Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 14/08/2021 08:07

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.
You've swallowed the Mermaids propaganda whole here. Activists trying to get us to prioritise gender over sex have done their level best to prevent research in this area, but a few short years ago when the number of trans-identifying people was far, far smaller than it is now, and when the majority were male, not teenage females as now, researchers found that most people with gender dysphoria had at least one of the following:

Experience of a family trauma, e.g. bereavement, parents divorcing

Experience of sexual abuse

Being on the autistic spectrum

Being depressed/anxious, often as a result of bullying at school

Came from home a home/community/religious group with rigid gender stereotyping and where homosexuality was regarded as a sin

If a boy is told from babyhood on 'Put the doll down, that's a girls' toy! You're a boy, you don't play with dolls. Why aren't you out playing football with the other boys? What's the matter with you? No, you can't play with the dressing up clothes, what are you, a cissy? Stop crying, you're a boy, boys don't cry!' and so on, it's no wonder he may start to feel that being a boy is awful and he'd be happier as a girl. And vice versa for girls.

If a child is in extreme distress, what's needed is counselling/therapy from an experienced, sensible professional, probably for the whole family, so the child's natural personality is accepted. It's beyond my comprehension how we've got to a point where this kind of approach is considered harmful and putting a child on track to have irreversible harmful changes to their healthy body from hormone therapy and surgery is considered preferable.

Icecreamsoda99 · 14/08/2021 08:06

so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth

What?!? Sex is determined at birth (and before) from what can be seen.

Awalkintime · 14/08/2021 08:05

I was that 4 year old who wanted to be a boy. The reality was I wanted to be able to do the things I wasn't able to as a girl such as play football or get muddy. I also looked up to my big brother and wanted to be just like him. I proved to people I was a boy by teaching myself to pee standing up.

I was immature with an immature logic about what would allow me to do the same things my amazing brother could and I figured being a boy would let me do that.

If I was 4 now, I would be pushed down the line of being trans and that would've fucked up my life completely. It would've ruined my life.

It is sexism for the new generation - if you are a boy you behave this way. If you are a girl who behaves this way, you are also a boy. It's 1950s sexism.

AndTheReasonIsYou · 14/08/2021 08:02

I hate this cult. Hell would freeze over before I would vote for them. I guess the issue is the lack of a viable alternative. My husband for example (highly clever and educated person) votes for them because there’s no one else for him to realistically vote for as a supporter of independence (we don’t discuss politics in our house. I think I’d end up divorcing him the whole thing makes me so angry). He simply will not vote Tory and the rest of them are pretty farcical.

chalamet · 14/08/2021 08:00

I don’t think it’s hugely helpful to be telling children that liking certain things that society says are female makes them girls, or the other way around. I think it’s far more beneficial to let them know that they can express themselves however they want regardless of whether they are a boy or a girl. They don’t need to put themselves in boxes.

There are trans people who say they’ve known they were trans since they can remember - I’m not saying that children don’t experience these feelings but the majority don’t. I have always dealt with it by saying that all children can enjoy all toys/clothes/games.

NecessaryScene · 14/08/2021 07:53

Here's Helen Joyce (of the Economist, who's just written a book on the subject) talking about the social contagion aspect, comparing it with eating disorders, and how they've spread around the world, partly via teaching:

NecessaryScene · 14/08/2021 07:48

Teaching about "gender dysphoria" is to some extent like teaching about anorexia or bulimia.

There may be a very small number of children who might suffer spontaneously.

There is a much larger number of children who will pick up the idea because of the teaching, and some of those will try to use it as a solution/coping mechanism.

This is already happening without the "help" of schools, from online influence - hence the 4000% increase in girls going to gender clinics over the last 10 years.

But even beyond that, the entire philosophical basis ends up creating a complete mess - teaching kids that "femininity = woman" and "masculinity = man". (Activists will deny this to the cows come home, but how else can you pitch this at 5-year-old level? It's either anatomy or stereotypes. You can't teach them Judith Butler postmodern "what do words mean anyway" bullshit).

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:47

Exactly. It's all sexist tripe.

The child I taught with asd who started to think he was trans (after being told that was "his problem" by older siblings who watched a documentary on trans; "I have a woman trapped in my head") simply liked long hair and dresses, but society said no.

Then the damage was done. The Tavistock recognised he had no issue with his body or name luckily.

I remember he refused to play football on pe lesson till I showed him the women's team and a men's team who wear pink. Then he did so happily and aced it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/08/2021 07:44

The key issue is that guidance is advising teachers that significant information relating to a child’s welfare may be withheld from a young child’s legal guardian without any proper process.

That’s been part of the guidance since the original guidance, which was deemed to be unlawful (yet still remained live for 4 years). This guidance has been amended to better reflect the law, the original was a horror show but the ability to socially transition without parental knowledge has been in place for several years now. I’m just glad that folk are finally becoming aware of what’s happening in schools.

GreenEggsAndBacon · 14/08/2021 07:42

Ok, so say there are a tiny amount of dysphoric children that this may help. Great!

But are they helped by imposing stereotypes on them? My DS is a happy boy and wants to be a boy. After these gender lessons he wanted to stop hobbies that were “for girls”. That is crazy. What if he had come home as said “I like drawing so I must be a girl?” In his case football won.

However well intended these lessons don’t seem to work in many cases.

rogdmum · 14/08/2021 07:40

[quote Cabinfever10]@BoredZelda considering that the guidance that this replaced was ruled illegal in a court of law I am extremely troubled by how little has been changed especially when you look at the number of parents who have been reported to social services by schools simply for choosing a watchful waiting approach (tried and tested treatment) verses affirmation therapy (highly controversial and experimental) this is what happens when the person who is in charge of the education department is the same person who is behind the self id for anyone who is 16+ after just a few months 🤯🤬[/quote]
My daughter’s school referred us to social services for not affirming her as a boy. This was a year after they fully supported her social transition at school without telling us, then when we found out, pretended they had rowed back and then we we found that out, told us we had no say as parents.

My daughter has been assessed both privately and on the NHS and affirmation is harmful to her. Social services also assessed after the school reported us, and agreed with the mental health professionals and said school was causing division.

Yet the school refuses to row back - I’m assuming because of their adherence to the previous LGBTYS guidance (and now official from ScotGov) which says pupils must be affirmed.

I raised it with ScotGov who assured me the role of parents would be included in the new guidance and they are- to pretty much tell schools to work to educate us in the importance of affirming. ScotGov did tell me that schools are not legally obliged to affirm where mental health professionals have advised against it- I.e. it is a choice by the school and it is likely unlawful without parental agreement (hence the stressing to schools in the new guidance that they need to take their own legal advice):

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/35e99aa2-b038-11eb-b844-593e41a4a1a5?shareToken=111b69dc74c66a8e42f675ad782cf15d

I have written to LGBTYS to ask their position where mental health experts have advised against affirmation. They haven’t bothered to respond.

I’m far from alone. It has been happening in schools under the old guidance and I suspect will increase under the new one.

stillcrazyafterall · 14/08/2021 07:38

I was a 'tomboy' when young. No one laughed, or gave a monkey's. My eldest son (in his 30s) 'got married' at play school. He wore the dress. No laughed or cared. When 11 he dressed up as a WW1 nurse. No one cared or laughed. Just let everyone be what they want to be when they want to be it.

Jourdain11 · 14/08/2021 07:35

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.
The "wrong call"? Medical professionals react to what they see! It might be "incorrect" subsequently, but it's not "wrong".
WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:34

I've seen that the guidance recommends teaching about pink and blue brains.

Is this sexist tripe true?

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:34

*if

merrymouse · 14/08/2021 07:33

'Recognising the rights of all parents and carers, it is recommended that consent is obtained from all of those with parental responsibilities for those young people under 16. '

Legal guardians don’t need information about their child’s welfare to protect their own rights, they need it to protect their children’s rights.

The document seems to frame this as a confrontation or clash of rights.

However, unless a court has intervened, a parent is the only person who can represent their child’s rights. A school does not have the authority to make decisions on a child’s behalf, so is not in a position to provide care.

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:33

Of Scotland are happy to allow young children to transition, I hope they're going to be honest about some of the side effects youngsters will end up with, that are rarely discussed, so that full informed consent can be made:

Sinead moves on to discuss the gynaecological issues cross section hormones cause, which really belong on the meno board.

twitter.com/imwatson91/status/1426304418727833604?s=21

Obviously this isn't including effects on bone health.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught
SpellItOutForMe · 14/08/2021 07:30

When the discussion (inevitably) turns to the definition of 'trans' being something along the lines of, "having a different gender identity to the sex you were assigned at birth", I always want to ask what gender identity they think matches being 'assigned female at birth'.

Even leaving aside the "assigned at birth" bit, that phrase is always a sleight of hand. It's not, "identifying with another sex to the sex you were assigned at birth" or even, "having a different gender identity to the gender identity you were assigned at birth" which compare apples and apples, or oranges and oranges and can be debated sensibly. The sentence starts with gender identity and quickly pivots to sex as though they're synonymous.

The only answers to the question of which gender identities match being female lead down a sexist rabbit hole. At best you'll have someone tell you that it's someone who "feels female", but probing that one step further either leads to exactly the same sexist stereotypes or a claim to basically religious belief and a refusal to expand ('you just know') because they are completely aware that any fuller answer leads to sexist stereotypes.

I don't think it's conscious and deliberate in most people; I think it's a sad indictment of the deeply baked-in sexism in which we live without really being aware of it.

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:27

Why should kids (parents of kids and the adults around them) fuck up their bodies when it's social pressures that are the root cause?

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 07:26

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.

So much complexity in what kids are told/ taught/ absorb from society: (words of a transwoman)

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught
merrymouse · 14/08/2021 07:21

It’s not great, but it’s more measured than it was.

I don’t think so.

The key issue is that guidance is advising teachers that significant information relating to a child’s welfare may be withheld from a young child’s legal guardian without any proper process.

WouldBeGood · 14/08/2021 07:20

And people are scared in case they’re called transphobic and possibly prosecuted.

WouldBeGood · 14/08/2021 07:19

@Namechangednotanewuser

What I don’t get is why are Scottish parents ok with it? Why do they put up with this? It’s a child protection issue. The relentless proliferation of this ideology is creating a problem for our children where there isn’t one.
@Namechangednotanewuser I genuinely think people don’t know what’s going on.

And they struggle to believe it as it sounds so mad.

merrymouse · 14/08/2021 07:13

Maybe you would have been happier changing gender or not being confined to a gender had you been given the option.

Women have been fighting for the right to not be confined to a gender for hundreds of years.

Until recently we were making good progress.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/08/2021 07:10

The new guidance is more measured than the old - yes it’s still possible for a child to transition socially at school without their parents knowledge, but the previous guidance saw girls being excluded from toilets, changing rooms and dormitories if they refused to share with a transitioning child, and parents not being told their child was sharing a bedroom with a trans child.

It’s not great, but it’s more measured than it was.