Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Incel” AIBU to think forums should be banned?

132 replies

SteveArnottsWaistcoat · 14/08/2021 08:18

Following from the horrible tragedy of the mass shooting in Plymouth, I had never heard of Incel before and had to Google what it was.

I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men. (I’m not going to link to the one I found but if you put in Incels then a dot and then net you’ll find it. The description made it sound like a support network but the content is very different)

Now I could be being totally naive here, I’m sure there are forums out there with all kinds of hate speech against everything going, but some of the stuff I read on there made me wonder how that kind of thing is allowed in such an open public way!

Is it freedom of speech? AIBU to think it shouldn’t be allowed? Do you think these websites are monitored?

OP posts:
TheMoth · 14/08/2021 11:28

purplepeonies I agree. Students think feminists or 'feminazis' are on some crusade to destroy men and the world. Their heads combust when I, in full makeup and heels, tell them that I am a feminist and that my dh and ds are, as far as they can be. I don't fit their expectation. I also explain that feminists actually want an equal society, and that feminism helps both men and women. Especially men and boys who don't fit the masculine stereotype.

But I'm pissing in the wind, a lot of the time.

Frugblie · 14/08/2021 11:20

@BoredZelda

Who decides what is the right speech and the wrong speech? The government? Is that what you want?
Erm yes, if it's extreme and directly inciting hatred and/or informing people how to carry out atrocities. Of course not all of the forums do that, but there is a very nasty and dangerous underbelly to the subculture, do you think no one should do anything, even though they do for other groups that have similar sounding boards?
Paulinna · 14/08/2021 11:13

The authorities can police the internet. If there was a public forum posting child abuse images it would be banned and taken down, and so would a forum where people were planning terrorist activity. So these incel forums can and should be removed too because they’re inciting hate and violence.

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 14/08/2021 11:07

@TheMoth

I agree with more being taught in schools, but an awful lot of boys come to school with contempt for women already ingrained. It's really something else, as a professional woman, when some 15yr old lad sneers at you because he feels superior. A superiority based on what though? Fuck all. It's their future girlfriends I always worry about there.
We used to teach about pornography and controlling relationships in pshe, I remember one conversation with a 16 year old who told me some of the statistics used were ‘probably written by some dirty feminist’, at which point I decided that the battle for his education was lost. Very demoralising but that attitude totally came from porn and home attitudes.
BoredZelda · 14/08/2021 11:02

Who decides what is the right speech and the wrong speech? The government? Is that what you want?

gardeninggirl68 · 14/08/2021 10:55

I looked on the uncle site mentioned upthread but didn't see anyone encouraging violence or anything similiar

The few parts I read were from males angry and upset they were not valued in any part of their lives due to being 'ugly'.

thedancingbear · 14/08/2021 10:42

I think we're on the same side, Frugbile. There's a clear enough legal dividing line between expressing views, and inciting violence. I would like to see the law properly enforced re the latter: something which isn't happening.

But many people on this thread are talking about closing down forums. I agree with some but not all of what is posted on the GC forums; but it would be very wrong if that conversation were not able to happen.

Frugblie · 14/08/2021 10:36

Whilst I think Incels ideology is repellent, I think petitionining for forums to be 'cancelled' is a dangerous route to go down. Because there's one forum quite close to home that would be very much in the cross hairs of certain parties.

Yes this forum would, when what they are trying to censor is biological reality and people standing up for women's rights. So ask yourself why nought is done about forums that not only allow a space for hateful comments to be spoken about women, but many go beyond that and actually have guides on how to do atrocious things to women, and radicalise young men, whilst ones like this after often cited for being hateful and harmful.

Frugblie · 14/08/2021 10:34

their victims include a good percentage of men

They also hate men who they perceive as having more success with women, or strolling through life based on their looks. So yes, hateful of all, but specifically of women as their hatred for men stems back to women.

thedancingbear · 14/08/2021 10:32

@OnwardsAndSideways1

What annoyed me is that the police kept saying 'this is not a terrorist incident, this is not a terrorist incident' to make us all think it's just a domestic one; in fact, Incels are part of an ideological hate movement against women so it very much is an act of terrorism to shoot at 13 people and kill 5 because you feel so angry towards women.
I think you've misunderstood. Terrorists acts are only committed by brown people.

