Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the whole gcse / A level grading system is rigged

260 replies

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 18:23

Just my opinion.

But isn’t it funny how GCSE and A level grades have significantly for higher ever since exams were cancelled?

I can’t help but think the whole thing is flawed. I am not teacher bashing, but come on, It’s hardly surprising to wonder if some, not all, teachers bumped their students grades up intentionally.

AIBU?

OP posts:
CallmeHendricks · 13/08/2021 21:11

So, @Cherryana, what do you suggest should have happened this year?

Cherryana · 13/08/2021 21:11

being a teacher (!) not being a teaching!! Back to skool for me.

Cherryana · 13/08/2021 21:08

I actually think that pure internal teacher assessment is immoral. It can not be fair year on year as the system is too open to variation.

That may sound harsh but it is based on 16 years of being a teaching including a senior teacher, PGCE mentor, NQT mentor.

From my experience there are vast variations in house even with internal moderation. Take the work to external moderations to compare with other teachers, for professional development reasons - and there was always great variations in standards of work.

I worked for an exam board. As an exam marker there were huge variations in the work that came in to be marked but the standardisation process was rigorous and then marks were scaled each year to ensure consistency.

No one likes to hear it but it was a good system for ensuring that year on year - the standards were the same and pupils who took GCSE's a few years previously were neither advantaged or disadvantaged.

I was a SENCO, so on to the second most prevalent argument regarding that teacher assessment supports SEN pupils better.

What we need is a different approach to SEN pupils completely with a return to more practical and less academic qualifications which are well funded.

It is flawed to have the people who teach the content to assess the content and award the marks. This is not teacher bashing nor a slur on the professionalism of teachers - it is basic accountability.

museumum · 13/08/2021 21:07

Every year a certain number of students are 100% capable of getting an A.
On the day, one will have a cold, two will be going through family break up and / bereavement. One will have an unexpected panic attack and one bad hayfever. In the end maybe 6 or 7 will fulfill their full potential.

So in teacher assessments which 7 do they give the A to? Roll a dice?? Of course not!! All 10 with A potential get the A. It’s only fair.

mineofuselessinformation · 13/08/2021 20:58

'Ok I mean yeah, I can see the other side too'
Only now, 130 posts in? Hmm

FlosCampi · 13/08/2021 20:52

How about if someone said " nurses were rubbish at their jobs last year, they let si many people die"? It would as risible as your comment is. Yes grades were higher, because they were assessed differently, the variables of exams were ironed out, and that difference meant teachers' workload and stress spiralled.

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 13/08/2021 20:48

If you had 6 kids all capable of getting an A but they sat exams. On that day 3 might get an A, two a B one had a bad day and got a C. How can you evaluate this unless they sat the exam? You can't so they all must be awarded their potential grade of an A.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 13/08/2021 20:45

JulesCobb
Why complain about being called a goady fucker and then make post after post being a goady fucker?
It’s not appropriate to call someone that.
It is if that’s exactly what you’re being.

Not a goady fucker, I was expressing my opinion on the fact i thought it was strange that all of a sudden grades have increased.
This is the thing with “opinions” people should be open to, shock horror, changing their opinions when presented with, oh I don’t know, actual facts and reasoning from those who are experts in the subject rather than their own bitter feelings. People will, and rightly so call a spade a spade when you become so entrenched in your own narrative when you won’t accept what those more educated in the subject are telling you. You can continue to be ignorant to what is actually happening / happened with the results, but prepare to be called out for your “opinion”.

And I’m not alone.
Ah yes, excellent company you’re keeping.

bottleofbeer · 13/08/2021 20:41

Christ, I wouldn't be a teacher for all the tea in China. I often proof read for uni students and my son. You imagine it's a quick ten minute skim read to check for errors. It takes agesssssss and I can read an entire book in two hours when the mood takes me.

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 20:38

They couldn't have been used for next year because there is a November option for pupils to sit them exams. This was the same last year. So the papers will be used for that.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 13/08/2021 20:37

@SparklesandGold

What gets me is that some students complain that they’ve had it so tough.. their exams were cancelled, what more could they want?
I take it you didn’t have a kid in this years cohort?

