Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling to Coe to terms with shooting in plymouth

293 replies

Thomasina79 · 14/08/2021 08:30

Not an AIBU I know, I’m sure we all are. This was a misogynistic man who identified as an ‘incel’. I’ve never heard of this phrase, but this man”s attitudes to women are common enough. Ok he hated his mum, not unusual, but no reason to kill her. But why kill the others, especially the child? This is all so sad and shocking and it seems that violence against women is becoming so prevalent again.

OP posts:
Furries · 14/08/2021 10:02

@wherethewildthingis

Let's not latch onto the potential for mental health issues being a reason for this. That is not known, its just speculation at this point from a neighbour. In any case these "mentally unwell" violent males who take lives in this way never lose control and attack a group of large, burly men who can fight back, do they? No. They go for women and children. Or they also use a gun, like this one did, to make sure those they kill cannot defend themselves. It's internalised mysoginism that makes us leap to "he must have been unwell". No-we need to recognise that these types of men are actually common and they do what they do because they choose to. No other reason
This.

My life probably hasn’t turned out as expected. And I’m sure that’s the same for a hell of a lot of women. Funnily enough, we don’t tend to go around abusing, beating the crap out of, or killing people. Yes, I am aware that there are some cases of abuse by women - but it is nowhere near the scale of acts carried out by men. And I’m sick of the mental health “excuse” given to men.

With regards to the incel movement - it’s definitely more than just a few thousand men whinging online.

AbsolutelyPatsy · 14/08/2021 10:02

@Iloveginger

I watched some of his YouTube videos before they were taken down. He was a desperately sad, lonely young man with clear mental health issues crying out for help, not the villain you would expect. Tragic situation all round, that was preventable if he’d been given the correct support.
what sort of support? support for loneliness? unhappiness?
wherethewildthingis · 14/08/2021 10:02

This is an interesting perspective from two family survivors, they are very articulate and they completely reject the mental health discourse around male violence:

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/luke-ryan-hart-father-murder-mother-sister-spalding-a8928471.html

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 10:02

Once again, what was his ideology?

And, of course mental health services should be improved - and that includes locking dangerous people up.

WorldsBestBoss · 14/08/2021 09:59

@Clymene

No it's not just boys and men. Please don't try and correct my post. I had to bury a close female friend of mine earlier this year as she had taken her own life. Yes she didn't take anyone else with her, but she left behind a family who will forever live with this devastation.

Another male friend of mine is a victim of his mother's suicide. Appears to be fine on the surface but dig deeper and he has spent his life feeing abandoned. Consequently feels angry at women and has lack of respect for his wife/cheats etc.

It all stems from issues dripping down through generations and the lack of support from society and/or the government.

ChaToilLeam · 14/08/2021 09:59

It is absolutely horrifying. And could have been prevented had his mother been listened to, had his gun license been withheld, had the whole issue of incel radicalisation been taken seriously.

There will be more, I’m afraid. This is becoming a focus for alienated, violent young men seeking validation.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 14/08/2021 09:55

Jihadists don’t only kill non-Muslims. That the killing is indiscriminate is part of the terror.

ThreeWitches · 14/08/2021 09:54

@Blossomtoes

What a ridiculous thing to say

Sounds pretty sensible to me.

Yeah, so sensible to not want to improve mental health services so things like this can be avoided. Yeah, soooo sensible. 🙄
Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 09:54

@Blossomtoes

he was an ideological extremist

What was his ideology? He was a vicious, out of control thug. Stop making excuses for him.

It’s not an excuse, it’s a warning. There are many others out there in the same frame of mind existing in echo chambers and bolstering each other’s feelings of injustice.
wherethewildthingis · 14/08/2021 09:53

@Lockheart do you have experience in this area? Because mine is extensive. I can count on the fingers of one hand, the number of violent males I've met who had a genuine mental illness. Better mental health services will not stop these attacks, because mental illness is not the primary driver for them.
The Hart brothers, whose mother and sister were murdered by their father, have also spoken about the "must be mental illness" discourse being harmful and distressing to surviving family members. It's a simplistic view to say its caused by mental illness and it's just not correct.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 09:52

What a ridiculous thing to say

Sounds pretty sensible to me.

ThreeWitches · 14/08/2021 09:50

@wherethewildthingis

Exactly Fleek I agree with you entirely. They do not need better mental health support. What they need is locking up where they will no longer be a danger to women and children.
What a ridiculous thing to say.
Cornettoninja · 14/08/2021 09:48

[quote supermoonrising]@Cornettoninja
but radicalisation and mental health problems coexist and are separate issues

Clearly not in this criminal case or thousands of others.[/quote]
It’s not actually clear though is it? Given the relative rarity of incidences of mass killings and the prevalence of mental health issues I would say that the link with so many instances of the perpetrators involvement with incel communities is strong enough to draw the conclusion that the motivating factor is unlikely to be down to a mental health condition.

Using the linked Wikipedia article there have been 12 instances of mass killings (including Plymouth) linked to followers of incel ideology since 2014.

Mental health provision is almost universally woeful, but that isn’t the root trigger of acts like Plymouth.

This study (link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43545-021-00220-8#Sec18 ) gives an interesting insight.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 09:48

he was an ideological extremist

What was his ideology? He was a vicious, out of control thug. Stop making excuses for him.

Clymene · 14/08/2021 09:47

@WorldsBestBoss

*No sane person guns down their mother and several strangers.

Doesn't matter if you're an Islamic terrorist or an incel. None of these people are healthy.*

Absolutely this.

There are SO many reasons that children are either growing up with mental health issues or they are surfacing in adulthood.

Many children grow up feeling unloved, unwanted, alone, perhaps the child of a parent with unmet mental health needs, victims of bullying, undiagnosed autism, adhd, other SEN, extreme anxiety, health issues, the list goes on and on.

A very high proportion of prisoners have previously undiagnosed ADHD.

I am not in any way excusing this devastating attack, but I think if society focused more on the reasons that people get to this point then many of these atrocities could be avoided.

It's it not children, it's boys and MEN. We need to name the problem.

And it's not better mental health support, it's a shift away from a porn soaked culture which is dripping in misogyny, which celebrates mam violence against women where men think they deserve sex, where women are routinely hit during sex, and where girls are raped in school. That's what needs to change

Iloveginger · 14/08/2021 09:47

I watched some of his YouTube videos before they were taken down. He was a desperately sad, lonely young man with clear mental health issues crying out for help, not the villain you would expect.
Tragic situation all round, that was preventable if he’d been given the correct support.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 14/08/2021 09:46

@jasminoide

I'm so bloody infuriated that people/the media are trying to "understand" his motivations, him being labelled as "lonely" etc. If he was brown he'd simply be called a terrorist, which he is in my book.
I quite agree. If he was a Muslim, people wouldn't be umming and ahhing about whether he's a terrorist because he had no specific funding from an organisation. He was radicalised online, he was an ideological extremist.
Blossomtoes · 14/08/2021 09:45

@AlternativePerspective

He was a psycho.

I have no idea about this movement he was apparently part of, but it’s worth remembering that he didn’t only kill females.

Whatever he was a part of, he made this decision for himself, not for others, and the only positive thing to come out of it is that he’s dead.

This. Mindless killing like Hungerford and Dunblane.
the80sweregreat · 14/08/2021 09:42

' lessons will be learnt'
It Seems they never are though.

CutePanda · 14/08/2021 09:42

@Balonzette please do not excuse a murderer’s actions because he was “mentally ill” and “vulnerable” to extreme anti-women views. He did not just kill women. He killed 2 men and a child too. He killed because he wanted to kill.

WorldsBestBoss · 14/08/2021 09:41

*No sane person guns down their mother and several strangers.

Doesn't matter if you're an Islamic terrorist or an incel. None of these people are healthy.*

Absolutely this.

There are SO many reasons that children are either growing up with mental health issues or they are surfacing in adulthood.

Many children grow up feeling unloved, unwanted, alone, perhaps the child of a parent with unmet mental health needs, victims of bullying, undiagnosed autism, adhd, other SEN, extreme anxiety, health issues, the list goes on and on.

A very high proportion of prisoners have previously undiagnosed ADHD.

I am not in any way excusing this devastating attack, but I think if society focused more on the reasons that people get to this point then many of these atrocities could be avoided.

Newrumpus · 14/08/2021 09:39

“I think there comes a time when we have to stop trying to understand these men”

If that time comes, we will be in a complete mess. We must try to understand, not matter how hard that is, so that we can attempt to prevent similar tragedies.

Mrsmorton · 14/08/2021 09:38

@supermoonrising you're coming across as slightly ignorant. Did you read about the incel murders in China recently? Canada? The murders in the yoga studio? This is a widely known global issue and it's getting worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread