Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Outrage! Socialist discovered in Labour Party as Ken Loach says he's expelled

129 replies

longwayoff · 14/08/2021 13:23

Yes. KEN LOACH for crying out loud, director of "I, Daniel Blake" and many other films. AIBU to suggest this is not likely to be a vote winner? Idiots.

OP posts:
Snoozer11 · 16/08/2021 11:56

@SummerWhisper Starmer having only one successful election may be due to the fact that there have only been a handful since he became leader.

Zotter · 15/08/2021 16:29

It’s incredible that people are still in denial to how much damage was done to Labour under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership.

The Labour Party really consists of two political parties in one, centre/centre left and left, first past the post forces them to unite. The right of the party undermined Corbyn and now the left Starmer. I will vote for Labour under either as I want Tories out.

sunshinesupermum · 15/08/2021 15:45

I wish people would stop accusing others of anti semitism without looking at what was actually said, rather than cherry picking words to suit their narrative. It wholly diminishes the harm that actual antisemitism causes.

It is my view FWIW Corbyn, Loach, Livingstone etc hide their antisemitism/hatred of Jews behind their antizionism/hatred of Israel.

I am Jewish and a Zionist (which means believing in a homeland for Jews) but I do not under any circumstances support the actions of the Israeli Government just as being British I don't support the actions of the current Conservative Government.

samG76 · 15/08/2021 14:45

Broz - who is "we" in "we said", and what has happened?

BrozTito · 15/08/2021 14:13

We said again and again absurd accusations of AS would have a boy who cried wolf effect. It was ignored and guess what has happened?

Orf1abc · 15/08/2021 14:05

I wish people would stop accusing others of anti semitism without looking at what was actually said, rather than cherry picking words to suit their narrative. It wholly diminishes the harm that actual antisemitism causes.

samG76 · 15/08/2021 14:03

Exactly, the luggage - just like Livingstone. How strange that he so often finds himself talking about Hitler and Zionism, when he knows absolutely nothing about either, can't as far as I know speak a word of German or Hebrew, and seems to have obtained all his info on the subject from some obscure and controversial book written 40 years ago.

OhWhyNot · 15/08/2021 13:51

It’s baffling how so many on the left have been misunderstood and labelled as being anti Semitic

If only more Jewish people would listen to them and educate themselves on anti Semitism (and non Jewish people)

After all the righteous left knows what’s best for everyone they have a deeper understanding being so intellectual

Theluggage15 · 15/08/2021 13:36

Nice that Lerman sticks up for him, but many Jewish people think Loach is anti Semitic and it’s amazing how, if he isn’t anti Semitic that he getting into trouble for anti Semitism. How terribly unlucky and misunderstood he is.

samG76 · 15/08/2021 13:24

I have canvassed in most elections since 1987, including in white working class areas, and only twice has anyone raised the question of the Middle East on the doorstep. The problem with Corbyn/Loach/Livingstone and their allies isn't so much their views on the ME (though these are pretty repulsive, and involve giving a free pass to loads of racist and homophobic groups provided they oppose Israel) but that they are obsessed with the conflict and see everything through its lens. Blair, Cameron and May, although sympathetic to Israel, were not obsessed with the ME - they ran a broad church and had plenty of supporters who felt differently.

This is all the more ironic because there is arse all that Britain can do to alter the situation - both sides hate us for historical reasons. You would have thought it is better to go to the wall for something that you can actually influence....

tilder · 15/08/2021 13:18

Johnson delivered Brexit. And in the eyes of the majority he delivered the vaccine. The shit needs to hit the fan in a really big way for Brexiteers to go against him.

Starmer has a major uphill battle. Bitter infighting plus the Brexit/vaccine effect. I think he is making gradual inroads on the Corbyn infighting front (see Loach). Which is frankly dealing with a very vocal but small minority of the population. Who won't win an election.

Brexit and the vaccine? That gifted Boris a free ticket. People genuinely don't care about his lack of morals. Because Brexit.

Zotter · 15/08/2021 12:51

And, sadly it needs to be said, Labour's defeat in 2019 was extraordinary. Unparalleled in its history. To revers that loss and gain government would require a voting swing that has never been achieved previously. - Brexit definitely hugely contributed.

Starmer would be better than this government but I fear would not address the systemic issues ailing this country. Would still have him over this awful govt though.

Zotter · 15/08/2021 12:45

@Theluggage15

Loach is a nasty anti Semitic dickhead. The fact he made some tedious films does not give him a free pass on behaviour.
Anthony Lerman, Director of JPR (the Institute for Jewish Policy Research) before he retired, does not believe Loach is an anti semite as he writes here:

antonylerman.com/2020/03/24/flimsy-and-vindictive-the-case-against-ken-loach/

NannyAndJohn · 15/08/2021 12:13

I quit the Labour Party last year after Sir Starmer's pathetic response to Covid and the attacks on Corbyn.

Every day my decision is vindicated.

OhWhyNot · 15/08/2021 12:08

I agree sst1234

The Tory party are the most successful political party ever and there is a reason for this they are efficient in getting into power and they making changes regardless of what you think about the changes. They are also a party that will be flexible in their approach

Boris Johnson is still a vote winner at the moment so he will go when he wants to or when the party know they are onto a loser

That’s not happening right now. I had high hopes for Starmer I thought being almost opposite to Johnson would be helpful but I don’t think it’s is.

Labour could learn a lot from the Tory party but we don’t (last time we did was under Blair three consecutive terms but many on Labour don’t want to move to centre left so in opposition we stay)

And not too many on the left are living in a social media bubble how many times have I read that Boris Johnson is about to resign (an MN favourite)

Theluggage15 · 15/08/2021 12:01

Loach is a nasty anti Semitic dickhead. The fact he made some tedious films does not give him a free pass on behaviour.

thecatfromjapan · 15/08/2021 11:59

They really are worried about toppling Johnson.

I absolutely agree with you about the ruthless pragmatism.

It's basically why Johnson is still there despite a lot of the Party having deep, deep misgivings about him.

He is still seen as charmed, though - and a major factor in the 80-seat majority.

That's why leadership challenge rumblings come to nothing.

sst1234 · 15/08/2021 11:56

@thecatfromjapan

It is an incorrect assertion that the Tories are afraid to topple Johnson or that they have any regard for a leader. They simply do not follow the leadership cult that Labour do. Tories are a machine, they are in it to win it. Whether you agree with their policies or not, that is how politics should be done. They are effective at implementing what they want, that is the success criteria. Labour, in the main, over the last 100 years have been an amateur protest movement bar the few times they manage to get their act together to win. With the next crop of Tory leaders emerging, somehow I don’t think Starmer is going to stand chance vs Rishi and co. Though he is still a superficial improvement on Ref Corbin and his band of Marxist loons.

thecatfromjapan · 15/08/2021 11:44

The 'no policies' mantra is bizarre. MesBede has spelled out why there aren't policies at this stage of the election cycle.
Plus, as Labour members know, some policy is drawn from Conference - and we didn't have Conference last year because of the Pandemic.

Keir Starmer and the Labour Party are releasing - in verbal and written form - statements about the direction of travel.

None of its a surprise: plans for economic recovery that focus on social and economic equity; getting to grips with the social care problem (which is urgent); economic plans that focus on dealing with climate change; putting an emphasis on children (education and well-being).

It's all pretty obvious stuff, which I guess doesn't get the pulse racing.

Of course, one obvious point is that it's not being done by our present government.

And, sadly it needs to be said, Labour's defeat in 2019 was extraordinary. Unparalleled in its history. To revers that loss and gain government would require a voting swing that has never been achieved previously.

The media know this as well as I do. So media aren't making a big song and dance about Labour being 'on course for victory' because, statistically, it's not likely.

'Swing' media aren't going to swing behind Labour unless they sense that an absolutely unprecedented victory is around the corner.

And that is a significant factor in the lack of cut-through for Starmer.

It's tough - but that's the hand that's been dealt.

And, yes, it is a tragedy.

The 80-seat victory has definitely made this government worse. It's meant they're less worried about the next election and it's meant there's precious little in the way of checks and balances for what they do. And it's made the Conservative Party quite wary of toppling Johnson. And Johnson is a key element in why this government is so shockingly awful.

The 80-seat majority is a key factor in the issues Starmer is dealing with - and it's not helpful to pretend it doesn't exist. 🤷‍♀️

But, you know, there are many of us who know things could be better. We know that corruption on the level we're seeing is unacceptable. We know it's unusual to think it is acceptable to turn the pandemic into a money-making opportunity for mates.

Indeed, I'm pretty sure a lot of Conservatives feel that way.

So, yes, I'll be putting my shoulder to the wheel, and pushing on. I won't be spending my energy on delusion and undermining Labour.

People deserve better than that. And I know that Labour can deliver better.

I have no doubt Starmer would be a better PM than Johnson. I have no doubt that the U.K. would be a happier place, people more at ease with themselves, less fractured and oppositional, more cohesive and hopeful, with a Labour government.

For most of us, this government produces anxiety, worry about the future, worry about making ends meet, uncertainty about old age I'll-health. It's brought people turning against each other and a lot of barely-suppressed anger.

I'm afraid I really do want a government that seriously builds towards a future and a vision of that future that is fit for the C21. A future where the U.K. builds on its strengths as a technologically advanced, innovative and creative place. Where we are at the forefront of developing green technologies. And where we celebrate industries like our creative sector and world-class education.

I am tired of being fed a promise of us going into the C21 as a threadbare, moth-infested place of squalor for the many and grubby money-laundering and squalid tax-evasion for a tiny few. I'm tired of the greasy draining of moral standards in public life.

I always say this (because it's true): I really like the U.K. I'm proud of living here. And that is precisely why I can't bear what Johnson and co are doing.

There is absolutely no way on Earth Starmer wouldn't make a better PM.

And all the pinging on about 'lack of policies', 'not charismatic', etc is there to do one thing and one thing only: to distract people from the absolutely obvious point that Starmer would be a better PM and Labour would serve the U.K. better.

sst1234 · 15/08/2021 11:02

This thread alone shows that Labour has a lot of tearing itself apart to do yet, before it can move on from being a fringe joke. Magic grandpa and his band of socialist troopers may be gone, but some of the party membership still remain with their student politics bubble. Also the PLP is mostly made up of mediocre hangers on, offensive caricatures of the working class and career salary takers who probably couldn’t manage in the real world.
Never mind, it makes for good entertainment at least.

OhWhyNot · 15/08/2021 10:48

Stamer is killing off the Labour vote Hmm

It was under Corbyn that Labour lost areas that have been Labour for decades Corbyn and Co took their vote for granted didn’t bother listening to them as they knew what they wanted they know what the working class voters believed in

It’s incredible that people are still in denial to how much damage was done to Labour under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership. But let’s not forget they had the largest party membership and he was hero worshipped by them so all was fantastic in their title world

longwayoff · 15/08/2021 10:29

Couldn't agree more tilder. My bitterness comes from despair, if not Labour then what else? It's dreadful, fighting like cats in a sack whilst Bozza and his mates are stuffing the family silver under their coats before they leg it out of the window leaving the detritus for those that remain to pick over. I can't see a solution. Sacking Ken Loach is not the answer, it's simply a diversion away from focusing on the main issue. No leadership and no policies of note.

OP posts:
tilder · 15/08/2021 08:47

Labour is a tragedy. It makes me want to weep. Until it moves past Corbynism and into actual opposition, it has no chance of winning.

It is a very divided party trying to rebuild from a shattered base. So much infighting.

I still have no idea who I would vote for.

Tory? I would rather drink bleach. Morally corrupt.
Lib dem? Who?
Greens? Why would a woman vote for them? Too far left and have forgotten genuine environmental issues.

Come on labour. You can do better. You need to do better.

knittingaddict · 15/08/2021 08:38

I'm not a fan of Ken Loach and, from some of the posts on here, I'm happy to see him gone.

Langsdestiny · 15/08/2021 08:31

Yes it was the worst Tory election campaign I have ever seen and labour still didnt win.