Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling to Coe to terms with shooting in plymouth

293 replies

Thomasina79 · 14/08/2021 08:30

Not an AIBU I know, I’m sure we all are. This was a misogynistic man who identified as an ‘incel’. I’ve never heard of this phrase, but this man”s attitudes to women are common enough. Ok he hated his mum, not unusual, but no reason to kill her. But why kill the others, especially the child? This is all so sad and shocking and it seems that violence against women is becoming so prevalent again.

OP posts:
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 14/08/2021 11:54

It does really upset me when male violence by white males in specific is put down to "troubled family life" etc. and people trying to "understand" and sympathise with him.

I still haven't got past the same happening about male family annihilators, especially that utter fucking bastard teacher in Ireland who wiped out his whole family, Alan Hawe. Oh how they went on about his "depression" and how his state of mind caused him to sink into psychosis, the poor man - how he had been caught masturbating to porn at school (probably) and was addicted to porn, which caused "troubles in his marriage" - fuck OFF. He was a narcissistic prick who cared only about his social standing and his porn habit. And he killed his wife and sons because of it. Not cleanly, either. I truly hope there is a hell and he is in it. Same with all these bastards.

oakleaffy · 14/08/2021 11:51

@LemonSwan

Incel is a pity party.

An acquaintance I know calls himself Incel. Its very sad. He has convinced himself he will never get a girlfriend, never get a job, never move out.

He is very clever and a very high achiever at school, but was never one of the 'cool' kids.

I cant see him being top of the list for one night stand but he would be an ideal long term partner for many women. He is interesting, considerate and kind.

Its a real shame. Its like they are scared of failure so never try. They become too fragile and either just give up, or move to the bitterness and anger this shooter had.

Theres no solution. Only they can sort their lives out.

Reading Elliot Rodger's ''Manifesto'' after he went on a murderous rampage , it was a clear the {American} Police failed there, too.

Rodger had a police visit, his house was full of ammo and guns, but he was able to get away be seemingly being passive, polite and well spoken.

He then murdered innocent people.

Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 11:48

@NorthernStarss

Utterly lost for words.
His first paragraph is disgusting. His second raises a valid point.

The monsters are telling us why. Do we listen?

oakleaffy · 14/08/2021 11:47

Michael Ryan...Our dad used to get served by him when Ryan worked in a local shop, and no way could anyone have known he'd have gone on a massacre.
These 'Incels' are obviously mentally ill.
Why kill innocent people?
It just doesn't make sense.

Elliot Rodger was the same, but Rodger had done nasty things like pushing a girl off a wall out of anger beforehand.

His parents paid for counselling, but it did no good.

Antwerpen · 14/08/2021 11:46

@NewlyGranny

Of course there's a sense in which every killer must be "crazy" to breach our society's boundaries around harming other people, but it's not helpful to blame a case like this in mental illness, is it? One in ten of us - or probably more - are mentally ill at some point in our lives, but we mostly don't go on the rampage. If people suffer mental illness it doesn't mean they are potential mass murderers who should be treated as pariahs.

This man radicalised himself online and he was given back his weapon and licence by the police.

His grossly entitled attitude to women in particular and the depth of his resentment towards the ones who weren't flinging off their clothes to gratify him sexually are part of the porn-sick culture that has sprung up in the last 20 years or so.

I do see his actions as misogynist terrorism fuelled by online hate sites. It's as if we were breeding our own Taliban from among the population.

Very well said
Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 11:45

@Auntienumber8 Like many I’ve followed developments around legislation of the internet, initially I fell on the side of protecting it as it was, but as time has gone on I’ve changed my view quite dramatically. I think it’s clear that society isn’t capable of self regulation and it’s basically a lawless wasteland doing immeasurable harm.

I don’t see another way to manage it other than with restrictive legislation and access unfortunately. Certainly not in its current form.

NorthernStarss · 14/08/2021 11:43

Utterly lost for words.

Struggling to Coe to terms with shooting in plymouth
Flowers500 · 14/08/2021 11:41

@Flowers500

Incels don't just want to have sex with women, they actively want to ABUSE them. That's the thing--read the quotes from his posts above.

He wants to be a powerful man ("Chad") who can rape his wife and get away with it, not a "Betabux" (weak man who financially supports his family) whose wife would call the police if he raped her. He wants to get 16 year olds knocked up so he can give their daughters to other incels. There is regular discussion of violence towards women, like hitting them and how they should submit in relationships.

But it's not just about womenincels have a world view of there being powerful men (Chads and Tyrones) who demonstrate their power by having beautiful women that they abuse. They aspire to be Chadseither by being "redpillers" who work on improving themselves/harassing women to try to get takers, or "blackpillers" who give up and decide they can't get women anyway
godmum56 · 14/08/2021 11:41

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

hahahahahahahahaha you don't know me and yet you judge me. Why am I not surprised?

Because you hate women. HTH.

and again how do you know that?
Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 11:41

It's not about the fact that Priti Patel is brown but the fact that Begum is brown

Dear God - seriously? Can you walk and talk at the same time?

Casiloco · 14/08/2021 11:39

GuyFawkesDay

Yup- nailed it.

Flowers500 · 14/08/2021 11:38

Incels don't just want to have sex with women, they actively want to ABUSE them. That's the thing--read the quotes from his posts above.

He wants to be a powerful man ("Chad") who can rape his wife and get away with it, not a "Betabux" (weak man who financially supports his family) whose wife would call the police if he raped her. He wants to get 16 year olds knocked up so he can give their daughters to other incels. There is regular discussion of violence towards women, like hitting them and how they should submit in relationships.

EmeraldShamrock · 14/08/2021 11:38

Shocking news, the innocent victims.
I know MH is taboo and you can't discriminate against a gun licence.
I'd heard of incle tosh before it's dangerous how they commicate online their hatred view online.
We need dedicated Internet police.
Sick bastard shooting a DC pushing her dolls pram.

Auntienumber8 · 14/08/2021 11:37

The Incel movement has been around for a while now, fuelled by online media. Men like this have always existed but they have platforms fuelling each other anonymously. They have a poster boy, for a while an American who went on a murder spree.

As much as the internet can be a force for good, seeing women get help and people telling them about the Freedom programme on here for example . Overall I wonder if the extreme negative effects outweigh the good. As a junior researcher when microfiche and looking through books of bound journals was the norm I really welcomed and embraced the web in its fledgling form back in the early 1990’s. But the damage it does. Forums for the disaffected, porn, child sex abuse images so easily shared, body issues, competitive lifestyles. I think I preferred life before the web.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 14/08/2021 11:37

@Blossomtoes

The fact Priti Patel is Home Secretary does not disprove the fact that our government, society, and media still has huge problems with race and misogyny

Of course it doesn’t. It does disprove the brown and female argument though. The person who could repatriate the brown and female Begun is the brown and female Home Secretary who has chosen not to do so. The Home Secretary who removed her British passport is also brown. Race isn’t automatically at the heart of every issue, despite the current tendency to try and shoehorn it in wherever possible.

It's not about the fact that Priti Patel is brown but the fact that Begum is brown
leonpride · 14/08/2021 11:35

@Blossomtoes

I think we know the answer to that unfortunately, given Begum is brown and female and Davison is white and male

That argument really doesn’t hold water when we’ve got a Home Secretary who is brown and female.

Poor Shamima was wrongly labelled a terrorist for being brownConfused

The problem here is people not taking white/male killers/Terrorists seriously, not brown terrorists being called terrorists

Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 11:35

@Meltinthemiddle, the incel movement isn’t just about women. Women are one of their primary focuses but ultimately it’s a group who blame society for how they feel and believe that they are powerless because of anyone who isn’t like them. It’s the ultimate perpetual victim mindset.

Tbh I’m not even sure that it’s right that a solution for that would come under mental health, it’s a complete re-education in life that’s needed.

The PREVENT programme basically works on the idea that identifying those most at risk of radicalisation can be brainwashed and manipulated to function within the confines of society before someone else gets to them. It’s not a comfortable thought, but ultimately that’s probably what’s needed in cases like these.

It’s not mental health per se, it’s not a chemical imbalance, it’s not going to be cured with suppression through medication and it’s unlikely traditional counselling will be successful once someone is deeply entrenched.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 14/08/2021 11:35

hahahahahahahahaha you don't know me and yet you judge me. Why am I not surprised?

Because you hate women. HTH.

CantSayJack · 14/08/2021 11:35

The sympathy towards this fuck up is unreal. Posters get a grip.
He was a murdering piece of shit, a terrorist. Shut up with this “incel” crap, making excuses for the low-life.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 14/08/2021 11:34

This is someone who needed help and didn't get it which left him vulnerable and trying to find help in the wrong places. I don't think this was an attack on women he didn't specifically shoot at women let's not make it about that.

Fuck that - we absolutely make it about women, he was an incel.

His mum tried to get him MH help, but you can't force a person to help themselves.

When do we actually expect someone who's murdered a toddler to take personal responsibility. The blame culture we live in is terrifying, and absconding people of their actions this way serves nobody at all.

wheresmymojo · 14/08/2021 11:33

I find it a bit odd that we spend so much time arguing between ourselves as to whether it's mental health issues, incel ideology or whatever that's the cause.

Human beings are complex.

There is no 'one' root cause.

It can be absolutely true that...

  • He was driven by incel ideology and
  • He was very sad, lonely and needed help and
  • He had MH issues and had received no support and
  • Had an alcoholic, violent father and witnessed abuse and
  • He was an entitled misogynistic arsehole.

There's no point arguing about which of these is the real reason he went on to kill people because it the mix of all of them that led him to that path.

It's rare because if any one of these factors was missing his life (and that of his victims) would have turned out differently.

buzzy06 · 14/08/2021 11:32

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

As a side note isn't it interesting that sympathy for terrorists was never extended to Shamima Begum who was groomed, recruited and impregnated as a teenage girl and despite being a British Citizen has not been allowed to come home.

Yet a white boy who couldn't get laid and it's all "Oh bless him he seemed sad"

Stamina is scum like this guy, nobody should feel bad for either.

NovemberRain2 · 14/08/2021 11:32

@jasminoide

I'm so bloody infuriated that people/the media are trying to "understand" his motivations, him being labelled as "lonely" etc. If he was brown he'd simply be called a terrorist, which he is in my book.
This 100%
buzzy06 · 14/08/2021 11:31

@Lockheart

Empathy, not sympathy. Everyone gets that's he's sad, lonely, angry. In no way should we feel sympathy. It's easy to sit here and feel sorry, but imagine actually witnessing what happened, or being one of the relatives, and people are concerned with the killer's circumstances

It is possible to feel sympathy or empathy for more than one person at the same time.

Also, let's remember this guy would've killed you, too. I am always dumbfounded when people feel bad for terrorists and mass murderers who kill completely indiscriminately and with zero remorse

Of course he would have killed me too. He would have killed my mother and my family and my friends, and you. Therefore it's in my (and your) interest to argue for a society that catches these people early and provides them with robust support so that you and I don't become victims.

That's literally what I said. They can be supported beforehand. I don't have sympathy for a crazed killer, though. That's when most people's sympathy goes out the window.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 11:29

The fact Priti Patel is Home Secretary does not disprove the fact that our government, society, and media still has huge problems with race and misogyny

Of course it doesn’t. It does disprove the brown and female argument though. The person who could repatriate the brown and female Begun is the brown and female Home Secretary who has chosen not to do so. The Home Secretary who removed her British passport is also brown. Race isn’t automatically at the heart of every issue, despite the current tendency to try and shoehorn it in wherever possible.