Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my daughter change her name?

510 replies

katherine1983 · 14/08/2021 16:09

My daughter wants to change her name to Rose, however I believe she should keep her birth name until the age of 18. I’m aware she can change it without my permission as she’s 16 however I’m hoping she wouldn’t as she knows I’m unhappy with it. It was the name I chose for her and I do believe her reasoning for wanting to change her name (too masculine) is wrong. Shes been using Rose as her name with some of her school friends and her online friends for over a year.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sunglassesonthetable · 20/08/2021 00:08

It doesn't matter what her name currently is, and it doesn't matter what she is proposing to use instead. What matters is that she is the one living with it, and she wants to change it, and the law allows her to change it. So, it changes.

Yep, totally.

Elainereadsapage · 19/08/2021 13:26

Not to say you shouldn’t let her but when I was her age I ‘changed my name’… Now I look back on it with embarrassment. Blush

TheFeistyFeminist · 19/08/2021 12:57

It doesn't matter what her name currently is, and it doesn't matter what she is proposing to use instead. What matters is that she is the one living with it, and she wants to change it, and the law allows her to change it. So, it changes.

Please don't continue to use her old name (I know you have said you won't). Those few family members of mine who use my old name over my preferred name grate on me every time. It's like they are saying their view of MY NAME matters more than my feelings. That's absurd and annoying.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 18/08/2021 09:10

@bemusedmoose

Cool username BTW...

I too hated my birth name... I'm known by a different name.

Don't suffer a name you hate, there's plenty of online name generators you can play with and find a name that is more 'you'!

MeanderingGently · 18/08/2021 03:00

Your daughter is 16, she is old enough to know what she wants. It's her name, of course she can change it. I changed mine at 17, I have certificates from school in both names, I just show a legal document if I go for jobs which require proof of education.

Your daughter will still have to do that if she waits until she's 18, so she might as well get on with it now. Forcing her to wait will only cause friction and won't serve any useful purpose. Nor will it make any difference if she wants to change it back or to any other name in the future....it's her life, she can change as often as she likes as long as she isn't doing it for fraudulent purposes.

DerAlteMann · 18/08/2021 02:29

I'm with your DD. I have a first name that can be either male or female and I hated it as a kid and hate it now. It was chosen by my late DM but I still won't use it. My DF isn't happy but I'm sorry, that's too bad. I stopped using it when I was about 13.

CCN2012 · 18/08/2021 00:30

My daughter changed her name last Christmas. She had (in my opinion) a beautiful name but due to domestic violence and her father not being around , she changed it to a name I had considered when pregnant. Her explanation was that she wanted a name that her father didn't know and wouldn't know. She didn't want a name that reminded her of him. She uses her new name in school and for support services. She was 12 when she made the decision, she can't wait until she can legally change her name. I've had to support her due to her reasons but it does sadden me when I think of her given name.

TinselTinsel · 17/08/2021 01:48

Most people where I live don't know my actual name, I go by a shortened version (not by my doing originally) which is in itself a name albeit spelt differently and everyone assumes it is the different variation (suits me because i have hated my actual name since primary school and the amount of people that say my actual name wrong is stupid given that it isn't THAT unusual, just not common)

Fudgemonkeys · 16/08/2021 20:07

I hated my birth name, called myself a name I love and only family call me by my given name. My parents know I hate it but respect me for being known by another name but not legally changing it. Makes calls easier depending on what name they use. Legal stuff given name simples

Ginandtonics · 16/08/2021 19:18

The point about exams is a good one, she's going to change her name at some point, the sooner she gets it official the less faff explaining to prospective employers and educational establishments why her name is different in different documents. YABU

bemusedmoose · 16/08/2021 17:04

Honestly - it's her identity, if it doesn't fit then she isnt going to feel comfortable.

She will fight you over this and the more you argue the more she will go against you.

She can have her birth name and 'known as..' name. Most schools and work places ask for the actual name and what you are actually known as. So she can have both. Being a teen she is likely to fall out of love with the new name so I would just go with the flow and if after 18 she still wants to change it then not a lot you can do. You don't own her identity or her name - she does.

I know it might hurt your feelings but she has to live her own life.

Personally I hate my name, I hate hearing it when people call me, i hate writing it... But I can't think of a name that suits me or I would have change mine years ago! So I know how she feels. I dont feel like my name, it makes me feel awkward. It's a perfectly fine name, I just really don't like it.

