Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the parent at home with the baby should do night feeds..

262 replies

bluevelvets · 14/08/2021 12:27

When other parent is working outside home from six am to four pm but then said parent takes over completely until bedtime ?

OP posts:
Blendabrethin · 14/08/2021 17:24

Confused no, working outside the home doesn't let you opt out of the hard parts of parenting. You share the sleepless nights. Everyone NEEDS a decent ammount of sleep.

The only caveat to this I think is if the stay at home parent does genuinely get to rest during the day e.g. if they have a baby that reliably naps long enough for them to also nap and no other children or commitments to take care of during that time.

Though this is all a bit hypocritical of me because I bf'd and did all night feeds but I co-slept and often got lie ins to boot.

SleepingStandingUp · 14/08/2021 17:17

@bluevelvets

I leave the house to go walking or meet family or friends .
Then yes. I think you should do nights.

Incidentally if you're out the house 3 or 4 hours every working day, and hes coming in from worm and doing baby / house for those hours, when does he get 15-20 hours to hang out with his mates / when do you actually spend time as a couple?

DrCoconut · 14/08/2021 16:59

It depends on the scenario. If the working parent is a eg a coach driver or a surgeon they have to concentrate harder than the person at home. Their job is harder work and they need decent sleep or there is a serious chance that someone could die to be blunt. Being at home with a baby doesn't carry that same level of risk (I'm not counting things like PND here) so it's reasonable to expect the at home person to do night feeds and rest when they can. If the working person has a relatively easy 9 to 5 office type job that's maybe different. Whatever, it's for each family to find what works.

Harpydragon · 14/08/2021 16:56

We tried me doing all the night feeds and it just didnt work for us. I couldn't sleep during the day and doing night feeds finished me off. It got to the point where I was unsafe. We ended up splitting the night, my husband did everything up to 3am and I did everything after. It felt like we were both getting a decent run of sleep and worked with our sleep patterns. Bit of a game changer for us

RealBecca · 14/08/2021 16:53

Funny how people, usually men, can go out partying or up half the noght watching tv or shit or their phones and get up for work the next day and hold down jobs but as soon as these things are swapped for childcare the dad needs 8 hours interrupted. Load of shit.

My partner did half the nights and we took naps at the weekend to top up.

Sceptre86 · 14/08/2021 16:50

I don't know many people who can function on very little sleep, especially for prolonged periods. I disagree with you and in my case my dh would do nights with the baby 3x a week so that I could feel more human. He would also take over when he got in largely but I wasn't just chilling out. I did the majority of the housework because I was home but at the weekend he would take over. It is a hard slog for both partners in the beginning and as long as you are both on the same page it shouldn't cause resentment.

it doesn't really matter what anyone else's set up is if you are happy with your own.

Goldbar · 14/08/2021 16:49

The thing that interests me is whether men who have done very little for their babies during maternity leave suddenly change their ways and split things 50/50 when the mum goes back to work.

Or is it just men who can't work full-time and care for children (including dealing with night wakings)?

8dpwoah · 14/08/2021 16:47

Bit difficult for the working parent to do night feeds if the at home parent is EBF, and I believe maternity leave is there for a reason so yes, I did all the night feeds with first and plan to with second. I used to go to bed about 8pm leaving a bottle of expressed milk just in case, I'd then just do the next wakeup whenever that happened after DP had gone to bed about 11pm. He used to have a bit of time with her before he went to work too so I could at least have a hot coffee and a shower before our day at home got going.

But as others have said, what works for on won't suit another.

bluevelvets · 14/08/2021 16:46

I leave the house to go walking or meet family or friends .

OP posts:
loulous1985 · 14/08/2021 16:43

@Thethuthinang

I did all the night feeds as I was working from home and breastfeeding while partner was working out. I also got super sick (mastitis, pneumonia) repeatedly due to sleep deprivation tanking my immune system. So in retrospect not the best.

Mastitis is absolutely awful, I've had repeated infections due to a shitty immune system.

Thethuthinang · 14/08/2021 16:39

I did all the night feeds as I was working from home and breastfeeding while partner was working out. I also got super sick (mastitis, pneumonia) repeatedly due to sleep deprivation tanking my immune system. So in retrospect not the best.

SleepingStandingUp · 14/08/2021 16:33

@bluevelvets

I'm the sah parent and while I appreciate being able to switch off for three/ four hours every evening and do my own thing , I don't take the opportunity to sleep when baby sleeps during the day . I should . He doesn't function well without sleep and needs it to be productive . We share household 50/50
Are you actually out of the way, switched off, not actively parenting for 4 hours every evening doing something you want though. Or are you making dinner. Cleaning up, changing nappies etc. I think of you're literally doing nothing towards parenting/house for 4 hours eveey day you should be doing night wakes
Tresal · 14/08/2021 15:47

It is different for every family. Depends on how many kids, how much the baby wakes up, breast fed or bottle fed, what job the other parent does, what hours they do etc.

Goldbar · 14/08/2021 15:44

I'm amazed at all these fathers who think it's fine for their wives/partners who may only have slept a couple of hours a night for months on end to drive their children around? Do they not care about their children's safety?

Most of us can deal with a couple of nights' broken sleep. It's the cumulative effect of night after night of never sleeping more than a few hours which destroys you. Imagine going through that and the person who is meant to love you and have your back just lets you endure it and does nothing.

RobynRedHead · 14/08/2021 15:19

@DixonD

I agree with you OP. Why should the parent who is going to work have to get up in the night? The parent who will be home all day the next day should do the night feeds, as they can catch up on sleep in the day if they want. Why anyone would think otherwise is quite frankly selfish and beyond me. Would anyone really want their other half driving when sleep deprived?

I did every single night feed for ours. I wouldn’t have it any other way; I certainly did not feel aggrieved because my husband didn’t do any. He was going off to work the next day.

And even more shocking, I did all the housework and cooked him dinner for when he got home! 🤣

Do sahp never drive anywhere then? Hmm
miltonj · 14/08/2021 15:13

Unless one of the parents is a surgeon though... it's probably important that they sleep!

miltonj · 14/08/2021 15:12

Both parents need to do their fair share. The parent looking after the baby all day will be just as knackered as the one who goes out to work... even more so if they're doing all the nights.

stillcrazyafterall · 14/08/2021 15:11

I did week night feeds, DH did weekends. Worked for us. That's all that matters.

PizzaCrust · 14/08/2021 15:03

In that scenario the SAHP would do the night feeds every night their partner is working, and then the days off they have the working partner would do them. Any annual leave would be an equal split.

If you start work at 6am you’d probably be getting up at 5, if not earlier, so it would be incredibly unfair to have them up when they’re probably not getting a whole lot of sleep. Plus even if your baby doesn’t sleep during the day, you can still sit on the sofa and “switch off” a bit as opposed to being in work.

I’m all for 50:50 parenting but someone going to work that early not getting ample sleep is a dangerous situation if it wasn’t a very short term thing (ie one or two nights)

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 14/08/2021 15:02

Really depends on the family. Parent at home isn’t sat around all day doing nothing. When I had a newborn and an 18 month old my husband and I took turns to get up in the night as he recognised that I needed to get some sleep to be able to function and look after both children during the day.

illuyankas · 14/08/2021 15:00

I was a sahp, and I co slept with my dc. The night feed was a breeze. I never felt like I had no sleep, baby wakes up, fed him in bed(ebf), back to sleep.

Who does the night didn't even come up as convo. But if I didn't ebf, still I would have done the night feed, since dh would be going to work without proper sleep if he did, while I can have a nap with baby if I wanted to.

JaggedLittlePilI · 14/08/2021 15:00

@bluevelvets

I'm the sah parent and while I appreciate being able to switch off for three/ four hours every evening and do my own thing , I don't take the opportunity to sleep when baby sleeps during the day . I should . He doesn't function well without sleep and needs it to be productive . We share household 50/50
I take it this is your first child? Not sure if you want our support or if you are stating what you think all families should do, but your OP came across as the latter. Funnily enough, life is different for different people and different ways of doing things work in different households. Given that a SAHP with older children can't sleep during the day, suggesting that that parent never have a full night's sleep for potentially a year or more won't go down well with everyone. It's also interesting that men (well it's usually men) can't possibly be expected to hold down a job on anything less than a perfect night's sleep, and yet many women end up working whilst still breastfeeding through the night when their maternity leave ends.
HoppingPavlova · 14/08/2021 14:57

I think it’s situational. Think if you were in the situation your child had a brain tumour, was having long complex surgery and beforehand the neurosurgeon (either female or male) says ‘I’m a bit shattered, was up all night with the baby’, you would probably think WTAF. Of course a neurosurgeon would not say this but you get the point. Same if it was a long distance truck driver or any other occupation where it could be dangerous/fatal if the person was not well rested to do their job. To be fair, it’s a minority of jobs but I would never jump in with a 50/50 rule without knowing what either parent had on the next day.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 14/08/2021 14:51

I didn’t expect DH to do any when he had work the next day and we split the weekend a night each. The person home isn’t working so much easier for them.

Neverrains · 14/08/2021 14:49

There isn’t any ‘should’ about it Confused. Each family can choose what’s right for them.
I did most of the night feeds. If I was on my knees with exhaustion DH would do some so I could get some sleep. I find any arrangement where one parent is expected to survive on very little sleep while the other has uninterrupted nights us a bit ‘off’, but each to their own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread