Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
Kittii · 14/08/2021 15:27

@Whatwouldscullydo do you know what the 8 criteria are? I've googled and can't find anything.

Whatwouldscullydo · 14/08/2021 15:19

@KittiiI’ve never seen a definition other than “boy things/girl things

The charities that support trans people say its nothing to do with stereotypes or being in the wrong body

However a dx of gender dysphoria requires 6 symptoms out of a list of 8 criteria.

Now if you remove the parts that correlate to the body being wrong or gender stereotypes you are not left with enough to qualify fir a DX

Feelingoktoday · 14/08/2021 15:06

@MellieBellie

The guidance has an infographic that shows the difference between supportive and unsupportive parents. Amongst other things, it states that 4% of 'trans youths with supportive parents' attempt suicide compared to 57% of those with unsupportive parents. I'd imagine any parent would be terrified by these stats.

The data is misleading though. It comes from a Canadian study carried out in 2012 where none of the participants were under the age of 16.

This thread goes into more detail:

threadreaderapp.com/thread/1426476745662902273.html

It's appalling that they've used data gathered from adults in guidance aimed at children as young as 4 yo. It's also shocking that they have advised schools and local authorities that they may need to seek legal advice to ensure that they are complying with the law when they implement these guidelines. That's totally unacceptable from the SG. They have published guidance that they know may be illegal. The SNP are an absolute disgrace.

The data issue is a disgrace. Scaring parents. There is no evidence to support these statements regarding suicide.
WouldBeGood · 14/08/2021 14:57

@Kittii I’ve never seen a definition other than “boy things/girl things”

Jorrris · 14/08/2021 14:55

They have published guidance that they know may be illegal. The SNP are an absolute disgrace.

Yes. How anyone can support them I do not know.

MellieBellie · 14/08/2021 14:46

The guidance has an infographic that shows the difference between supportive and unsupportive parents. Amongst other things, it states that 4% of 'trans youths with supportive parents' attempt suicide compared to 57% of those with unsupportive parents. I'd imagine any parent would be terrified by these stats.

The data is misleading though. It comes from a Canadian study carried out in 2012 where none of the participants were under the age of 16.

This thread goes into more detail:

threadreaderapp.com/thread/1426476745662902273.html

It's appalling that they've used data gathered from adults in guidance aimed at children as young as 4 yo. It's also shocking that they have advised schools and local authorities that they may need to seek legal advice to ensure that they are complying with the law when they implement these guidelines. That's totally unacceptable from the SG. They have published guidance that they know may be illegal. The SNP are an absolute disgrace.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught
Kittii · 14/08/2021 14:08

I find it hard to understand how gender ideology has become so mainstream when no-one can even say what gender means, other than regressive stereotypes e.g. if you like dinosaurs and football you must be a boy with a "boy brain" even though you are biologically a girl.

I've never come across any definition of gender by gender ideologues that doesn't rely on regressive stereotypes or tautology. Does one exist?

merrymouse · 14/08/2021 13:39

And I didn't know about either of them until after they'd already come to the conclusion that they identified this way.

I obviously can't comment on your children or how they reached this conclusion.

However identity based concepts of 'gender fluid' and 'cis' and 'trans' depend on the belief that everyone's identity can be viewed through the lens of cultural expectations of how a man or woman should behave and that there is such a thing as a male and female identify.

People should be as free to believe in gender identity as they should be free to believe in heaven or God.

However people should also be free to believe that identity is an individual and subjective concept and people should not have to classify their identify as anything, and it should be possible to debate and discuss this just as it is possible to debate and discuss any religious belief.

Separately, some people suffer from gender dysphoria and they need evidence based care.

The policy proposed in Scottish schools is ideological, not evidenced based care for children with gender dysphoria.

Feelingoktoday · 14/08/2021 13:39

I’m genderfluid - I think. I’m wearing trousers today. But my hair is long. I work in a traditionally male career and I’m not particularly maternal. Is that what it means that I don’t confirm with what society says is male or female behaviours? But I’m sexually attracted to males.

It’s not the same as bi sexual. Gender fluid does not mean no sexual. Gay, lesbian bi, are not anything to do with gender. To say otherwise is homophobic.

So when someone says their child is gender fluid what does it actually mean?

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 12:56

@GromblesofGrimbledon very well said. People can choose to live as they choose and plenty do. I do not live as a stereotypical woman but i am not living as a man either. I just live my life as i choose.

However there are people who are trans and need to make that change to live their lives as fully as they can. Many of these people as adults state they knew as young children so we need to have the measures in place to support the children when they are young so they dont go through the years of mental torture many trans adults have.

Its about putting in the right education and the right support at the right time. Not forcing it on Children and young people who are trying to find their way in what is a very confusing world.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 14/08/2021 12:56

"However it does not follow that all children who have gender dysphoria have abusive parents."

I didn't say that it did. I said "many". As I have 2 children with gender dysphoria, why would I say that? And I didn't know about either of them until after they'd already come to the conclusion that they identified this way.

GromblesofGrimbledon · 14/08/2021 12:56

@Wakeupin2022

The best way to give EVERY single child in Scotland the best chance is sort out the fuck up that the SNP has made of the education system.

A better education will give those children who do need to change gender a better chance of succeeding in life.

Instead, they are disadvantaging every child in Scotland, females especially.

I get it, Independence is important and the be all and end all for so many- but seriously get a grip and look at the damage these people are doing.

Unfortunately a huge number of Scottish people want independence enough that they are blinkered and do not see the SNP for what they are. Most SNP voters are ex-labour voters. Labour managed to royally fuck up their reputation in Scotland. Everyone I know who votes SNP do so because they don't see an alternative, they are left leaning and think the SNP represents their views, and they are Labour refugees.

The SNP certainly don't get my vote.

toystoyseverywhere · 14/08/2021 12:55

Absolutely agree with the statement kids should just be kids.

At that age they are so young and should just be left to be kids.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/08/2021 12:54

Just like i wouldn't let my 4 year old drive my car or let my 6 year old head off to a nightclub for a night out. When they are old enough they make these decisions for themselves and then i support them to make sure they are carried out safely.

Indeed, my 8 year old can’t decide whether he wants peas or carrots for dinner but can decide he wants to live as a girl? I don’t think so.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 14/08/2021 12:52

@Soberanne

I dont understand how a child can be gender fluid. . Sorry and i genuinely dont mean to offend and would really like to learn.

A child remains the same sex, so gender fluid means they are Sometimes choosing stereotypical male gender roles and sometimes female. But if we just let children be children without the stereotyping in the first place they could freely do as they please without the added issues of labels and declaring them self male or female.

Young children only know what we teach them about gender.

Please dont all attack me as i am genuinely trying to understand and respect everyones opinions.

My genderfluid child is 14 and has identified as genderfluid for about 2 years. He's already said that he didn't know what gender was when he was 4. I don't know when my trans son started identifying as trans, as he lived with my DM and stepdad and police advised we went NC when DD1 was 18, because of a criminal investigation. He told me when he was 25.
GromblesofGrimbledon · 14/08/2021 12:49

@jellybe

I think at four kids should just be kids. It saddens me that any child that young is questioning their gender identity. Maybe if we stopped as a society with the bollocks that gender is and stuck to sex based differences- biology, fewer kids would feel out of place. Some still would due to bodily dysphasia but if we had a truly gender neutral approaches (not sex neutral) for kids when so young would surely help.

I agree. This situation has been created. There are those who would argue that "trans children" have always existed when in fact this issue has been created in modern society, and very recently at that.

There is a vanishingly small section of the population who will decide to live as though they are the opposite sex and are free to do so in adulthood. That does not mean we should be pushing what amounts to the political ideologies of gender identity and self-identification onto primary aged children.

