Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Outrage! Socialist discovered in Labour Party as Ken Loach says he's expelled

129 replies

longwayoff · 14/08/2021 13:23

Yes. KEN LOACH for crying out loud, director of "I, Daniel Blake" and many other films. AIBU to suggest this is not likely to be a vote winner? Idiots.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 15/08/2021 08:29

Interesting that some people think Corbyn getting more votes in 2017 than 2019 was because Corbyn was great and not because Theresa May ran a terrible campaign and handed him votes. Fox hunting and grammar schools? Plus how strongly Remainers felt about Brexit. Have people forgotten how bad she was?

2019 and people had seen far more of Corbyn and didn’t like the cantankerous, stubborn old man with a tolerance for nutters and antisemites.

By 2019 it was impossible to convince people that he wasn’t worse than the alternative.

SummerWhisper · 15/08/2021 08:12

@thecatfromjapan why doesn't Starmer release the Forde report? What doesn't he want the public to know? It's almost a year overdue and he has buried it. He has no integrity.

Why is he flailing in the polls? They used to scream about Corbyn "any other leader would be 20 points ahead" yet Starmer is miserably trailing the most incompetent and corrupt Prime Minister ever. Labour is losing votes across the UK and the only thing we know he has a position on is the death of an alpaca. Not the death of corruption , or the death of privatising the NHS, or the death of austerity, but the death of an animal. He is incapable of reading the public mood. Now he wants to bring Blairism back at a time when US troops are pulling out of Afghanistan, so he will no doubt support another illegal war (this time a Tory one) and help send our youth to their deaths. So the killing of an animal and the lauding of a warmonger is who he is as a leader. That's the closest we have come to decisive courses of action.

The EHRC report was welcome. Antisemitism is 100% not welcome in the party. If you are antisemitic, you are a cunt. What the report showed is that Labour's processes were flawed and needed improvements. I welcome that. Corbyn and his office made attempts to speed them up but that was seen as interference by the EHRC. Starmer made a public statement about his suspension of Corbyn, which is of course against the EHRC recommendations (leader interfering in process) then denied it. Len McCluskey is about to publish a book that includes this event and is 100% confident he will win a court case if Starmer wants to attempt to challenge him in court and waste even more money the party doesn't now have.

Starmer is killing off the Labour vote in the same way John Major killed off the Tory vote. The Greens are seeing a rise in vote share. Young voters want a focus on environmental issues, hence why Corbyn was so popular with them. There has to be a leadership challenge to give the party any chance in 2023.

newnortherner111 · 15/08/2021 07:27

Ken Loach's films whilst excellent and deservedly award winning are not films largely watched by a mainstream audience. The merits or otherwise of him not being in the Labour Party any more are unlikely to affect how many people vote.

VashtaNerada · 15/08/2021 06:10

Ken Loach is more Labour than Starmer could ever be. Antisemitism is real and it is morally repugnant to pretend this is the reason those to the left of the party are being treated so badly. There are many Jewish supporters of Ken Loach (& Jeremy Corbyn for that matter) who are disgusted by what’s going on. Our eyes need to be firmly on the racists in government rather than pretending that Ken Loach is the problem here.

MessOfEyelinerAndSpraypaint · 15/08/2021 05:13

Just shows what kind of labour party Starmer is running: one for the status quo (the primary role of government is to protect property from the many, and so it remains)
Booting Loach, a longtime bane of the Tories by making their lethal policies brutally visible via film, is the final act in a drama which centred on kicking Corbyn into stasis. It has failed to silence decent people who just want a fairer society, but instead we are misrepresented & mocked by people who aren't profoundly affected by austerity or the corporate takeover of the NHS & who think Boris is a bit of a laugh while he & his cronies fill their pockets with our taxes.
Also, Loach is not a Holocaust denier & everyone who has posted this vile smear needs to retract it.

thecatfromjapan · 15/08/2021 02:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BrozTito · 15/08/2021 02:39

Sure you understand lenin and marx (you dont, neither invented socialism) when you cant even spell 'labour', sst. Stick to your own country, you lot like that idea dont you?

AJGranny · 15/08/2021 02:16

@SummerWhisper
I couldn't agree more.

SummerWhisper · 15/08/2021 02:12

@Unfashionable I think plenty of white, working class people give a fuck about Palestine. It was obvious in 2014 during the air strikes in Gaza. Public outrage across the UK was high. I wish there could be a peaceful solution for all affected.

Unfashionable · 15/08/2021 01:54

Good. Loach’s expulsion is long overdue. Well done, Keir.

