Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do Scottish parents feel about what 4 year olds are being taught

284 replies

Namechangednotanewuser · 13/08/2021 21:56

Name changed for this.

So the Scottish govt decided that 4 year olds should be taught about gender dysphoria. Does a 4 year old really need to think about this or be taught about it. Is there anyone you know, looking back wishes that they had been taught this at 4? Who really thinks this is a good idea. Has every other generation been disadvantaged by not having this relentlessly pushed upon them as children. Just cannot get my head around it, and cannot imagine any Scottish parents being ok with this. But they clearly are or otherwise it wouldn’t be happening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1471447863 · 24/08/2021 13:51

It's not just Scotland though, Wales also has trans school issues.
I wonder what the charity was that supplied the advocate? 2 guesses really seeing as they were very pro progressing transition than obtaining appropriate medical/mh support

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9916567/Parents-slam-school-calling-son-female-told-trans.html?ito=social-facebook

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/08/2021 18:21

Anything to do with the SNP or their gardening division,

I love this description of the Scottish Greens - to say they’ve lost their way is an understatement.

Jorrris · 17/08/2021 18:14

You may well not like what you have - it may not work properly or you just don’t like they way it looks. It’s not a ‘wrong one’ unless you believe in souls getting slipped into bodily forms by angelic beings, and there is the potential for a mix up on the dispatch dept..

💯

KittenKong · 17/08/2021 15:23

No one is on the ‘wrong’ body - you just get what you get really.

Otherwise why was my grandmother born deaf? Why was mum riddled with arthritis? Why was my grandfather born with a dodgy heart? Why was I ‘made’ with some bones that weren’t formed properly? Why are some children born with their lifespan estimates in hours, days or months, rather than years and decades? The kid in the class with spina bifida or the one with a huge port wine birthmark on their face?

You may well not like what you have - it may not work properly or you just don’t like they way it looks. It’s not a ‘wrong one’ unless you believe in souls getting slipped into bodily forms by angelic beings, and there is the potential for a mix up on the dispatch dept...

user1471447863 · 17/08/2021 14:52

@merrymouse got it in 1.
It's part of their grievance politics too, disagree with them and your talking Scotland down, holding Scotland back etc.
They have to be seen to do things different.

As a Scottish parent of 2 daughters this infiltration of policy making by the wierdo contingent is very worrying.
I've no issue with genuine transgender people - I believe there are genuinely people in the wrong bodies, but they are fewer and further between that the activists would have us believe.
The age old method of listening to kids, not pigeonholing them at an early age, letting them experiment and investigate and supporting those that need it worked well.
My sister went through an "I'm a boy phase" when a child, thankfully this crap wasn't being pushed or else she may well have been steered down a dangerous path the irreversible damage. She's now a normal middle-aged mother.

Anything to do with the SNP or their gardening division, the Scottish greens (the only green party in the world the doesn't have the environment at the top of their agenda) is scary.

KellyJonesLeatherTrousers · 16/08/2021 09:12

Maybe have a watch of this to bring some of it to life…
bbc.in/2XfooVT

rogdmum · 16/08/2021 07:26

Cross posting from Sex & Gender:

The Times: Transgender guidance for schools ‘based on flawed data’

archive.ph/Dakuk

Lucy Hunter-Blackburn is blistering in her quotes:

“ You have got this incredibly unsound base for presenting something as being a fact that applies to the whole population. It is technically incompetent and completely irresponsible to use that kind of data to draw conclusions about what would be true for an entire population.”
“All of that put together means this is not a sound basis for promulgating such an alarming statistic. They should withdraw the document and take out this graphic . . . This is too important to get wrong. These children matter and they, and their parents, desperately need good advice.”

The graphics in the guidance come from this report:

transpulseproject.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Impacts-of-Strong-Parental-Support-for-Trans-Youth-vFINAL.pdf

Which comes from a subset of this study:

www.cjcmh.com/doi/pdf/10.7870/cjcmh-2011-0021

You can see the full survey (all 87 pages of it!) here: transpulseproject.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Trans-PULSE-survey-information-only-copy-2012.pdf

And for an additional piece, this presentation seems to show different numbers for the % of young people with supportive parents who attempted suicide in the past year:

transpulseproject.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Trans-Health-Advocacy-Summit-2012-Results-vFINAL.pdf

It’s not fit for purpose. ScotGov have lifted it from the old LGBTYS guidance and don’t appear to have done any doublechecking.

And the ScotGov quote in the article!

“ A Scottish government spokesman said: “The infographic contained within the guidance is intended to be illustrative of the concerns which transgender young people may face. The infographic clearly contains the reference to the study as the source, and therefore is appropriate.”

Giving the reference to the source makes it appropriate?!??!?!? You mean you can stick any old survey into guidance and just by referencing the source you are fine?

You couldn’t make it up.

HeddaAga · 16/08/2021 06:42

And people (so they have kids? Have they met a 4 year old?) think that a 4 year old is a rational, thinking being? On what planet???

Unfortunately they're not thinking. They're in thrall to an ideology that requires trans kids exist to a) validate the feelings of a particular co-hort of middle age men and b) keep the funding flowing for certain charitable organisations.

KittenKong · 15/08/2021 10:18

My GF died when I was 4. Mum told me that he had gone to heaven and was spending his time sitting in a deckchair under a lovely tree, with the dog.

When my GM pulled out some old letters that he had written to her from WW2 (I miss you, my pals are here with me, etc), I genuinely thought he’d listed them from heaven (lucky they have lost boxes there eh?).

Now I was a very bright kid - high iq, at the top of the class, a year younger than my classmates but doing work the year above. I remember my classmates being unable to tie their shoe laces and believing that they had been on a trip to Disneyland for the weekend...

Maybe they should have started me on my training for the cloth? Or spiritualism? At 4 I wanted to be a witch. At 4 DS wanted to be a policemen with a dog - or a dog. At this age my friend thought he could fly and broke his leg jumping off the wardrobe. At that age my sister have herself a boy name and had imaginary friends. She also planted sweet wrappers before abuse sh thought they would grow into a toffee tree.

And people (so they have kids? Have they met a 4 year old?) think that a 4 year old is a rational, thinking being? On what planet???

Itsmeagainandagain · 15/08/2021 10:09

Most young kids prefer to pretend to be airplanes or some magical creature, should we start identifying them as unicorns and jumbo jets?

GromblesofGrimbledon · 15/08/2021 09:56

@merrymouse

I feel that there is a strong instinct within the SNP to adopt policies that can differentiate Scotland from rUK so I think that adds an additional tribal dimension.

Bingo!

The SNP will do anything they can to show they are more enlightened, more progressive, so much more wonderful in every possible way that England. They will push any agenda to its limits to say "look how much better we are than those lot."

The same fighting to be the first to do anything happens amongst different council authorities too, particularly in the education sector. They clamour to be the leading light for whatever new madcap pilot scheme is trendy each year and the kids are the guinea pigs for it. Then they drop it the next year for the new trendy thing in education.

WouldBeGood · 15/08/2021 09:53

The SNP had a really weird attitude to all this. They’ve had the drag queen, Flo Job, in schools, and has summer drag schools for primary and secondary kids.

Not that drag is trans, but it all seems quite unusual to me anyway.

merrymouse · 15/08/2021 07:55

It’s very striking that on one hand organisations like Mermaids stress the idea that surgical and hormonal intervention is necessary as soon as possible to enable ‘passing’ as the opposite sex, and on the other hand more and more people are identifying as gender fluid or non binary.

So many different strands are lumped together, and any investigation - why the increase in teenage girls identifying as trans? What are links to conditions like autism? - runs the risk of being labelled as transphobic and shut down.

‘Queer’ and ‘trans’ now include pretty much everyone on the planet, and seem to function as tribal identifiers rather than objective and coherent definitions.

I feel that there is a strong instinct within the SNP to adopt policies that can differentiate Scotland from rUK so I think that adds an additional tribal dimension.

HeddaAga · 14/08/2021 22:19

@KittenKong

I don’t understand how they can agree that this is the best way - potentially injuring and messing up a high % of children for what? Potentially zero of the class year ‘finding themselves’?

So what happens if your primary 1 teacher decides that Jenny really had kids a desire to be Kenny? It goes on their record, do they then contact social services? Recommend psychologists and ‘charity groups’, set up meetings with the child and ‘advisors’/ doctors? What is the scope of their responsibility?

Well also, why are they being encouraged by a government to stage an intervention when NHS evidence suggests that almost all kids who display gender dysphoria (which they admit is extremely rare anyway) grow out of it by the time they reach puberty. Why then encourage lay people to transition kids?!
cariadlet · 14/08/2021 21:11

This poster took part in the study. She's now a detransitioned woman.

twitter.com/somenuancepls/status/1426579099775078401?s=19

cariadlet · 14/08/2021 21:09

@KittenKong

It looks like the gvt is using an infographic to ‘prove’ that this is the best way forward. It’s from a Canadian study - of paid respondents, whose average age is just shy of 30, and the conclusion is NOT as the Scottish government is stating.

HOW ARE THEY GETTING AWAY WITH THIS???

Interesting analysis of it on Twitter.

twitter.com/gentlemanbroad/status/1426476745662902273?s=19

KittenKong · 14/08/2021 20:46

It looks like the gvt is using an infographic to ‘prove’ that this is the best way forward. It’s from a Canadian study - of paid respondents, whose average age is just shy of 30, and the conclusion is NOT as the Scottish government is stating.

HOW ARE THEY GETTING AWAY WITH THIS???

KittenKong · 14/08/2021 20:38

Has kids = harbours (it’s wine o’clock here...)

KittenKong · 14/08/2021 20:37

I don’t understand how they can agree that this is the best way - potentially injuring and messing up a high % of children for what? Potentially zero of the class year ‘finding themselves’?

So what happens if your primary 1 teacher decides that Jenny really had kids a desire to be Kenny? It goes on their record, do they then contact social services? Recommend psychologists and ‘charity groups’, set up meetings with the child and ‘advisors’/ doctors? What is the scope of their responsibility?

Soberanne · 14/08/2021 20:33

@kittenkong i agree.
I know a few people in my circLe of school friends who would have been ripe picking too, but we had the freedom to explore and to make choices without labels or pressure. And thats exactly what kids really need. Safe environments to explore their own position in the world without prejudice or pressure

KittenKong · 14/08/2021 19:53

Thinking back to when I was a kid at school (in good old transalba): - the tomboys are now straight-with-kids or gay, the ‘gay’ boys are now (mostly) straight-with-kids or gay, some ‘straights’ are now out gay, none are now ‘living their true life’ as trans and none have committed suicide (there was a sad case about a dozen years ago but it was old fashioned shorty bullying, no sex/gender issues).

The attention seeking cutters have now become pretty stable mums, the goths hold down jobs in accountancy and estate agency.

I went went the name ‘Bill’ sometimes. I forget my sisters ‘boy’ name (I think it was Tom). She would have been ripe pickings for this lot of we were kids now (and what she did, I did, regardless).

HeddaAga · 14/08/2021 19:33

@KittenKong

Oh but we were all so wrong. Those poor children (who must’ve all committed suicide by now surely) were living a life or torment and lies!
It's funny how they don't show up in the suicide stats and even Mermaids seem to struggle to find evidence of any kids killing themselves over this.
HeddaAga · 14/08/2021 19:29

When the NHS says on its website that cases of gender dysphoria in young children are rare - they mean practically non-existent:

'Signs of gender dysphoria in children
A diagnosis of gender dysphoria in childhood is rare.
Most children who seem confused about their gender identity when young will not continue to feel the same way beyond puberty. Role playing is not unusual in young children.
However, ask a GP for advice if you are worried your child is showing signs of being depressed, anxious or withdrawn.
You might want to ask if these behaviours have been noticed at school before seeking advice from a GP.'

But even they are surprisingly woolly on what the hell it even means. What behaviours would the school be looking for? How would a teacher know how to diagnose GD beyond 'well he always plays with the girls' or 'he likes the pink toys'. This movement is beyond irresponsible. Social transition = a much higher likelihood of a lifelong medical pathway as it's incredibly hard for these kids to desist once their new social identify becomes established. Why are any young children being encouraged to think like this. I've honestly got to the point where I view it as wicked. A fast track to breast binding, pubert blockers, mastectomies, castrations and lifelong infertility.

QueenBee52 · 14/08/2021 19:23

I, for one, do not trust our First Minister .. I do not Vote for her and I fear where her governing policies will take Scotland in the future..

I love Scotland ... but I don't like the path she is on ... 😩

Whatwouldscullydo · 14/08/2021 19:09

And children take the messages they learn I'm school out into the world.

If you affirm their bodies are wrong they will believe it.

If you tell then there's a special group of adults who are exempt from safguarding policies they will believe that too.

The accommodation has to take that onto account too