a few weeks older than mine)
im know around here as the woman whos had 2 babies without periods and the one that home educates it really is that small here

i had a lovely midwife at the next one and even an personal apology in the mail from the practice manager

hvs i declined all services so had no dealings with them

Decmama10 · 06/12/2021 05:46

When did you all find out you were pregnant? Were you drinking a lot up to that point?

Belladonna12 · 23/08/2021 10:54

@pam290358

Did quite a few searches on various NHS and research sites and the info was from one detailing the AUDIT-C, which is the shortened version of the more detailed AUDIT questionnaire - if I can find it again, I’ll post a link - but the shortened version relies on the first three questions with a cut off of 4 points for a referral. Was only posting this as a possible explanation as to why the MW referred because there was some variation between sites, and differing points of referral. This one seemed to be specific to pregnancy as it went into more detail about the relevance of pre-pregnancy drinking in the immediate period before a positive test. Couldn’t find anything specific about discussion or agreement before referral, as the terminology used was ‘mandatory’, but I agree, generally the other NHS sites I’ve visited, stress that treatment plans of any kind should be discussed and agreed with the patient.
You seem to know a lot of detail for someone who can't provide a link. Every version I have ever seen requires more than just four points before a referral. The fact that it doesn't say the patient should agree to referral means nothing. It's pretty basic.
pam290358 · 23/08/2021 10:12

Did quite a few searches on various NHS and research sites and the info was from one detailing the AUDIT-C, which is the shortened version of the more detailed AUDIT questionnaire - if I can find it again, I’ll post a link - but the shortened version relies on the first three questions with a cut off of 4 points for a referral. Was only posting this as a possible explanation as to why the MW referred because there was some variation between sites, and differing points of referral. This one seemed to be specific to pregnancy as it went into more detail about the relevance of pre-pregnancy drinking in the immediate period before a positive test. Couldn’t find anything specific about discussion or agreement before referral, as the terminology used was ‘mandatory’, but I agree, generally the other NHS sites I’ve visited, stress that treatment plans of any kind should be discussed and agreed with the patient.

Belladonna12 · 23/08/2021 09:03

@pam290358

From various NHS websites it seems that the AUDIT-C alcohol scoring system, advises that if a patient scores 4+ points a referral for advice mandatory. If the OP has advised that she is drinking more than four times a week she would score 4 points before any questioning about the amount of alcohol consumed. Another point is added if 3 or more units of alcohol are consumed each time. I don’t think it’s a stretch by the MW to consider that home measures would total 3 units, but in any case it appears that the reason for referral is the number of times a week - and it appears not to matter if the person advises they stopped drinking after a positive pregnancy test. If the drinking took place 2 months or less before the positive test, it still warrants a referral. Not commenting on whether this is right or wrong, but as a possible explanation as to why the MW referred the OP.
Could you link to the guideline which states that it is mandatory to refer someone for advice if they score 4+ points even without the patients permission. Everything I have seen would requite further reasons for referral than just 4+ points and even then I am sure discussion and agreement with the patient would be expected.
pam290358 · 22/08/2021 16:55

From various NHS websites it seems that the AUDIT-C alcohol scoring system, advises that if a patient scores 4+ points a referral for advice mandatory. If the OP has advised that she is drinking more than four times a week she would score 4 points before any questioning about the amount of alcohol consumed. Another point is added if 3 or more units of alcohol are consumed each time. I don’t think it’s a stretch by the MW to consider that home measures would total 3 units, but in any case it appears that the reason for referral is the number of times a week - and it appears not to matter if the person advises they stopped drinking after a positive pregnancy test. If the drinking took place 2 months or less before the positive test, it still warrants a referral. Not commenting on whether this is right or wrong, but as a possible explanation as to why the MW referred the OP.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 22/08/2021 07:57

@pam290358
Thanks for sharing you experience.
I agree that the OP’s question definitely opened up the conversation and raised further questions about daily drinking. It was a good opportunity to explore the effects and misconceptions.
For example, people talking about the health benefits of the Mediterranean diet and the inclusion of daily, low-level alcohol consumption within it, but not recognising that the Mediterranean diet is not just daily drinking, it’s drinking a glass of wine or beer with a meal. As such, two gins before bed wouldn’t be considered part of the Mediterranean diet.

Belladonna12 · 21/08/2021 19:11

[quote pam290358]**@Belladonna12* Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!*

This is what I was answering - to my mind she wasn’t asking about it in reference to the pregnancy, she was asking whether people thought she was drinking too much generally. I get that she stopped drinking when she found out she was pregnant, but you’re still questioning why she was referred - who knows. I would have thought the simplest explanation is that she’s a healthcare professional, she has a responsibility to mother and baby and because the OP reported home measures and regular drinking, the MW thought it best to refer on to make sure that the support was there if she needed it. I’m coming at this from a slightly different point of view because I’ve had health professionals seemingly railroading me into things I didn’t want and thinking they were being a bit heavy handed - not realising until after the intervention that I’d actually either learned something or been helped in some other way by whatever the intervention was. If the OP doesn’t attend the referral, she’ll never know will she.[/quote]
You keep saying that you are leaving the thread but then you always come back!

I took the question to mean that was her drinking before pregnancy so bad that she needs to be referred even though she is no longer drinking. Obviously the MW thought "it best to refer" but that doesn't mean she was right to do so and other midwives on this thread have also said they wouldn't have done that. She didn't get all the facts and ascertain how much OP was drinking each night. It's not good enough just to assume that they were large measures and that she always had two. She also shouldn't have referred her without discussing it first as that totally defeats the object of the exercise. You may not mind the paternalistic approach but it doesn't work with most people nowadays and is not how healthcare professionals are supposed to operate. Decisions on treatment, referals etc should be discussed and agreed on.

pam290358 · 21/08/2021 09:00

@Belladonna12 Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!

This is what I was answering - to my mind she wasn’t asking about it in reference to the pregnancy, she was asking whether people thought she was drinking too much generally. I get that she stopped drinking when she found out she was pregnant, but you’re still questioning why she was referred - who knows. I would have thought the simplest explanation is that she’s a healthcare professional, she has a responsibility to mother and baby and because the OP reported home measures and regular drinking, the MW thought it best to refer on to make sure that the support was there if she needed it. I’m coming at this from a slightly different point of view because I’ve had health professionals seemingly railroading me into things I didn’t want and thinking they were being a bit heavy handed - not realising until after the intervention that I’d actually either learned something or been helped in some other way by whatever the intervention was. If the OP doesn’t attend the referral, she’ll never know will she.

surreygirl1987 · 20/08/2021 23:33

That sounds like a lot to me, but I have on average 2 or 3 drinks a year. I imagine it's just policy.

That said, I got shamed by a midwife for eating bananas. I mentioned my first born was massive and I was worried about how big the second one would be, and she said I was in control of that. She asked me what I ate in a typical day and when I mentioned a banana as a snack she suggested that this was a huge problem and to stop eating bananas immediately. Ironically, she was utterly enormous so I didn't follow her food advice. So some midwives are just weird. Anyway, if you're not drinking now while pregnant, there's no problem.

Katefoster · 20/08/2021 21:26

I was honest with my midwife and said I drank too much but when it was the TWW I didn't drink and since being pregnant I haven't and she was happy and it's never been mentioned again so this seems strange!

Megan2018 · 20/08/2021 20:04

I drank 3-4 bottles of wine a week before DD and my midwife wasn’t fussed!
I didn’t drink a drop after BFP and only drink occasionally now (DD is 2).

Belladonna12 · 20/08/2021 19:41

[quote pam290358]@Belladonna. Never said my experience was relevant to OP’s pregnancy and actually clarified in my last post that I was answering the wider question she asked about whether people thought she had been drinking too much previously. I’ve taken part in studies myself over 50 years, as I have a birth defect. I know how they work. I’ve tried to present a balanced view and you’ve called me out on almost every aspect. As I said, some will go to any lengths to dispute information which makes them feel uncomfortable. Definitely done with it now.[/quote]
You don't know how all research works if you think it always involved asking people if they want to take part in it. As I said, a great deal involves using annoymised medical records.
OP didn't ask whether she could have been drinking to much for perfect health before being pregnant. She gets that what she was drinking previously probably wasn't that healthy so I don't see why you keep lecturing on it. She was questioning whether she really needed to speak to someone now even though she is not drinking any alcohol and won't be for many months. Nobody including you has given a reason for why she needs to be referred other than she might be lying about not drinking during pregnancy which is ridiculous because anyone could be lying.

LobsterNapkin · 20/08/2021 19:15

@Ingridla

This is why people lie to their doctors about this type of thing. Ridiculous.
Yes, this is true. Many people just don't want to put up with doctors giving them morality lectures, and they are well aware that the things they do, eat and drink might have health effects. They are also aware that they will die and probably the process will suck.
LobsterNapkin · 20/08/2021 19:09

I would be pretty pissed off if my midwife did that. For her to ask a few more questions, sure - they have to sometimes dig a bit to get the real story with a patient they don't really know.

The medical guidelines on this stuff are mostly about health outcomes. So possibly it's not so great for your liver when you get to be old. But it's entirely possible to drink two drinks a night and not be an addict or have behavioral issues related to it. There are plenty of cultures where two glasses of wine or two beer with your food every night would be completely normal.

pam290358 · 20/08/2021 18:04

@Belladonna. Never said my experience was relevant to OP’s pregnancy and actually clarified in my last post that I was answering the wider question she asked about whether people thought she had been drinking too much previously. I’ve taken part in studies myself over 50 years, as I have a birth defect. I know how they work. I’ve tried to present a balanced view and you’ve called me out on almost every aspect. As I said, some will go to any lengths to dispute information which makes them feel uncomfortable. Definitely done with it now.

DoYouLikeOwls · 20/08/2021 18:02

Wheretoeattweenandteen

Totally agree.

My MIL died of bowel cancer and didn't hardly drink. Cancer is a bastard.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 20/08/2021 17:52

" his death from cancer was awful"

Flowers

It's utterly wicked that here we are forcing terminally ill people to last until their body gives out. We don't ask this if animals

It's an absolute stain on our humanity and I had to watch a terminal ill 80 year old die begging to go.

It's a disgrace

DoYouLikeOwls · 20/08/2021 17:43

@DingDongThongs

OP if you're lying about your alcohol consumption you HAVE a DRINK PROBLEM!
Have you read the same thread that everyone else has?
Belladonna12 · 20/08/2021 16:52

@DingDongThongs

OP if you're lying about your alcohol consumption you HAVE a DRINK PROBLEM!
What makes you think OP is lying?
Belladonna12 · 20/08/2021 16:50

[quote pam290358]@Belladonna12. Well to my mind, taking part in a study is voluntary, and I wouldn’t have thought there’s much point in volunteering to help research if you’re going to lie !! Whereas a MW or any other health professionals’ questioning around consumption may be perceived as having repercussions - which is probably why some posters on the thread have encouraged lying. Having said that, I haven’t suggested that anyone is lying to anyone - the OP certainly didn’t lie to the MW, she was truthful about the amount she drank as she saw it, but the MW clearly had concerns about the true amounts consumed because the OP reported they were home measures, and the fact that it had been regular drinking. I really wasn’t trying to answer whether the MW was right or wrong in referring on - I assumed the OP had hit some kind of target from the questioning and the MW had no choice. But for reasons I’ve stated numerous times, I don’t believe the NHS approach to be either ridiculous or overzealous ‘policing’. They must see an awful lot of disease caused by alcohol abuse and I presume this is the reason for the low threshold. Prevention is better than cure, and from their point of view it’s aimed at saving money in the long run in treating disease caused by long term alcohol abuse.

I tried to address the OP’s question as to whether other people thought she was drinking too much, by giving a truthful account of my own experience, and the advice given to me by several health professionals, which is that low levels of alcohol, drunk on a regular basis can be harmful for several reasons. Home drinking can mean you’re drinking more if you don’t measure the amounts properly, drinking regularly can be habit forming and can lead to problems long term, and, as several posts on here have demonstrated, some people have little or no idea what constitutes a unit of alcohol or how to use the recommended weekly units. You, and several other posters jumped on me, citing various other reasons why fatty liver had developed. Do you really think that these hadn’t been discussed and ruled out ? The liver function tests indicated fatty liver and I HAD been drinking more, and on a regular basis, and they had been home measures. On retesting several months later - after I stopped alcohol intake altogether - the results were normal. I really don’t think there can be much argument as to what caused the problem in the first place.

Since that time, I’ve tried to learn more about how alcohol affects the body, because I don’t want to get into that position again - not least because I’ve seen alcohol related illness in my own family and it’s devastating for all concerned. I tried to share some of what I learned here, and I’m quite shocked by the lengths people will go to - either by persistent argument or sheer unpleasantness, judging by some of the posts - to try to disprove something which, for whatever reason, clearly makes them uncomfortable.

In the end, how much you drink is a personal choice - you have to weigh the risks against your own consumption/enjoyment. I’m not saying, and have never advocated not drinking.

@DingDongThongs. I’m so very sorry for your loss. I lost a much loved close relative in similar circumstances about 5 years ago. She was drinking regularly, as much as a bottle of red wine most nights and didn’t see any harm in it - wouldn’t follow medical advice to either cut down or stop, and wouldn’t listen to friends or relatives who were worried for her. Regular vigilance liver scans showed she was deteriorating, but she was never diagnosed with actual cirrhosis, and I think she used this to comfort herself and stay in denial. She had a shock diagnosis of advanced lung cancer after collapsing, and died a couple of weeks later. The cancer was determined to have started in her liver from a lesion that the scans had missed, and had spread rapidly to her bones and lungs. It’s so difficult to watch someone harming themselves for so long like this - inevitably the person won’t admit to a problem, which makes helping them impossible. You find yourself in the awful position of standing by helplessly and waiting for something terrible to happen. I admit, that experience is also probably why I’ve been so vocal on this thread, because when you read between the lines, a lot of people seem to be demonstrating a similar reluctance to accept that they may be harming themselves further down the road. Damage from alcohol is largely silent for many years, and by the time it does start to cause problems it’s more difficult to deal with because the person is older, damage may be extensive, or the person may be much more dependent. I lost my husband to cancer a couple of years ago, and I know how awful the journey is. My sincere condolences.[/quote]
People haven't necessarily volunteered to be in a study about alcohol. A large proportion will have use annonymised medical records. Others may have been asked when attending medical appointments if they would take part in a questionnaire. People who don't want to divulge how much they drink won't necessarily refuse to answer the question. It's easier to lie. Even if they were volunteers why do you think they would no underestimate how much they drink at home?

Your experience of liver damage seems irrelevant to OP as she is not drinking during pregnancy.

DingDongThongs · 20/08/2021 16:26

OP if you're lying about your alcohol consumption you HAVE a DRINK PROBLEM!

DingDongThongs · 20/08/2021 16:25

@Belladonna12
Well done on the liver! He loved going to gigs and he was highly paid. We went to see Ozzy in Mcr. I miss him lots and my children too. The cancer spread to his liver and he went yellow, a pale waxy yellow.

It worries me how many people think regular alcohol abuse isn't a problem. Just because it's socially acceptable doesn't mean it's safe and even more dangerous in pregnancy. FAS is evil and blights children's lives.

Sorry for your loss xx

DingDongThongs · 20/08/2021 16:21

StepDad not partner. Husband and I don't drink unless it's Xmas/anniversary etc.

He was a talented, educated and highly skilled guy. He worked and achieved a lot. He died of bowel cancer that spread to his brain, bones, everywhere.

He was always the life and soul of the party. He was a lot of fun. Please OP I've seen children with FAS and it severely impacts them and their quality of lives. See the midwife and get help.

We all miss him immensely and our lives are quieter for his passing.

pam290358 · 20/08/2021 15:44

@Belladonna12. Well to my mind, taking part in a study is voluntary, and I wouldn’t have thought there’s much point in volunteering to help research if you’re going to lie !! Whereas a MW or any other health professionals’ questioning around consumption may be perceived as having repercussions - which is probably why some posters on the thread have encouraged lying. Having said that, I haven’t suggested that anyone is lying to anyone - the OP certainly didn’t lie to the MW, she was truthful about the amount she drank as she saw it, but the MW clearly had concerns about the true amounts consumed because the OP reported they were home measures, and the fact that it had been regular drinking. I really wasn’t trying to answer whether the MW was right or wrong in referring on - I assumed the OP had hit some kind of target from the questioning and the MW had no choice. But for reasons I’ve stated numerous times, I don’t believe the NHS approach to be either ridiculous or overzealous ‘policing’. They must see an awful lot of disease caused by alcohol abuse and I presume this is the reason for the low threshold. Prevention is better than cure, and from their point of view it’s aimed at saving money in the long run in treating disease caused by long term alcohol abuse.

I tried to address the OP’s question as to whether other people thought she was drinking too much, by giving a truthful account of my own experience, and the advice given to me by several health professionals, which is that low levels of alcohol, drunk on a regular basis can be harmful for several reasons. Home drinking can mean you’re drinking more if you don’t measure the amounts properly, drinking regularly can be habit forming and can lead to problems long term, and, as several posts on here have demonstrated, some people have little or no idea what constitutes a unit of alcohol or how to use the recommended weekly units. You, and several other posters jumped on me, citing various other reasons why fatty liver had developed. Do you really think that these hadn’t been discussed and ruled out ? The liver function tests indicated fatty liver and I HAD been drinking more, and on a regular basis, and they had been home measures. On retesting several months later - after I stopped alcohol intake altogether - the results were normal. I really don’t think there can be much argument as to what caused the problem in the first place.

Since that time, I’ve tried to learn more about how alcohol affects the body, because I don’t want to get into that position again - not least because I’ve seen alcohol related illness in my own family and it’s devastating for all concerned. I tried to share some of what I learned here, and I’m quite shocked by the lengths people will go to - either by persistent argument or sheer unpleasantness, judging by some of the posts - to try to disprove something which, for whatever reason, clearly makes them uncomfortable.

In the end, how much you drink is a personal choice - you have to weigh the risks against your own consumption/enjoyment. I’m not saying, and have never advocated not drinking.

@DingDongThongs. I’m so very sorry for your loss. I lost a much loved close relative in similar circumstances about 5 years ago. She was drinking regularly, as much as a bottle of red wine most nights and didn’t see any harm in it - wouldn’t follow medical advice to either cut down or stop, and wouldn’t listen to friends or relatives who were worried for her. Regular vigilance liver scans showed she was deteriorating, but she was never diagnosed with actual cirrhosis, and I think she used this to comfort herself and stay in denial. She had a shock diagnosis of advanced lung cancer after collapsing, and died a couple of weeks later. The cancer was determined to have started in her liver from a lesion that the scans had missed, and had spread rapidly to her bones and lungs. It’s so difficult to watch someone harming themselves for so long like this - inevitably the person won’t admit to a problem, which makes helping them impossible. You find yourself in the awful position of standing by helplessly and waiting for something terrible to happen. I admit, that experience is also probably why I’ve been so vocal on this thread, because when you read between the lines, a lot of people seem to be demonstrating a similar reluctance to accept that they may be harming themselves further down the road. Damage from alcohol is largely silent for many years, and by the time it does start to cause problems it’s more difficult to deal with because the person is older, damage may be extensive, or the person may be much more dependent. I lost my husband to cancer a couple of years ago, and I know how awful the journey is. My sincere condolences.