Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling to Coe to terms with shooting in plymouth

293 replies

Thomasina79 · 14/08/2021 08:30

Not an AIBU I know, I’m sure we all are. This was a misogynistic man who identified as an ‘incel’. I’ve never heard of this phrase, but this man”s attitudes to women are common enough. Ok he hated his mum, not unusual, but no reason to kill her. But why kill the others, especially the child? This is all so sad and shocking and it seems that violence against women is becoming so prevalent again.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 14:44

@Meltinthemiddle

Early invention is definitely the key and ensuring they have a place and purpose in society, so they are not vulnerable to these disgusting groups.
As I said previously, this already is happening in theory. What it isn’t is particularly effective because identifying and re-educating a person is a politically unpopular move.

To implement an effective strategy would mean working around many privacy and autonomy issues. We like the technology but not the responsibilities that come with it or the methods it can be policed by.

Re-education also isn’t popular since it’s basically brainwashing and peoples automatics reaction is that this is a ‘bad thing’.

Mental health provision, even at its very best, doesn’t compensate for someone’s basic beliefs or motivations because those aren’t mental health illnesses.

There is no easy answer and very few difficult ones.

ChiefInspectorParker · 14/08/2021 14:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Meltinthemiddle · 14/08/2021 14:37

Early invention is definitely the key and ensuring they have a place and purpose in society, so they are not vulnerable to these disgusting groups.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 14/08/2021 14:29

@Blossomtoes

You do Understand these things are solely at the discretion of the Home Secretary don't you?

Yes, which is kind of my entire point.

Mine should have read "are NOT" 🤦🏼‍♀️
Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 14:25

@Iloveginger

*Its no comfort to anyone that he didn't only target women. Incels target women, and men who are 'successful' with women - husbands and fathers. Thats why he shot the Dad carrying his daughter.* From the limited information available, the people he shot after his mother were random people that had the misfortune to cross his path. It seems to be a have started off as a domestic incident, not an incel fuelled rage against women.
An incel fuelled domestic incident. His posts are earlier in this thread. He hated his mother for being old and ugly and only having old, ugly friends with no teenage daughters to set him up with.
WorldsBestBoss · 14/08/2021 14:25

@LoislovesStewie

I suspect that I am in a minority, but if he had a learning disability (ASD?) , or a personality disorder or undiagnosed psychiatric condition, then he has been let down. Yes, what he did was horrendous, my heart goes out to the deceased and their families. I admit quite freely that I cried when I saw that a 3-year-old had been killed. But I also feel that something catastrophic has happened to the perpetrator in his life; we don't KNOW what that might be, but I hope that over time there are some answers. If he does have a learning disability, and he does, by some reports, seem to have attended a special school when young, then that might give some clues. I can only tell you about my son, who has an ASD. He was badly bullied at school, and despite what he told the teachers, he was labelled the perpetrator of the bullying. He would sit all day with people doing awful things to him and when he lashed out he was punished. it seems that because the bullies were female or from an ethnic minority, they were deemed to be incapable of being bullies. Eventually, a well respected teacher saw the whole of an episode of bullying, and that stopped the bullies in their tracks. He was then seen, quite rightly, as the victim, but oh my god, did it take a long time! As a consequence of this my DS has been left with severe anxiety, I have spent the last 2 years trying to get some help, we were just getting somewhere when the pandemic hit, so we are back to square one. And I won't even start on the knock-on effects to the rest of the family. It seems almost impossible to get any serious help, waiting lists are just ridiculous and from where I am standing mental health services have always been a Cinderella service. When people with learning disabilities leave education, it seems that too often they are abandoned. No-one wants to know. Why am I saying this? Because we don't know what was happening; we don't know if the shooter has himself suffered. We don't know if he had some psychotic episode, we don't know if he just wanted to end his life and go out with some infamy. We don't know if he was evil or ill. Of course, he shouldn't go out and kill 2 men,2 women and a toddler. I am not defending his actions, but perhaps we should understand that there many people who don't fit into the model of society that we have, and they don't get any help either. I know all of this is a long, probably incoherent ramble. It's clearly my own frustration coming out, but I do think I might have a bit of insight into why some people just snap. Instead of condemning him, I want to await some answers from the professionals who should have dealt with him.
@LoislovesStewie

I hear you. I have seen first hand how things can unfold in families with SEN children with lack of support.

