Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Removing dairy

64 replies

Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 00:05

Posting for traffic

Just found out I need to remove the dairy in my diet. I don't normally drink tea but of I so someone said have the Oatly batista milk but I worried if I have it in hot chocolate as I don't want it to taste like porridge.

As I am removing dairy can anyone recommend dairy free products to try such as cheese, yoghurt, chocolate and ice cream and and any snacks that don't contain dairy.

N. B

I have been diagnosed with a medical condition called ademoysis and a website I was encouraged to look at says I need to remove dairy to help ease symptoms. I am not doing it for any other reason then to help.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 16:43

@lljkk

Since yours is a customised programme, I'm curious what it will look like compared to a total omnivore diet. Where do you think most your calories will come from.

No wheat, gluten, milk or soy, I gather.
Only small amounts caffeine (whatever you get in hot chock)

What about booze, maize, white sugar, added salt, mango, sesame?

Booze. I don't drink Maize I have gluten free cereal if I want it I very rarely eat breakfast and prefer toast which I have with carb free bread I don't eat alot of white sugar. Everthing that has sugar in I make myself so. I can limit the sugar and use xytol. Mango I ready eat Sesame I don't like
OP posts:
lljkk · 14/08/2021 15:25

Since yours is a customised programme, I'm curious what it will look like compared to a total omnivore diet. Where do you think most your calories will come from.

No wheat, gluten, milk or soy, I gather.
Only small amounts caffeine (whatever you get in hot chock)

What about booze, maize, white sugar, added salt, mango, sesame?

Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 14:41

@lljkk

I'm all for trying things to see what suits you, but I can't find a single credible (scientific) study that supports any of these dietary changes being truly helpful. Instead they read like a wish list from any paleo-fan, from people who fervently want to believe in magical good and bad foods.

Anyway, Oatley is the nicest of the fake milks in drinks, I dunno about pancakes. OP shouldn't be having any hot chock or tea of course, if following the common (not proven) advice for her condition, that caffeine is bad.

Mayonaise (soy free) & humus might be allowed spreads on... rye? Mayo is possible to make at home. Are you allowed rye crispbread?

After speaking to my gp, friends who at least 3 are nurses and speaking to people who have the condition they said cutting out dairy was helpful and eased some of the symptoms. My gp also said Tey it for a month and see. I have checked all of my sources and I want to see if it helps. Is there any halm in that. I have 2 hot choc a week and rarely drink tea but it is always decaff
OP posts:
Scarlettpixie · 14/08/2021 13:37

There is vegan mayo and salad creams out there and they are good.

Scarlettpixie · 14/08/2021 13:36

Alpro unsweetened uht oat milk is my preference in tea. Save the barrista ones for coffee. I get oat milk in bottles from the milk man. Its lovely on cereal and in coffee but again to creamy for tea. It doesn’t taste like porridge and has a less distinctive flavour than the nut milks. By all means try them all though , that is what I did. I found the one I likeed best and then after 2 weeks it was normal and I really liked it. Cows milk tasted odd after that.

With cheese you might find dairy free tastes like feet! If that is the case for you, give it a few months and then try. I like violife mature cheddar and cream cheese and applewood smoked but do use them more sparingly than I did real cheese. Like anything you don’t really miss it after a while.

pastabest · 14/08/2021 13:28

@lljkk

I'm all for trying things to see what suits you, but I can't find a single credible (scientific) study that supports any of these dietary changes being truly helpful. Instead they read like a wish list from any paleo-fan, from people who fervently want to believe in magical good and bad foods.

Anyway, Oatley is the nicest of the fake milks in drinks, I dunno about pancakes. OP shouldn't be having any hot chock or tea of course, if following the common (not proven) advice for her condition, that caffeine is bad.

Mayonaise (soy free) & humus might be allowed spreads on... rye? Mayo is possible to make at home. Are you allowed rye crispbread?

Yes that's the same conclusion I came to. I clicked on the thread initially as we regularly have to go Low FODMAP to treat a family member's Crohn's disease flare ups. We are also an entirely gluten free house hold due to 2/3rds of us having coeliac disease. I know all about restrictive diets for health reasons.

It's really restrictive and I would never wish that on anyone unless there was some evidence that it might be beneficial.

I've not been able to find anything that backs that up in this case, other than the dodgy website and other websites that have scraped that website for information.

lljkk · 14/08/2021 13:13

I'm all for trying things to see what suits you, but I can't find a single credible (scientific) study that supports any of these dietary changes being truly helpful. Instead they read like a wish list from any paleo-fan, from people who fervently want to believe in magical good and bad foods.

Anyway, Oatley is the nicest of the fake milks in drinks, I dunno about pancakes. OP shouldn't be having any hot chock or tea of course, if following the common (not proven) advice for her condition, that caffeine is bad.

Mayonaise (soy free) & humus might be allowed spreads on... rye? Mayo is possible to make at home. Are you allowed rye crispbread?

DeathByWalkies · 14/08/2021 12:29

A useful group, if you can ignore the posts about people worrying whether the vitamin D came from sheep wool or not

www.facebook.com/groups/accidentallyveganuk/?ref=share

Fernando072020 · 14/08/2021 11:56

I've been dairy free for around 10 months now as my little boy has cmpa and I'm still breastfeeding.
Oatly barista is definitely the best alternative and I actually like it so much that I will keep drinking it even after I've started having dairy again!
Margerine replaced butter - this didn't bother me so much
Lots of dark chocolate has no dairy, just be sure to check the label first to make sure. Again, I got used to it as I wasn't a fan before. I would eat some dark chocolate with a glass of oatly barista. But lindt also have three types of vegan chocolate made with oat milk now which are amazing.
Vegan type Philadelphia's are good enough too.
There is no cheese replacement I'm afraid to say. They are all awful. Cheese was the hardest thing for me to give up.
Supermarkets "free from" range have lots of treats like cakes and chocolate that are dairy free too.
Pizza I've been making myself. I buy the base and just make up a pizza without cheese adding things like vegan sour cream or vegan cream cheese and cover it in vegetables and salami/chicken. It tastes great.

dancinfeet · 14/08/2021 10:36

My DD is a vegan who is allergic to soya. Oat milk, almond milk, hazelnut milk in tea, or on cereal. Coconut or almond based yoghurts, Koko brand is quite good, and there are various vegan dark chocolate brands. Hotel chocolat do nutmilk chocolate batons and various other vegan options as well.

Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 10:15

@DeathByWalkies

I'm not vegan, but work in food and have spent a lot of time finding dairy alternatives

Best options I've found are

  • Elmlea Plant Cream (doesn't taste identical, but good as an ingredient and it's by far the best at 'behaving' like cream)
  • Food Heaven squirty cream
  • Oatly barista BUT it's not technically gluten free - just www.oatly.com/uk/healthcareprofessionals/faq/gluten-free+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">'very low gluten'. Based on what my customers tell me, most who aren't coeliacs are ok with this level of gluten. I do drink regular cows milk and if anything I think Oatly is nicer in coffee.

Vegan cheese is, unfortunately, nowhere near as well advanced as other types of dairy alternatives.

.... but, like others, I'd seriously question your actual need to remove dairy, and your info sources.

The gp told me about it. She said she had had heard alot of good things from women who had eliminated dairy. She said it had taken some of the pain away. I didn't really understand so I researched and asked my friends two are nurses and people who suffer from the condition. They said eliminate dairy was great as it stopped the pain and bloating that normally happened.

I did look at various websites and I asked several people's oppion. I didn't just wake up one morning and think that's it I'm not drinking milk anymore. I did vast amounts of research and I came to the conclusion that I maybe should try and see what happens.

My gp said when she called again to try it for a month and see if it had any effect on me. I am starting on Monday.

OP posts:
pastabest · 14/08/2021 10:05

[quote FeralWoman]Clearly England has some sort of gluten free oats that the rest of the world doesn't for everyone to keep suggesting oat milk.
www.coeliac.org.au/s/article/Oats-and-the-gluten-free-diet[/quote]
Oats are gluten free.

However production methods mean they can become contaminated with gluten from other grains milled using the same equipment.

Additionally some people with coeliac disease can also be sensitive to the protein in oats which is avenin rather than gluten which is the protein that is in wheat, barley, rye

In the UK we do indeed have 'gluten free oats' which are oats that are milled entirely separately from gluten containing grains.

DeathByWalkies · 14/08/2021 09:58

A friend of mine said she used lactase if she was going out as it broken down the enzymes of the milk and stopped any symptoms

This is fine for people with a lactose intolerance - but many with a milk allergy are allergic to the milk proteins, and lactase will have zero impact on that.

DeathByWalkies · 14/08/2021 09:54

I'm not vegan, but work in food and have spent a lot of time finding dairy alternatives

Best options I've found are

  • Elmlea Plant Cream (doesn't taste identical, but good as an ingredient and it's by far the best at 'behaving' like cream)
  • Food Heaven squirty cream
  • Oatly barista BUT it's not technically gluten free - just www.oatly.com/uk/healthcareprofessionals/faq/gluten-free+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">'very low gluten'. Based on what my customers tell me, most who aren't coeliacs are ok with this level of gluten. I do drink regular cows milk and if anything I think Oatly is nicer in coffee.

Vegan cheese is, unfortunately, nowhere near as well advanced as other types of dairy alternatives.

.... but, like others, I'd seriously question your actual need to remove dairy, and your info sources.

FeralWoman · 14/08/2021 09:50

Clearly England has some sort of gluten free oats that the rest of the world doesn't for everyone to keep suggesting oat milk.
www.coeliac.org.au/s/article/Oats-and-the-gluten-free-diet

Perpop · 14/08/2021 09:44

I love oatly milk, you don’t need the barista one for tea/coffee it’s basically the same as the normal one. Their whole range is great and the plant ranges in most supermarkets are decent. If you have Facebook search for a local vegan group, mine posts regular tips for good meals, restaurants, new items in stock etc. There are also some good vegan recipe groups. I hope it improves your health 😊

Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 09:43

@TheRabbitStoleMyHat

My DS is dairy free and we/he likes

Alpro unsweetened oat milk (there is a lot of sugar in dairy replacement milks which I was surprised about, which is why I buy the no sugar version)
Oatly ice cream
Vegan magnums
Wicked chocolate and berry cornettos
Wicked black olive pesto
Asda free from pesto
Naturli block butter
Flora plant life block butter
Pure butter spread
Vitalite spread
Heavenly squirty cream
Alpro custard
Biscoff spread
Violife cheese
Vitalite block cheese
Moo free chocolate
Aldi/Tesco/Lidl ice creams
Vegan Cornettos
Oatly cream

There is more dairy free food than you realise, you need to get into reading labels on everything. Things such as Oreos and jammy dodgers are dairy free. Green and blacks dark chocolate powder is good for cakes. Be careful with crisps and bread, I’ve no idea why so many salt and vinegar crisps contain milk.

Lidl and Aldi sell the cheapest milk!

Thank you for this. I will look at all of these and try as many as I can
OP posts:
TheRabbitStoleMyHat · 14/08/2021 09:41

My DS is dairy free and we/he likes

Alpro unsweetened oat milk (there is a lot of sugar in dairy replacement milks which I was surprised about, which is why I buy the no sugar version)
Oatly ice cream
Vegan magnums
Wicked chocolate and berry cornettos
Wicked black olive pesto
Asda free from pesto
Naturli block butter
Flora plant life block butter
Pure butter spread
Vitalite spread
Heavenly squirty cream
Alpro custard
Biscoff spread
Violife cheese
Vitalite block cheese
Moo free chocolate
Aldi/Tesco/Lidl ice creams
Vegan Cornettos
Oatly cream

There is more dairy free food than you realise, you need to get into reading labels on everything. Things such as Oreos and jammy dodgers are dairy free. Green and blacks dark chocolate powder is good for cakes. Be careful with crisps and bread, I’ve no idea why so many salt and vinegar crisps contain milk.

Lidl and Aldi sell the cheapest milk!

Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 09:32

Gluten also bloats me has done for years and I have cut It out slowly after the last 3 years at least . I don't eat alot of it anyway. I have salads instead of sandwiches so i dont like rice. Also no bananas as I don't like them or the taste

OP posts:
Rizzoli123 · 14/08/2021 09:15

@pastabest

Sorry to labour the point but i do perhaps have a vested interest in this which is why I've been looking into it.

I am really surprised that your GP has suggested a really restrictive diet to treat a gynaecological condition - there's no indication that this should be part of the treatment plan on the NHS website or in the NICE guidelines.

The only place I have been able to find this advice is on the Adenomyosis Advice Association website (which as I said appears to not be an official website and seems to be more like someone's own blog) or websites that have blindly reposted what's on the Adenomyosis Advice website without fact checking.

The Adenomyosis website also claims that various NHS bodies are following their advice/ campaign. One of them is the hospital trust I work for - I've very briefly checked our external and internal comms etc and the search returns ABSOLUTELY NOTHING almost as if we've never heard of them...

So I'll be passing that on internally for someone else's to look at more closely as I would imagine that there be some concern that our trust logo is being used, potentially without permission on what appears to be a website offering advice that hasn't got much clinical basis in the UK.

By all means have a healthy diet, sleep well etc that's just good advice for anyone medical issues or not.

If you read it properly it said it was for the hormone reasons. It may not be an official website more a blog like you say but isn't life full of experience and what's the saying aren't we supposed to learn from experience

Well she did and I asked why such restrictive measures and she said as this has worked for other patients so let's try for a month and see. It's a month. Fitting these things out for a month isn't going to kill me.

I know that good diet and sleep is better theb anything but I'm in pain what's the harm in trying something that could relive the symptoms. If I follow your advice I will just carry on as I am and be in pain for the rest of my life

OP posts:
oneglassandpuzzled · 14/08/2021 09:12

Thanks for this its amazing am defiantly going to try some.

You're not even being defiant, just sensible. Good luck!

ScaredOfDinosaurs · 14/08/2021 09:06

I'm gluten and dairy free, the dairy free is recent...

Tesco own brand oat milk is just as nice as oatly.

Magnum do amazing vegan versions of their ice creams. Not sure if they are soya free too, sorry.

Cheese, not found a good one yet but honestly I find it easier not to bother with it at all - hummus, ham and salad instead of a cheese sandwich for example.

DayKay · 14/08/2021 08:45

Sorry I missed the no bananas.

DayKay · 14/08/2021 08:44

It’s definitely worth trying. If it makes no difference then you’ll know.
Changing diets has helped many people with all sorts of conditions. Most people figure it out for themselves rather than get gp advice.
Dairy actually causes a Lot of issues for many people so carry on.
I don’t eat dairy as I don’t tolerate it well. There will be no medical evidence that it causes issues for me but I know it’s no coincidence.

I use oatly mainly. It doesn’t taste of porridge. Almond milk is good too. Try them and see which one you like.

I’ve discovered banana ice cream which is amazing. Frozen bananas blended with a dash of vanilla and oat milk and, if you like, other flavours such as berries or cocoa powder. Have a look on YouTube.
Any dairy free spread or sunflower oil works for baking.

Apart from that, I just have foods that don’t use dairy.
Snacks are fruit or hummus with crackers or veg sticks, nuts, ready salted crisps, popcorn.
Good luck.

pastabest · 14/08/2021 08:30

@tropicalwaterdiver

My understanding avoiding dairy for gyno conditions is not due to lactose but due to high content of hormones in cow milk.
I would be really grateful to see a UK based source for that advice if you have one?

I can understand the concerns about hormones in US milk but that's mostly irrelevant to people consuming milk in the UK /EU.

Even if you don't want to take the chance on dairy for that reason what's the reason given for eliminating gluten and ... bananas?