Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop talking to a friend for getting back with her ex?

38 replies

Hairbrush123 · 13/08/2021 17:15

I’ve had a friend (who is one of my closest friends) who has been seen a man for circa seven years. The first year or two was normal - arguments happened but a healthy amount but then suddenly it all changed.

He broke up with her after admitting he doesn’t love her anymore about a year-and-a-half into the relationship and went on a lads’ holiday and slept with several women and got back with her after the holiday. Their relationship has never been stable ever since! They argue in the middle of the night, he calls her horrific names, says she’s not good enough for him, says their sex life is shit and he wants to have a threesome and has said she’s not wife material. To add to this, he’s constantly breaking up with her when she speaks up and she begs for him to come back and which he does.

The latest is, he’s broken up with her (for the 7th time this year) and I give it until the end of the week before they’re back together. I am quite frankly sick of hearing about their problems as I always give good advice and she doesn’t listen and gets back with him. AIBU to cut her off if they get back together? If not - is there another way I can get her to not get back with him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hairbrush123 · 26/11/2021 23:25

Thought I’d give an update if anyone else is going through the same thing!

I told her that I am no longer interested in listening to her and her boyfriend’s problems but anything else - I’m happy to listen to. She seemed shocked but hardly surprised that I said that. Ever since then - our friendship has frazzled.

We no longer chat on the phone, meet up (could be perhaps we no longer live in the same town as I moved elsewhere and she can’t drive), and whenever we text, she mentions about her boyfriend being difficult and the arguments they’re having but I just ignore it and the conversation dies there.

In a way, I miss our friendship as we have been friends since we were in reception however I cannot deal with the calling-me-at-4am-crying calls about her boyfriend and getting back with him later the same day. Thanks everyone for the suggestions.

OP posts:
Sssloou · 14/08/2021 20:47

@Kanaloa

Of course I have all sympathies with those in abusive relationships but you can’t fix it for someone, and I don’t think it’s helpful to listen to someone crying about breakups for five years - it’s fine to offer practical support/signpost to appropriate charities and helplines, but I wouldn’t continue to be an emotional crutch in this way.
I think “emotional crutch” is important to define as sometimes it can lean to far and be counterproductive - inadvertently enabling the dysfunctional relationship like some sort of drama triangle / tug of war. If you take the tension out of your end of the dynamic (not racing to rescue, or getting caught in any histrionics) but giving “detached love” and considered support and focusing on your own friendship with your friend over and above her relationship I think it is more helpful to your friend.

I regret being at the beck and call of my own DM - my own MH and relationships suffered - and somehow I was shadowed / blamed / implicated when things went wrong - whereas my younger sisters maintained a light, fun and social relationship with our DM which I was excluded from - I just got the “dumping” - late night phone calls / drama etc.

Kanaloa · 14/08/2021 18:39

Of course I have all sympathies with those in abusive relationships but you can’t fix it for someone, and I don’t think it’s helpful to listen to someone crying about breakups for five years - it’s fine to offer practical support/signpost to appropriate charities and helplines, but I wouldn’t continue to be an emotional crutch in this way.

Kanaloa · 14/08/2021 18:38

I actually don’t think it’s harsh. There’s only so much you can help someone who doesn’t want to help themselves. At a certain point you need to recognise your own part in enabling the drama and step away from it.

Hairbrush123 · 14/08/2021 18:22

Something I’ve taken lightly*

OP posts:
Hairbrush123 · 14/08/2021 18:20

I appreciate I might not be giving perfect advice to her however she agrees with what I say and she also says she doesn’t see him in her future as a husband or a father to her child so she must think I’m right…

I have been trying to help her for the last five years. This isn’t something I’ve taken. I’ve been listening to her for years about this, I’ve actually stopped giving feedback now as I realize she doesn’t appear to listen. If you could tell me a way I could build her self esteem, that would be great.

OP posts:
PixieLaLa · 14/08/2021 18:07

I think your being a bit harsh.
You also sound quite patronising thinking you give great advice. Maybe she doesn’t want advice and just wants someone to listen?

It sounds like she has very low self esteem if you are a real friend focus on that and building her up rather than trying to make her not get back with her BF.

MaudebeGonne · 14/08/2021 17:35

This is so difficult. My oldest and best friend was in a relationship with a horrendous, abusive wanker for years, and I went through the same thing. In the end I stopped offering any advice, just hmmmed and tutted when she gave out about him and changed the topic of conversation. I just stopped talking about him or his behaviour altogether. They have been split up for over 15 years and she is happily married to someone else and I honestly don't think she knows how much I hated her ex. And I really fucking hated him.

Sssloou · 14/08/2021 17:28

@cookiecreampie

I'm in a similar position with one of my friends. One minute she's crying asking my advice, then the next she's back with him, telling him everything I said about him and she's hardly talking to me. I admit I feel frustrated with her and think god you must be so stupid, but then I remember she's been worn down with this man and has no confidence as a result. So I continue to talk to her, but I just don't get involved in her relationship.
I have inadvertently been in this position with my DM - clearly it was an abusive / dysfunctional RS but she also used / abused my advice as ammunition for conflict. Quite manipulative and exploitative as well as draining. Also as above it was an opportunity to offload and make her feel lighter (and me heavier and burdened / worried) - enough for her to go back time and again.

Boundary was I don’t want to talk about the Relationship - sign post to resources.

CremeEggThief · 14/08/2021 14:14

Personally, I think cutting her off completely is a bit harsh. I would give her another chance, but be very blunt/clear.

Could you tell her you don't want to hear any more about the relationship as you are at the end of your tether with it all, you've put a lot of time and effort in to trying to help and you're done?

If she can't or won't comply with your request, then by all means cut her off.

cookiecreampie · 14/08/2021 14:08

I'm in a similar position with one of my friends. One minute she's crying asking my advice, then the next she's back with him, telling him everything I said about him and she's hardly talking to me. I admit I feel frustrated with her and think god you must be so stupid, but then I remember she's been worn down with this man and has no confidence as a result. So I continue to talk to her, but I just don't get involved in her relationship.

Hairbrush123 · 14/08/2021 13:47

The thing is, she sort of recognizes this relationship is unhealthy/borderline abusive but she’s also in denial. Yes she’s aware of Women’s Aid as her mum was in an abusive marriage and she used them and helped her leave the marriage. I just feel hopeless and not sure what to do!

OP posts:
QueenBee52 · 13/08/2021 19:30

OP would she speak to Women's Aid ?

could you persuade her that there are people willing to listen and help her, when things get to a point where you cannot fill that role?

over2021 · 13/08/2021 19:01

This was me once OP. I'm a sensible person normally but in the middle of this kind of relationship I was a different person- I genuinely felt worthless without him because he'd made me feel like that. Thank god for my friends who stuck by me.

Nayday · 13/08/2021 18:59

Well if you want to save the friendship id be saying to friend that you'll be there for her if they split up, but you're not going to give advice on the relationship woes as your input isn't helping and it's taking over your friendship in an unhealthy way. For a few weeks get good at polite mmm-ing and gently changing the subject/ moving the conversation along.

crocus146 · 13/08/2021 18:53

@dustofneptune

I was in a relationship almost as bad as this for six years. When you're in it, you can't see the wood for the trees. It fucks up your entire sense of self, your self-worth, self-esteem, and you no longer know what reality is.

My two best friends were AMAZING to me. They were patient, they always listened, they always encouraged me to leave her, and they never abandoned me. If they had, I think I'd still be in that relationship, because I wouldn't have had any kind of totem of reality at all. I would have had nobody to turn to.

It's completely up to you what you do. You don't have to sit there and spend hours and hours of your time constantly rescuing her from the situation. You can say that you don't know how to help her, because she keeps going back; but that you love her and will be there for her no matter what. If you want to be.

This was me too.

My STBXH was vile to me for years and totally gaslit me. I was made to feel crap - made worse by some of his friends who seemed to back him up and say I was controlling/jealous/blah blah (not knowing what he was like until they were on the receiving end of his behaviour in due course).

I am SO SO grateful to the friends who stood by me (and listened to me offload), they were my life saviours. I totally get how bored they must have been listening to me in despair at times.

I eventually left him and an in a much better place now.

You certainly find out who your friends are.

TheFoundations · 13/08/2021 18:45

I would tell her how you feel. Not in a horrible way, but that you're exhausted with all the relationship ups and downs and all the upset.

See how she responds before you make any decisions.

DrManhattan · 13/08/2021 18:41

It's hard to call if this is an abusive relationship or she's just loving the drama and attention.

BrilliantBetty · 13/08/2021 18:26

I would say to her really simply and honestly that you don't think her relationship is healthy, it is abusive and you tried hard to be supportive and listen but you now want to remove yourself. You can't continue to support her in this.
If she is ever in the position where she needs your help or has left him for good, you'll be there for her and would love a friendship but for now you are backing away and won't be in contact.

She needs to hear the harsh truth and feel the severity of how much this man is destroying her life.

MushMonster · 13/08/2021 18:10

You are a great friend OP!

I would not cut her off.
I would tell her what I think, that I think she should leave him and never come back, and that I would not be there to listen to their issues anymore because it is draining. But willing to remain her friend, go out, share interests and so on....
Hopefully she will get rid of him this time.
If it gets too much for you because she keeps offloading on you the same stuff again, then, yes I would understand to end the friendship. But I think it is worthy to have a chat first.

dustofneptune · 13/08/2021 18:07

I was in a relationship almost as bad as this for six years. When you're in it, you can't see the wood for the trees. It fucks up your entire sense of self, your self-worth, self-esteem, and you no longer know what reality is.

My two best friends were AMAZING to me. They were patient, they always listened, they always encouraged me to leave her, and they never abandoned me. If they had, I think I'd still be in that relationship, because I wouldn't have had any kind of totem of reality at all. I would have had nobody to turn to.

It's completely up to you what you do. You don't have to sit there and spend hours and hours of your time constantly rescuing her from the situation. You can say that you don't know how to help her, because she keeps going back; but that you love her and will be there for her no matter what. If you want to be.

Sssloou · 13/08/2021 18:05

It seems that there may be many layers to this.

She is in an abusive and dysfunctional relationship - but it seems that you might be unwittingly be part of the dynamic. If you are used for offloading then maybe that’s releasing just enough pressure for her to go back to him?

Seems that she might be dumping her load on you rather than shouldering it herself?

You can “be there for her” in another way. Say that you any conversations about her relationship are off limits - see what’s actually left of your friendship or is it all one sided?

Have a look at the woman’s aid resources and the advice they give about supporting someone in an abusive relationship.

HurryUpAndWait23 · 13/08/2021 18:04

Don't abandon. She's in an abusive relationship.

Kanaloa · 13/08/2021 18:02

I also find people like this are very self obsessed. They are wrapped up in their drama so every lunch out becomes about listening to them go on and on about the latest dramatic showdown, and very little of them asking about you and your life.

Kanaloa · 13/08/2021 18:00

I hate things like this. I had a friend who did it repeatedly, made worse by the fact that they had a child together. One week I was hearing how he was a shit, worst man in the world, not fit to lick Donald Trump’s boots. The next week he was lovely and couldn’t believe what a fab dad he was and she couldn’t wait to go away with him.

Eventually I just sort of phased her out and became a lot less available for play dates etc. It felt mean but I don’t like drama and didn’t want to be on a constant carousel of heartbreak with someone who had no interest in trying to help themselves. I don’t mind comforting a friend when they’ve had a breakup or something but not regularly, then it just becomes so that you’re an audience to their drama.