Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
WouldBeGood · 14/08/2021 07:10

I’m a Scottish parent and horrified, though I am pleased that at last what the SG has been pushing has got the attention from the outer world. People can’t believe it as it’s so insane.

The guidelines are actually just as bad. No right to single sex toilets in schools, no talk of safeguards for, example, women and girls.

merrymouse · 14/08/2021 07:06

Any government policy that uses the phrase ‘assigned at birth’ is not neutral and is an imposition of ideology.

GreenEggsAndBacon · 14/08/2021 06:56

I think this must be beyond difficult to teach. And I am very unhappy with schools keeping things from parents. I think keeping anything from parents should only be the last resort.

We are not in Scotland but DS’ (early primary) school taught the children this crap without warning the parents. I was so cross. DS came home telling me that drawing was for girls so he needed to quit drawing (DS loves drawing and is amazing at it). DS actually seemed to worry that he might turn into a girl if he kept drawing and the thought terrified him. He also speculated that a boy in his class might really be a girl because this boy had shoulder long hair.

How can you teach this sensibly to children who believe in Santa? Without increasing stereotypes? I hate sex stereotypes Angry.

54321nought · 14/08/2021 06:45

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.
small children do not feel suicidal

suicide is a learnt behaviour

suicide is a lot more likely after transitioning compared to before

FourTeaFallOut · 14/08/2021 06:39

No class, Mel Gibson is not a woman. Yes, he does have long hair....yes, it's technically a skirt, I suppose...yes, he does like a blue eye...but, he's a man and we know this because ...yes, I'll resign.

HeddaAga · 14/08/2021 06:19

They dressed in a non-typical way for a year or so before changing their name.

They dressed in a non-typical way? What does that mean? So they dressed differently from the way society expects a boy or girl to dress? Why does this always come back to social stereotypes about clothes. This. Does. Not. Mean. A. Child's. Body. Is. Wrong.

SmokeyDevil · 14/08/2021 06:09

@FourTeaFallOut

Are they also going to teach 4yo children to jump through the linguistic hoops and reality pitfalls to affirm other people's dysphoria? Shall we tell them that we should affirm the anorexics assertion that they are actually fat or that the teen taking steroids to bulk up is following their own path to self acceptance?
Well they won't talk about anorexia or steroids because they aren't the 'in' topics right now. Give it a year and the snp will either change it to the next controversial subject or they will be gunning for independence so they'll have braveheart on repeat in all schools. Grin
ItsDinah · 14/08/2021 06:03

Children much older than four believe in Santa Claus. The myth of the Vagina Fairy ,who will swap your biological sex,should not be told to children in schools until they have a grip on the distinction between the reality and unreality of Santa.

FourTeaFallOut · 14/08/2021 05:47

And would it make them kinder children to do that?

FourTeaFallOut · 14/08/2021 05:44

Are they also going to teach 4yo children to jump through the linguistic hoops and reality pitfalls to affirm other people's dysphoria? Shall we tell them that we should affirm the anorexics assertion that they are actually fat or that the teen taking steroids to bulk up is following their own path to self acceptance?

SmokeyDevil · 14/08/2021 05:33

@GreatAuntEmily

Horrendous stats on drug deaths, shortage of funding for education etcetc but SNP want to be wokey McWokeface and they spend their time on this. Honestly Scotland gets what it deserves voting for this bunch.
We don't all like snp, trust me. Only 45% of Scotland actually voted for them, the snp are just too daft to have realised this means they are not actually as popular as they think.

They should be spending money on things they have control over, which is a lot now thanks to their whining. But they don't bother. They just blame England for things failing. Them being in full charge of Scotland will bring it to its knees.

I also don't agree with this. Tell kids they can like whatever they want, sure. But telling them they may not feel like they are a boy or a girl and want to be different? That's just pushing confusion onto them. You wait, give in 20-30 years and you'll have people complaining that they were pushed into believing they were a boy when they were a girl and vice versa.

montysma1 · 14/08/2021 03:57

A, great many S kttish parents are not OK with this. But we can do fuck all about it.
A woman is already facing charges for saying that sex is real.

SaltySheepdog · 14/08/2021 03:24

Personally I feel this will create safeguarding issues with schools automatically affirming the ideology and parents unable to safeguard their vulnerable children. Particularly in light of trans identifying young people often being influenced by peers ideas around the trans ideology or having some body issues due to puberty/trauma/abuse or other factors such as autism and anxiety.

Yellownotblue · 14/08/2021 03:14

@PicaK
so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth

I don’t understand this. There is no call made about gender, either at birth or afterwards.

Sex is observed (at birth and, in the vast majority of cases, well before birth), not assigned. There is no sorting hat.

Gender is a social construct, but sex is biological. My 10 year old boy understands this.

As for “making the wrong call” - whose call do you think that is, and how is it wrong?

Scottishskifun · 14/08/2021 03:06

I'm all for teaching acceptance and tolerance. Not happy with the language used though especially the "assigned at birth" statements.

Definitely agree with moving away from stereotyping especially in young children but for me it has the potential to go too far and is then dependent on the teacher.

Given our education stats are horrific I would have hoped that more focus would have been on improving this but I don't expect anything more from the SNP.

Also a lot of us don't vote for this!

VashtaNerada · 14/08/2021 02:59

I think teachers deserve more credit here. In my class I relentlessly challenge gender stereotypes and obviously wouldn’t be saying that a child who doesn’t conform to stereotypes is another gender. I’ve only ever taught one child who has transitioned socially (with parental knowledge) and it is really unusual at primary age. This particular child has been adamant about being a different gender since nursery but only started to use a different name in Year 4. They dressed in a non-typical way for a year or so before changing their name. I’m no longer their teacher but I know that I’d be making it very clear that they could change back to their old name any time they want, and would continue to challenge gender stereotypes with the whole class. It is really rare for this type of thing to come up with young children and teachers would use their professional judgement as and when it does.

LemonSwan · 14/08/2021 02:40

I am starting to think we should be telling the kids earlier.

Young kids are pretty cutting with their question interrogations and have literally no filter. That doesn't really develop until 7 earliest.

You try telling a 6 yo that a non passing TW is a woman and they will laugh at you, stamp their feet and indignantly shout 'no its a man!'

QueenBee52 · 14/08/2021 02:03

@GintyMcGinty

I'm a Scottish parent and I'm quite happy that my children are taught understanding and tolerance in nursery and school.

do you not practise this at home ?

KingofQueens · 14/08/2021 02:03

@mizz70

I am Scottish also had a female only cancer that only biological females can have , I have a daughter this makes me mad you cannot change biological sex
No. But you can change your gender. Sex and gender are not the same. This is about GENDER not biological sex.
GintyMcGinty · 14/08/2021 01:55

I'm a Scottish parent and I'm quite happy that my children are taught understanding and tolerance in nursery and school.

QueenBee52 · 14/08/2021 01:53

@Wineandroses3

It’s absolutely totally and utterly ridiculous to any reasonable person.

I agree 🌺

JustJoinedRightNow · 14/08/2021 01:25

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.
I agree with this post.
MummBraTheEverLeaking · 14/08/2021 01:21

Sex is not "assigned at birth". This was usually used when talking about those with DSDs. For it to be used in this manner is ridiculous.

You cannot change sex. Sure you can take various hormones, have whatever surgeries but it does not mean you have literally changed into the opposite sex. We are not doing anyone any favours by presenting the line that you somehow can just because we don't want anyone to get upset. Not everyone has a 'gender identity' whatever that even means. Everyone has a sex though. Gender should not be trumping sex.

Kids should be able to play with whatever the hell they want or wear what they like without a "that's for girls/boys" message behind it. Kids don't know 'girls' things and 'boy' things until they get told ffs.

There is nothing wrong with watchful waiting, but unfortunately that doesn't make certain charities and organisations any money - so now we're told there is! Who'd have thunk it eh?!

So yes, creating a problem where there is none for lots of affirming only sevice referrals and forking out for training and it's all very lovely and progressive isn't it 🤔

Wineandroses3 · 13/08/2021 23:56

It’s absolutely totally and utterly ridiculous to any reasonable person.

QueenBee52 · 13/08/2021 23:55

@HeddaAga

The relentless proliferation of this ideology is creating a problem for our children where there isn’t one.

Amen. Leave the kids alone.

this 🎉