If Labour wants to win again it must start actually listening to the ordinary working people outside the M25 whose economic interests it is supposed to represent, instead of listening to the obsessions of its own left wing activists

Traditional white working class Labour voters in Stoke, Mansfield or Hartlepool who feel ignored and abandoned don’t give a fuck about Palestine. They are not interested in patronising lectures about Trans rights. Nor do they appreciate sneering at their patriotism and desire for law & order, or telling them that their concerns about uncontrolled mass immigration are racist.

Do Starmer and his allies actually get this? I hope so, because if they want to win again they have to stop ignoring the people who are supposed to be their core voters.

SummerWhisper · 15/08/2021 01:35

Ken Loach is not a holocaust denier. Labour is dwindling in the polls. Starmer is a vacant leader with no vision. Corbyn and his cabinet created policies early on and you knew what they stood for. He inspired hundreds of thousands to join Labour, making it the biggest party in Europe and put the party in the black with a very healthy bank balance from membership subs. The 2017 election saw him come to within a few thousand votes of winning. In that election, he stated he would respect the referendum result on Brexit. Labour won seats that had never been won before. Enter Starmer and his grand plans to reverse the referendum and hold a 2nd one. It was a major factor in the 2019 losses. Nearly all of the red seats lost were high Brexit areas. Starmer and his Brexit reversal policy and the relentless attacks from the mainstream media and from within Corbyn's own party killed Labour off in 2019. Ironically, research showed that around 70% of the public polled agreed with Corbyn's socialist manifesto (without knowing it was Corbyn's manifesto). In opposition, Corbyn forced hundreds of U-turns out of Cameron, May and Johnson. Starmer...how many? None, so far.

Starmer has only had one successful election - Batley and Spen. Under Corbyn, the majority of many thousands was upheld. Under Starmer, it dwindled to just 300. Labour has lost most council by-elections and altogether around 300 Council seats under Starmer. Over 100,000 members have left the party. Starmer gave an undisclosed compensation to 6 staffers when the party's legal team advised him that the party would win the case in court, but he took money from the membership subs to pay them off. The party is now skint due to this pay-off and the huge loss of membership subs. He is making a quarter of the staff redundant. Since April 2020, the start of Starmer's tenure as leader, there was £13.5 million in the bank. That has now gone.

Starmer is a fucking disaster and instead of going after the Tories and forming a manifesto and forcing u-turns, he is greeing with government policy and not calling for resignations when he should be (Matt Hancock!) He is instead going after socialists and more specifically, he is going after those who support the rights of the Palestinian people to have autonomy and freedom in their land. It is not antisemitic to support the freedom of Palestine, but it is antisemitic if you blame Jewish people for the Palestinian struggle.

The next election will be 2023. We need a stronger leader to win.

Zotter · 15/08/2021 00:43

Sorry missed people already shared evidence KL is not a Holocaust denier

Zotter · 15/08/2021 00:42

@Suprima

And that’s not even considering the Holocaust denial.
www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/05/ken-loach-i-give-no-legitimacy-to-holocaust-denial
StoneofDestiny · 15/08/2021 00:28

Ken Loach has been a multi millionaire for decades. He has absolutely no comprehension of what it is truly like for the poor, the working class, the just about managings etc

You can be a multi millionaire and understand deprivation and struggle. Many who have been born into poverty or had a childhood filled with unemployment or with an experience of living in a sink estate have gone on to be successful and economically privileged later in life.

flashbac · 14/08/2021 23:41

@robotcollision

He doesn't in any way seem to be a holocaust denier here:

Loach refutes accusations of Holocaust denial here

I know he's far from perfect but to accuse someone of holocaust denial is a really offensive thing to do unless you have irrefutable proof.

I agree. It seems an easy way to discredit someone. Reminds me of the JK Rowling stuff, DD's mates are all "bUt She's TrANsPhObiC!" but they mumble some bullshit non answer when you ask why or what she has said or done that has made them believe that.
sst1234 · 14/08/2021 23:38

@Snoozer11

Ken Loach has been a multi millionaire for decades. He has absolutely no comprehension of what it is truly like for the poor, the working class, the just about managings etc.

Why he is held up as the voice of the worker is beyond me.

I thought some of the plots in 'I, Daniel Blake' were a bit off. Woman can't afford to feed kids, so she turns to sex work. Man from the North East refuses to use a computer.

By all means, tell the message. What has happened to those on the sick has been appalling, and the existence of food banks is awful. But don't sensationalise with lazy stereotypes.

He’s just a champagne socialist who, like Corbyn, never grew out of student politics and virtue signaling protest into the real world.

As the saying goes: a socialist is someone who has read Lenin and Marx, an anti socialist is someone who understands Lenin and Marx.

