Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Incel” AIBU to think forums should be banned?

132 replies

SteveArnottsWaistcoat · 14/08/2021 08:18

Following from the horrible tragedy of the mass shooting in Plymouth, I had never heard of Incel before and had to Google what it was.

I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men. (I’m not going to link to the one I found but if you put in Incels then a dot and then net you’ll find it. The description made it sound like a support network but the content is very different)

Now I could be being totally naive here, I’m sure there are forums out there with all kinds of hate speech against everything going, but some of the stuff I read on there made me wonder how that kind of thing is allowed in such an open public way!

Is it freedom of speech? AIBU to think it shouldn’t be allowed? Do you think these websites are monitored?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rahri · 24/08/2021 03:51

@NiceGerbil

I also think that the danger of online radicalisation with these groups. Should be seen by the authorities in the same way as terrorism.

Disaffected men who are angry. Find places that give them someone to be angry at and a justification.

The appeal of some of the current extreme/ terrorist ideologies taps into a hatred of women as well. Often men who commit terrorist acts are found to have committed DV etc.

Angry men who feel they are hard done by are drawn to places where they are told they're right to feel that way and action is reasonable.

Where men are online and discussing ways to terrorise women then it needs to be seen the same way.

IMO.

I agree completely. 👏👏👏

So who the hell are we meant to vote for who will actually make sure misogyny is treated as seriously as racism?

NiceGerbil · 24/08/2021 03:08

I also think that the danger of online radicalisation with these groups. Should be seen by the authorities in the same way as terrorism.

Disaffected men who are angry. Find places that give them someone to be angry at and a justification.

The appeal of some of the current extreme/ terrorist ideologies taps into a hatred of women as well. Often men who commit terrorist acts are found to have committed DV etc.

Angry men who feel they are hard done by are drawn to places where they are told they're right to feel that way and action is reasonable.

Where men are online and discussing ways to terrorise women then it needs to be seen the same way.

IMO.

Rahri · 24/08/2021 03:06

@NiceGerbil

Not read the whole thread.

Tricky.

Certainly the net has increased polarisation generally. Echo chambers. Like minded people finding each other and sharing ideas, egging each other on.

This is across pretty much every viewpoint, political colour etc etc.

OTOH it has allowed people to tell what is happening. TOR has meant people around the world being able to tell the world what's going on. Find out how to get away (?). Support each other.

For the MRA/ incel etc stuff. I think.

The major sites need to be even handed in what they tolerate. There's a big gap in what they see as over the line, depending on the topic/ posters.

Do you imagine there would be such a "big gap" in what is deemed acceptable if the comments were racial hatred rather than misogynism?

That is the only "gap" that needs to close: the idea that at some low level misogynism might be acceptable. It isn't.

NiceGerbil · 24/08/2021 03:03

Not read the whole thread.

Tricky.

Certainly the net has increased polarisation generally. Echo chambers. Like minded people finding each other and sharing ideas, egging each other on.

This is across pretty much every viewpoint, political colour etc etc.

OTOH it has allowed people to tell what is happening. TOR has meant people around the world being able to tell the world what's going on. Find out how to get away (?). Support each other.

For the MRA/ incel etc stuff. I think.

The major sites need to be even handed in what they tolerate. There's a big gap in what they see as over the line, depending on the topic/ posters.

Torvean · 24/08/2021 03:00

I'd heard of Incels before what happened in youth. I think the least YT should do is to delete the Incel TV channel they have.

Rahri · 24/08/2021 02:52

@VladmirsPoutine

Thing is I don't think they just bemoan that they are ugly. Ugliness is very subjective and some of these men as pointed out in the LB podcast are everyday men, not some basement dwelling ogre who recoils at daylight. It comes down to their visceral hatred of women. They absolutely cannot stand that women are and can be autonomous beings. They don't believe women should have rights and the mere thought of women having choice, independence and a 'voice' sends them into a fit of seething rage.
Quite some cognitive dissonance then for them to be baffled (apparently) about why they are unsucessful with women. Confused🤣
Kanaloa · 19/08/2021 23:35

Available women should be given to men. Yuck yuck yuck yuck.

I have a better solution - all these incel boys who feel unwanted write their names down and pop them in a hat. They then all pick a name out. Paired up, bish bash bosh. You take turns having sex with each other. If you don’t like it you lump it, since you’re ‘available.’

Thisisworsethananticpated · 19/08/2021 17:00

That’s with children so rightly so
They will just go on the deep web anyway

Branleuse · 19/08/2021 16:35

They banned pro-ana and pro-mia forums after public decided that allowing people to openly encourage girls into serious eating disorders was harmful, and one by one they closed any they could find.
Its not perfect as obviously they would still exist if people really did go out of their way to find them, but it made it nearly impossible for people to just accidentally happen upon them, so I think its bullshit that people say they cant be banned.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 19/08/2021 13:09

You can’t ban them , especially on the basis of some fast googling
As vile as they are we can’t police hatred

PineapplePanda · 19/08/2021 12:02

@PineapplePanda

YouTube is one of the worst platforms for uncle breeding. And I am never shocked when it's revealed these terrorist incels made YouTube videos.

So many comments on YouTube are ridiculously sexist and considering a lot of users are child-age it's a very worrying trend that they have these opinions at such a young age and that they aren't pulled up on it.

*incel not uncle...
BriocheForBreakfast · 19/08/2021 11:55

@VladmirsPoutine

How do you suggest we 'police' those forums?
I'm in a menopause FB group and Facebook manage to police that very well. If there's any whiff of 'men bashing' then FB are on them like a ton of bricks. The admins are always warning posters not to 'men bash' as they are worried that the group will be closed down.
PineapplePanda · 19/08/2021 11:49

YouTube is one of the worst platforms for uncle breeding. And I am never shocked when it's revealed these terrorist incels made YouTube videos.

So many comments on YouTube are ridiculously sexist and considering a lot of users are child-age it's a very worrying trend that they have these opinions at such a young age and that they aren't pulled up on it.

patkinney · 19/08/2021 11:07

@VioletSand

Re: ’I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men....’

I bet if you looked around the internet, you’d probably find open forums with really vile things being said against men by angry women, too... It’s the world we live in.

When was the last tome you heard about a woman roaming around the street with a shotgun because she didn't feel she got enough attention from men?

Please show me where you have seen posts like this from women, advocating state mandated rape Handmaid's Tale style to appease men who aren't successful in their love lives?

I'm sorry but it's incredibly rare that women behave like this, there are not communities online of women plotting massacres against men because they won't fuck them. To pretend it is equivalent is absurd.

Well yes, when indeed did I hear about a woman roaming the streets with a shotgun....? the answer is never. However, that terrible incident last week was the first time I’d heard about a man doing it (under the banner of the ‘incel movement’) so I would argue it is incredibly rare across both gender groups.

P.S. You are correct when you say: ‘there are not communities online of women plotting massacres against men because they won't fuck them.‘ But as someone points out on page one of this discussion, if a woman joins a ‘dating site’ asking for ‘no-strings’ sex, she will be inundated with offers, the same doesn’t apply when the genders are flipped. Not sure why, possibly to do with biology, or maybe society, but whichever it is, it’s relevant to this debate.

As is this: I read a book recently about the dreadful case of the Yorkshire Ripper. It looked at the problems the police had catching him and there were several including it happened just before I.T. and DNA tracing came on the scene, there was a poor attitude towards sex workers at the time, (amongst police and wider communities) but most pertinent as regards this discussion: when the police tried to track men driving into and out of red light areas in these northern towns, they were overwhelmed by the numbers. So men wanting sex without all the emotional stuff, is nothing new.

The difference between then and now? Quite simple: the world wide web.

VioletSand · 19/08/2021 06:52

Re: ’I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men....’

I bet if you looked around the internet, you’d probably find open forums with really vile things being said against men by angry women, too... It’s the world we live in.

When was the last tome you heard about a woman roaming around the street with a shotgun because she didn't feel she got enough attention from men?

Please show me where you have seen posts like this from women, advocating state mandated rape Handmaid's Tale style to appease men who aren't successful in their love lives?

I'm sorry but it's incredibly rare that women behave like this, there are not communities online of women plotting massacres against men because they won't fuck them. To pretend it is equivalent is absurd.

“Incel” AIBU to think forums should be banned?
patkinney · 19/08/2021 05:48

@SteveArnottsWaistcoat

Following from the horrible tragedy of the mass shooting in Plymouth, I had never heard of Incel before and had to Google what it was.

I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men. (I’m not going to link to the one I found but if you put in Incels then a dot and then net you’ll find it. The description made it sound like a support network but the content is very different)

Now I could be being totally naive here, I’m sure there are forums out there with all kinds of hate speech against everything going, but some of the stuff I read on there made me wonder how that kind of thing is allowed in such an open public way!

Is it freedom of speech? AIBU to think it shouldn’t be allowed? Do you think these websites are monitored?

Re: ’I was pretty shocked to discover open forums full of what I can only describe as hate speech. Really vile things being said against women by angry men....’

I bet if you looked around the internet, you’d probably find open forums with really vile things being said against men by angry women, too... It’s the world we live in. Hmm

VioletSand · 19/08/2021 03:52

@DismantledKing

The alternative (my preference) would be to solve the problem by relaxing the gun laws. If members of the public had been armed in Plymouth, it's possible someone could have taken him down before he'd killed all of his victims. Obviously assault weapons aren't needed, but a few handguns, owned by people trained to use them, would have helped massively. I think at least two lives could have been saved.

It’s only Monday, but that’s already the most moronic thing I’ll read all week.

Probably posted by an incel who has too many mental health problems to get a gun licence. Otherwise, that poster's comment is unfathomable.
VioletSand · 19/08/2021 03:50

@Kanaloa

Also, someone who is angry at feminism because women won’t sleep with him IS a woman hater. He thinks he’s entitled to have sex with women and is angry at the feminist movement because they’ve denied him that.
Yep. Hateful creeps who are advocating state-mandated rape. This particular incel has a PhD, apparently. Confused
“Incel” AIBU to think forums should be banned?
RedToothBrush · 16/08/2021 14:45

Number 1. If you want the best people in the area, you have to pay the wages to match.

Otherwise you are going to lose to crime and the margins of society.

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2021 14:42

Ten women have been shot dead in the last nine years by partners who were allowed to hold gun licences despite claims of domestic abuse or severe mental health problems, it has been revealed.

Data shows six cases where police returned guns to owners, despite allegations of domestic abuse, or where a GP had flagged serious concerns over mental health, the Times reports.

This would be much more effective than an internet ban.

Dh works in internet security. It never fails to shock me how little people know about the subject to any level.

Pandora opened the box.

PlanDeRaccordement · 16/08/2021 14:12

@Mummyoflittledragon
Thank you for apology, @VladmirsPoutine got what I was trying to say.
Things that are passed off as lighthearted can be made to look sinister by anyone, take for example the murder my DH and bury him under the patio thread. Sinister or keyboard cowboy joking.....hard to tell at times from the outside.

Bunnyfuller · 16/08/2021 13:08

Fgs,

Firstly, an internet history is only as useful as the lack of techy no how the individual has. And the more nefarious the activity, the less chance you have of nailing them to an incriminating web history. If it were that fucking simple no paedophile would be roaming the streets after having accessed their material.

The journalist found it in seconds because he was given that ONE job. Do let me know where the police get the budget for several internet searchers (there are more than a few gun licences out there), or which under-staffed policing department you would suggest these people are drawn from @Cyw2018

‘I know, let’s blame the police and suggest solutions without knowing a fucking thing about policing, cyber crime or budgets’. I think you should go for PCC, you have some bright ideas

Oceanbliss · 16/08/2021 12:42

@RedToothBrush Your post is thought provoking, thank you.

DismantledKing · 16/08/2021 12:17

The alternative (my preference) would be to solve the problem by relaxing the gun laws. If members of the public had been armed in Plymouth, it's possible someone could have taken him down before he'd killed all of his victims. Obviously assault weapons aren't needed, but a few handguns, owned by people trained to use them, would have helped massively. I think at least two lives could have been saved.

It’s only Monday, but that’s already the most moronic thing I’ll read all week.

AtticusHoysAnus · 16/08/2021 12:04

Excellent idea

It's a shite idea.

A VPN can easily mask internet usage. A browser such as duckduckgo doesn't even save history.

Failing either of those people can use the tor network.

Swipe left for the next trending thread