Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
Soberanne · 14/08/2021 10:08

Ideally we would live in a world without gender where everyone regardless of sex can live the life they choose without discrimination. We are a long way from that sadly.

And i dont believe for a second there are that many young people claiming to be trans just so they can access the opposites sexes private space. And that seems to always be the argument we come back too.

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 10:05

Why are most posters only talking about male to female trans. What about young female teens wanting to be boys. Surely the issues are the same. Should a female be able to access male changing areas.

What we need is good educated school staff who can identify gender dysphoria and put the support in place. While allowing all the children the freedom to explore gender, sexuality etc etc without pressure or assumption while we educate them along the way.

Jorrris · 14/08/2021 10:03

Gender dysphroria is real.

Although not a requirement to transition.

Artichokeleaves · 14/08/2021 09:58

Supposed tolerance has given way to heightened intolerance.

This.

The massive majority of people are/were very chilled about all this.

Boys want to play with dolls, wear dresses, girls want to play football and climb trees, great, gender stereotypes are restrictive nonsense.

But now we're into :

Sex is assigned at birth. Er, no. Sex is in every cell, determined at conception, and no one is confused about this.

Your likes and choices decide your true sex, not your body. Er, no. Because that's sexism on crack.

Male children should be allowed to undress and toilet in female children's facilities if they wish to, regardless of the female children's privacy, dignity and feelings about this. Er no. Because female children are not less human or important than male ones.

Having homosexual feelings is bad and wrong because it excludes people who are not of the sex you are exclusively attracted to but identify as being, and this makes them unhappy. - WTF?

Female children's boundaries must be predicated first on what a male person's choice is and whether their 'no' is upsetting to the male person. If it is, they should set aside their boundaries and 'be kind'. Are you fucking kidding me?

Standard, basic safeguarding exceptions should be made for children who identify as being a different sex to their reality: also in reality this almost always is about a male person being able to access female only facilities because kindness and supporting identity matters more than protecting children. Hell to the no.

The weaponisation of suicide has been debunked repeatedly. In fact, children with anorexia and autism are statistically much higher risk, there are just no expensive, government funded groups informing everyone of this to support a political agenda.

There is a whole lot to question here. Just hoping #bekind will disappear the issues is naive in the extreme at this point.

ikeepseeingit · 14/08/2021 09:58

@mogsrus

Mrs cat has 2 kittens,1 is female,the other is obviously a male,& through their entire life,neither will want to change, only humans could dream up,for that's what it is,an absolute rubbish dream,such ridiculous thoughts such as wanting to be this or that, despair at its finest.
Are you comparing the human brain to a cats? Gender dysphroria is real. We have no idea what the cat is thinking, mostly they want to chase mice. Adult humans have far more complexity than that. The real problem is that 4 year olds do not have that same kind of complexity, and to assume they will understand what we’re explaining to them when they don’t know their ABC’s is a bit preposterous.
Soberanne · 14/08/2021 09:50

@mogsrus sorry i completely disagree. To me your comment is insinuating that there is no trans people. There is. And For many of them its a long and difficult journey.

mogsrus · 14/08/2021 09:45

Mrs cat has 2 kittens,1 is female,the other is obviously a male,& through their entire life,neither will want to change, only humans could dream up,for that's what it is,an absolute rubbish dream,such ridiculous thoughts such as wanting to be this or that, despair at its finest.

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 09:45

sorry i disagree. Its still much more difficult for a middle age man to come out as trans than young adults and teens. So you cant compare. Young people are growing up in a society where it is more accepted and rightly so.

However i do think amongst teens it has become a trend. Ad every generation of teens had their trend. The reason this is so worrying is that children are being allowed to physically change their bodies.

Further to this, the huge increase is also seeing services being pushed to their limits meaning that those young people who genuinely need the help and support cant access it.

Whatwouldscullydo · 14/08/2021 09:38

It’s absolute garbage to assert that there are scores of school aged children running around with gender dysphoria. It seems like the political trans lobby have pushed it until it has become a trend amongst older kids to want to try this ‘trend’. It’s just the Lea test fad. And onto the younger ones. Why should they be left unscathed by this harmful indoctrination

This is frequently asked. Where are all the middle aged transmen. If this was really about increased tolerance etc we'd see equal declarations representative if the current cohort ( majority now being girls ) . But we aren't.

If there was a 4000 percent increase in people getting cancer or developing onset adult allergies or something they're woykd be some kind of investigation. Instead penny mordant promised us ( I'm in England) a review but it never materialised.

Why.

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 09:36

I think that overall its great that society is becoming more Accepting as we should be, but we are going a step too far. Children should be taught about all walks of life and should be taught acceptance. But

Young children know nothing of gender. Its a social Construction based on what society thinks should be the norm regarding sex. By declaring children need to change sex to meet gender stereotypes is actually going backwards when we spent such a long time fighting for gender equality.

Since teaching children about trans etc there has been a rapid increase, is this because more children are willing to speak or is it because its a trend p. Of course these things have always been around and of course the children who need the support should absolutely be given it to the highest level but i feel that we are planting seeds in children's minds that just dont need to be there.

We can educate children when the time is right, as teenagers and young adults but we dont need to be focusing on this for nursery and primary children . Let them be children. But educate the adults, all adults so that if and when children do need support its there.

GreenEggsAndBacon · 14/08/2021 09:35

I worry about gay children too based on what DS said. He came home and told me that all gay boys were effeminate. This was after the same external trans/pride/whatever was in school. I read him the riot act - poor DS was quite taken aback.

Sexuality has nothing to do with identity and presentation.

DS had tons of questions about both trans, mainly “what do I need to stop doing so I won’t turn into a girl?”. I think that is limiting and unforgivable.

DS also had questions about being gay mainly “why do all gay boys act so silly” - where I told him it was utter bollocks, they don’t!!! And after that, “ would you mind if I was gay and how would I know?” on which I said that of course I wouldn’t mind the slightest and that he would figure it out once he got older.

The thought of many children having all these stupid misconceptions after these lessons and not being able to talk to their parents or their parents being busy. And what if one of them said “I like drawing, maybe I am a girl then” and the school kept it secret from the parents.

My son came home filled with sex stereotypes and statements I perceived to be homophobic. DS is 8!! We have mostly undone this damage as I am very close to my son and we talk about everything. I fear for the other children.

WouldBeGood · 14/08/2021 09:23

I do agree it’s particularly hard on gay children, as they are not now permitted by a certain sector to assert same sex attraction without being proclaimed bigots.

Namechangednotanewuser · 14/08/2021 09:16

It’s absolute garbage to assert that there are scores of school aged children running around with gender dysphoria. It seems like the political trans lobby have pushed it until it has become a trend amongst older kids to want to try this ‘trend’. It’s just the Lea test fad. And onto the younger ones. Why should they be left unscathed by this harmful indoctrination.

OP posts:
headintheproverbial · 14/08/2021 09:13

@PicaK

I think gender dysphoria is real. I think if it saves a small child from feeling suicidal it's a good thing. I can only imagine it's an incredibly emotional and hard thing to parent... so much guilt at having let the wrong call be made after birth. Showing signs by 4 and having battled through seeing Drs and being referred - It's hardly something people are going to rush into on a whim.
No one 'made a call' at birth. A baby's sex is declared at birth and noted. No one can change sex. That is quite different from gender and gender identity.
Mummyoflittledragon · 14/08/2021 09:11

Kids are proclaiming they’re trans at dd’s school. Not to the extent of your dd’s school Bridget. That is off the scale. I’m in England btw. Notably this only started happening after lessons at school. Schools are doing such harm to children. Woke bollocks.

Dd is 13 and part of a group of kids, who are all basically super straight. Then there is another group, the lesbians. Again this categorisation of kids in this way only became apparent after the lessons. It then stands to reason at some stage in her school or other schools, there will be a group known as the trans kids, probably filled with the odd boy and a lot of girls with ROGD.

As a parent imo all identity politics has done is created an expectation that children identify themselves within a bunch of stereotypes and sexual preferences. Supposed tolerance has given way to heightened intolerance. And it’s coming from both sides, which is only to be expected due to the hostility surrounding trans. Predictably homosexual kids are getting caught in the cross fire.

When I was at school, it certainly wasn’t like this and I’m early 50s. We didn’t know who was straight, gay or lesbian. Well, one or two boys it was obvious. He used to hang around with the girls because they boys weren’t nice. But kids still aren’t nice and it’s getting worse as battle lines seem to be being drawn. So as far as I’m concerned, things have gone backwards, not forwards.

WarriorN · 14/08/2021 08:48

There's some posters here who really don't have a clue do they?

Even a large number of trans people absolutely do not agree with boxing young children in so early on, given that 80/90 % of children who think they're trans later realise they're gay and the long term medical implications of the drugs.

BridgetJonesPanties · 14/08/2021 08:42

DD is 13yo and in Scotland

Last year was particularly difficult as everyone of her friends seemed to have declared themselves as non-binary, lesbian, gay or trans.

DD got put under pressure to conform and if she continued to say she was straight she was apparently homophobic.

One of her male friends changed his name to Demon (no joke) and apparently demanded all teachers and school staff respected that. They refused as his parents did not know or consent nor did the pupil want them to know. Will they now have to agree?

Another of her friends (female) changed her name to Bubbles (again, no joke) and sent everyone messages about how she loves Pssy and can anyone help find her some pssy. I have known that girl since P1 as she and DD were good friends. She's a lovely girl and its shocking how she's changed. Her mum clearly has no idea of the name change etc but her mum has expressed concerns about her DDs mental health during lockdown.

DD was getting so upset and confused that she begged us to move her to another school. We looked at private schools because the trans movement is everywhere in state.

Fortunately, however, DD seems to have found a 'normal' group at her current school, partly with our help, and hopefully she's gotten away from that crowd now. It was a very scary time for us as parents.

GreenEggsAndBacon · 14/08/2021 08:41

I just wonder about all this. I totally get that we need to help confused children.

But why push gender stereotypes on them? As DS who thought that he had to stop some interests as they were “girly”? This came up on the way home from school the day this was taught.

Why can’t we do away with stereotypes and tell everyone that they are valid?

Waitwhat23 · 14/08/2021 08:31

Posted too soon- *This particularly

Waitwhat23 · 14/08/2021 08:31

I also do hope that there are specific policies to teach tolerance and understanding about all the protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010.

If not, why the focus on particularly?

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/08/2021 08:30

And yes, I noticed that the tone of the whole of this new document is very much about 'educating' 'intolerant' parents - never mind about 'watchful waiting', right?

It was also expressly stated in the old document, this is nothing new.

supermoonrising · 14/08/2021 08:29

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

  • If a boy is told from babyhood on 'Put the doll down, that's a girls' toy! You're a boy, you don't play with dolls. Why aren't you out playing football with the other boys? What's the matter with you? No, you can't play with the dressing up clothes, what are you, a cissy? Stop crying, you're a boy, boys don't cry!' and so on, it's no wonder he may start to feel that being a boy is awful and he'd be happier as a girl. And vice versa for girls.

If a child is in extreme distress, what's needed is counselling/therapy from an experienced, sensible professional, probably for the whole family, so the child's natural personality is accepted. It's beyond my comprehension how we've got to a point where this kind of approach is considered harmful and putting a child on track to have irreversible harmful changes to their healthy body from hormone therapy and surgery is considered preferable.*

Interesting. Sounds possible. Do you have any links to the research you mention which arrived at these conclusions?

Whatwouldscullydo · 14/08/2021 08:28

I'm a Scottish parent and I'm quite happy that my children are taught understanding and tolerance in nursery and school

People always spout this. Usually to try and shut down discussion.

Kids should already he being taught not to he bullies.

If someone could tell me what's tolerant about teaching kids their bounderies and discomfort are bigoted and that removing their privacy and dignity by forcing them all to get changed in mixed sex spaces , that would be great.

That seems the opposite of tolerant to me. It trampled over the rights of every other child.

Waitwhat23 · 14/08/2021 08:27

@rogdmum that's really awful and shows that when people say 'it'll never happen', they are just deluding themselves. The Scottish Government are so captured by this ideology that they are prepared to be unlawful. And yes, I noticed that the tone of the whole of this new document is very much about 'educating' 'intolerant' parents - never mind about 'watchful waiting', right?

Hoping it all works out for you

Feelingoktoday · 14/08/2021 08:11

I’m not happy about the sexist language “girl brains”. I thought we had moved on from this in 2021. I remember in the late 1970s I was not allowed to study metal work or DT at my secondary school because I was a girl. I had hoped this sexist attitude had changed but clearly not.

When I was 6 I thought I was a horse.