Snoozer11 · 14/08/2021 21:16

Ken Loach has been a multi millionaire for decades. He has absolutely no comprehension of what it is truly like for the poor, the working class, the just about managings etc.

Why he is held up as the voice of the worker is beyond me.

I thought some of the plots in 'I, Daniel Blake' were a bit off. Woman can't afford to feed kids, so she turns to sex work. Man from the North East refuses to use a computer.

By all means, tell the message. What has happened to those on the sick has been appalling, and the existence of food banks is awful. But don't sensationalise with lazy stereotypes.

MrsBede · 14/08/2021 20:51

I don't get this attitude. If its a good idea, surely any political party would,want it introduced as soon as possible. If it a stolen idea badly implicated, then you go after that.

Come on, that is not how it works. Do you honestly think that the best way for an opposition party to operate is to hustle for the govn to implement some half-baked version of their own policies?! That never happens (not just KS isn't doing this- it just isn't how it works). Firstly, you can't force someone with an 80 seat majority to do anything. You just can't. And if they do pick something up and do a crap version it could cause more harm than good, and if it goes well where does that leave the opposition when it comes to an election? Either their policies have been used and shown to be crap (because they weren't done properly) or they worked and someone else gets the credit. The opposition is there to oppose, not try to govern alongside the ruling party.

I agree to an extent that Starmer needs to do a lot better - I'm not saying he's doing brilliantly, but I don't really get the obsession with policies when an election is still a few years away and he can't know what the economic situation, for instance, will be at that point. They do need to create a vision for the future though, I do hope that will be forthcoming soon.

Also, while the Hartlepool by-election was a disaster, the local elections afterwards weren't that bad, though his hasty reshuffle was a bit of a disaster. The Tories didn't do that well - I do think some of the shine is coming off Johnson and Labour can exploit that.

longwayoff · 14/08/2021 20:49

McCarthyism. It's not encouraging.

OP posts:
robotcollision · 14/08/2021 20:40

He doesn't in any way seem to be a holocaust denier here:

Loach refutes accusations of Holocaust denial here

I know he's far from perfect but to accuse someone of holocaust denial is a really offensive thing to do unless you have irrefutable proof.

robotcollision · 14/08/2021 20:38

@sunshinesupermum

Good riddance Loach is a Holocaust denier. That's enough for me.
Seriously? Is he really? Where is the evidence for this? I can't believe it.
flashbac · 14/08/2021 20:35

It's not good news that he's expelled Ken Loach. The optics don't look good. Is this more pandering to the focus groups I wonder. Either way Labour are doomed and so are we!

Earlydancing · 14/08/2021 18:22

Oh, it is sticking.

But it's amazing how often it has to be repeated

Maybe you work in the party and you see figures I don't? Because honestly I'm not seeing much movement in friends voting patterns. There is such huge scepticism about him. I remember at the start if the pandemic there was such optimism about his election. Now there's definitely more criticism of the govt but no one is speaking about Starmer to replace him. Just anecdotal I know. If you have any political connections, I'd be greatly comforted if you could give assurances that Starmers credibility is rising.

Earlydancing · 14/08/2021 18:16

@sameproblem

what sort of decent politician goes into local elections and by election with no policies to give people reason to vote for you. People won't vote for an empty vessel. Unfortunately Keir Starmer has no charisma

Johnson had this famed 'charisma'. He was also an empty vessel with vacuous soundbites instead of policies - e.g. oven ready Brexit. People voted for him and his lot, lamentably. What Labour were offering in comparison did not convince people. (Still waiting for an explanation of why if so many people want the 'more left wing' option represented by Ken Loach, Labour didn't win in 2019)

Personally I long for someone uncharismatic but competent and honest to be running the country.

@sameproblem

Personally I long for someone uncharismatic but competent and honest to be running the country.

No one can deny that lots of people voted for Johnson because they liked him and felt a connection to him. That might change and have changed. But he was an empty vessel with charisma (whether you liked him or not). At the moment Starmer is an empty vessel with no charisma. He has to become substantial to get elected.

thecatfromjapan · 14/08/2021 17:47

@Earlydancing

Oh, cronyism, venal govt, chaotic etc etc. It's been said a million times. It's not sticking. The Labour party has to introduce another string to its bow.
Oh, it is sticking.

But it's amazing how often it has to be repeated.

Personally, I think it's the scale that is part of the problem.

It's actually hard to believe the corruption that the PPE contracts and Greensill reveal. It's so awful.

Greensill en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greensill_scandal

PPE www.google.co.uk/amp/s/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idINKBN2AJ1KF