My DC has been on the CAMHS waiting list for coming up to 2 years. There has been NO contact from them or anyone else during this time, only one letter to say that the waiting lists are very long. The only children being seen are those that have already attempted suicide or harmed themselves or others. I feel that by this time it's too late for a lot of kids. Early intervention is key. But also looking at why as society we are in this situation.

Hope things are better for your family x

Flowers500 · 14/08/2021 14:21

That’s not quite true—the times was reporting his neighbours saying he hated dogs, hence why he went for the pensioner with the dogs. He passed others that he ignored. It was semi-random yes but not completely

WorldsBestBoss · 14/08/2021 14:15

@EastWestWhosBest

I think the problem is that the incel movement hasn’t been taken seriously.

You have a young person who feels that they are weird and wrong. Like they don’t fit in. They don’t fit the social norms.
In the past they would have either changed as they matured and found their place or always been that slightly odd person that you know.
The problem is that now they go online and find groups of people that tell them that they aren’t weird or odd. That the whole of society that is wrong , not them.
For the first time they find companionship and belonging.
Remember this man was 22, he hadn’t just joined these groups last week. It’s not like this had only been a month. He’d certainly felt this way since school.
He was radicalised by this group. These people told him that the way he felt was acceptable and that doing what he did was the best answer.

It is no different to someone who is a follower of a religion/political group going online and finding people who reinforce the way they feel, encouraging them to take the next step.
They feel they don’t fit, no one understands. Then they find a group online who listens to them.

The incel movement is as serious as extremist religious or political views, as can be seen through what this man did.
It should be taken as seriously.

We have seen cases where people have posted much less ‘controversial’ views and have had a knock on the door from the police. Yet you can have groups like this encouraging and inciting violence which no one seems to have noticed.

This is spot on.

We need to get to these people before they start to feel weird/wrong/don't fit in and look at the reasons why they feel this way.

Meltinthemiddle · 14/08/2021 14:14

Apart from his mother those people were in the wrong place at the wrong time. We don't even know what led up to that attack. I just wish I hadn't read the details leading up to the little girls death in the Paper this morning. The media are just awful and literally have no respect for their families.

Iloveginger · 14/08/2021 14:01

Its no comfort to anyone that he didn't only target women.
Incels target women, and men who are 'successful' with women - husbands and fathers. Thats why he shot the Dad carrying his daughter.

From the limited information available, the people he shot after his mother were random people that had the misfortune to cross his path.
It seems to be a have started off as a domestic incident, not an incel fuelled rage against women.

tsmainsqueeze · 14/08/2021 14:00

@Balonzette

It seems from the videos posted of the killer that he felt desperately lonely, insecure, unloved, unwanted, and rejected. He felt like a failure and felt unlovable and physically disgusting. His father was also apparently a violent criminal so had didn't have that positive male role model. He seems like a really sad young man who desperately needed mental health support and treatment which his mother had been trying to get for him but which unfortunately is barely available anymore in the UK. The incel movement seems to attract people like this - they're just very unwell and/or very unhappy and this movement attracts them. I am in NO way excusing what he did, but rather trying to understand it. When someone reaches such a low, and has become so full of pain, which turns to rage and hatred, they are capable of awful, evil things. It's horrific. If we had adequate mental health care and resources in the UK, maybe his mother could have got him the help he needed long before he got to this point 😢
I completely agree with this, but despite this how on earth could anyone be so full of hate to kill an innocent 3 year old pushing her dolls pram ?
Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 13:57

Thats why he shot the Dad carrying his daughter.

I disagree. He shot anyone and everyone he came across indiscriminately. He shot a middle aged guy walking two dogs and a pensioner. He just didn’t care who it was.

Thelnebriati · 14/08/2021 13:54

@AlternativePerspective

He was a psycho.

I have no idea about this movement he was apparently part of, but it’s worth remembering that he didn’t only kill females.

Whatever he was a part of, he made this decision for himself, not for others, and the only positive thing to come out of it is that he’s dead.

Its no comfort to anyone that he didn't only target women. Incels target women, and men who are 'successful' with women - husbands and fathers. Thats why he shot the Dad carrying his daughter.
Meltinthemiddle · 14/08/2021 13:51

@LoislovesStewie

I suspect that I am in a minority, but if he had a learning disability (ASD?) , or a personality disorder or undiagnosed psychiatric condition, then he has been let down. Yes, what he did was horrendous, my heart goes out to the deceased and their families. I admit quite freely that I cried when I saw that a 3-year-old had been killed. But I also feel that something catastrophic has happened to the perpetrator in his life; we don't KNOW what that might be, but I hope that over time there are some answers. If he does have a learning disability, and he does, by some reports, seem to have attended a special school when young, then that might give some clues. I can only tell you about my son, who has an ASD. He was badly bullied at school, and despite what he told the teachers, he was labelled the perpetrator of the bullying. He would sit all day with people doing awful things to him and when he lashed out he was punished. it seems that because the bullies were female or from an ethnic minority, they were deemed to be incapable of being bullies. Eventually, a well respected teacher saw the whole of an episode of bullying, and that stopped the bullies in their tracks. He was then seen, quite rightly, as the victim, but oh my god, did it take a long time! As a consequence of this my DS has been left with severe anxiety, I have spent the last 2 years trying to get some help, we were just getting somewhere when the pandemic hit, so we are back to square one. And I won't even start on the knock-on effects to the rest of the family. It seems almost impossible to get any serious help, waiting lists are just ridiculous and from where I am standing mental health services have always been a Cinderella service. When people with learning disabilities leave education, it seems that too often they are abandoned. No-one wants to know. Why am I saying this? Because we don't know what was happening; we don't know if the shooter has himself suffered. We don't know if he had some psychotic episode, we don't know if he just wanted to end his life and go out with some infamy. We don't know if he was evil or ill. Of course, he shouldn't go out and kill 2 men,2 women and a toddler. I am not defending his actions, but perhaps we should understand that there many people who don't fit into the model of society that we have, and they don't get any help either. I know all of this is a long, probably incoherent ramble. It's clearly my own frustration coming out, but I do think I might have a bit of insight into why some people just snap. Instead of condemning him, I want to await some answers from the professionals who should have dealt with him.
You've summed it up perfectly.
thedancingbear · 14/08/2021 13:48

Women are not responsible for the actions of men.

But on what basis is anyone responsible for the actions of any other of us?

BringBackThinEyebrows · 14/08/2021 13:46

@NorthernStarss

Utterly lost for words.
That Tweet is stupid beyond belief.

The murderer had stated that he'd had opportunities with girls who were interested when he was slightly younger but HE had a 'mental block'. He was angry that he didn't have access to girls in the past few years due to working in a male-dominated environment. He wrote online that he didn't like his mum because she was 'untidy' and he wasn't sexually attracted to her friends. There is absolutely nothing to suggest he was ever mistreated by women or girls. Quite the opposite.

Women are not responsible for the actions of men.

Zilla1 · 14/08/2021 13:46

@LoislovesStewie it wasnt incoherent and sorry to hear about your DC's experience. Hope they are doing better. I think to some PPs, there is no difference between understanding and excuses. IME, those people tend to be the most judgmental and have least insight into themselves.

EastWestWhosBest · 14/08/2021 13:46

The internet companies can very easily pick i looked at a sofa and bombard me with adverts from DFS but if i join extreme right wing misogynistic groups, they powerless to do anything about that????

The internet companies don’t care.
The police should care but they don’t. That’s the problem. They didn’t recognise this group as being a threat. They just thought they were a bunch of sad sack men whining about shit. The man involved here posted videos on YouTube and comments on Reddit. Hardly the ‘dark web’. Not exactly some underground dusty corner of the internet.

Meltinthemiddle · 14/08/2021 13:44

But why do males commit more violent crimes then females? Why are they statistically more likely to commit suicide then women? I work with really young children aged 2 upwards and most of the behaviour we see is from boys. The anger and aggression. The lashing out rather then communicating. I see teenage boys behave the same, where girls can vocalise their feelings more.

thedancingbear · 14/08/2021 13:44

^I don’t understand why people can’t see what’s staring them in the face.

MALE VIOLENCE.

Mental health or lack thereof plays a part but women don’t go on killing sprees; we don’t terrorise, injure and kill our partners at horrifying rates; I can think of one family annihilation case in the US where a lesbian couple killed themselves and all their children but generally women are not family annihilators.

There are so many women on MN who have or are suffering DV, it’s truly shocking.

Male violence is the problem. Men need to start taking responsibility for it at every level - in the pub, in schools, online, at work, in the police, in government.^

What about this feller. Does he need to take 'more responsibility' for Jake Davison's behaviour? He was killed shielding his adopted daughter (apologies for the Sun link): www.thesun.co.uk/news/15865238/brave-lee-martyn-died-shielding-daughter-jake-davison-plymouth/

I know I'll be accused of NAMALTing. But can we please remember that two of Davison's victims were male, and one of them died a hero. The victims will have male relatives who are grieving. They had done nothing to deserve this.

Male violence is a problem but the vast majority of men are no more or less perfect than you and I, and have little or no individual capacity to stop someone going postal like this. Most men will be shocked and horrified, the same as you. A Man Bad-based rant disrespects the male victims, and moves us nowhere forward.

LoislovesStewie · 14/08/2021 13:43

I suspect that I am in a minority, but if he had a learning disability (ASD?) , or a personality disorder or undiagnosed psychiatric condition, then he has been let down. Yes, what he did was horrendous, my heart goes out to the deceased and their families. I admit quite freely that I cried when I saw that a 3-year-old had been killed. But I also feel that something catastrophic has happened to the perpetrator in his life; we don't KNOW what that might be, but I hope that over time there are some answers.
If he does have a learning disability, and he does, by some reports, seem to have attended a special school when young, then that might give some clues.
I can only tell you about my son, who has an ASD. He was badly bullied at school, and despite what he told the teachers, he was labelled the perpetrator of the bullying. He would sit all day with people doing awful things to him and when he lashed out he was punished. it seems that because the bullies were female or from an ethnic minority, they were deemed to be incapable of being bullies. Eventually, a well respected teacher saw the whole of an episode of bullying, and that stopped the bullies in their tracks. He was then seen, quite rightly, as the victim, but oh my god, did it take a long time! As a consequence of this my DS has been left with severe anxiety, I have spent the last 2 years trying to get some help, we were just getting somewhere when the pandemic hit, so we are back to square one. And I won't even start on the knock-on effects to the rest of the family. It seems almost impossible to get any serious help, waiting lists are just ridiculous and from where I am standing mental health services have always been a Cinderella service. When people with learning disabilities leave education, it seems that too often they are abandoned. No-one wants to know.

Why am I saying this? Because we don't know what was happening; we don't know if the shooter has himself suffered. We don't know if he had some psychotic episode, we don't know if he just wanted to end his life and go out with some infamy. We don't know if he was evil or ill. Of course, he shouldn't go out and kill 2 men,2 women and a toddler. I am not defending his actions, but perhaps we should understand that there many people who don't fit into the model of society that we have, and they don't get any help either.
I know all of this is a long, probably incoherent ramble. It's clearly my own frustration coming out, but I do think I might have a bit of insight into why some people just snap. Instead of condemning him, I want to await some answers from the professionals who should have dealt with him.

Ghislainedefeligonde · 14/08/2021 13:42

I think male violence and the violent misogynistic porn that younger men take to be normal sexual encounters are a big part of the growing incel movement.
And the fact that we can’t name misogyny as a hate crime, which it clearly is.
This added to the institutionalised racism in our media (poor, lonely sad man etc) all contributes to these angry entitled white men resorting to killing sprees.
I don’t feel in the least bit sorry for that man, it’s his victims and his family we should be thinking about

jasjas1973 · 14/08/2021 13:39

@Meltinthemiddle

Agree without any hope or a path anyone can become vulnerable to these groups. A place where they are understood, listened to and accepted.
The internet companies can very easily pick i looked at a sofa and bombard me with adverts from DFS but if i join extreme right wing misogynistic groups, they powerless to do anything about that????

Men murder 2 women a week in the UK, in a domestic setting, been going on for years.... absolutely nothing is being done about it.

So what society has told men is its ok to abuse and kill women, indeed its normalised -so jeez you can even get away with killing your partner by saying it was rough sex that went wrong and accidently strangled her FFS :(

ChiefInspectorParker · 14/08/2021 13:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 13:21

You do Understand these things are solely at the discretion of the Home Secretary don't you?

Yes, which is kind of my entire point.

Struggling to Coe to terms with shooting in plymouth