Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wills related are we being unreasonable to leave our house to just one DD

317 replies

fortifiedwithtea · 13/08/2021 08:23

We are mid fifties still have not made our wills. We have 2 daughters. However I have been open with the eldest girl that the house is to be left to her younger sister.

Our DD1 love her to bits but she’s not the easiest of character. I would describe her as highly strung And suffers with anxiety But doesn’t take any medication. She has been with her partner 4 years, he lives with us too. She has one more year of uni. Afterwards she is likely to move to another part of the Country and will most likely have an extremely well paid career.

However, DD2 has a learning disability and is dx with bi polar. She is unlikely to be able to live independently without support. Her greatest fear is that in the future she will be homeless. She has no qualifications and will struggle to get a job or keep it frankly as she has disorganised thinking.

I have reassured DD2 that she will never be without a home. Dd1 has told her quite bitterly in the past that she doesn’t need to worry as shes getting the house.

I went out with DD1 the other night and death came up in conversation because I am not well and I not likely to reach the great age of my own mum who is still going strong at 84.

I am an only child. Assuming my mum doesn’t ever need to go into a home, I will inherit her house. I told DD1 that if I inherited my mum’s house I would pass that on to DD1 and Dd2 would get our family home.

Dd2 said she understood my wishes but didn’t think it was fair.

I want to be open about wills with dd1 because of my experience with my Dad. He was the youngest of 3 . His eldest sister died young. She was also widowed at the time of her passing leaving an only son. His other sister is still alive at 94 and has lived in a nursing home for the past 4 years.My Dad assumed I would inherit the grandparents home and with that assumption put in his will that if my mum and him died at the same time their house could not be sold until DD2 was 25 and then the estate would be split 3 equal ways.

Lesson from that never assume an inheritance!

I was quite shocked at my Dad’s will. He passed when DD2 was only 5. I could have been liable to upkeep a house I could not sell for 20 years! As my mum survived him his entire estate went to her. She then made a new will that everything should go to me..

How can I fairly financially protect my girls?

What if I die within the next few years and my DH gets a new wife? What then?

OP posts:
SueSaid · 13/08/2021 10:09

Far too much over analysing.

You have 2 daughters, you leave any estate to be divided equally.

Lucia574 · 13/08/2021 10:08

You are being unfair. It’s not DD1’s fault that her sister has additional needs. If you go ahead with this, you will destroy their relationship. DD2 will need a small, easy to run, flat, not a family home.

TriCeraBottom · 13/08/2021 10:05

YABU on several fronts really.

  • you’ve more or less told you dc1 that you favour dc2
  • you aren’t really setting dc2 up for life after your death with this. Rather you are burdening her with a family home with large gardens. She likely won’t be able to run this properly and it could impact what benefits and support she’s entitled to as more knowledgeable pp have stated. You’d be much better trying to get her into supported living or her own flat and supporting her in that big step while you are able to (depending on your own health of course I haven’t read your other threads).
  • you are making huge assumptions about DC1 and the life she will lead. Yes ideally she’ll graduate and enter a well paid career and have a financial secure comfortable life. However, she hasn’t even finished uni yet!!! When I was at that stage I was flying high - very bright, first class degree guaranteed, opportunities abound but my personality wasn’t suited to a high flying career at all. I had low self esteem and anxiety. I’m unemployed now although managing and not on the breadline it’s not the life I’d have imagined when I was at university. I am happy though. So you really have absolutely no idea what your dc1 needs will be later in her life. It’s not right to make assumptions that she’ll be so much better off that her sister at the stage she’s at.
  • you seem to be downplaying dc1 anxiety and own mental health issues which is quite sad given what you’ve later said about her being your designated hospital visitor etc etc. She’s obviously keen to support you yet you don’t seem to have considered that your own health issues are something that would concern her and cause her anxiety too. You labelled her highly strung which seems unfair.
ShitPoetryClub · 13/08/2021 10:04

I feel so sorry for DD1 here. You talk about her disparagingly, anxiety in itself can be disabling.

Also getting a degree doesn't guarantee a good career. I know waitresses with 2.1s.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/08/2021 10:03

If there are ultimately going to be two houses in the pot, so to speak, I can’t see what on earth is wrong with selling both and splitting the proceeds.

As pps have said, an easily manageable flat would almost certainly be better for dd2. Sounds to me as if a house would just be a burden for her.

BettyCarver · 13/08/2021 10:02

I think your proposed action is terrible. I can't fathom how parents can treat their children with such a lack of equity.

Quite aside from anything else, no one knows what's round the corner and the daughter who you just assume will fall into some fabulous well paid career might get ill/disabled/ widowed or god knows what else

If this is for real then it's unspeakably awful.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/08/2021 10:02

@UserStillatLarge

If DD2 is unable to live independently without support, then surely the most important thing you can do for her is to work out how she will cope when you have passed? Simply leaving her with a house and a disgruntled sister is unlikely to be the answer.

Also, you have no idea what the future may hold. DD2 need more financial support now but who knows what might happen to DD1 in the future. Maybe she'll fall on hard times and end up worse off.

I think this is something you seriously need to consider. If your dd cannot live independently, a little flat in some kind of sheltered accommodation would perhaps be the best way forward. I imagine 50% of the inheritance would be enough for that.

I’m sorry you are struggling with a life limiting illness and disability. Being disabled and being too ill myself to participate in normal life, I do understand where you’re coming from. But I still think you’re over empathising with your dd2.

I will be inheriting 50/50 with my vile sibling and on the face of it, yes, it seems terribly unfair to me when they are on a 6 figure salary and im far too ill to work. But at the end of the day, this person is still my mother’s child. And when all said and done and despite being nc from them for my physical protection, they still should get half from her.

Your dd2 is even telling you this. Please don’t set your children up to resent one another. Your dd2 needs her sister. Flowers

EmeraldShamrock · 13/08/2021 10:01

My grandmother left her sole asset, her house, to my uncle, because he was her son.
Mine too with €30,000 for the eldest daughter in 1999, the eldest was to give a token she didn't, she died recently, her 3 DC sold the house for €600,000. Yes thanks grandma.

Budapestdreams · 13/08/2021 10:01

I agree with the majority of posters who say you should split any inheritance equally

Like pp have said, you don't know what the future holds. After you have gone your DD1 may become ill/disabled before she had had the chance to buy a house or build up savings. She would live the rest of her life with nothing, knowing that DD2 inherited everything.

Her anxiety could realistically get much worse over time and prevent her from working.

Don't assume anything.

I also agree that your DD2 is a vulnerable adult and as such she will be a target for unscrupulous people.

I think that knowing your intentions/feelings could be contributing to DD1's anxiety.

Definitely get specialist advice but I really think you should split anything 50:50.

Bryonyshcmyony · 13/08/2021 10:00

You really sound like someone who loves drama OP. I appreciate that you are ill but even more reason to approach this sensitively and not use your house as a way to drive a wedge between your dds

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/08/2021 09:59

Unless one child does something truly heinous, it will be 50/50 for ours. Anything else is very hurtful.

Singlebutmarried · 13/08/2021 09:58

Before sorting the wills go and talk it all through with a financial adviser. They will be best placed to talk you through the types of trust available.

They may also be able to advise your DM on how best to distribute her estate in advance.

Potentialscroogeincognito · 13/08/2021 09:58

Poor DD1. What parent would do this, can you not see how hurtful this is?

Of course you split it equally, both houses sold and the cash split between both girls. Why the fuck should DD2 benefit more because DD1 might one day get a high paying job. I get she has additional needs but that means she can then buy something suitable for her not be left a family home that she can’t maintain.

Poor girl and your comments about her “anxiety”. I would be anxious if I knew my own mother was favouring my sibling due to a hypothetical situation in the future, can’t imagine what damage that’s done to her.

I imagine of course you’ll lean on DD1 for support but not fairly distribute any inheritance.

This is genuinely one of the most insensitive threads I have seen on here for while.

BrilliantBetty · 13/08/2021 09:57

Terrible, terrible idea.
You divide your assets equally between your children.

And if DD2 is unable to manage a job, running a home would be an enormous struggle. Surely. If she is so needed of additional support, she will be housed by the council as 'priority need' if all else fails.
Alternatively a small manageable property could be bought for her rather than family home.

Your DD1 might be on track for a great career but what if she has an accident or something unexpected happens...

Equal shares of equity OP.

Ellie56 · 13/08/2021 09:56

@fortifiedwithtea

You need to treat your daughters equally and fairly and you need a solicitor that specialises in wills and trusts.

DH and I have mirror wills which when one of us dies, allows the surviving spouse to live in the current home or buy another home if necessary, but the deceased partner's share of the house and savings is left to our children.

That way if the surviving spouse needs care, it avoids all the assets being swallowed up in care home fees, as if the house is sold, half of it belongs to the children.

We were advised it was not a good idea to split our estate three ways between our 3 sons in the normal way, as that would affect any benefits our autistic son is currently entitled to. (The minute your savings go above a certain threshold you lose your benefits.)

Subsequently his share is tied up in a special trust that when the time comes, will be administered by his elder brother and a solicitor.

How old is your DD2? Does she claim benefits? Does she have a social worker? It may be that looking into supported living for her now is a better option.

costcocosmos · 13/08/2021 09:56

Equal split or leave it all to a cats home.

You have no idea whether DD1 will be financially secure when you die. She might get a good job and be in a stable relationship. She might not. She might be divorced with sole care of small dcs, an ex who pays no maintenance and in a difficult financial situation juggling part time work round child care responsibilities.

Also as pointed out by PP it would be insane to leave a large sum to a vulnerable adult. Monies should be in trust to protect her.

NotableTree · 13/08/2021 09:55

My grandmother left her sole asset, her house, to my uncle, because he was her son, and nothing to the two daughters who’d looked after her and had her living with them for the last 20 years of her life — however, my uncle’s MH issues have meant he, despite being a carpenter/builder by trade, has let the house literally fall into ruin over the past 30 years, and sits outside it in his van crying.

godmum56 · 13/08/2021 09:54

@fortifiedwithtea

To those who are calling me vile. Please take a moment to process that I am already disabled and if you read my other thread at best am facing blood condition that may turn cancerous or at worst have an incurable bone cancer. Please be kind.

DD1 have always had a very open say it like it is relationship. She is my emergency contact. She has asked that if I need to go to hospital she is my designated visitor. This is why we are having this talk now.

People who have said DD2 won’t cope with a large house. Yes you are right, think I needed to have that spelled out. Its a large garden on 3 sides too we struggle now between the 5 of us to maintain. I was hoping DD2 could stay here because its so ideally located and its the comfort of being the family home. I am worried moving will upset her mental health. But yes you’re right in the long run it won’t be practical for her.

I never want for DD1 to be responsible for her younger sister. As individuals they are very different. I absolutely do not want dd1 to become her sister’s carer. That would be dreadful for both of them.

Is there a register of specialist solicitors in this area. We definitely need professional help to get this right.

if this is the case then why are you factoring in your Mum's house?
I think before you go to a solicitor, you need to sit down WITH YOUR HUSBAND and discuss what it is that you want to do in terms of outcomes.....the who gets what aspect, that's about solutions, about HOW you achieve what you want. eg you: "I want DD2 to have a home for life" That's an outcome. leaving her your house is a solution but not the only one.

I am concerned about the way that your husband is being left out of all this.... Don't you think that you need to be speaking to him FIRST.....If it were me, I'd find it incredibly hurtful if you were making decisions based on the fact that you think that he will remarry and screw over his own children....I mean if your positions were swapped and he was the one with the life limiting conditions and he was saying what you are saying, how would you feel?

rose69 · 13/08/2021 09:54

I am sorry to hear about your illness. Have you looked into finding some kind of supported living for your second daughter. The responsibility of home ownership can be great even for people in full health.

Zilla1 · 13/08/2021 09:53

There are mechanics (trust funds, life interests to DC with disabilities with non-disabled DC inheriting rights to half after life interest. Managing spouse's future relationship risks with mutual wills or bypassing spouse to trust). Unlike most PPs, I have seen asymmetric wills on several occasions relating to work where a DC has disabilities and with one exception, this has worked fine as the other DC understanding, expecting and wanting this as part of a loving family.

Gingernaut · 13/08/2021 09:52

You can't rely on inheriting you mum's house.

She may need care home costs.

She may marry a young gigolo and he could inherit - very unlikely, but you can't predict the future and can't rely on what may never come.

The only thing you can rely on is you and your possessions.

Could the house be sold with the proceeds paying for a flat?

Does your DD have an advocate who could help her with legal and financial issues?

Write your will now as you see fit, but you can't factor in any inheritance from your mother.

If she does pass away after you write your will, then you can re-write it.

Shedbuilder · 13/08/2021 09:51

I haven't had time to read the full four pages but if your DD2 is as unlikely to be able to have a decent career and look after herself as you think, how do you imagine she'll be able to pay the bills on a house and maintain it? If she owns the house she may not be eligible for the benefits and support she might receive if she didn't have it.

I had a bi-polar friend throughout my 20s and 30s. She suffered, despite medication, from highs where she overspent crazily, and lows where she couldn't possibly have worked and often needed to be sectioned and taken into the local psychiatric unit. She was always in debt or trouble of one kind of another. She was in a HA flat and workers there understood her situation and protected her from the worst consequences — so she was never made homeless. Your daughter's bpd might manifest differently, of course.

We have in our family a person with learning difficulties who was left the family home when his parents died. He had a four-bedroom house but was living on benefits and dependent on the rest of the family (cousins, aunts and uncles) and friends to support him because he was unable to live completely independently. He had a minimum wage job and couldn't manage money well. He could do no DIY or maintenance for himself. For a few years the extended family helped with everything from shopping and gardening to paying for repairs to the house. Eventually when it needed a new roof we drew the line. It had to be sold. The funds were invested in a trust and he now rents a small HA flat in a facility designed for older people with special needs. He is much happier and if his money ever runs out he will be in a position to claim benefits.

I can envisage a future where your older daughter ends up not inheriting anything but also gets lumbered with all the responsibility of caring for, and bailing out, your younger daughter. That's not fair. Get advice from Mind on the best way to protect your younger daughter's interests without penalising the older one. That may involve selling the house on your death, giving half of the proceeds to your older daughter and putting the rest in trust for your younger one.

Chewbecca · 13/08/2021 09:50

No, YABU.

Go and see a solicitor and get your wills in place with professional advice and treat your DD equally. Most estates pass to the surviving spouse anyway, not to DC, but you absolutely need advice on this.

hedgehogger1 · 13/08/2021 09:49

Poor DD1. I think your damaging your relationship with her and then will do further damage to the relationship between the sisters

BluebellsGreenbells · 13/08/2021 09:47

If you leave a house to a vulnerable young woman, aren’t you risking her being taken advantage of?

Wouldn’t it be better to leave her enough for a flat, which you could do from the sale of grandmas house, renting it out until she’s ready, so she knows that’s hers? At least there would be a smaller chance of her being forced into marriage and losing her home that way.

You could then leave money in a trust fund that pays out annually, or she would need to seek approval for funds, maintenance or holidays etc so the account holder can make sure she’s ok?