Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the parent at home with the baby should do night feeds..

262 replies

bluevelvets · 14/08/2021 12:27

When other parent is working outside home from six am to four pm but then said parent takes over completely until bedtime ?

OP posts:
Lotusmonster · 14/08/2021 14:39

What’s it to you what other people ‘ought’ to do….🙄!!! Crikey. Mind your own beeswax.

Peanutsandchilli · 14/08/2021 14:28

I don't think it's necessarily wrong. Plenty of women do every feed when they're breastfeeding and it's fine. I guess it might be more tiring if you have to get up and make a bottle, rather than just whack a boob out, but it's got to be what works for the family.

User5827372728 · 14/08/2021 14:26

@DixonD

What if they have other kids so can’t catch up on sleep during the day?

Lalliella · 14/08/2021 14:22

YANBU. When I was on maternity leave I did every night time feed because I was breastfeeding. But even if I hadn’t been I would have some all the weekday ones, and maybe got DH to do one at the weekend. I was at home, I could rest during the day. DH has to be alert for his job.

Blondeshavemorefun · 14/08/2021 14:18

Varies what works

Yes the working parent could do the 6/7 bedtime feed and dream feed 10/11 then sleep weekdays till gets up for work

While at home parent sleeps 8/9 till baby wakes after df so 1/2/3am and does feeds and naps daytime

Then Saturday night working parent does the night shift and other gets full nights sleep

This obv only works if baby is mixed feeding or bottle only

How old is baby ? Broken nights won’t be forever, esp if baby in a routine

romany4 · 14/08/2021 14:17

The parent who will be home all day the next day should do the night feeds, as they can catch up on sleep in the day if they want.

Presuming your baby naps. Mine never did and I was awake every night breastfeeding.
DH would let me lie in at weekends to help me catch up on sleep.
Parent working out of the home should be doing this at weekends

twinningatlife · 14/08/2021 14:14

@YukoandHiro

I'm guessing you're the outside the home parent? Try doing the "inside the home" work for one day and then see how you feel about the idea of doing that on zero sleep endlessly

"Inside home work" come on?! Cooking, cleaning, childcare and general house hold duties does not require the same levels of decision making, concentrating or operating heavy machinery or same levels of responsibility as found in many jobs outside the home (I'm not saying all jobs before I'm accused of having something against STAHMs - I have a lot of respect for them)

Zilla1 · 14/08/2021 14:11

So one parent has seven days unbroken sleep a week even if they work outside the home 5 days a work if a traditional job and the other has seven days a week broken sleep. That might work for some voluntarily who can wake and sleep painlessly but seems an unsatisfactory starting point for allocating broken sleep between two parents.

Fullofglee · 14/08/2021 14:05

I think the person on maternity leave should do the majority of the night feeds that's why they are lucky to get leave in the UK unlike America. When we had our dc we were a team. I would express and go to bed early and dh would do the feed at 11 at night then I would do the two during, he was HGD and needed to sleep as he drives.

My sil has one baby and she has my bro doing the night feeds as he can only settle him, then up early in the morning 2 hours before he goes to work so 6.00 to go the gym and then he goes to work whilst she goes to groups, she then leaves baby with him so she has a break when he comes home. She also spends 2 days a week resting at her mother's house whilst she takes care of the baby, personally I think she takes the piss.

I had 2 under 3 and got on with it. At the weekends we each had a sleep in.

cadburyegg · 14/08/2021 14:04

It depends on individual circumstances. I breastfed both of mine so it made sense to do the feeds. DH did the nappy changes before the feeds, he could go straight back to sleep afterwards and it meant that I didn’t have to get out of bed. Both times I used to go to bed early on in the evening when they had their last feed, they’d settle on DH who would then bring baby up when he came to bed. I got a good few hours sleep that way. With DS2, DS1 would get up in the night occasionally and DH would get up with him in the night and when he woke in the morning, which was often 6am ish. “Lie ins” didn’t happen until DS2 was sleeping more solidly.

justlonelystars · 14/08/2021 14:01

Depends. My DS is EBF so I do all the night feeds. DH (who copes much better on less sleep than I do) changes all the nappies in the night though and cuddles him back to sleep if he needs it. Just do what works for you.

loulous1985 · 14/08/2021 14:00

@bluevelvets

I'm the sah parent and while I appreciate being able to switch off for three/ four hours every evening and do my own thing , I don't take the opportunity to sleep when baby sleeps during the day . I should . He doesn't function well without sleep and needs it to be productive . We share household 50/50

If you're the SAHP and you think the SAHP should be the one to do all the night wakings, which you are happy to do, what's the point of this thread? Confused

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/08/2021 13:59

It depends
What job the parent has outside the home.
How both parents cope on broken sleep
How well the baby sleeps

My husband helped me in the night even though I breastfed, sometimes he would take them for a long walk in the pram so I got some extra sleep. But then I had severe anaemia and a baby who woke up 7x a night every night and I literally wouldn't have coped if he hadnt. It's not really fair if one person gets ill through lack of sleep while the other carries on with sleeping normally in ky opinion

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 14/08/2021 13:57

Dh is able to fall asleep within seconds. After 3am I am wide awake if I am woken for any reason. Despite me being on a long maternity leave of a year with Ds1 we did shift pattern sleeping. 10-2am was me getting up with Ds as I was tired enough to fall back asleep. 2-6am was Dh. That way we both got at least a solid 4 hours of sleep every night.

If you have more than one child there is little chance they sleep at the same time during the day. The female who delivered the baby is also physically recovering from growing a baby inside her.

Parenting is shared, you work out what works well for you without either one feeling resentment. I know plenty of women who could have slept during the day but just couldn't drop off to sleep.

bobdidit · 14/08/2021 13:57

We did what worked for us. Husband used to do last feed at about 11.30 so I could go to bed about 9ish if needed. Then I would get up at 3 for the next feed and I would do the morning feed too. It meant we both got sleep

Goldbar · 14/08/2021 13:56

Also what about when the parent on maternity leave goes back to work? Are night wakings then going to be magically shared?

loulous1985 · 14/08/2021 13:56

@YukoandHiro

I'm guessing you're the outside the home parent? Try doing the "inside the home" work for one day and then see how you feel about the idea of doing that on zero sleep endlessly

This

loulous1985 · 14/08/2021 13:55

[quote KingdomScrolls]@loulous1985 that's your experience and it's a shame you don't have more support, but you can see a lot of people here don't feel the same way.
I didn't have an easy baby he liked to be held wouldn't sleep on his own, would randomly scream for hours, didn't sleep compartment through the night until after he was two, but walking with a pram listening to podcasts drinking coffee for hours or even pacing with a crying baby over and over were physically tiring and frustrating but I didn't find it mentally taxing. I can't visit a friend while I'm working, I can't get things done around the house , I could put DS in a sling and get in with things, or snuggle on the sofa in a cold rainy day, I could organise things and set reminders on my phone while he was feeding, I could rest when he did even if I couldn't sleep. I didn't have to get my brain into gear and go and deal with the adult world.

I don't think to write off working as a break is helpful for a couple and levels of resentment. The working parent absolutely should be fifty fifty when they are around, but to say as suggested in the OP they take over all parenting responsibilities when they walk through the door is unfair and diminishes the impact of being out at work all day.[/quote]

I didn't say they take over when they walk through the door. I said you do whatever works for your own family set up, and that for some people being at home with a baby is much, much harder than being at work for their own reasons

Goldbar · 14/08/2021 13:55

SAHPs/mums on maternity leave have to drive as well in many cases.

Would you want your older child being driven to school or your baby being driven places by a woman who hasn't slept for more than a few hours in months?

vivainsomnia · 14/08/2021 13:54

I agree with you too OP. Most jobs outside of home require a high level of concentration. Looking after a newborn doesn't. You go through the motions. The latter might be more emotionally demanding, although stressful job will probably beat it, but it really does come down to the need of concentration and the fact that the SAHP can indeed rest or even sleep with baby. This is not an option at all for the person working.

bluevelvets · 14/08/2021 13:52

I'm the sah parent and while I appreciate being able to switch off for three/ four hours every evening and do my own thing , I don't take the opportunity to sleep when baby sleeps during the day . I should . He doesn't function well without sleep and needs it to be productive . We share household 50/50

OP posts:
SunbathingDragon · 14/08/2021 13:52

@EgonSpengler2020

I'm a paramedic and have been driven around at high speed on 12 hour shifts by sleep deprived colleagues after they have been up in the night giving feeds whilst their partner is on maternity leave.

If one parent is working and one is on maternity/paternity leave then the working parent should not be attending work avoidably sleep deprived from caring for their infant at night.

Also been a paramedic after having a baby and it’s not that black and white.
Katefoster · 14/08/2021 13:52

My husbands a surgeon. There's no way hel be able to do the night feeds and go to work okay the next day so I'll be doing them all. I know on the weekends and evenings he'll help loads though. Itl be hard but we have no choice 🤷🏽‍♀️

EgonSpengler2020 · 14/08/2021 13:48

@MrsJBaptiste

Being at home for me was far easier than being at work!

I loved my 6 months of mat leave - baby groups, meeting friends for coffee, seeing my parents, shopping - I struggled to fit those things into the week when back at work.

Same here. I clearly choose the wrong profession.

I EBF and bed shared and my DD who wasn't and still isn't (at 3.5) a great sleeper. Even so I was never as tired with her as a newborn than I was whilst working a full time rotating shift pattern as a paramedic.

Fortunately when I returned to with I went back part time days only Grin

ReggaetonLente · 14/08/2021 13:48

I think you just need to work out what works best for you, so that no one is totally sleep deprived or resentful.

I do all the night wakings with the 2yo and the 3mo, but DH gets up with the 2yo before work (she's an early riser).

My brother shared nights with my SIL when their baby was born, despite her breastfeeding for 6 months. There is no right or wrong, we all cope with things differently.