Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the whole gcse / A level grading system is rigged

260 replies

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 18:23

Just my opinion.

But isn’t it funny how GCSE and A level grades have significantly for higher ever since exams were cancelled?

I can’t help but think the whole thing is flawed. I am not teacher bashing, but come on, It’s hardly surprising to wonder if some, not all, teachers bumped their students grades up intentionally.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/08/2021 21:46

So fed up of all this teacher and student bashing. These people have been doing their very best in the most difficult of circumstances. They have had to show resilience, resourcefulness, deal with their lives turned upside down, new technologies and ways of learning and GAVIN bloody WILLIAMSON possibly the worst education secretary ever. They deserve all the luck and success in the world.

Phineyj · 13/08/2021 21:46

Of course the 44% aren't all equally academically able. The point is, you can't make fine distinctions when you bosh a system together at the last minute (and anything under a year's notice is last minute in education). Tbh, it was a miracle the outcome wasn't worse. The Ofqual guidance wasn't published until after some schools had broken up for Easter. They cancelled the exams in January!

bridgetreilly · 13/08/2021 21:45

If you are a teacher you assess based on work the student has done.

In a normal exam, not every student produces their best work on the day for all kinds of reasons.

So nothing has to be rigged, it’s just that teacher assessment will always tend to grade higher.

CallmeHendricks · 13/08/2021 21:44

Oh and then there's a bit of this we're up against now too:

To think that the whole gcse / A level grading system is rigged
Cherryana · 13/08/2021 21:43

@CallmeHendricks - its a good question. The problem was caused by the freedom really. Some schools did mini assessments, some schools made their students sit old exam papers. The variation has caused the variation. An integral part of an exam is its parity with previous and future years.

I teach drama as my main subject and actually there is a lot of teacher assessed work. I think drama has a good system.

Once per year (in normal years) we get a visit from an external moderator who checks our practical work. From that check - none of our given marks can be higher nor lower on any of the previous or next set of assessments although they can vary for the individual child.

We do more assessments than we need and then chose the best two to go forward, giving the child the best chance of individual success whilst maintaining parity over the country.

I think there was time to revise the course criteria to be less than usual years and set standard exam questions for different parts of the course and effectively make the exams modular.

I then think that one of the modules could have been sent to the exam board for external moderation. The external moderation would have provided the parameters for the rest of the teacher assessments for the modules and provided a good standardisation guide.

Then an uploading of the module marks from the teachers would be able to be scaled in line with previous years because that is done on percentages and not mark bands.

I know what I mean although maybe it doesn't come across clearly?

Sobel · 13/08/2021 21:43

www.jcq.org.uk/summer-2021-arrangements/

Enjoy 😉

AngryWhompingWillow · 13/08/2021 21:42

[quote Hercisback]@AngryWhompingWillow

You're clearly out of date.

Early entry and multiple exam sitting is now frowned upon, to the point that the first exam sat counts towards school progress figures. This stopped early/multiple entry overnight.[/quote]
That is why I said MUCH of the last couple of decades. I know it has changed recently.

AngryWhompingWillow · 13/08/2021 21:42

@SailYourShips

It beggars belief that almost half of all candidates received top grades.

That's it in a nutshell.

Well yeah. This. The OP has a point IMO. There are way too many high grades. No way can all these kids be THAT^ academically smart.

As I said though, in many cases, the schools have their arses kicked if they don't have a MASSIVE amount of hugely high grades from their pupils. It's madness. No everyone s academically gifted. And that is fine!

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 21:40

@AngryWhompingWillow

You're clearly out of date.

Early entry and multiple exam sitting is now frowned upon, to the point that the first exam sat counts towards school progress figures. This stopped early/multiple entry overnight.

MarshaBradyo · 13/08/2021 21:40
Oh this is great thanks!

Loads to read

AngryWhompingWillow · 13/08/2021 21:37

Regarding GCSEs..... The results have been high for YEARS now. Over a decade and a half for sure. Massive amounts of high passes, and A*. Thing is, for much of the last couple of decades, a large chunk of the final grade was course work, and in many schools, the teachers made sure the course work was of a high quality; in some cases helping the pupil, and sometimes even re-doing the work, so that the school would have pupils leaving with mostly good grades.

