Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I honestly believe she is lying. AIBU to call her out on it?

40 replies

PepperPepperMan · 13/08/2021 21:29

New colleague blatantly embellishing the truth to say the very least.

We spend a lot of time travelling in a car together. She always instigates the conversations which are far stretched.

Most reason one is being adopted under the age of 1. Birth mum found out about a tragic event that hit the adoptive family 15 years after adoption.
Birth mum found the adoptive mum on Facebook, contact made wanting to take child back but social services intervened and said no because birth mum had killed said child’s brother.

Today’s revelation is much more far fetched than other examples but even so, there are so many holes in each yarn. Do I remain silent with a head tilt or call it out in the hope that it stops?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
vampirethriller · 14/08/2021 07:00

I knew a woman like that. She had every illness including cancer but cured herself with a vegan diet. She went for a reception job in a school but they thought she was so amazing they offered her a job as a teacher on the spot. Don't you need qualifications though? Oh I mean teaching assistant for foreign students. You still need qualifications though? Oh I mean.... Well I've decided not to take it and give someone else a chance.
It was non stop and so tiring. I stopped reacting at all and she soon found another person to lie to.

Marmitemarinaded · 14/08/2021 06:18

You keep silent OP
What would you achieve?
Leave it

Bluntness100 · 14/08/2021 05:24

I think the fundamental issue is you dislike her intently. Do you need to travel together? Can you find a way not to?

DeathStare · 14/08/2021 05:01

I've had a similar issue - not with lying, just with someone in the car who wouldn't shut up. Audiobooks are your answer! When she gets in the car, point out that you're listening to the book and every time she starts to speak shush her and remind her of the book. You could try the radio or a podcast but I found that didn't work as well.

DoubleDeckerSwimmer · 14/08/2021 00:34

I have had a fairly chequered life with very well travelled and far flung family members and I have been in the situation where people have disbelieved me. But I have recognised that my stories while sounding far-fetched are actually true have never especially minded a gentle challenge from people who do not yet know my back story well. How would she feel if you challenged her?

Fiddliestofsticks · 13/08/2021 23:19

If this most recent story is similar to the others she has told, then I would start distancing. If she isnt getting the sort of reaction she wants, then the next lies will be even more insane.

PepperPepperMan · 13/08/2021 23:16

@JaceLancs

I tell stories to friends and colleagues (always true) but I’m aware that others may think otherwise - I’ve had a very chequered life I try not to bore people and keep it in context We work with people who make my life seem like a walk in the park - I am rarely shocked now but often dismayed by how fantastically awful things can be
I really understand your post. This isn’t that but I do appreciate your reply.
OP posts:
JaceLancs · 13/08/2021 23:02

I tell stories to friends and colleagues (always true) but I’m aware that others may think otherwise - I’ve had a very chequered life
I try not to bore people and keep it in context
We work with people who make my life seem like a walk in the park - I am rarely shocked now but often dismayed by how fantastically awful things can be

TreeSmuggler · 13/08/2021 22:53

I had a friend like this and I agree a non committal response is the best. The more outrageous the story, the more bland your response should be. My friend once arrived to meet me and said she had seen a pedestrian hit by a car and killed on the way to meet me, right in front of her. I just said "huh". She didn't mention it again.

toocold54 · 13/08/2021 22:52

I find compulsive liars draining and I have to try and catch them out but the problem is a lot of the time they genuinely believe what they’re saying so they’ll never admit the truth.

My sister on the other hand loves them!
We have a family member who comes up with some story every time we see them and my sister acts really interested and the story gets wilder and wilder. This person has said they’re a multi millionaire (they rent a 1 bedroom council flat), they’re having an affair with a very famous celebs wife, they have had a mansion but they don’t live there for whatever reason, they’ve knocked out a famous boxer etc etc it’s quite funny actually. I do sometimes feel sorry for them as they must not have very good lives.

PepperPepperMan · 13/08/2021 22:45

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also to add - a colleague sharing something deeply traumatic (in a moment of closeness) is usually not lying compared to someone who has a hard life story every single day…
She does have a true life event which was made very public in our area. That is true, I knew about it. On the first day we worked together she disclosed the event plus more, embellished truths/stories and it’s just ramped up and got worse as the days have gone on.
OP posts:
Whatinthelord · 13/08/2021 22:42

@BoredZelda

I can’t really put my finger on it but it’s very trump every issue a client has with a story much longer and harder than anyone else.

My brother’s partner is like this. We thought at first she was just trying to fit in/be interesting, but 15 years on we just inwardly roll our eyes.

