Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the whole gcse / A level grading system is rigged

260 replies

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 18:23

Just my opinion.

But isn’t it funny how GCSE and A level grades have significantly for higher ever since exams were cancelled?

I can’t help but think the whole thing is flawed. I am not teacher bashing, but come on, It’s hardly surprising to wonder if some, not all, teachers bumped their students grades up intentionally.

AIBU?

OP posts:
HappySonHappyMum · 14/08/2021 08:48

You do realise that marking and grading is part of a teachers normal job! That they spend most of their days teaching and then marking work to see how much their students have understood. I would imagine that deciding a students grades comes pretty naturally when you've been doing that every day for years. They know exactly what they're looking for - plus they have guidance to show what each student needs to acheive to warrant each grade.

SparklesandGold · 14/08/2021 08:44

@Evvyjb

I am a head of department (large, core subject, heavy marking load....). Our % were absolutely in line with 2019, when students sat exams. They are excellent grades and students did well, but they have NOT been inflated.

The reason that grades are higher is that this has taken the "random" element out. If you have 5 students who you think will get a 7, in an exam 2 will get the 7, one might work really hard and get an 8, one might be a mark or two under the grade boundary and get a 6 and one will have a dreadful exam and get a 5. So 5 "certain" grade 7s become 7, 7, 8, 6, 5.

With this system, we remove the random and all 5 would be a 7.

I'm going to ignore the claims of wild unprofessionalism...

So when you were calculating a grade for your student, how did you do it?

I’m genuinely interested. Do you just look at their classwork books and think “yeah this stuff is worth an 8 grade”

OP posts:
HappySonHappyMum · 14/08/2021 08:44

In my DDs school she was given a candidate number and was not allowed to write her name on any of her 36 formal assessments. No teacher knew who's paper they were marking - so there was no teacher bias at all. The grades she received were fair and consistent compared to the grades she had been receiving in her subjects usually. The only thing that caused real problems was the government making decisions so late about what was actually going to happen with exams this year.

MarshaBradyo · 14/08/2021 08:34

@Morgoth

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/education-58174253.amp

Ok finally found an article that gives the figures. So GCSE inflation this year is only a couple of percent?!

That’s absolutely incredible and in which case I don’t know why OP has decided to include GCSE’s in the thread. That means secondary school teachers have pretty much got their assessments almost spot on to what a normal year of exams would be with only a small margin of error %. That’s actually really impressive.

The article also states that less than 1% of grades that awarding bodies asked for evidence for in their checks were changed. 1%! Again, just shows that 99% of grades teachers assessed were spot on. So really, GCSEs have experienced barely any inflation this year (only a couple of percent) which if anything shows how bang on 99% of teacher predictions were. Getting it that close is brilliant.

This is useful

I agree it doesn’t help that op has thrown GSCE into title without looking at information

Evvyjb · 14/08/2021 08:34

I am a head of department (large, core subject, heavy marking load....). Our % were absolutely in line with 2019, when students sat exams. They are excellent grades and students did well, but they have NOT been inflated.

The reason that grades are higher is that this has taken the "random" element out. If you have 5 students who you think will get a 7, in an exam 2 will get the 7, one might work really hard and get an 8, one might be a mark or two under the grade boundary and get a 6 and one will have a dreadful exam and get a 5. So 5 "certain" grade 7s become 7, 7, 8, 6, 5.

With this system, we remove the random and all 5 would be a 7.

I'm going to ignore the claims of wild unprofessionalism...

SparklesandGold · 14/08/2021 08:33

Some people on here don’t realise that I am not criticising everyone’s grades.

I’m just saying, the top grade numbers are very high and I’m sure not all of them deserve the high grades.

OP posts:
Morgoth · 14/08/2021 08:26

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/education-58174253.amp

Ok finally found an article that gives the figures. So GCSE inflation this year is only a couple of percent?!

That’s absolutely incredible and in which case I don’t know why OP has decided to include GCSE’s in the thread. That means secondary school teachers have pretty much got their assessments almost spot on to what a normal year of exams would be with only a small margin of error %. That’s actually really impressive.

The article also states that less than 1% of grades that awarding bodies asked for evidence for in their checks were changed. 1%! Again, just shows that 99% of grades teachers assessed were spot on. So really, GCSEs have experienced barely any inflation this year (only a couple of percent) which if anything shows how bang on 99% of teacher predictions were. Getting it that close is brilliant.

Hercisback · 14/08/2021 08:17

There's not really any such thing as percentage inflation overall. The A level percentages discussed are the grade A&A* changes. The article below is a good round up.

ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/2021/08/gcse-results-2021-the-main-trends-in-grades-and-entries/

Morgoth · 14/08/2021 08:14

What was the % inflation for GCSE grades this year? I can’t seem to find the figure. Was it as much as A-levels?

Sunflowergirl1 · 14/08/2021 06:40

@Imapotato "Maybe some school have inflated, but I really don’t think that was the case at dds"

Oh it is definitely a shit show. It appears some schools have worked really hard assessing and moderating etc and demonstrating they are in line with previous results and trends, and some (mainly crap schools) have had sudden and unexplained massive improvements in scores which suggests their pupils respond and learn much better having no lessons or a few on MS Teams. For some, it is no favour as they can be heading for an Alevel or university course they don't have the intellect to cope with

Hercisback · 14/08/2021 06:37

@Phineyj No it wasn't aimed at you! You're clearly well informed and understand the process.

NotBadConsidering · 14/08/2021 06:06

HarebrightCedarmoon everyone is so focused on their own children, and you’re talking about GCSEs, but project forward two years to A levels. Do you really think that half of the candidates are just as capable and high achieving as your DD? Your DD’s grades are diminished in stature, because nothing discerns her from half of her peers. Instead of lower grades harming her prospects, high grades for everyone else will harm her prospects because everyone will appear to be of the same high ability. She will need to do more to stand out.

Everyone is so convinced their own children have the correct grades, I get that, but surely people can see that there must be a reasonable number of those who haven’t?

ouchmyfeet · 14/08/2021 05:55

Great post @NotBadConsidering. This is exactly the issue with grade inflation. These kids might feel good this week but it won't help them in the long run

UnsolicitedDickPic · 14/08/2021 05:52

@SparklesandGold

What gets me is that some students complain that they’ve had it so tough.. their exams were cancelled, what more could they want?
Most students I know endured continuous assessment for the last year of their GCSEs which ramped up considerably in the last five or six months. My DN had subsidiary and anchor assessments, all of which were marked against an exam rubric designed by the exam board by their teachers and in some cases, second marked by other teachers in the department. The amount of work they've undertaken this year is a considerable leap beyond what they would have done if they'd sat an exam.

YABU.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 14/08/2021 05:27

So, do you think the system they initially tried to get away with last year to prevent grade inflation was better? Where high achieving kids were marked down becsuse of the area they live in? What do you suggest as an alternative?

DD1 got one 7 and the rest were all 8s and 9s. If she had sat full GCSE exams based on having only half the teaching she would normally have received during the course of two academic years, she'd probably not have done quite so well. But how would this be fair? It's not her fault that we have been in a global pandemic and schools had to close. But lower grades would have affected her prospects for years - people would soon forget that these were the year groups affected by Covid.

The grades she received were not plucked out of the air but a true reflection of her achievement as a consistent high achiever throughout her education.

Newkitchen123 · 14/08/2021 05:17

But I kind of just thought, well, Sarah is a good person so I will give her a higher grade and I also want our schools grades to be high so I’ll give the class As and Bs

This just shows you don't have the first clue how it works

yoyo1234 · 14/08/2021 05:06

I'm sure there has been some research already into this but how has the attainment gap between the sexes been altered (if it has)?

nolongersurprised · 14/08/2021 03:07

I think teachers can judge better than any exam could without a doubt!

Teachers have awarded half of the students the highest possible grades.

I doubt they really believe that half of their students are academically exceptional, so why has an A grade been devalued so much?

Asherline · 14/08/2021 02:23

I kind of agree that if you need a B to get to uni course if everyone gets an A a B will be the value of a D previously. But I think the system was always crap. Some kids will never measure up based on essays and tests and that's obvious , we don't do this crap as adults yet if kids do bad on a test they are marked as failures. I think teachers can judge better than any exam could without a doubt! And gcse/ Alevel kids have had a crap time of it and should come out a success

NotBadConsidering · 14/08/2021 01:58

@FrippEnos

But what do you do when your internal assessments show that the pupil would get an A or a 9?

I whole heartedly agree that the system over the last two years has been seriously flawed, but this is not the fault of the teachers, it is the fault of the government, the DfE and the exam boards.

And it is entirely probable that we could have a similar issue this year if the powers that be don't get their fingers out and start doing their jobs properly.

No one is blaming teachers. If the assessments show that a pupil should get an A, then the pupil should get an A. But if the assessments across the entire country should that half of all students should get an A, then there are two possibilities. Either:

a) the 2021 cohort is the most genius cohort ever and half of them are truly exceptional, statistically anomalous to the usual spread of ability, or
b) it’s way too easy to get an A.

We are now saying that any student who gets a B or below is in the bottom half of A level candidates. People can say A level results don’t matter in the long run, but prior to the results being published the Guardian reported that there was extra demand for medical and dental school places as a result:

www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/05/grade-inflation-forces-ministers-pay-extra-medical-school-places-england

(Funnily enough, after the results were published the Guardian talked about how amazing it all wasHmm.

There will also be kids deferring till next year, putting pressure on next year’s A level candidates. Will there be over correction? Will next year’s kids see kids with real ability shafted out of an A grade? This will affect a family member of mine.

What does an A mean? If you are applying to university and you say you got an A, they’ll just say “so what? So did everyone else.”

I asked this on the other thread. Can people honestly say, hand on heart, that they don’t think a single candidate anywhere across the country has been given an inflated grade? Can people honestly say hand on heart that they don’t feel for a brilliant candidate who is truly exceptional who does not stand out from a huge cohort of candidates who are all one big giant group of homogeneous As including kids deep down we know don’t really deserve such an accolade?

It will become more evident of the next few weeks, months and years. Exceptional kids will lose out to poorer candidates. They’ll start coming home and saying “I can’t believe so-and-so also got an A, he/she is hopeless.” Some kids won’t believe their luck. Some kids will think they’re good enough for medicine, like the Guardian are reporting, and get a real shock when they start, this year or deferred next year.

It’s all very “these kids deserve it” because of how tough things have been, but lying to them by saying that half of them are exceptional isn’t going to help. And next year’s kids will cop it I suspect, with good candidates getting Bs, and will look comparatively “worse” as a result.

FrippEnos · 14/08/2021 01:34

But what do you do when your internal assessments show that the pupil would get an A or a 9?

I whole heartedly agree that the system over the last two years has been seriously flawed, but this is not the fault of the teachers, it is the fault of the government, the DfE and the exam boards.

And it is entirely probable that we could have a similar issue this year if the powers that be don't get their fingers out and start doing their jobs properly.

nolongersurprised · 14/08/2021 01:27

I’m not commenting on the move of 2% a year though. I’m saying that the further move of 20% this year is devalues the meaning of an A grade. It’s not an exceptional grade if half of students are getting it

FrippEnos · 14/08/2021 01:22

nolongersurprised

But a move of around 2% per year is not really a lot.

The jump in the last two year has been because of the lack of external exams.

As most teachers on here have pointed out, if you have 6 pupils that are capable of getting an A you will be fairly sure that 2 or 3 will not get an A due to the stress of exams.

The question that this poses is which 2 or 3 pupils don't get an A from the teacher?

nolongersurprised · 14/08/2021 01:15

Look at that graph, worried - Just under 20% of students getting A grades in 2002, increasing gradually to 25% by 2019 - then a sharp jump to 44%.

That is very different

FrippEnos · 14/08/2021 01:14

worriedatthemoment

I was the first year in 88, it was a mess from the start with teachers teaching entirely the wrong syllabus, and I agree that we were left to our own devices with a very much sink or swim attitude from the teachers.

In schools today not only are there before and after school catch ups, but pupils are pulled out in tutor time for extra teaching and there is a whole raft of support staff for mental health etc.

And that's not going in to the provision for SEND which was pretty much non existent in main stream schools in the 80s

Swipe left for the next trending thread