Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the whole gcse / A level grading system is rigged

260 replies

SparklesandGold · 13/08/2021 18:23

Just my opinion.

But isn’t it funny how GCSE and A level grades have significantly for higher ever since exams were cancelled?

I can’t help but think the whole thing is flawed. I am not teacher bashing, but come on, It’s hardly surprising to wonder if some, not all, teachers bumped their students grades up intentionally.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Phineyj · 14/08/2021 11:06

To say

Phineyj · 14/08/2021 11:06

Independents had higher grade inflation 2019 to 2020 (compared to state) but lower 2020 to 2021 (because the same percentage increase of a larger number has a smaller effect than on a smaller number).

Although of course these are all averages so the individual schools will vary a lot.

There's a footnote on those FFT reports to day they don't think the govt stats include all the grammar schools. I think they'll probably have the highest grade inflation of all.

The picture is also complicated by different types of school offering different qualifications - I'm not sure IGSEs are in these stats and IB and Pre-U certainly aren't.

But this debate doesn't seem to have much capacity for statistics or nuance.

As Dr Ben Goldacre likes to say, "I think you'll find it's a bit more complicated than that..." Grin

Hercisback · 14/08/2021 10:57

@MarshaBradyo
Here's an article about the state vs private ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/2021/08/gcse-results-2021-has-this-years-grading-system-impacted-some-more-than-others/

At A level, independent schools had higher grade inflation.

FrippEnos · 14/08/2021 10:47

@SparklesandGold

Could they not have used the unused papers for next years exams?
There are no written papers for next year.

Also the exam boards released all of the questions/resources that they told teachers that they could use including the ones from behind the secure websites.

MarshaBradyo · 14/08/2021 10:46

I am really pleased with our school. I know everyone worked harder than usual to get the children through. They and others should feel good.

In general would people say state and private had similar outcomes? Ie grades close to what they should be - and do they have the random check up that I think state had

I use both sectors so not down on either at all just interested

Technonan · 14/08/2021 10:44

@SparklesandGold

Could they not have used the unused papers for next years exams?
These will be used where they were not used for this year's assessment. Some papers, those with pre-release material for example, had to use the new papers.

The exam boards would have preferred to run the assessments, but Ofqual devised and selected the incredibly complex system that was finally used. The boards had a lot of input in checking and supporting proposed assessment systems, and in providing a system of quality control. All the staff doing this work had to be paid. Any remaining money was returned to schools and colleges.

Don't blame the exam boards. The system was not devised by them, they simply had to go along with what was imposed, along with schools.

FrippEnos · 14/08/2021 10:43

Just so posters are aware these are the grades descriptors for the JCQ

www.jcq.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Summer-2021-Grade-Descriptors-GCSE.pdf

Exam boards did not give out any grade boundaries, new exams/questions and very little guidance beyond a paragraph or two as to what changes were being made to the exams/coursework.

Biker47 · 14/08/2021 10:37

My partners head teacher has inflated the grades of at least 5 of their students in one class, odds are they've done it to other classes as well. I think it will have been rife, particularity in private schools.

worriedatthemoment · 14/08/2021 10:34

Really to me it seems like some adults are a little jealous of these kids , like they clearly didn't work as hard as you to get an A or you only got a B so its not fair.
Give these kids a break instead of knocking there achievements, understand how we are producing kids who perform in exams now ( not great) and thats why year on year exam grades have gone up.
A levela have gone up for 25 years so why is this year different?
Maybe give credit to teachers who worked bloody hard , its insulting saying did you look at a book and just grade a 8 , either that or your just deliberately being obtuse
Many employers give zero shit about gcse by the times these kids are 20 anyway and working and Uni can have there own criteria, sometimes that a * student isn't always the best worker anyway , so anyone who employs solely on grades may be missing out on some great workers.
But please give these kids a break and just say well done . How hard is that

worriedatthemoment · 14/08/2021 10:29

@ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia clearly not read all the thread either thinking teachers marked there homework ffs , give the kids a break and stop trying to knock them down
Is like older adults are jealous that kids now do well , if you have kids who have done exams in last few years you will know thats because they are taught how to pass exams , absolute crap to me but thats why they do better year on year
This year prob most got a more reflective mark, as to their ability some will feel hard done by as they maybe are better at exams than assessments
All this shows is we need to revert back in my option some coursework and some exams
No one queries degree results often marked by the students lecturers certain aspects that count

Getawaywithit · 14/08/2021 10:23

Some people on here don’t realise that I am not criticising everyone’s grades

You’re not a teacher and you clearly haven’t listened to anything any teachers posting here have tried to explain.

We’re on page 10 with several hundred posts and this is the best you can come up with:

Do you just look at their classwork books and think “yeah this stuff is worth an 8 grade

Teachers predict grades every year. Sometimes we get it wrong. Mainly we get it right.

Hercisback · 14/08/2021 09:57

PISA isn't perfect either fwiw. China for eg doesn't include students with SEN. As a broad brush measure its probably OK but doesn't stand up to scrutiny when you look deeper into the methodology.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 14/08/2021 09:55

Yes with assumptions of grade inflation despite lost pandemic education. Therefore with own teachers marking their pupils homework or in school assessment - there is a generosity of seemingly blanket a* which I probably not much more than c or b equivalent historical difficult to grade a in old money exam only classifications.

It is obviously a win win all round as schools and their “super able” pupils suddenly appear to have aced the pandemic conditions or arguably the pandemic has perversely been conducive for learning despite all the complaints, frustrations and challenges which all disappeared with the charitable self declared every pupil is a quality as it’s appears like a reversed grading system where all pupils starts with 💯 and their own teachers “try” to mark them down which will suggest they are both bad teachers and their pupils are not that smart in real life non pandemic world under real mostly examination conditions. Makes a mockery of the self “grading” system as those without the ubiquitous a must have skipped school or otherwise not showed up to collect their default a* (old classification b/c) grades handouts.

What are universities and employers going to do in the view of this blanket or widespread grade inflation? They themselves used to assessed in a fairer balanced way when not all or most candidates are awarded made up top grades which is only equivalent of a b or c when they did proper education?!

The real crux of the matter is PISA. international comparable to benchmark English and UK wide grades.

The Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) is a worldwide study by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) in member and non-member nations intended to evaluate educational systems by measuring 15-year-old school pupils' scholastic performance on mathematics, science, and reading.

The UK school education is benchmarked consistently behind Hong Kong, China, Macao, Singapore etc in the rankings independent of own teachers grade inflation of own work and pupil attainment.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programme_for_International_Student_Assessment

Hercisback · 14/08/2021 09:50

@Sobel That's why I drink gin and tonic when marking.

Evvyjb · 14/08/2021 09:46

@Sobel

I’m genuinely interested. Do you just look at their classwork books and think “yeah this stuff is worth an 8 grade.

Yes. Down the pub. It’s a bugger getting the beer stains off the papers.

Did you not just put them all up on the dartboard? Much quicker!
worriedatthemoment · 14/08/2021 09:43

@SparklesandGold your on some kind of wind up really , did you not do too good at your own exams so want to out current kids down
Not teacher bashing yet clearly you are with the questions you have asked
Im not a teacher just one very grateful mum who knows how hard the teachers worked and who's son got the grades he deserved because he worked his arse off , sat lots of exams which he struggles with due to anxiety, he was 4/5's so not in the top but thats where he constantly works at
These very few who pull ait out the bag last minute I always wonder hiw they will fare at work, as in most jobs you can't pull it out bag last minute , you have to work consistently at a high level all day every day , formal sit down exams only don't teach kids much about life , and many are just taught how to pass an exam as opposed to actually understanding , enjoying all the subject and thats wrong .

CallmeHendricks · 14/08/2021 09:29

@Sobel, Grin

bearfood · 14/08/2021 09:15

@UnicornMadeOfPinkGlitter hits the nail on the head. I am a head of department for a core subject in a large secondary school and I'm not being flippant when I say I was burned out by the process. The sheer amount of work involved was overwhelming, with the mental load and huge weight of responsibility even greater. The burden of saying this child gets a pass and this one doesn't was no easy feat. YABU.

Sobel · 14/08/2021 09:15

I’m genuinely interested. Do you just look at their classwork books and think “yeah this stuff is worth an 8 grade.

Yes. Down the pub. It’s a bugger getting the beer stains off the papers.

Morgoth · 14/08/2021 09:15

@BeyondMyWits

My daughter had the A level fiasco last year. She is a middle of the road performer til exams where she performs well. Teachers gave C based on middle of the road, wasnt allowed to appeal based on mocks, so she sat actual exams in the autumn and gained A. Not all kids are advantaged by teacher gradings.
This is also a good point. Like your daughter, some kids work averagely throughout most of their school life and then pull it out of the bag and exceed all expectations on exam day. Of course a teacher can only give them a predicted grade based on the cumulative evidence of their historic school work so a student consistently producing C grade work throughout their school life, will only be predicted a C as the teacher has no way of knowing this student will perform uncharacteristically exceptionally on the final exam day.

Your daughter did absolutely the right thing by waiting to retake an actual exam as should all students who tend to do better than expected in exams. Like you said, teacher assessed grades are more favourable for students who perform well all throughout school but may lose their nerve on exam day (a large minority) than students who perform reasonably ok throughout their school life but perform very well on the final exam day when it counts (a smaller minority).

Snog · 14/08/2021 09:13

There's not much differentiation if a huge proportion of entrants receive the top grade. This will just give rise to universities/employers etc having to set their own additional exams.

balloonsintrees · 14/08/2021 09:12

@SparklesandGold

What gets me is that some students complain that they’ve had it so tough.. their exams were cancelled, what more could they want?
But they still say exams, just not formal ones in an exam hall. The boards sent out assessment papers, grading examples, mark schemes, exemplar answers, guidance for grade boundaries and loads of other stuff that had to be read, digested and applied to students. Most students across the country sat more exams than they would in a normal series because teachers had to be able to evidence the grade that was given. No evidence, no grade. I had to give 3's to some students as they didn't pull their fingers out at the right time. My students don't get 3's in exams because we train them to be better than that. Which leads to my second point; it isn't grade inflation per se, teachers are far better informed of the exam board requirements and pass that onto students. We spend a huge amount of time on exam skills, different styles of teaching and then massive support of students. In direct contrast to my own A-level experience (25 years ago) where we had lectures, were expected to take notes and no guidance on exam technique. Personally we have gone too far away from this model; we have better results because teachers work a damn sight harder and students have to take less responsibility for their own learning and understanding. And btw, you really really are a goady fucker OP.
Morgoth · 14/08/2021 09:06

Do you just look at their classwork books and think “yeah this stuff is worth an 8 grade”

Do you think policemen superficially just look at a pile of evidence collected from a crime scene without forensically testing any of it or going through any computer files and just think “yeah this guy is not guilty”?

At my school, the grade awarded was based on 40 x end-of-unit tests taken by each student throughout their school duration (year 7 to year 11). Each tests was blind remarked and then blind peer-marked by two other teachers in the department. 40 tests taken in the classroom in reasonable exam conditions over a few years gave us a pretty solid estimate of each students ability.

I assume other teachers did similar. And clearly they proved they were bang on as the article above mentions, GCSE grades only went up by 1-2% this year which is well well within the margin of error and less than 1% of grades were changed after moderation by exam boards. So basically it sounds like teachers knew what they were doing. I’m actually in awe that they got their predictions so phenomenally close to what would happen in a GCSE normal year in exam conditions. I think it’s a testament to their professionalism and judgement.

Evvyjb · 14/08/2021 08:55

@SparklesandGold

Erm.... I mark their work??

More seriously, there are a combination of things:

  • assessments which use past exam questions which are marked against the mark scheme and that year's grade boundaries applied
  • assessments in the style of standard assessments with an averaged set of grade boundaries applied
  • comparison of work to the exemplification material for each grade, provided by exam boards
  • years of experience as a teacher
  • years of experience as an examiner

And then ALL this evidence is put into a file, clearly marked and annotated, to show why that student got that grade. These were sampled by the exam board to check that the evidence supported the garde given.

We had NO changes. All the grades were upheld, they were clearly based on accurate evidence.

BeyondMyWits · 14/08/2021 08:55

My daughter had the A level fiasco last year. She is a middle of the road performer til exams where she performs well. Teachers gave C based on middle of the road, wasnt allowed to appeal based on mocks, so she sat actual exams in the autumn and gained A. Not all kids are advantaged by teacher gradings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread