Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
Waitwhat23 · 13/08/2021 23:54

The Scottish Government were pulled up in a recent court case for stating that TWAW is a Governmental policy when this has not been publicised to the general public and neither have the general public been consulted. This is a natural progression of that policy.

HeddaAga · 13/08/2021 23:50

The relentless proliferation of this ideology is creating a problem for our children where there isn’t one.

Amen. Leave the kids alone.

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 23:49

@Waitwhat23
Strangely enough the guidance in question has been created in consultation with stonewall.

OP posts:
Waitwhat23 · 13/08/2021 23:47

And the phrase 'sex assigned at birth' indicates institutional capture. Sex can be observed in utero through scans and amino tests, sometimes at a very early stage. It is not assigned at birth, unless referring to historically in terms of people with a disorder of sexual development (DSD, often incorrectly referred to as Intersex) whose sex would be assigned in the case of ambiguous genitalia. However, people with a DSD have either XX or XY chromosomes and this can now be pinpointed by karyotype testing. Stonewall (who have recently come under fire for misrepresenting the law when advising institutions who are 'Stonewall Champions') use this sort of language.

Cabinfever10 · 13/08/2021 23:44

@BoredZelda considering that the guidance that this replaced was ruled illegal in a court of law I am extremely troubled by how little has been changed especially when you look at the number of parents who have been reported to social services by schools simply for choosing a watchful waiting approach (tried and tested treatment) verses affirmation therapy (highly controversial and experimental) this is what happens when the person who is in charge of the education department is the same person who is behind the self id for anyone who is 16+ after just a few months 🤯🤬

Ellieboolou33 · 13/08/2021 23:43

@Namechangednotanewuser

What I don’t get is why are Scottish parents ok with it? Why do they put up with this? It’s a child protection issue. The relentless proliferation of this ideology is creating a problem for our children where there isn’t one.
Agree, all this woke shit is ruining childhood / children
jobbeedancer · 13/08/2021 23:40

Maybe you would have been happier changing gender or not being confined to a gender had you been given the option.

I think genders and trans etc can become quite a confusing matter. But when I was young I was assumed to be straight. I was told I would grow up and marry a man and have children (which I did) but I've always found women much much more attractive than men? And it just makes me wonder if when I was younger had I been allowed to explore my sexuality by being educated about it if I might actually have ended up dating women?

I think educating children on these topics and allowing them to explore themselves is a good thing.

Waitwhat23 · 13/08/2021 23:39

This is the document referred to in media reports - www.gov.scot/publications/supporting-transgender-young-people-schools-guidance-scottish-schools/pages/2/

In terms of parents not being informed, this initial passage refers only for it being recommended to gain consent from parents

'Recognising the rights of all parents and carers, it is recommended that consent is obtained from all of those with parental responsibilities for those young people under 16. '

However, it is later stated that-

'• If the young person has not told their family, school staff may want to discuss the most likely reaction with the young person. This will allow the teacher and the young person to discuss whether sharing information is in the young person’s best interests, and if so, what information to share and with whom.
• Offer to arrange a meeting with parents or carers; agree this with the young person in advance of the meeting and mutually agree key information to be shared in the
discussion and by whom.'

Which gives the impression that parents may well not be advised of social transitioning.

From the document - 'There is no law in Scotland which states that only people assigned male at birth can use men's toilets and changing rooms, or that only people assigned female can use women's
toilets and changing rooms. This is instead done by social convention' which may come as a surprise to many people. There have been anecdotal reports of girls limiting liquids in order not to use the mixed sex toilets which are gradually being introduced into schools.

However, there is a requirement for single sex accommodation in terms of residential trips under the exemptions of the Equality Act 2010, (fairplayforwomen.com/equality-act-2010_womens-rights/) so it is slightly startling to read -

'• If a transgender young person wants to share a room with other young people who
share their gender identity, they should be able to do so, as long as the rights of all
those involved are considered and respected.

• If any young person, including a transgender young person, is concerned about sharing a room with others, you could consider making alternative arrangements, including giving them their own room where appropriate.

• If any young person voices a concern, this should be considered - responses should be reasonable and proportionate, taking into account the rights of all young people.'

as its not at all difficult to envisage a young person who is uncomfortable with the situation to be 'encouraged' into the 'correct inclusive mindset', particularly given the language throughout this document.

In terms of PE lessons, the document states-

'We recommend:
• if PE classes are organised by sex, a transgender young person should be allowed to take part within the group which matches their gender identity. For a non- binary young person, ask them which group they would feel most comfortable being with
• that any school competition should take account of the age and stage of development of the participants
• for inter-school competitions, the same approaches to ensure fairness and safety
should apply. It may be helpful to a young person if you speak to the equivalent staff in the other school(s) to let them know there is a transgender young person in your team/competition, but only with the young person's consent.'

In Primary school aged children, mixed sex sports are not a issue to any great extent. With the effects of testosterone when a boy goes through puberty, this will create a disadvantage for girls. Teenage boys can easily beat women's world records - www.boysvswomen.com

Is there a policy advising on how to deal with sexism and misogyny against girls in educational establishments? There may well not be as the Scottish Government's Hate Crime Bill does not include women and girls as a group to be protected against Hate.

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 23:38

What I don’t get is why are Scottish parents ok with it? Why do they put up with this? It’s a child protection issue. The relentless proliferation of this ideology is creating a problem for our children where there isn’t one.

OP posts:
Ellieboolou33 · 13/08/2021 23:34

It's ridiculous and totally unnecessary, thank god I don't live in Scotland.

The world has gone mad.

Beebababadabo · 13/08/2021 23:32

@Namechangednotanewuser

It is utterly utterly utterly bizarre. How, seriously how does a 4 year old change their gender. They can barely write their own name or wash themselves properly. How? This is like an alternate reality where or a Truman show style staged scenario where the tv presenter is going to jump out and go aha, got you! What is going on and how is the craziness of this not being seen.
This is exactly how I feel or a really strange dream you wake up from and go what was that?! Except it's not a dream this is happening and the kids just keep getting younger.
Rainuntilseptember · 13/08/2021 23:28

So what is the new guidance for then? If hardly changed from the old? Haven't read it yet.

RaspberryRoyale88 · 13/08/2021 23:28

I’m Scottish and I’m not comfortable with this.
But then this is the same SNP that allowed a drag queen called Flow Job in to read to that age group in a Glasgow school.

When my niece was four she wanted to be a fox and insisted on being called a boys name. Fifteen years later, that’s a thing we laugh at.
It’s scary to think think if she was at school now, how that would he handled.

Kids at four years old shouldn’t be worrying about changing their gender.

Rainuntilseptember · 13/08/2021 23:28

Cariadlet those girls would need re-educating I assume. The Scottish education minister is full-on TWAW so there is no hope really.

blueberryporridge · 13/08/2021 23:23

Of course it's ridiculous. Of course a far more sensible approach would be telling boys and girls that they can be anything they want to be and it's perfectly OK for a boy to dress up as a mermaid or a girl to play football.

This. And I am in Scotland. Can only hope that teachers at the coal face will continue to use their common sense.

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 23:19

@BoredZelda

Read the guidelines document published yesterday. You will find different. It’s not misreported at all. It’s under reported.

Very little has changed from the previous guidelines. The reason the tabloids are using “children as young as FOUR…..” is simply because the guidance is for schools and some children start school at 4 and a half (but most are over 5 before they start) I agree with PP that this is intentionally misreported in order to whip up a storm and encourage the kinds of posts you have made.

It is also the case that the more detailed guidance gives different advice on how to deal with this differently at the different ages and stages of school.

In that case it makes it more concerning, not less, that that the guidance was already so batshit crazy. This is not some progressive, enlightened attempt to deal with a problem. The problem is being deliberately created. Like deliberately breaking a leg and then medicating the patient to deal with the pain to show how compassionate you are.
OP posts:
cariadlet · 13/08/2021 23:18

"A transgender young person should not be made to use the toilet or changing room of their sex assigned at birth".
That bloody use of "assigned at birth" again. Otherwise, I don't have a problem with this. It seems reasonable to offer private facilities to a teen who thinks they're trans ad is worried about bullying.

"Recognise that some transgender young people may not be comfortable using a single sex toilet or changing room that matches their gender identity in which case providing a gender-neutral space or accessible toilet can be the best alternative."

Absolutely no guidance about how teenage girls might feel if asked to share single sex toilets or single sex changing rooms with a teenage boy who identifies as a transgirl. Nothing about respecting their feelings.

As usual, the feelings of boys are prioritised over those of girls.

Kittii · 13/08/2021 23:17

But surely you are using them to correct a medical condition?

It's like a diabetic using insulin correctly is not damaging. But someone without diabetes using insulin would be causing potentially catastrophic damage to their body.

Clocktopus · 13/08/2021 23:12

A medical situation is very different from a child wishing they were born as the opposite sex

Well yes but my point is that they are not harmful when used correctly. I have a child on these medications and the stigma attached to it is mind-boggling, they are on it for medical reasons but I've still had people query whether they should be, people make assumptions about why they're on it, and people imply that I'm damaging my child with them (and I don't mean randoms, I mean people who should know better like the SENCo).

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 13/08/2021 23:11

The SNP cult seem to be hell bent on destroying not only women's rights but corrupting children too. I'm finding it terrifying and wonder what they are going to do next.

Scottish parents won't stand for this shite though.

Catchthepigeons · 13/08/2021 23:08

I would remove my child from lessons around this topic.
They know people can love each other regardless of sex, they know age, skin colour, sex makes no difference to a person's value, BUT confusing small children about their own gender is not on.

I wanted to be a cat when I was 4.
By 7 I was playing football with boys and my best friend was a boy. I hated dolls and dresses but I've grown up to be very happy as a female. I think if I'd known I could change gender at that age I'd have looked at my friends, looked at the girls and decided I was obviously not a girl.

There will be a tiny minority of kids who suffer from gender dysphoria and they should be supported and clinically diagnosed. However I'm massively against confusing children who could be swept along on a whim by something like this.

Kittii · 13/08/2021 23:08

A medical situation is very different from a child wishing they were born as the opposite sex.

Clocktopus · 13/08/2021 23:06

But I am totally against offering hormone suppressants to confused teenagers when they do long term, irreversible damage

Can I just point out that hormone suppressants are used in other medical situations for specific reasons and that they do not do long term damage when used in a controlled way, under supervision, and at appropriate doses.

cariadlet · 13/08/2021 23:03

I'm currently reading the guidance.

Trans is used "as an umbrella term for those whose gender identity differs in some way from the sex assigned at birth"

Sex is not assigned at birth; that implies that doctors look at a new born baby and decide what sex to give it. Babies are born male or female; their sex does not need to be assigned to them by another person.

Language is important.

HeddaAga · 13/08/2021 23:01

Or indeed 'cue' panic