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 12:42

@Jellycatspyjamas i agree. Unless you completely bow down and agree to everything including transitioning you are accused of being unsupportive, transphobic,

But most parents want whats best for their children. And waiting to see what happens is not an easy option either but is often the right one. I would support my children in whatever they choose but i will not support my child to physically alter there body until they are an adult and can make that measured decision under their own merit. Just like i wouldn't let my 4 year old drive my car or let my 6 year old head off to a nightclub for a night out. When they are old enough they make these decisions for themselves and then i support them to make sure they are carried out safely.

jellybe · 14/08/2021 12:42

I think at four kids should just be kids. It saddens me that any child that young is questioning their gender identity. Maybe if we stopped as a society with the bollocks that gender is and stuck to sex based differences- biology, fewer kids would feel out of place. Some still would due to bodily dysphasia but if we had a truly gender neutral approaches (not sex neutral) for kids when so young would surely help.

merrymouse · 14/08/2021 12:41

@TheLovelinessOfDemons

"A 21 year old is legally an adult. Regardless of your relationship, you do not have parental responsibility.

If a child is being abused that is a matter for social services and there are procedures that must be followed.

Your post gives the impression that you haven’t thought about this issue in much depth."

He's been abused his whole life and this is just something else to use as an excuse for abuse. Thankfully, he's managed to get his money paid to him instead of his parents recently. I realise I don't have parental responsibility, but I do care about him. I've thought so deeply about this issue, you wouldn't believe. Most young trans people who commit suicide do so as a result of parental abuse. I actually don't understand why people can't support their children however they turn out.

There is no data that shows that trans people are more likely to commit suicide, and very, very few children commit suicide.

I think studies have shown that people who have suffered from abuse may be more likely to suffer from gender dysphoria.

However it does not follow that all children who have gender dysphoria have abusive parents.

However, this guidance goes beyond helping children with gender dysphoria and promotes an ideological stance on gender identity.

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 12:36

@Wakeupin2022 never in my life as a mumsnetter have I agreed so much with a post.

Well said

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 14/08/2021 12:34

@Jellycatspyjamas

Some parents are abusive, but this guidance assumes parents aren’t able to respond in a caring, measured way and also assumes that the only right way to support children exploring their gender identity is affirmation and social transitioning. The parent who supports their child while taking a watchful waiting stance (which is shown to be appropriate for children) are labelled as transphobic and abusive, and simply in need of education.

It’s gaslighting in the extreme and sets child against parent and parent against school. How can that possibly be a good place to work from.

Yes I agree that this is wrong.
Soberanne · 14/08/2021 12:34

Please dont take offence anyone as i am genuinely supportive of everyone and am just-trying to understand

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 12:32

@Kittii i agree

I really dont want to offend but am struggling to understand.

At birth i was born female. With that came certain expectations by society as a female, my gender role Was defined as female. I only know what it feels like to be me and i conform to some of these female gender roles but i also dont and technically i also conform to some male gender roles and others i dont.

Sorry i am struggling to explain. But i only know what i feel so how do i know if i feel male or female. How does a child know they are feeling male then female, really they are just feeling being them.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 14/08/2021 12:32

"A 21 year old is legally an adult. Regardless of your relationship, you do not have parental responsibility.

If a child is being abused that is a matter for social services and there are procedures that must be followed.

Your post gives the impression that you haven’t thought about this issue in much depth."

He's been abused his whole life and this is just something else to use as an excuse for abuse. Thankfully, he's managed to get his money paid to him instead of his parents recently. I realise I don't have parental responsibility, but I do care about him. I've thought so deeply about this issue, you wouldn't believe. Most young trans people who commit suicide do so as a result of parental abuse. I actually don't understand why people can't support their children however they turn out.

Jourdain11 · 14/08/2021 12:32

@Kittii

I'm finding it really hard to understand what genderfluid means. What does it mean for your gender to change hour by hour? And what does "people who feel as though only part of their gender is fluid" mean?
Maybe it means you identify as running water??
Swipe left for the next trending thread