I have seen it happen over and over. And in many cases, schools let the pupils take some of the GCSEs 3 or 4 times. Then they would put forward to best grade of the 3 or 4.

And don't anybody tell me that this has never happened. It's happened a LOT. Not blaming the teachers, the schools are told they must have good exam results, or they get their arse kicked/lose funding etc... So it's in their best interests to make sure the kids do well. So the work that isn't great, is re-done.

Not massively good for the kids really, as when they are almost ALL doing well, how are employers meant to decide who is good and right for the job and who isn't? SO many pupils have got jobs and apprenticeships based on fake results. Jobs they couldn't do that well, and often failed at, and ended up leaving.

Also, I have known many cases where pupils have been 'helped' with their GCSEs and they have gone on to fail their A levels spectacularly, because they aren't capable of doing them properly. They can hardly do the A levels well can they, when they couldn't do/didn't do most of their GCSEs on their own?

Then with their crappy A level results, some of them go to Uni on a 'clearing' course, and then fail at that too, because as I said before, they could barely do GCSE level work. So Uni work is way out of their reach, so they drop out - or end up with a rubbish grade - as they can't cope with the Uni level education.

Seen it happen quite a lot.

We need to go back to the days when it was OK for some people to not do too well academically, and we need to stop telling everyone they need to go on to A levels and university. It's not for everyone, and we need to stop this mad idea that you're a failure if you don't go to Uni. There's so much more out there for people to do, and so many more opportunities.

Hercisback · 13/08/2021 21:34

ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/2021/08/gcse-results-2021-the-main-trends-in-grades-and-entries/

Marsha here's a good gcse round up.

CallmeHendricks · 13/08/2021 21:33

@TSSDNCOP Grin

MarshaBradyo · 13/08/2021 21:31

Op you mentioned A levels which have been higher and reported on

But where have you seen the same re GSCE? For this year?

TSSDNCOP · 13/08/2021 21:29

@CallmeHendricks my sister says you're a big poo poo pants

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 21:28

@CallmeHendricks

"Freedom of speech and all that."

Yeah, right. Bugger how it makes others feel.
You go right on ahead.

I’m sorry, but this was not a personal thread against one person or a group of specific people.

I think because grades have suddenly shot up and teachers were deciding the grades, it is reasonable to wonder if some, NOT all, had been bumped up.

OP posts:
TSSDNCOP · 13/08/2021 21:28

Freedom of speech and all that.

Ffs OP are you 8, you're just embarrassing yourself.

CallmeHendricks · 13/08/2021 21:27

"Freedom of speech and all that."

Yeah, right. Bugger how it makes others feel.
You go right on ahead.

Hoppinggreen · 13/08/2021 21:25

@SparklesandGold

What gets me is that some students complain that they’ve had it so tough.. their exams were cancelled, what more could they want?
Perhaps not to have lots of exams instead of just one and not having to worry that one test they messed up in Y9 could pull down their whole grade? Or maybe trying to get motivated and used to a whole new system while being schooled via Teams and missing their friends?
SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 21:25

@leafygarden42

But you are being a goady fucker - the PP was completely right.
Freedom of speech and all that.
OP posts:
historygeek · 13/08/2021 21:24

@LadyLooLaa

I will accept that you are not teacher bashing and answer in that spirit. With no support from government or the exam boards, we set, standardised, marked and moderated hundreds of exams. We had to use the data from this to generate the grades. Every single grade was supported by data. We did not get paid extra for any of this and the exam boards still got paid for all of this (this is usually their jobs). We had to submit our grades for external scrutiny, so if we were wildly different from what was expected it would have been picked up on. We do not get performance related pay, so there is no incentive to inflate grades. If anything it makes it difficult for future years if we were to inflate them. So, YABU.
Well said. In addition to this, after all TAGs had been entered and the opportunity to enter data closed, exam boards called for samples of work in order to ensure the grades were fair and based upon robust assessment. These kids worked so hard, in really difficult circumstances, and to suggest that they do not deserve the grades they received is actually really shitty. And it quite clearly IS a teacher bashing thread!
leafygarden42 · 13/08/2021 21:18

But you are being a goady fucker - the PP was completely right.

Monkeytennis97 · 13/08/2021 21:15

@SmallPrawnEnergy

A poster shared this the other day on a similar scathing thread and I think it needs posting again to be honest.

__

You will read a lot this week about inflated A-Level grades with teacher's predictions and how teachers have deliberately exaggerated grades for their own gain.

Think again. We haven't. Let me explain.

Let's take five members of an A-Level class who are all slated to get B grades overall. They have been progressing all through the course towards those grades and look pretty good so far.
Now let's take a NORMAL examined year. Your five sure-shot B grades go into that exam room and sit those papers. Now let's go to August and you get the following:
Students 1 and 2 get B grades as expected
Student 3 spends extra hours revising, practising and practising, manages to revise the one question that comes up and gets an A
Student 4 drops to C because they were one mark off the higher-this-year boundaries. Any other year would have been a B.
Student 5 missed either one question/one text/one case study/one equation and dropped to a low C or even a D. Yup they screwed up, either by accident/stress/personal circumstances and there's at least one every year in every class who does.

Now let's take THIS year. Your five sure-shot B grades are back again, only now you have to predict their grades. They have all been consistently working to this level.

Do you give them all B's? Of course you do because that's your evidence. Which student becomes your scapegoat? Which one do you 'assume' will be the screw up or victim of boundaries? Student 1 who had that one bad assessment? Student 2 who has bad attendance? Student 3 who works at B grade but it is really low in the band? Student 4 who has major family issues? Student 5 who is actually capable of more but doesn't revise and blags assessments? No. You don't. Because you don't let (you are also forbidden to let) bias cloud your judgement. So they all get B's sent off, including that one student who may have managed an A.

So grades will go up and be artificially high, but of course they will, it's an anomaly year. You have no data to draw your usual bell curve from (what makes a B one year may not another).

Teachers haven't exaggerated grades, instead we are working against:

  • Previous years boundaries that go up and down, sometimes quite dramatically. I have had students get A's one year and C's in another with exactly the same mark.
  • Not knowing what is on the paper (e.g. mine only get examined on 2 out of 3 possible topics and if one particular one comes up, some students will do better)
  • Each year also brings 'bad' papers and 'good' papers - you get one bad paper/poor question/poorly worded section and that's your cohort all down - teachers have been asked to predict against this too.
  • Giving students the benefit of the doubt because you know they COULD and have demonstrated in assessment that they CAN so why not give them the grade?
  • Exam marking is notoriously unpredictable, inaccurate and uneven - particularly in essay based subjects even in regular years.
  • Also I cannot speak for other teachers but this year's group for me have been one of the most able I have had - and having a student's personal progress judged against previous who may have been less able/more disadvantaged/more scuppered by course changes seems ridiculous.

Also, quite bluntly, predicting and ranking exam candidates for teachers has been hellish. I don't think anyone would like to be asked to rank a group of people on their POSSIBLE performance knowing that the grades they give will make or break a student's future.

And finally, students WORKED for these grades. Teachers didn't magic them out of thin air. We based them on eighteen months of evidence, assessments and grades. And every time someone declares 'oh they aren't real grades' you belittle their work and achievements.

Save your judgements for the govt who turned schools into exam factories which means it's all on one or two papers at one moment in time.

(EDIT: This example can also be applied to the upcoming GCSE results too)

EDIT 2 - Also this year's grades will not be included in schools progress/judgements and league tables so it is literally in no teacher's interest to inflate grades artificially.

Brilliant post. Spot on.
Hercisback · 13/08/2021 21:13

@Cherryana I agree in the most part with what you say.

I want exams, as a maths teacher they are fine for assessing our subject. However I can see why other subjects may benefit from ongoing assessment.

I don't know what the answer is.

MarshaBradyo · 13/08/2021 21:13

Do people feel GSCE were inflated? State and private?

I heard about A level

Swipe left for the next trending thread