My daughter missed copious amounts of year 10 and year 11 face to face teaching. They hothoused all of that learning into the short amount of time between sept and Dec and then again from end of March to end of April before sitting RIDICULOUS amounts of assesments. She was required to stay after school 3 times a week for revision sessions.

You have no fucking clue how hard it has been.

Inflated grades?? She got a 4, 7 5’s and a 6….hardly fucking inflated!

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 20:35

Ok I mean yeah, I can see the other side too

OP posts:
MrsMariaReynolds · 13/08/2021 20:34

Instead of bashing teachers or the pupils, why not place blame at the feet of where it belongs?--the actual assessment system. High stakes exams serve no other purpose then award those who work best under pressure. They are by no means a fair assessment of a pupil's knowledge or progress of learning.

This year's assessments were probably a more accurate representation of a pupil's full body of knowledge, rather than a exam--a snapshot of learning taken on a particular (good or bad) day of a child's life.

CallmeHendricks · 13/08/2021 20:34

@BabyYoda9, would that be the same exam boards who were being paid full fees this year for school staff to do all the work (for no extra pay)?

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 20:34

Could they not have used the unused papers for next years exams?

OP posts:
BabyYoda9 · 13/08/2021 20:28

@SparklesandGold regarding the printed 2021 exam papers, the exam boards contacted schools and asked if anyone wanted to order them to use for their internal assessments... For a fee!!! Think they wanted around 60p a script if you were ordering over 100 (I can't remember the exact figures, I deleted the email while swearing my head off!)

ElliottSmithsfingers · 13/08/2021 20:26

I'm not a teacher. And reading this thread makes me think "thank God for that" if this is the shit teachers have got to put up with as part of their job.

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 20:21

Grin True that phiney!

Phineyj · 13/08/2021 20:19

No odder than an entire Olympics with the wrong year on Grin?

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 20:18

@SparklesandGold Some will be used for November resits. You could email exam boards and they'd send copies for mocks too after the government announced no exams. The resit papers still had June 2020 on the front. That was odd.

Phineyj · 13/08/2021 20:17

I think quite a few of us set them as assessments? But if you mean the physical papers, they wouldn't have been printed at the point the exams were cancelled.

Phineyj · 13/08/2021 20:16

Comma before 'or'. I should hope my students know a lot this year due to their massive cramming for the 6 formally invigilated assessments they took! We finished the course too, thanks to Teams.

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 20:16

@Technonan

I work for an exams board and I am involved in setting grades. For clear and understandable reasons, grades assessed in the way this year's grades were will be higher, as they make an assessment of a kid's work over a period of time. Exams are one-off snapshots, and take no account of 'off days' or exam nerves.

Exam grades are also nationally moderated and the grades awarded are set agaisnt national standards not just for that year, but against previous years. This year, though the grades were moderated, it couldn't be done as rigorously as is done in a national exam.

Schools worked incredibly hard to implement a system that the government shilly-shallied about so much that a lot of it was a real last minute rush. Very few schools played the system, and most didn't try - schools want fair assessment for their pupils as well.

Question - what did they do with all the exam papers that were unused because of the exam cancellations?
OP posts:
Phineyj · 13/08/2021 20:13

I think if there were threads criticising bin men daily, there'd be a little defensiveness there too (are there any bin women BTW? My mate has an HGV licence and occasionally takes a day off her council management job to drive the bin lorry if there's a strike, so I guess there's at least one...)

Anyway, this year's exam results are what you get when you have a last minute bodge by the powers that be. Doesn't mean students didn't work hard or know nothing. Does mean the grading system is now broken.

Speaking as a teacher, we did all we could to be fair in a ridiculous situation.

If you actually want to know the process used, the Ofqual document detailing it is freely available online.

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 20:11

The U grades will be less this year because you won't have even entered kids who weren't going to pass. You also didn't have the kids who didn't turn up on the day and therefore get a U.

Swipe left for the next trending thread