Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Incel” AIBU to think forums should be banned?

132 replies

SteveArnottsWaistcoat · 14/08/2021 08:18

Following from the horrible tragedy of the mass shooting in Plymouth, I had never heard of Incel before and had to Google what it was.

I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men. (I’m not going to link to the one I found but if you put in Incels then a dot and then net you’ll find it. The description made it sound like a support network but the content is very different)

Now I could be being totally naive here, I’m sure there are forums out there with all kinds of hate speech against everything going, but some of the stuff I read on there made me wonder how that kind of thing is allowed in such an open public way!

Is it freedom of speech? AIBU to think it shouldn’t be allowed? Do you think these websites are monitored?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 16/08/2021 11:13

The problem with censorship is who controls the censors.

We make the naive assumption that those making censorship decisions will always have our best interests at heart.

Power concerntrated in authority without oversight and accountability is dangerous.

Censorship ironically has the effect of often stopping the ability to have effective oversight and accountability in other areas unrelated to the area targetted.

A good example is how anti terrorism laws have been used in areas way beyond where they were ever intended to be used.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/08/2021 11:02

[quote VladmirsPoutine]@Mummyoflittledragon I think the point is/was that you can't go around banning things just because you don't like them. In essence there are many people who would be happy to see the end of Mumsnet and the poster was just pointing out that some of the discourse on here (though not in the extremes of incel forums) could be considered highly offensive towards certain groups c.f. trans threads.[/quote]
Oh I see. BlushI Sorry @PlanDeRaccordement I went a bit off at the deep end there. I was really confused with that comment, especially from someone so moderate and level headed.

thedancingbear · 16/08/2021 10:52

@Branleuse

Loads of internet content is policed and banned so absolutely this needs to include incel stuff
I agree. And anti-trans stuff too.

I mean, I obviously don't agree, but you get the point.

thedancingbear · 16/08/2021 10:51

The alternative (my preference) would be to solve the problem by relaxing the gun laws. If members of the public had been armed in Plymouth, it's possible someone could have taken him down before he'd killed all of his victims. Obviously assault weapons aren't needed, but a few handguns, owned by people trained to use them, would have helped massively. I think at least two lives could have been saved.

This is where this ends up: www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46473321

Sorry, but if you think the answer to the (in the UK, vanishingly rare) event where someone goes postal with a gun, is to place more guns into circulation, then you are a fucking nutcase.

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2021 10:49

@SteveArnottsWaistcoat

Following from the horrible tragedy of the mass shooting in Plymouth, I had never heard of Incel before and had to Google what it was.

I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men. (I’m not going to link to the one I found but if you put in Incels then a dot and then net you’ll find it. The description made it sound like a support network but the content is very different)

Now I could be being totally naive here, I’m sure there are forums out there with all kinds of hate speech against everything going, but some of the stuff I read on there made me wonder how that kind of thing is allowed in such an open public way!

Is it freedom of speech? AIBU to think it shouldn’t be allowed? Do you think these websites are monitored?

A few things here.
  1. Does banning achieve the desired effect?
    What is the desired effect? To stop communication between individuals who share these type of views.
    The problem being if you ban on certain places it merely moves the issue to closed groups or encrypted spaces where its more difficult to monitor.
    Banning rarely actually solves the problem. It just relocates it. That can make it harder to deal with rather than stopping the issue.

  2. Is the problem sharing of views or the environment which creates people with these views?
    People turn to extremism of all kinds for largely the same reasons. They lack opportunities and are often isolated or marginalised in society for a reason. Why aren't we looking more at social issues underlying why people feel isolated / lacking purpose?

  3. Appeals to authority about concerns of the risk of violence to women aren't taken as seriously as they should be.

  4. Mass shooting have a common theme. We should talk about this common theme. Cos we could say "guns dont kill people rappers do" like Americans and completely miss the point.

This most recent incident highlights a few things well: the internet beyond our borders and our (in)ability to control / restrict that being exceptionally difficult (especially in tech savvy circles), the failure and lack of adequate support/social structures for vulnerable adults after they've left the school system, poor checking for gun licences even in the uk.

More than this the normalisation of porn and poor attitudes to women at a low level mean that unusual levels of concern aren't identified as problematic and are dismissed as 'just a domestic incident' or nothing to be concerned about.

One of the common themes of mass shootings is there is a pattern of behaviour in the run up to a major incident. Things that authorities are aware of.

They don't come out of nowhere. They have a pattern of escalation.

There is almost always an incident that predates a mass killing and its usually against a female family member.

And you find as soon as you have the benefit of hindsight, an out cry about why was that ever ignored.

Banning something on the internet, is a simplistic knee jerk solution that people who want to reduce the issue to something that can be easily 'cured' turn to. The problem is it simply doesn't address the issue that content on the Internet is a symptom of a wider problem over and above a leading cause of it. It acts merely as an amplifier rather than a creater. And if the problem isn't dealt with it merely moves to other channels. It does not just 'go away'.

ChainJane · 16/08/2021 10:28

You couldn't make them disappear without shutting down lots of other things that some people disagree with too, like this site for example.

The idea of looking at a person's internet history is a non-starter, people can use VPNs or disposable email addresses to mask their tracks. How long should ISPs keep the records for anyway? Remember they'd have to keep everybody's records, probably indefinitely. "Nothing to hide" doesn't equal "nothing to fear" because what's legal today might be frowned upon or criminal tomorrow.

"Banning" hate speech and threats of violence is missing the point - these things are already illegal. You may as well say that people without a licence should be banned from driving - they're already not allowed.

In my view all the Plymouth incident does is show that our gun laws either need tightening or loosening. I've not yet heard what the justification was for the attacker to own a shotgun, but I can't see a legitimate reason for anyone of that age to have a weapon. Basically very few people need guns outside of the police and armed forces. Maybe farmers have an excuse in some cases.

The alternative (my preference) would be to solve the problem by relaxing the gun laws. If members of the public had been armed in Plymouth, it's possible someone could have taken him down before he'd killed all of his victims. Obviously assault weapons aren't needed, but a few handguns, owned by people trained to use them, would have helped massively. I think at least two lives could have been saved.

FreeBritnee · 16/08/2021 10:24

Nasty misogynistic hate speech is allowed everywhere. I’m surprised you haven’t noticed!!

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 10:22

Also, someone who is angry at feminism because women won’t sleep with him IS a woman hater. He thinks he’s entitled to have sex with women and is angry at the feminist movement because they’ve denied him that.

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 10:21

@MariposaLilly

Intel is an abbreviation of "involuntary celibate". They are frustrated nerds who only want a girlfriend/wife and family. They are super pissed off at the way they feel they have been treated by women - but do not want to kill us all.

Poor buggers need a place on the internet to vent and they are aghast by what that man did in Plymouth. From what I can gather the Incels are not women haters but are lonely, depressed and angry at feminism which they blame for not being able to get a girlfriend.

There's also the MGTOW movement - Men Going Their Own Way.

Is this a joke? Anyone whose first thought on not being able to get a girlfriend is to get angry at feminism (the movement to allow women equality) isn’t a poor misunderstood nerd. They’re aggressive creepy weirdos.

It always reminds me of the beginning of the social network, where the girl dumps Mark - she tells him you’ll think women don’t like you because you’re a ‘geek’ but it’s because you’re an asshole.

If a large number of people don’t like you, you don’t blame them. It’s you.

Branleuse · 16/08/2021 10:20

Loads of internet content is policed and banned so absolutely this needs to include incel stuff

Flamingo49 · 16/08/2021 10:16

Very interesting discussion on incels on This Morning right now, and how they should be classed as terrorists

Enough4me · 16/08/2021 10:12

The forums could be used to ID potential abusers?

thedancingbear · 16/08/2021 07:47

@Willyoujustbequiet

They could start with banning fathers 4 justice on Facebook. They really are the most bitter misogynist group spouting pure hatred about women. I'd encourage everyone to report them.
As others have pointed out, pushing for the shutting down of views that the majority don't agree with (and rightly so, in the case of F4J), could end very, very badly for MN.

If people on that page are advocating violence, or other criminality, then there are existing laws to deal with that. And it's not as if it's an anonymous forum.

Oceanbliss · 16/08/2021 04:22

Misogyny is everywhere and has been for longer than my lifetime and it is time it ended. I am so tired of the hatred, contempt, ostracism, oppression, control, harassment directed at women; at me and people I care about. I’m tired of feeling that my safety, my dd’s safety is under threat. I’m tired of dealing with the attitude of you can’t do that, or enjoy this activity, or be good at this, that or whatever because you are not a man. I’m tired of the every day sexism. I’m also tired of the women that throw another woman under the bus for the sake of a man.

What are the solutions to this misogyny problem that is so ingrained and permeates all of humanity?

We really do need specific objectives or steps that we can take that lead us to the ultimate goal of ending misogyny. And while we are at it we might as well tackle racism, ageism, all sexism, discrimination against people who are disabled, classism, xenophobia, terrorism. The list goes on.

Unfettered hatred is all consuming. Anyone that I have ever met that is consumed by hatred has never been able to be reasoned with, or has been changed by the love given to them. They have been unrelenting in their pursuit of acting on their hatred in some way or another and feels completely justified.

I have no idea what the answer or solution to these issues are. I agree simply banning or shutting down websites or forums will do little to stop this hatred and extremist views. However, it might make them a little less accessible to vulnerable people. And that’s a good thing.

One thing we can take from these forums is that we actually get to see into the psych of these people. We can see how prolific these views are. Maybe we can learn enough to figure out a solution; an antidote perhaps.

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/08/2021 03:01

They could start with banning fathers 4 justice on Facebook. They really are the most bitter misogynist group spouting pure hatred about women. I'd encourage everyone to report them.

Enough4me · 16/08/2021 01:58

Money talks. High fines should be sought for the forums that don't moderate messages of hate, to help reduce the issue.

MN can do it so why not others?
If I write here that woman are women my message stays as it's my opinion and a fact. If I write an intent to abuse TW my post is quite rightly removed.

Men can post frustrations with being single, but threats need removing. Yes these forums would go underground, but at least they need to be pushed back.

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 01:43

How could they ban them though? Aren’t there ways people can set up private chat rooms/message boards? And then it would just be driven underground but would still be there.

That’s the scary thing about the Internet, it’s so… big and uncontrollable in a way.

Unfashionable · 16/08/2021 00:08

I have been looking around some of the incel forums & wikis over the last couple of days. It has been quite an eye-opener.

There appears to be a whole subculture of misogyny and, in some cases, hate built on a kernel of truth : Any woman can find a willing partner to have sex with if she wants it, all she has to do is set up a profile on a dating app saying she is looking for ‘no-strings fun’ and she will be inundated with offers, but the same is not true for men, hence ‘involuntary celibacy’.

This idea is then used to justify self-pitying rants about how incels are so unattractive that they are destined to remain ‘forever alone’ and they should be entitled to sex with the attractive women of their choice. The idea that they can’t get laid because of their personalities, attitudes and behaviour rather than their looks never seems to occur to them.

DismantledKing · 15/08/2021 23:38

@MariposaLilly

Intel is an abbreviation of "involuntary celibate". They are frustrated nerds who only want a girlfriend/wife and family. They are super pissed off at the way they feel they have been treated by women - but do not want to kill us all.

Poor buggers need a place on the internet to vent and they are aghast by what that man did in Plymouth. From what I can gather the Incels are not women haters but are lonely, depressed and angry at feminism which they blame for not being able to get a girlfriend.

There's also the MGTOW movement - Men Going Their Own Way.

You’re very wrong. They actively celebrate it. Read ‘Men Who Hate Women’ by Laura Bates.
VladmirsPoutine · 15/08/2021 21:55

@Mummyoflittledragon I think the point is/was that you can't go around banning things just because you don't like them. In essence there are many people who would be happy to see the end of Mumsnet and the poster was just pointing out that some of the discourse on here (though not in the extremes of incel forums) could be considered highly offensive towards certain groups c.f. trans threads.

MariposaLilly · 15/08/2021 21:10

Intel is an abbreviation of "involuntary celibate". They are frustrated nerds who only want a girlfriend/wife and family. They are super pissed off at the way they feel they have been treated by women - but do not want to kill us all.

Poor buggers need a place on the internet to vent and they are aghast by what that man did in Plymouth. From what I can gather the Incels are not women haters but are lonely, depressed and angry at feminism which they blame for not being able to get a girlfriend.

There's also the MGTOW movement - Men Going Their Own Way.

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/08/2021 06:35

@PlanDeRaccordement

I find on MN really vile things said against -Chinese people -men -other women -black people -immigrants -trans people

Perhaps we should ban MN too?

Sorry what? I don’t see women on this moderated site, as it’s predominantly women, advocating / threatening for the rape, maiming or murder of men, women or children. You missed out disabled people btw. We always get missed. But there is never anything remotely like the crap posted on the incel sites posted on here and anything deemed inappropriate is reported and removed.
SunUmbrella · 15/08/2021 02:37

@VladmirsPoutine

Thing is I don't think they just bemoan that they are ugly. Ugliness is very subjective and some of these men as pointed out in the LB podcast are everyday men, not some basement dwelling ogre who recoils at daylight. It comes down to their visceral hatred of women. They absolutely cannot stand that women are and can be autonomous beings. They don't believe women should have rights and the mere thought of women having choice, independence and a 'voice' sends them into a fit of seething rage.
This. They have a particular hatred of women who choose to remain single or single mothers. They feel they are entitled to sex and how dare women say no? They are basically men with the mentality of rapists just waiting to spill over that social and moral and legal barrier to actually being a rapist.

They are pathetic individuals and it's no shock to any sane human why nobody is interested in sex/ relationships with them. But they find it unfathomable. It's all a but sad and pathetic really.

SunUmbrella · 15/08/2021 02:31

Can you imagine the amount of work this would take?

Police services have been cut to the bone. This suggestion is totally unworkable unfortunately.

If we can't afford to vet the people who have the licences safely, then no more licences, sorry.

Better that some people "miss out" on shooting random non-human things than some get to run around shooting humans.

RightYesButNo · 15/08/2021 01:08

Damn phone posted too soon and definitely don’t mean “lol lurrr fix.” They call such men names such as “betas” for beta male and “cucks” implying they must by cuckolding while the woman they are with also is with a more traditionally attractive man. It’s very ugly, and no surprise to me that when they kill, they often kill both men and women. It’s just awful all around.

When many feminists say that feminism can benefit everyone… this almost feels like viewing the direct alternative.