Whilst I think Incels ideology is repellent, I think petitionining for forums to be 'cancelled' is a dangerous route to go down. Because there's one forum quite close to home that would be very much in the cross hairs of certain parties.

RightYesButNo · 14/08/2021 10:24

Also, I don’t know if the police would want them shut down? I know they started following such forums in America at least definitely after the killings by an incel in 2018, and I imagine the police here do “watch” (perhaps have a bot that watches for key words) these forums to see if someone is going to take their hatred offline. If they didn’t before, they probably will do now. Also, users of these sites do turn on each other; as odd as it seems, they may think some “hate” is okay but killings like this are unacceptable, for whatever reason (maybe not the same reasons we would).

RightYesButNo · 14/08/2021 10:16

I’m guessing you missed in 2018 when Elliott Rodgers committed a mass killing and was lauded as an “Incel hero,” according to the BBC (it happened in the US, but it was covered over here and I think maybe he had family ties here?). I know we’re absolutely inundated with news, so its hard to either remember it all or even read it all, as for some people that would stick out - to me, that was the beginning of realizing how dangerous incels would be - and for some, maybe like you, it was one article in thousands that they saw that year, if you even saw it.

And just like Elliott Rodgers, this new “incel” killer said they hated women, but when he actually committed mass murder, their victims include a good percentage of men (4 of 6 for Rodgers and now 2 of 5 for this new killer). I’m sure there have been studies on that, why they claim to hate women so much but truthfully, they’re just all-around hateful arseholes who kill indiscriminately (their jealousy of men in successful romantic and familial relationships is actually much stronger than their hatred of women? I don’t know).

But yes… they’re dangerous. Any group who believes rape should be legal because they’re not having sex is, of course, dangerous. I really recommend every woman read up on how to spot an incel (it has nothing to do with physical appearance, as they may be very physically attractive, but often to do with bursts of anger, occasionally sharing opinions that the world has been unfair and owes them, etc).

AfternoonToffee · 14/08/2021 10:15

The bit that really saddens me is how young boys who feel lonely and alienated can be 'converted' through exposure to these spaces - kids who go looking for community and solidarity and find it in this kind of poison –and who might have turned out so very differently if they'd become immersed in something else.

My first reaction was "what has gone so terribly wrong that this is the outcome?" By the time they are on these sites it is too late, closing them down will not deal with the issues at the heart of them. There is a multitude of factors at play; breakdown of communities, everyone out for themselves, high crime, poor health outcomes, high unemployment, porn it goes on.

I honestly can't see this ever getting better.

salviapages · 14/08/2021 10:09

The problem is banning it doesn't do anything. If you ban certain language/hate speech then they use code, if you take the websites down they start up again under another name, it can also encourage the users in their belief that they are 'underdogs'. Laurs Bates wrote a great book about it called Men Who Hate Women. It's a dificult read but shines a good light on the issue

NinaBallerinaShoes · 14/08/2021 10:07

You don’t think the police check Facebook or Twitter or YouTube etc before issuing a licence?

Kpo58 · 14/08/2021 10:05

I'm not sure banning them would do any good.

Maybe it would be better to flood them with moderate posts to help them become better people (IE if you want a relationship you need to treat your potential partner with respect) to get rid of the echo chamber of hate.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 14/08/2021 09:57

What annoyed me is that the police kept saying 'this is not a terrorist incident, this is not a terrorist incident' to make us all think it's just a domestic one; in fact, Incels are part of an ideological hate movement against women so it very much is an act of terrorism to shoot at 13 people and kill 5 because you feel so angry towards women.

TakeYourFinalPosition · 14/08/2021 09:56

I guess though if it’s possible for things like paedophilia to be monitored closely and gangs brought down, then surely it’s possible to do this on some way too?

The “war” against paedophilia isn’t being won online either. It’s nowhere near closely monitored; anywhere. There are teams dedicated to it, and there could be for this, but it’s an idealistic view that we’re anywhere close to stopping child abuse and child abuse images circulating.

Potentially the biggest step forward was Apple’s announcement that they could scan photos on someone’s phone for CSA imagery, and look how that went down last week…

And that’s before you consider that the more you censor this type of person, the more angry they get. You support their view that the world is against them.

And that you’d never fully censor them anyway. They’d just build off shore communities, use the dark web, etc etc.

TheMoth · 14/08/2021 09:48

I agree with more being taught in schools, but an awful lot of boys come to school with contempt for women already ingrained. It's really something else, as a professional woman, when some 15yr old lad sneers at you because he feels superior. A superiority based on what though? Fuck all. It's their future girlfriends I always worry about there.

penguinwithasuitcase · 14/08/2021 09:47

Not the same thing, but I listened to a podcast earlier this year on the people who attacked the Capitol building moving to Telegram and other platforms to avoid being traced after the big platforms started sharing their info with police.

It's whack-a-mole - shut down one space and it'll pop up elsewhere.

The bit that really saddens me is how young boys who feel lonely and alienated can be 'converted' through exposure to these spaces - kids who go looking for community and solidarity and find it in this kind of poison –and who might have turned out so very differently if they'd become immersed in something else.

SteveArnottsWaistcoat · 14/08/2021 09:46

Lots of good points here.

I guess though if it’s possible for things like paedophilia to be monitored closely and gangs brought down, then surely it’s possible to do this on some way too?

Although having said that if Twitter haven’t banned the recent video of some revolting reality tv star getting gobbled off by his girlfriend then perhaps there’s still too much to contend with.

I feel sad and angry that it’s totally ok to specifically target women so openly like this.

Governments should take things like this more seriously.

OP posts:
TheMoth · 14/08/2021 09:45

I'm actually surprised at how much the incel stuff is being discussed in the news etc. Dh had no idea they existed, but I've known about it for a good few years and have met some young lads I worried would find the groups. I'm pleased at how seriously it's being taken, although annoyed it's taken an event like this to make people realise how abhorrent it is. I'm also torn by the publicity; are more men now going to veer towards it? But then, that's always the risk you take when you publicise cults.

YouJustDoYou · 14/08/2021 09:43

You can't even so much as breathe anything that isn't WokeThink about certain sections of society, and yet when it comes to these incels yearning for the hurt and killing of women no one cares. We live in a very hypocritical society.

Waitwhat23 · 14/08/2021 09:42

@FixTheBone strangely enough, yes I have read the article I linked.

Reddit have banned a few anti women sub reddits (as I said in my pp - when I said 'not generally' groups advocating violence and sexual threats against women).

However, there are many, many, many groups which are active and in which Incel groups have free rein to espouse violent views against women. From the same article I linked, the Active groups include many Men's Rights subreddits which hold incel views, including doxxing women who object to the existence of such subredits.

From the article - 'Critics of this position have argued that Reddit has not been consistent in following its free speech philosophy.'

Lockheart · 14/08/2021 09:42

@GCAcademic

Re. not being able to ban forums. Oddly enough, Reddit managed to close down many of its feminist subreddits (including some that focused on specific women's health issues) because they were deemed transphobic. It's wrong to think they couldn't take action here, but they won't because their corporate culture is fundamentally misogynistic, and the same goes for Twitter. The tech industry (and social media moderation) is dominated by women-hating men. It has greatly and actively facilitated the backlash against women's rights in the last ten years or so.
Reddit is a platform that controls the content and can remove pages on its own site, e.g. the GC forums like you say.

You can't actually ban Reddit, unless all countries around the world agreed to do so. Even then, there are ways around it.

It's a bit like Facebook - Facebook can remove pages that are deemed to violate its T&Cs, but you can't actually ban Facebook (practically, yes the US could arrest Mark whats his face etc etc but the company and the website can move offshore and operate from servers in Argentina, for example).

When talking about banning forums online, you need to remember that you or I could create a forum hosted on a South Korean server which the UK has no power to close down. The UK could try to ban the content, meaning that IPs in the UK would block our website, but there are ways around that. China famously "bans" a lot of western websites, which in practice makes bugger all difference
as an awful lot of their population use them anyway.

That's what we're talking about when we say how difficult it is to "ban" forums and websites.