Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wills related are we being unreasonable to leave our house to just one DD

317 replies

fortifiedwithtea · 13/08/2021 08:23

We are mid fifties still have not made our wills. We have 2 daughters. However I have been open with the eldest girl that the house is to be left to her younger sister.

Our DD1 love her to bits but she’s not the easiest of character. I would describe her as highly strung And suffers with anxiety But doesn’t take any medication. She has been with her partner 4 years, he lives with us too. She has one more year of uni. Afterwards she is likely to move to another part of the Country and will most likely have an extremely well paid career.

However, DD2 has a learning disability and is dx with bi polar. She is unlikely to be able to live independently without support. Her greatest fear is that in the future she will be homeless. She has no qualifications and will struggle to get a job or keep it frankly as she has disorganised thinking.

I have reassured DD2 that she will never be without a home. Dd1 has told her quite bitterly in the past that she doesn’t need to worry as shes getting the house.

I went out with DD1 the other night and death came up in conversation because I am not well and I not likely to reach the great age of my own mum who is still going strong at 84.

I am an only child. Assuming my mum doesn’t ever need to go into a home, I will inherit her house. I told DD1 that if I inherited my mum’s house I would pass that on to DD1 and Dd2 would get our family home.

Dd2 said she understood my wishes but didn’t think it was fair.

I want to be open about wills with dd1 because of my experience with my Dad. He was the youngest of 3 . His eldest sister died young. She was also widowed at the time of her passing leaving an only son. His other sister is still alive at 94 and has lived in a nursing home for the past 4 years.My Dad assumed I would inherit the grandparents home and with that assumption put in his will that if my mum and him died at the same time their house could not be sold until DD2 was 25 and then the estate would be split 3 equal ways.

Lesson from that never assume an inheritance!

I was quite shocked at my Dad’s will. He passed when DD2 was only 5. I could have been liable to upkeep a house I could not sell for 20 years! As my mum survived him his entire estate went to her. She then made a new will that everything should go to me..

How can I fairly financially protect my girls?

What if I die within the next few years and my DH gets a new wife? What then?

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 13/08/2021 11:00

I would suggest that you speak to someone like Mencap about the best way to leave something to your DD with learning disabilities so that she is able to manage what is left to her . And if she is unlikely to live independently can she cope with home ownership?

TheFrogsAreDying · 13/08/2021 10:59

Also OP what if DD1 has an accident the day after you die, and needs money to help fund a decent quality of life? Too bad for her huh.

What if DD1 has health issues at some point in her life too? What if the “extremely well paid career” you’ve decided she’ll have doesn’t actually occur?

It’s horrible parenting, you can’t favour one daughter over the other like that if you are a decent parent. What you should be hoping for is if DD1 is rich and successful that she’ll still care about her sister and provide emotional and financial support. Instead you are pitting the two against one another.

Branleuse · 13/08/2021 10:59

If you want your final parting gift to your children to be friction and upset and conflict and to potentially mess up their relationship after youve gone, then thats a great idea.

1Endeavour2 · 13/08/2021 10:58

Absolutely equal split for the many sensible reasons outlined above.
You cannot predict or control the future. I come from the same places as you.

fufulina · 13/08/2021 10:58

And I agree with the PP who said that a will is your last word on how you feel about your children. I believe it should be scrupulously 50/50.

Bibbidiboo · 13/08/2021 10:57

@fortifiedwithteaYou need to talk to a lawyer who can help write the will to make sure dd2 is taken care of in a more equitable way.

I have a family member who cant be independent. When her mum went to write the will she wasn’t sure what the right thing to do was. The lawyer suggested leaving her a larger share (4 other siblings) but structured the will in a way that the extra money is to be in a trust and on her death that money is then to be split between the other 4 (or their children if they die first)
I may have the exact details wrong but a lawyer will be able to structure something similar

jacks11 · 13/08/2021 10:57

My other observation would be that, in my experience (and for absolutely valid and understandable reasons) siblings of a person with SEN/LD etc often have spent a large chunk of their childhood having to make allowances/ having their wants come second to their siblings needs/ not taking priority and do on. If, even in death, you confirm that then I think you are going to cause some heartache to your elder child. You might even cause resentment to your DD2 (feelings are not always rational) and a rift between them. Think carefully about why your DD1 feels it’s unfair. I suspect you’ll find it’s not all about the money.

YanTanTethera123 · 13/08/2021 10:56

Poor DD1.
I bet she also ends up as default carer because she’ll be NoK when you die too.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 13/08/2021 10:55

I feel so sorry for your DD1, no wonder she has anxiety issues if your actions are just a snapshot of how you treat her. Even if you had left her just part of the property and explained the reasons why I’m sure she would have been more understanding than just leaving her NOTHING. Good careers and marriages can go south very quickly so I think YABVU to not have made any provisions for her if you have the ability to do so.

Auntienumber8 · 13/08/2021 10:54

It sounds like your DD needs supported accommodation so look in to this ASAP. It would also mean the transition is here while she has as much support as possible.

DH Father left everything to DH sister. She is not disabled. DH Father wrote that will when DH was studying at University and his sister had just graduated. He told no one he had left everything to one child. Thirty years hence he dies and everyone is shocked. MIL is upset still, he wrote the will shortly after they divorced. DH is an incredibly mild mannered kind of a chap and takes it remarkably well. I raged on his behalf. DH sister is just like the Father, personality wise, not very nice.

fufulina · 13/08/2021 10:54

I struggle to understand why DD1 being highly strung and struggling with anxiety has anything whatsoever to do with any inheritance.

Foobydoo · 13/08/2021 10:54

I would think more practically. A large house could end up being an albatross for dd2.
She would probably struggle to maintain it.
How old is dd2?
Is she capable of independent living or is she likely to need supported living?
I would consider some kind of equity release and set dd2 up in a small flat nearby or look into sheltered type accommodation for her assuming she is old enough. That way you can have her settled with your support. The rest of the equity in the house could then be split as you see fit between your dds.
I would definitely seek legal advice and also advice from a disability or benefit charity. As other have said a large inheritance could affect dds benefits and care and end up swallowed up on that instead. There could be some kind of trust you could set up instead.

TheFrogsAreDying · 13/08/2021 10:53

I think you’re being horrible. You’re basically saying you don’t give a shit about DD1 and whatever her sister needs or wants is far more important than her. Really really mean. You should split equally, no matter what. That’s really nasty parenting when you favour one child to that extent.

godmum56 · 13/08/2021 10:51

and again what about the Op's husband...the father of both these children?

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 13/08/2021 10:50

You have no way of knowing what DD1 life will turn out like. Yes, she may get a better job, but she could have years of unemployment at some point. She could develop mental health issues or illnesses at any time. She could become disabled through illness or accident. You simply cannot sit there realistically and say DD1 will be ok. As for saying she is highly strung🤦‍♀️. She is a young adult, she has grown up with a disabled sister and a moth who prioritises that younger sister needs above her needs- even if that is necessary and a sad fact of the situation you are in, it is not easy on her either.
Spilt the will evenly. Otherwise you are telling your elder daughter you don’t recognise she has need to or that you don’t care- hardly going to help your already difficult relationship . Your younger daughter does not need a entire family house left to her- if she has disorganised thinking and can have manic episodes she will not be able to come with maintaining a large house- a smaller property is much better. And how do you know that younger daughter, with her illness and disorganised thinking, won’t do something to fritter away your inheritance in a few years and still make herself homeless.
Really, stop trying to predict the future of your children- you have no. Control over it. Make your will based on what is fair and what expresses your love for each child only , ideally evenly.

MichelleScarn · 13/08/2021 10:50

*TatinaBis that’s ok as long as DD2 has enough to be taken care of on an equal split.

If not, it’s not fair to a disabled offspring to leave them in the lurch just so the other sibling gets more money.

Money is not the most important thing - looking after a vulnerable family member is.*

'More' money? Or just their share? Money is important or this whole thread wouldn't exist.
Dd1 also has difficulties, but very sadly they seem to be discounted.
And yes it be lovely if dd1 can help and wants to help dd2, but this shouldn't be at detriment to her.

HeronLanyon · 13/08/2021 10:48

Not family law but probate. Have just been through complex probate as executor and my probate solicitor although expensive (fees from the estate), gave great advice, told me some options I hadn’t thought of re tax, helped me avoid missteps Re selling property and distribution and did all of the Hmrc/probate etc and was really helpful. Simple or small estates you can do yourself very often obvs. I’ve now used him to do my own will.

jacks11 · 13/08/2021 10:48

YABU

I agree that your will is the last thing you leave your family with- the legacy of poor planning or unfairness tends to last a long time. You’ve just told DD1 she’s on her own as DD2 is your priority. I also think you are making a LOT of assumptions about the future of your eldest daughter. She looks likely to have a successful and lucrative career. But what if it doesn’t pan out that way? What if she develops an illness or has an accident? What if she doesn’t achieve her potential- things go wrong and sometimes it’s the individuals fault and sometimes it isn’t. What if she has a child who requires care and has to reduce hours/change jobs/become a full time carer?

Your Dd2 does not need a family sized home. I suspect she could not afford the upkeep of it, nor manage the day to day running. She needs an appropriately sized home and therefore, the house should be sold and proceeds split, along with any other assets. That should leave your younger daughter enough to buy a small home.

If she is unlikely to live independently what provision gave you made for that? If you are expecting your elder daughter to help then I think creating a sense that she is less important to you is highly unlikely to benefit your younger daughter. And you need to ensure you’ve thought through how your elder daughter would manage to do this, hold down a career (esp if you think she might move to a distant part of the country) and possibly have a family of her own?

I think equal split of assets is sensible. If your youngest is going to struggle to be independent, will she be able to sensibly manage an large inheritance? Would she use it for the purpose you intend? I think you may perhaps need to consider how to safeguard her inheritance to ensure that she is supported. Perhaps you could create a trust, which holds the money and it is used to ensure your daughter is housed/has money to live on etc. My aunt has this for m my cousin who has LD as he would not manage money well, though technically has capacity (just) he would never think to budget for bills or think about maintain the house etc- the trust ensures he will always have a home, can pay his bills, maintain e house and out food on the table. But his siblings are trustees so it does place the burden on them.

TatianaBis · 13/08/2021 10:48

Despite the selfishness and resentment on here, there are plenty of people with a disabled sibling who are happy for them to inherit a larger portion in view of their care needs. They actively support the decision.

Not everyone is as greedy as the posters on this thread.

SmokeyDevil · 13/08/2021 10:45

@NeverMetANiceOne

I feel very sorry for your DD1.
This. Kind of obvious op doesn't really like her. Loves her because she is her child, but if not related, it would be a different story. Really quite sad. I dunno how parents can ever think splitting things other than 50/50 is fair. Very strange people.
Thisisworsethananticpated · 13/08/2021 10:44

I don’t think you are vile and I’m sorry if this is upsetting

I think you need to come off here and look for a family law soliciters that have experience

Google is your friend here , not this snakepit

Remember they don’t need to be local
But they do need to have experience in this

X

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 13/08/2021 10:43

It’s your money and well done for actually having the conversation but I feel really sorry for DD1. The resentment could mean she isn’t prepared to help your DD2, who sounds like she might need a lot of emotional and practical support after you die.

As someone said, DD1 could be diagnosed with a serious illness, multiple redundancies and other horrible things which impact her financially. I would leave the house to both of them and perhaps ask social services for advice on sheltered accommodation for DD2 in case she can’t find a small flat - she wouldn’t need a family sized home.

SW1amp · 13/08/2021 10:41

@Toddlerteaplease

If DD2 struggles, she may be better in a flat rather than a house that's too big for her. Sell both houses and split the money equally. Your Poor DD1, it's really unfair on her.
This! If someone struggles so much they can't hold down any sort of job, a family-sized house will be a huge burden.

The means to buy a small suitable flat in a suitable area is the best gift. Not a big house to maintain and be full of memories of you

godmum56 · 13/08/2021 10:41

if you expect to die soon and can trust your dh and if not them why not, then why not leave it all to him? Its quite simple and tax efficient and will save you both one lot of IHT

Paint69 · 13/08/2021 10:41

This will likely cause resentment from DD1 to DD2 which sounds like an awful idea as DD2 may rely on support from her sister if you did pass. Similar situation happened in our family which led to a huge rift and two parties still don't talk 10 years later. I think YABU and should split equally.