I missed your mention or clients. Is she sharing very personal detailed stories with people you work with? Is that appropriate in your line of work?
WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 13/08/2021 22:40

You can tell a liar if you have knowledge about the subject as the language and process is often wrong
I knew a woman who claimed to be pregnant with twins. She lost one then the other. She talked in months not days and weeks. She didn't have any of the literature you bring home from appts (or did when I was pregnant) there was nothing but words
I an well versed with adoption and a friend claimed something buy again the words and understanding of the process were very wrong

NotableTree · 13/08/2021 22:36

Just say, ‘Look, we don’t know one another, and hearing all these traumatic stories on a day to day basis is a bit much for me. Let’s discuss the weather ‘

Kintsugi16 · 13/08/2021 22:35

Oh god I would love this!
The journey would be so much more interesting Grin

BoredZelda · 13/08/2021 22:34

I can’t really put my finger on it but it’s very trump every issue a client has with a story much longer and harder than anyone else.

My brother’s partner is like this. We thought at first she was just trying to fit in/be interesting, but 15 years on we just inwardly roll our eyes.

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/08/2021 22:32

Also to add - a colleague sharing something deeply traumatic (in a moment of closeness) is usually not lying compared to someone who has a hard life story every single day…

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/08/2021 22:31

I doubt that people with fantastical, traumatic stories that are true want to go around telling all and sundry about it. Especially a colleague.

Even if it is true - she really shouldn’t be telling you.
Just act normal and hope she gives up when she doesn’t get the attention she’s looking for. Work is work.

PicaK · 13/08/2021 22:29

Look up confabulation. Could it be that? Rather than lying.
Won't change anything except your reaction to it. But that might be easier to adjust than changing her.
Sounds infuriating though.

iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 13/08/2021 22:28

I used to work with someone like this.

It’s not just one unbelievable story, it’ll be one each day, or more. Sometimes I think things have a grain of truth but others were just borrowed from other people’s stories (sometimes my own) and there were huge holes in them. There was nothing to gain from pointing them out. She just brazened it out or ignored you, changed the subject and came up with another story. She couldn’t keep track of what she’d told you - one story was that she should have been a twin but her sibling died in pregnancy. I had lost a late-term baby myself, and I think she was trying to connect so that’s why she’d told me. Except a few weeks later I mentioned it again (not in a caught-you-out sort of way but just a reference to it) and her confusion was palpable until she suddenly remembered and recovered for a response.

Eventually I just stopped engaging. She liked the sound of her own voice so non-committal noises and nodding worked best.

DrManhattan · 13/08/2021 22:25

I used to work with someone just like this. Total crap made up rubbish every day. Some of it so ridiculous and far fetched. We are talking bit off his tongue and it grew back. Anyways these people always come unstuck in the end. It's fun to watch.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 13/08/2021 22:21

Are the clients vulnerable in some way? I know you may not want to give much detail, but if you're doing something like social work or care giving is there any danger that she might be emotionally affecting the clients or causing some emotional damage to herself?

If you think that she's competent for the work and it's just the monologue that's boring you could you have something like an audio book going anytime you're in the car? Something episodic and humorous might work, like Cabin Fever (BBC production) which is half-hour episodes and totally hilarious. She might enjoy listening, and even if she doesn't you can shush her, or maybe alternate days where you choose what to listen to and the next where she chooses. Distraction often works just as well for adults as it does for toddlers.

HeronLanyon · 13/08/2021 21:58

lemon I agree.

PepperPepperMan · 13/08/2021 21:56

@Ozanj

Ppl with some SEN and MH disorders don’t think linearly or able to storytell so the story may seem different to you (or not match up) but in fact they’re just telling a different version of the truth.
Very good point. I have siblings with SEN so I can understand to a point in regards to telling a very different version. The only thing I can’t identify with is the one up man ship and massive embellishment on their side.
OP posts:
LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 13/08/2021 21:55

@TheRealHousewife

If I was to give you my life story you would find it unbelievable. Really unbelievable. But it’s all true. Unfortunately.

I’ve been told I’m ‘far too nice’ for what I shared happened to me to actually have happened. Had resilience in spades when younger but not so much now.

YABU

But presumably, if you know it sounds quite extreme or intense, you only bring it up in contexts where that’s an appropriate thing to do?

The OP’s colleague is casually dropping her stories on someone she only knows slightly, who hasn’t asked, and who’s giving her a lift and should be focused on driving.

It’s partly the context in which someone shares this stuff that shapes whether it comes across as genuine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread