Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my daughter change her name?

510 replies

katherine1983 · 14/08/2021 16:09

My daughter wants to change her name to Rose, however I believe she should keep her birth name until the age of 18. I’m aware she can change it without my permission as she’s 16 however I’m hoping she wouldn’t as she knows I’m unhappy with it. It was the name I chose for her and I do believe her reasoning for wanting to change her name (too masculine) is wrong. Shes been using Rose as her name with some of her school friends and her online friends for over a year.

OP posts:
opinionminion · 15/08/2021 11:18

Rose is a beautiful name ! Kody sounds masculine. At 16 she is mature enough to make this decision and as she has already been using it for a year it's not unreasonable to want to make it official. Sounds like she is being incredibly mature actually. Choose your battles; kindness, support and understanding is what she needs.

katherine1983 · 15/08/2021 11:03

She has been waiting a while for this, she told me she has been waiting until her 16th and not long after she told us. She was wanting our opinion however she’s sure she wants to change it and thinks she won’t want to change it back. I take her word for that as she’s used it since 13 or 14.

OP posts:
HerMammy · 15/08/2021 10:55

This thread should be a lesson for all the baby name posters with their cute and quirky names, might be nice on a baby but not on an adult.

AgentJohnson · 15/08/2021 10:53

Well given her birth name, I think she’s been incredibly patient. I didn’t mean that to sound flippant but it is an unusual name particularly for a girl. I understand where you’re coming from but It’s her name not yours.

Biblionerd · 15/08/2021 10:41

@katherine1983

It would be easier for her now as she wants to look for a job. Hopefully the rest of the family don’t have my original reaction. She’s easily shy when it comes to them.

Don't let them have your reaction, advocate for your girl, make sure family accept and respect her decision. Don't let her have to deal with another fight to be called what she chooses, she's already had to fight to get her own mother to respect her. Be on her side fully, she should have you stood between her and the family without her having to be shy about it. Your reluctance to accept her decision will have been hard enough as it is, don't make her have this fight with everyone.

speakout · 15/08/2021 10:38

However, we negotiate these disagreements without any battles, on the basis of mutual respect and trust. I respect her choices and don't put arbitrary limits on what she can do. She respects the fact that I am reasonable and will only say no to stuff if there is a genuinely good reason that I will be able to explain to her.

Exactly my approach! I had two headstrong teens ( both in their 20s now) and the teenage years passed with no battles.
Differences of opinions sometimes yes, yes, but we sat down to discuss issues without fighting- both keen to find a solution.

AlexaShutUp · 15/08/2021 10:34

@Blossomtoes

Clearly my experience of teenagers is very different. I’m pleased for you both that you had compliant teens who you parented so beautifully. I was obviously a complete failure. At least all my friends, with a whole range of parenting styles, were too.
I'm not saying that anyone is a failure at all, but I do think it's entirely possible to get through the teen years without battles. And it's completely normal in my extended family and among some - not all - of my friends. It isn't about the kids being compliant either, there will always be differences of opinion and that's perfectly normal and natural. My 16yo dd certainly has a mind of her own, and sometimes makes choices that I wouldn't make. However, we negotiate these disagreements without any battles, on the basis of mutual respect and trust. I respect her choices and don't put arbitrary limits on what she can do. She respects the fact that I am reasonable and will only say no to stuff if there is a genuinely good reason that I will be able to explain to her. That approach might not work for all kids but it works well for us and it works for plenty of other people I know.

I'm not saying that it's unhealthy if some kids end up battling with their parents during the teenage years, or that the parents are failing if that happens. All kids and parents have different temperaments and for some, it might just be a stage that they have to go through. All I'm saying is that such battles aren't universal or inevitable and it certainly isn't unhealthy if they don't happen!

speakout · 15/08/2021 10:30

I agree with AlexaShutUp- and it isn't about having "compliant " teens.

It's about having relationships where differences are discussed, the needs of both the parents and child are made clear and solutions found.
All that can be done without a fight. Parenting needn't be a battle of wills.
As AlexaShutUp points out this teenage cliche of rebellion is not universal.
It is possible to avoid it.

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 10:19

Clearly my experience of teenagers is very different. I’m pleased for you both that you had compliant teens who you parented so beautifully. I was obviously a complete failure. At least all my friends, with a whole range of parenting styles, were too.

AlexaShutUp · 15/08/2021 10:15

And I would add that teenage rebellion isn't a cliché in all cultures. If it was a biological imperative, then surely it would be?

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/08/2021 10:14

YABU

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 15/08/2021 10:13

@Paulinna

How can a birth name cost you jobs? For example if you’re applying to a professional job and your birth name name makes you sound like a stripper. Nobody is gonna hire a teacher called Randee-Leigh or a solicitor called Kandy. People assume I’m thick and trashy.
There's a whole literature on nominative determinism....

Many UK names that instantly identify someone as being from a particular age /background...

I mean how many Shirleys or Denises or Marions are there under 70??

Are there any judges called Darren, Darryl, Kaydee, or Khloe??

Or equally shop workers called Gerrard, Ralph, Fenella, Benedick...

Of course they may have these names and be known as something different....

An old social work manager used to joke with newly pregnant women... Was their chosen name more likely to be attached to the judge or defendant?! Grin

AlexaShutUp · 15/08/2021 10:13

@Blossomtoes

Because teenagers are hardwired to rebel. That’s what they do. It’s part of the separation process. Why do you think it’s such a cliche?
But many teenagers don't rebel, that's the point. If their growing autonomy is handled appropriately, many won't ever feel the need to rebel. There is nothing unhealthy about that as long as they are still being allowed to grow up and assert their independence.
Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 10:09

Because teenagers are hardwired to rebel. That’s what they do. It’s part of the separation process. Why do you think it’s such a cliche?

speakout · 15/08/2021 10:08

*Separation from parents and growing independence and autonomy is normal and healthy. There is nothing inherently healthy about "battles" and differences of opinion don't have to be handled as such. Battles between teenagers and their parents may be common enough, but it's absurd to suggest that it's somehow unhealthy if they don't.

Totally agree.

AlexaShutUp · 15/08/2021 10:07

[quote Blossomtoes]@speakout, I was the least authoritarian parent you could ever imagine. I was the “cool mum” and our house became my son’s friendship group’s common room and we still had battles because that’s what teenagers do. Anything else is really unhealthy.[/quote]
Nonsense. Separation from parents and growing independence and autonomy is normal and healthy. There is nothing inherently healthy about "battles" and differences of opinion don't have to be handled as such. Battles between teenagers and their parents may be common enough, but it's absurd to suggest that it's somehow unhealthy if they don't.

speakout · 15/08/2021 10:04

Anything else is really unhealthy.

I disagree. Battles need not happen.

Why is not fighting unhealthy?

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 10:01

@speakout, I was the least authoritarian parent you could ever imagine. I was the “cool mum” and our house became my son’s friendship group’s common room and we still had battles because that’s what teenagers do. Anything else is really unhealthy.

speakout · 15/08/2021 09:55

Lockdownbear
Teenagers are learning about themselves and their place in the world, questioning their parents’ boundaries and establishing their independence.

I agree.

But that can be done without battles.

My sister and I fought terribly with our authoritarian mother as teens, she was so rigid and every day brought screamig, banging doors.

It need not be like that.
Teenagers need to grow and expand their autonomy, and parents need to relax their control, but all that can happen without the need for violent communication.

katherine1983 · 15/08/2021 09:52

I assume some of the family won’t be pleased. Her dad is happy with it and won’t tolerate any of them if they say anything.

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 15/08/2021 09:45

@Rangoon

I wish I'd had the initiative to change the dreary Scots name I got landed with. We're not even Scottish. My father misrembered his late mother's name (who died when he was a child) and landed me with the Scottish horror instead. I mean there were only four letters he had to remember in the right order. I have been toying with changing it to the name I was meant to have been called but the thought of the paper work puts me off.
Curious on the names! However I think the paperwork would be the easy part. The hard part is getting family & friends to change. And not be Rose the artist previously known as Kody.
Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 09:40

@speakout

In teenage years you need to let them win some battles,

The teenage years don't need to be about battes and conflict.

I think they do need to be. Teenagers are learning about themselves and their place in the world, questioning their parents’ boundaries and establishing their independence. It would be very unhealthy if there wasn’t some conflict. I remember mine saying his teens were weird because, unlike his peers, he had nothing to rebel against. We still had the odd battle.
whiteroseredrose · 15/08/2021 09:38

Good points about doing it quickly so that her GCSE and A Level certs are in her new name.

I wouldn't imagine that she would change it back. I went to uni with two people that had changes their names and they are still using the new names at 55!

Hepzibar · 15/08/2021 09:31

@BlackeyedSusan

It's a lovely name. Must be hard for you to adjust though. Is it completely different from her given name?
After 300+ posts 🙄
Lockdownbear · 15/08/2021 09:31

@DinaofCloud9

The comments on here would be completely different if the daughter wanted to change her name from Rose to Kody.
That is very true. But people would also question if they were trans or going through a trans phase.

The girl has chosen a very feminine traditional, easy to spell name. Op support it sooner she does it the better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread