Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have seen a very ugly side to my 'friend'

188 replies

Notmoresugar · 13/08/2021 22:25

I would be very interested to hear how you wise and knowing ladies would deal with a friend who did this to your child (DS in my case) when you're on a short stay with her and her DS and under her roof:

Shreaking at my DS at full volume to do some heavy lifting for her (relating to her work) when he was already working for her. Her DS was doing nothing and just standing around on his phone.

Shreaking at my DS but kindly telling her DS to exit a venue at a different entrance (not relevant but they were going in the right direction anyway).

Both of our DS's were doing a sport that could hurt them if they weren't wearing appropriate clothing. Her DS had thick layers on, yet she kept telling me (3 possibly 4 times) that my DS would be ok with a thin top on.

My DS sleeping (badly) on the floor for 5 nights in her DS's room and her not asking her DS to let him have the bed for not even 1 night.

There are a few other things that I haven't mentioned.

'Friend' is under immense pressure with work and living with very difficult parents, albeit a very large house with space and land etc.

We have been friends for 15 years and this has completely put me off her, so much so that I am considering ending our relationship.

Am I being unreasonable and what would you do or say to someone like this if you were in my position. I was completely taken off-guard as it came from out of nowhere. I was a couple of hundred miles away from home and under her roof?

My DS is very laid back and fine about it, but I am not happy that she chose my DS as her personal whipping boy/scape goat.

I would never treat her DS or any of my DS's friends so badly.

Her DS goes to a private school and I know she wouldn't speak to any of her DS's school mates like that ever.

So over to you and thank you for your comments good or bad - they are all welcome and sorry it was so long!

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 14/08/2021 13:12

And don't get too stressed about not saying anything in the moment.

Very, very few of us would embark on a conversation that was unlikely to end in anything other than a confrontation when
a. A guest in the other person's home.
b. Aware the situation is ridiculously tense and simmering with ridiculous, complicated relationships.
c. Surprised.

thecatfromjapan · 14/08/2021 13:08

I'd recommend stepping back from the friendship, rather than creating an outright break. Things change: she's a nightmare right now but she may calm down in five years or so.

I think what you've noticed is a power imbalance. Possibly, it's always been there - and you've only noticed because you mind when she treats your son badly but barely notice when she does similar to you.

Or perhaps it's new/reached a new pitch - possibly because she's stressed and the filters that help her mask such stuff with social blandishments just aren't working right now.

For whatever reason, she's over-stepped your boundaries.

So, given that the current situation/way the relationship is working just doesn't work for you, I think you have three options:

  1. Say nothing but step back quietly. The relationship may just fizzle out, or you may continue it at a lower level and perhaps re-kindle at a closer level when/if she's less unpleasant.
  1. Say something. You can be very forthright and risk a break - though it might have the effect of making her reassess your doormat/lesser-person status.
You can be less forthright, which may help preserve the relationship, though might rankle with you.
  1. Just give the relationship up.

The question, really, is about what appeals to you most.

Ultimately, she's over-stepped your boundaries.
You don't need strangers on the internet to tell you this , or whether you're being reasonable.
It's useful to ask others - it will help you get a bearing on it all, and help you think it all through.
But ultimately, you already know that you feel she has stepped right over the boundaries that help you feel comfortable and give shape to how you treat people and how you like to be treated.

It's valid to feel very cross about that.

Feedingthebirds1 · 14/08/2021 12:54

@NotSorry

I know her parents from old (they have always been very nice to me and I like them) and I would never be rude/take sides as it would have made the situation much worse in my opinion

Whilst I agree with the above, my parents would come across like that to people outside the family. So while you are being nice to them, in my head I would be saying "if only you knew"

I'm not excusing her behaviour, but your update does give us some understanding into her situation

I understand that, and maybe you're right. But the OP is clear that the friend wouldn't behave like that to people at her son' boarding school so she can control it. The OP and her son don't have to be friend's punchbags. They may have been friends for years, but that doesn't give her a green light to yell at OP's son, or treat him as a lesser human being (thin vs thick clothing as an example).
NotSorry · 14/08/2021 12:29

I know her parents from old (they have always been very nice to me and I like them) and I would never be rude/take sides as it would have made the situation much worse in my opinion

Whilst I agree with the above, my parents would come across like that to people outside the family. So while you are being nice to them, in my head I would be saying "if only you knew"

I'm not excusing her behaviour, but your update does give us some understanding into her situation

TempleofZoom · 14/08/2021 11:48

Ps
It might be helpful to ask MN to move this to relationships

TempleofZoom · 14/08/2021 11:47

[quote Notmoresugar]@billy1966
Pretty much from the start - I can see now she was a pressure-pot waiting to explode.

Possibly another factor and a bit of a drip-feed (there's always far more background to a story but I would literally be writing pages and pages):

I didn't realize how grave/bad the situation was between her and her parents until we were actually there.

Her father is narcistic and can be extremely difficult/controlling.

With hindsight I think I probably went down like a lead balloon with her because I engaged with her parents on the odd occasion they were present (the mutual ground in the house is the kitchen).

I know her parents from old (they have always been very nice to me and I like them) and I would never be rude/take sides as it would have made the situation much worse in my opinion.

Don't get me wrong, I completely understand having been in a similar situation myself at just how difficult her current living situation is.

For the record, I took lots of food/wine and a present for her and of course for her DS's birthday.

Someone asked upthread if my DS was working for her when she shreaked at him and turned me into stone.

Sorry I didn't phrase it properly - he wasn't actually working for her - he was helping her by lifting her very heavy work for her.

Not blaming her DS at all (he's lovely), but just to explain the situation, he was lounging about on his phone at the time and didn't volunteer at all to help.[/quote]
Crikey!
Well it sounds like it was pretty inevitable that things would go tits up then and a huge confrontation/ row would have been the result.
It sounds like she was masking her stress/anxiety/ anger for the first 3 days and then couldnt.
Probably wise not to stay again given the toxic dynamic.
Personally I would thank her for having you to stay and also enquire as to how she was as her behaviour to your ds was some what out of character and not on.
She will either talk about it or go batshit and block you -probably the second given the toxic family situation.
Also chat to your son, apologise and tell him how shocked you were.

Very sad when things like this happen to old friendships but we cant always predict or control these things and sometimes stepping away is the best option Flowers

Notmoresugar · 14/08/2021 11:25

@TempleofZoom
You are absolutely right - it was complex and there was far far more going on that I just didn't realise the gravity of at the time.

OP posts:
Notmoresugar · 14/08/2021 11:20

@billy1966
Pretty much from the start - I can see now she was a pressure-pot waiting to explode.

Possibly another factor and a bit of a drip-feed (there's always far more background to a story but I would literally be writing pages and pages):

I didn't realize how grave/bad the situation was between her and her parents until we were actually there.

Her father is narcistic and can be extremely difficult/controlling.

With hindsight I think I probably went down like a lead balloon with her because I engaged with her parents on the odd occasion they were present (the mutual ground in the house is the kitchen).

I know her parents from old (they have always been very nice to me and I like them) and I would never be rude/take sides as it would have made the situation much worse in my opinion.

Don't get me wrong, I completely understand having been in a similar situation myself at just how difficult her current living situation is.

For the record, I took lots of food/wine and a present for her and of course for her DS's birthday.

Someone asked upthread if my DS was working for her when she shreaked at him and turned me into stone.

Sorry I didn't phrase it properly - he wasn't actually working for her - he was helping her by lifting her very heavy work for her.

Not blaming her DS at all (he's lovely), but just to explain the situation, he was lounging about on his phone at the time and didn't volunteer at all to help.

OP posts:
TempleofZoom · 14/08/2021 10:44

@BoredZelda

Very interesting that freezing is hard-wired into us at a very young age where we are too weak to speak up for ourselves or to flee the situation

There are lots of things that are natural reactions when we are young. We grow out of them when we realise they are a problem.

No Freeze or fight/ flight is hardwired into us . Fawn is often the result of an abusive situation and the need for survival. Freeze is actually sometimes a mechanism by which the brain processes and assesses threat and while this is happening prepares us pysiologically for fight or flight. This need to always be right or prove the Op is wrong is really tedious. Its far more complex and while the behaviour wasnt pleasant it sounds like there is far more going on here.
billy1966 · 14/08/2021 10:34

@kumquat365

Actually I don't think the shower is unreasonable at all.

Extremely practical to say upfront that hot water is limited.

My teens are demons for the 30 minute shower and I have definitely roared at them over it.

As for snacking on a full packet of ham from the fridge, extremely rude, likewise a full pan of bread.

If I was bringing teens with a large appetite anywhere, I would have a boot full of carby snacks for them to go through between the hosts meals.

Basic manners IMO.

Several of my children have stayed with friends families over the summer and I sent them away with bags of snacks and gifted pre made currys/ homemade pasta sauces all ready to cook.

Hosting can be a big logistical effort if it is for a crowd and shops aren't close by.

It is a very generous thing to do.

OP, was she fine before the 3rd day?

SoupDragon · 14/08/2021 10:32

@LitPearl

It's a different situation and I don't know why kumquat posted because presumably she is not planning on making her guests sleep on the floor and not planning on giving less consideration to safety protocols for her friend's children than she would give to her own children.

the OP didn't come on here moaning about ham slices so it's a different set of circumstances.

If you would treat your guests well and give them a bed and the same safety equipment you'd give your own children then this thread isn't about you.

Nevertheless, she did post and people responded.
LitPearl · 14/08/2021 10:29

It's a different situation and I don't know why kumquat posted because presumably she is not planning on making her guests sleep on the floor and not planning on giving less consideration to safety protocols for her friend's children than she would give to her own children.

the OP didn't come on here moaning about ham slices so it's a different set of circumstances.

If you would treat your guests well and give them a bed and the same safety equipment you'd give your own children then this thread isn't about you.

BoredZelda · 14/08/2021 10:28

Very interesting that freezing is hard-wired into us at a very young age where we are too weak to speak up for ourselves or to flee the situation

There are lots of things that are natural reactions when we are young. We grow out of them when we realise they are a problem.

Haveyoubrushedyourteeth · 14/08/2021 10:27

You need to speak with your son, tell him your friend was out of order shouting and that you're sorry that you didn't intervene.

The sleeping arrangements were unfortunate, but I'd take it she just wasn't thinking, especially if she's stressed, and the appropriate clothing issue I'd think the same. But shouting at my child....just no. When it comes to my children it's once strike then you're out.

There's no point explaining to her because she'll likely come out all guns blazing, and there's no point beating yourself up about what you did or didn't do. What's done is done. In my opinion silence speaks louder than words in these situations so I'd cut her off without a second thought.

SoupDragon · 14/08/2021 10:21

@MadameMonk

No, I disagree that *@kumquat365* is being somehow… what… ultra bossy? Mean?

She’s offered to host multiple people, over multiple days, at her own expense. She’s outlined all the details of what she’s offering, and been clear about a few basic houserules. That’s called Assertiveness 101. She’s also said that she’s expecting she might need to underline what she’s laid out, if previously entitled teens don’t take her seriously.

Do we all have to be saccharine walkovers who whinge afterwards on MN, or are we also allowed to enjoy putting effort into hosting our mates and their kids, while dealing sensibly with those things that can derail everybody’s good time? And just plain take the piss?

Limiting shower times when there’s not enough water, or restricting the ‘full fridge smorgasbord’ when you’ve got 16 meals ahead? I really don’t see that as stingy or unreasonable?

I host a lot of people, often. In a sought-after location. If I wasn’t ‘allowed’ a few basic ‘house rules’, that’s when I’d stop inviting. It’s an enormous expense and effort. I love it, and the chaos that ensues. But I’m not a mug.

I agree 100%

I can't believe people thought she was unreasonable!

LitPearl · 14/08/2021 10:19

with regard to the freeze fawn fight flight responses, I also find them fascinating.

I have found over the last two or three years that having been excluded from not one but two groups by 2 different covert scapegoating narcissists, and having survived two exclusions with my integrity intact both times, my poly vagal I was ok. The ''worst'' was tough but survivable and I feel that this will have relaxed my freeze response around these types.
I don't know this yet but I feel it.

The next time some covert narc is trying to exclude me from a group, I won't wither to the same extent. And they may move on to somebody else.

LBirch02 · 14/08/2021 10:18

If it’s put you off OP and from what you’ve posted I don’t blame you - I’d end the friendship - no question. Go with your real feeling here

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/08/2021 10:14

“If you speak to me or DS in that way again it will be for the last time. Now, please apologise to DS”.

EmergencyPoncho · 14/08/2021 10:14

Sorry I should have RTFT. It was last week. I'm surprised you managed to stay quiet tbh.

EmergencyPoncho · 14/08/2021 10:11

Leave. She's taking you for granted. And your DS.

MoreAloneTime · 14/08/2021 10:07

And fuck me a whole loaf of bread and I'm not even one of those competitive low carbers

MadameMonk · 14/08/2021 10:06

No, I disagree that @kumquat365 is being somehow… what… ultra bossy? Mean?

She’s offered to host multiple people, over multiple days, at her own expense. She’s outlined all the details of what she’s offering, and been clear about a few basic houserules. That’s called Assertiveness 101. She’s also said that she’s expecting she might need to underline what she’s laid out, if previously entitled teens don’t take her seriously.

Do we all have to be saccharine walkovers who whinge afterwards on MN, or are we also allowed to enjoy putting effort into hosting our mates and their kids, while dealing sensibly with those things that can derail everybody’s good time? And just plain take the piss?

Limiting shower times when there’s not enough water, or restricting the ‘full fridge smorgasbord’ when you’ve got 16 meals ahead? I really don’t see that as stingy or unreasonable?

I host a lot of people, often. In a sought-after location. If I wasn’t ‘allowed’ a few basic ‘house rules’, that’s when I’d stop inviting. It’s an enormous expense and effort. I love it, and the chaos that ensues. But I’m not a mug.

Notmoresugar · 14/08/2021 09:51

THANK YOU to so many of you - you know who you are and I'm sorry not to have reply individually to you as there are so many of you, but you have really helped me and I cannot tell you how much I appreciate it.

@SchadenfreudePersonified
Very interesting that freezing is hard-wired into us at a very young age where we are too weak to speak up for ourselves or to flee the situation. Thank you - it makes so much sense to me now.

OP posts:
Ijsbear · 14/08/2021 09:51

It's AIBU, notmore, you'll get people who love to make you the one in the wrong. Just ignore 'em.

When something is so unexpected and shocking it does floor you!

carboncheque and a couple of other posters have made really sensible points. About speaking to her, you said she's the sort to not behave like this to private school parents and that she'll probably call you oversensitive if you speak to her directly. If she's that sort of person you won't get any resolution and it can leave you feeling worse, so the only reason to speak to her is for your own satisfaction. Someone upthread phrased a possible sentence or two well.

A shame the friendship's ended like this but for whatever reason she behaved like this, it's done.

WorldsBestBoss · 14/08/2021 09:48

@stepupandbecounted

Any else feeling a bit sorry for kumqat's 'friends'? When friends stay with me they are very welcome to eat whatever they need to stop feeling hungry particularly if they are teenagers! How can you start limiting food, and if they eat more than you have allocated you will shout at them?

You have 'allocated' food?? You sound like a total nightmare host, potentially eclipsing op's experience.

ffs buy more bread, remind them gently the water runs out quickly or don't invite them in the first place Confused

Yes!!
Swipe left for the next trending thread