Blueink · 16/08/2021 12:32

Teens are much more sensitive to gender/identity so it’s great you’re now supporting her use of name

katherine1983 · 16/08/2021 12:00

Starting to think the unisex opinion might just be my family Grin

I do agree Rose is quite a nice name

OP posts:
notthemum · 16/08/2021 10:04

Sorry OP. I think Rose is a classic and that Kody is definitely more a boys name

katherine1983 · 16/08/2021 07:59

Yes, it’ll be hard to get used to but i’ll get there. One of my friends mentioned it would be easier for her as she wants to go into law as Rose. I just want her to be happy and get into the career she wants. Smile

OP posts:
Emmylouisa · 16/08/2021 01:04

My vote goes to your daughter. She's still the same girl, let her call herself what she feels comfortable with. I know it must be hard for you but it's the right thing to do.

Mamanyt · 16/08/2021 01:00

One of the biggest gifts you can every give your daughter is, right now, sit down with her and tell her that although you love the name you gave her and that some part of you will always think of her by that name, you support her choice, even though you do not totally agree with it.

This will open doors to her talking with you about other things later...but you must always remain calm, even when disagreeing, and when you HAVE to object in the future, do so with rational reasons, not gut reaction.

Harmonypuss · 16/08/2021 00:56

When I divorced my ex 23yrs ago, I legally changed my name, nothing drastic, I shortened my first name, completely scraped my middle name and went back to my birth surname.
Fastforward to 2008 and my eldest son changed his name (quite drastically). My mother had plenty to say about it but my attitude was how can I complain about him doing it if I've done it myself?

We had a similar situation when my youngest got into a relationship with someone over 25yrs their senior. My first husband was 26yrs older than me but I learned my lesson. I told my son that he would experience prejudices and people would assume things (wrongly) about their relationship but said that I wouldn't try to discourage them, only that I would be here for him if it all went wrong because if been through it myself. 7yrs on and they're still together and happy.

Moral.... our children will do as they want to, we don't always approve but we just have to be supportive and there for them in case anything goes wrong.

Ifeelsuchafool · 16/08/2021 00:17

Oh how I wish people would be respectful and call me by my preferred name. I'm known by a diminutive of my full first name but used to be known by another diminutive of the same name (think Annabella full name and diminutives Anna and Bella - not the case but a similar idea). I changed the diminutive when I got divorced for reasons I won't go into and to anyone I've met since my divorce I've given my new, preferred diminutive at introduction/meeting so no problem. Some of my old friends are very respectful and use the new diminutive, (even if they occasionally slip up, which I do understand, having known me for many years, they quickly correct and apologise) others, however, persist in using the old diminutive and when I repeat that nobody uses that these days as I go by, "alternative diminutive" they just repeat that they'll, "never get used to it" and ask, "why on earth do you want to change it anyway?" To which I usually reply, "want to change? I have changed it, I changed it over 10 years ago!" But still they persist because they don't agree/approve. I find it really annoying and disrespectful and find that I now avoid these people like the plague.

Saoirse82 · 15/08/2021 23:15

I always thought of Cody/Kody as a girls name as the first time I ever heard it was from Cody in neighbours in the early 90s. When people started calling their boys Cody/Kody around 10 years ago I thought it was odd as I thought it to be quite girly. Now I think its fine for either. But if she doesn't like it and has been using Rose for a year I'd fully support her in changing it.

M1551nglink · 15/08/2021 23:07

Shakespeare Quote - "What's in a name?"
Juliet:
"What's in a name? That which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet."

CrankyFrankie · 15/08/2021 22:59

Sounds like she has thoughtfully tried to link her preferred names to her heritage etc. I like people assuming I’m a man before they meet me though :D

CrankyFrankie · 15/08/2021 22:55

She can call herself what she likes, it’s not a legal thing when it comes to first names right? And you should respect her wishes and call her whatever she wants to be known as.

ODFOx · 15/08/2021 22:47

OP I think that most MNers would recognise Rose as a girl's name with few negative connotations, so it is difficult to understand why you are so troubled.
Why/how did you choose Kody originally? It is quite an unusual spelling of a name which would, to most people in the UK at least, be considered a boy's name of US origin (Cody). Is there a personal reason that you chose it?
Certainly it is a very different name to Rose Josephine, in many ways.
My child also changed their name, so I understand your upset. We spend so much time choosing names for our babies: to have one reach the teen years and reject that choice to reinvent themself is hard to not take personally, but really it is about them, not us.

Copperas · 15/08/2021 22:35

I would strongly recommend getting the deed poll enrolled. So many people mislay the deed poll: enrolling it will make life a lot easier