Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wills related are we being unreasonable to leave our house to just one DD

317 replies

fortifiedwithtea · 13/08/2021 08:23

We are mid fifties still have not made our wills. We have 2 daughters. However I have been open with the eldest girl that the house is to be left to her younger sister.

Our DD1 love her to bits but she’s not the easiest of character. I would describe her as highly strung And suffers with anxiety But doesn’t take any medication. She has been with her partner 4 years, he lives with us too. She has one more year of uni. Afterwards she is likely to move to another part of the Country and will most likely have an extremely well paid career.

However, DD2 has a learning disability and is dx with bi polar. She is unlikely to be able to live independently without support. Her greatest fear is that in the future she will be homeless. She has no qualifications and will struggle to get a job or keep it frankly as she has disorganised thinking.

I have reassured DD2 that she will never be without a home. Dd1 has told her quite bitterly in the past that she doesn’t need to worry as shes getting the house.

I went out with DD1 the other night and death came up in conversation because I am not well and I not likely to reach the great age of my own mum who is still going strong at 84.

I am an only child. Assuming my mum doesn’t ever need to go into a home, I will inherit her house. I told DD1 that if I inherited my mum’s house I would pass that on to DD1 and Dd2 would get our family home.

Dd2 said she understood my wishes but didn’t think it was fair.

I want to be open about wills with dd1 because of my experience with my Dad. He was the youngest of 3 . His eldest sister died young. She was also widowed at the time of her passing leaving an only son. His other sister is still alive at 94 and has lived in a nursing home for the past 4 years.My Dad assumed I would inherit the grandparents home and with that assumption put in his will that if my mum and him died at the same time their house could not be sold until DD2 was 25 and then the estate would be split 3 equal ways.

Lesson from that never assume an inheritance!

I was quite shocked at my Dad’s will. He passed when DD2 was only 5. I could have been liable to upkeep a house I could not sell for 20 years! As my mum survived him his entire estate went to her. She then made a new will that everything should go to me..

How can I fairly financially protect my girls?

What if I die within the next few years and my DH gets a new wife? What then?

OP posts:
QueeniesCroft · 13/08/2021 12:12

I think that I would take steps now to make sure that the daughter who needs it has a place in supported housing and is well settled before my death. The estate could then be split evenly, and the proceeds of DD2's half put in a trust which could pay for rent and living expenses.
If there is likely to be enough money for her to live without benefits, then it's surely more important to safeguard that (with trusts or whatever the expert you consult suggests) than for her to have less actual money in order to qualify for benefits which may be changed or discontinued at some time in the future.

TatianaBis · 13/08/2021 12:09

@Clawdy

Has to be equally shared, or the bitterness and resentment will last for years, as I know from experience.
Really? People are so mean spirited and self centred that they would resent a sibling with disabilities being adequately looked after?

The selfish grabbiness on this thread, and complete lack of concern for a vulnerable family member, is appalling.

RuthW · 13/08/2021 12:08

Poor dd 1

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 13/08/2021 12:05

I'm sorry but your plan is a terrible idea. Do not do it unless you want to set up a lifetime of resentment and bad blood.

You need to consider that DD2 will need support from DD1 so preserving their relationship is important. You also need to consider DD2s ability to manage money and a house. Leaving her the family home free and clear is a really really really bad idea.

I suggest that you apologise to DD1 and explain that you don't want to cut her out and were just trying to work out how to provide for DD2.

I would talk to DD1 about how she envisages things when you aren't around anymore. She has likely thought about whether she would consider living with her sister, whether she would live separately but provide hands on support or would prefer to see her set up in sheltered accommodation. Would she be willing to be a trustee? Is there anyone else who would be prepared to look out for DD2 and can DD1 work jointly with them or should it be an either or situation. Talk to your DH separately about the same topics. Ask him how he feels about staying in the family home too. Depending upon DD2s level of competence you might want to broach some of these subjects with her too.

This is a fact finding exercise, not a chance to lay down any firm plans.

Then when you have an idea of how they feel get proper legal advice. Look for a STEP registered solicitor and make an appointment to discuss your wishes and needs.

You should look at things like trusts so that money left to DD2 can be protected. You should do your best to leave DD1 an equivalent sum, but depending upon the size of the estate and the needs of DD2 you may have to consider other options, and this is where talking comes in. DD1 may prefer less money if it means reliable provision for DD2 and limited input from her but she might rightly be upset at less money if she is thinking that she will have to step into your shoes and become primary carer. You need a two way conversation though, no point making provision for sheltered accommodation if neither daughter would be happy with that and no point leaving a lifetime interest in the family home if living there would be impractical.

Get advice, talk about it again, then get the wills made with everyone aware of the content and review the provisions whenever there are changes of circumstances.

Clawdy · 13/08/2021 12:04

Has to be equally shared, or the bitterness and resentment will last for years, as I know from experience.

godmum56 · 13/08/2021 12:01

@fortifiedwithtea

Ok I’ve heard you all loud and clear. Leaving a house to DD2 is a terrible idea.

Neither ours or DM is a big house. We are talking 3 bed semi’s but because of the locations of both close to London they are worth a lot. In fact DM house is worth more than ours. DF was in finance. He took out investments when each grandchild was born. Dd2 also benefitted from a government scheme. To make it fair we opened an investment for DD1 so each child had 2 investments. Safe to say they BOTH have a nice nest egg.

This thread has brought up another issue that had not even occurred to me. DD2 might have too much already in savings to qualify for full benefits. So something else that needs professional help .

Dd1 has never had a good relationship with DD2. They are too different in personality. They have never been company for each other. Nearly 5 years age gap. I was so desperate to give DD1 a sibling as I hated being an only child I never considered that DD1 might actually enjoy being the only one or that DD2 could be born different. Dd1 never wanted her sister to be at her sporting events and we never forced DD1 to support DD2 in her sport either. With hindsight maybe that was a mistake. Or if I’d forced them to be together maybe the resentment would be worse. I don’t know.

and you STILL haven't mentioned your husband!
HollowTalk · 13/08/2021 12:01

I agree with @Shedbuilder. Your younger daughter, given her bipolar condition, could easily sell that house and spend everything. There's no love lost between your two girls, so why create even more division by only leaving your house to one?

Nomorepies · 13/08/2021 11:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

Sweetchocolatecandy · 13/08/2021 11:57

Just seen your update OP. If your daughters have a strained relationship anyway then I fail to see how leaving everything to one and nothing to the other will help in healing any rifts between them? Surely your actions will just make the situation worse. I don’t understand your logic at all.

UmamiMammy · 13/08/2021 11:51

Be very careful about leaving the house to DD2.............the asset could affect future benefits. Is she capable of managing the property.........Maintainance, repairs, arranging insurance etc???

Would supported living be a better option for her?

I think you are being unfair to DD1.

SpeakingFranglais · 13/08/2021 11:49

Shocking and I say that as one of three whose eldest sibling has learning difficulties and cannot manage money himself.

My mum has written her will to split her entire estate between the three of us but my DB’s share is held in a trust and will be used to make his life more comfortable. It is likely he will have to go into social housing (but he still lives with mum at 58 now) as he couldn’t afford the bills on the family home even if he stayed there. The trust fund means that he can still receive the small benefits he receives for His learning and physical disabilities but my other DB and I can use the trust fund to help with bills. If he makes it to retirement age he will live off his pension.

You are being grossly unfair and absolutely not considering how your DD2 will be able to stay in the house and manage her finances. All money should be split equally and provision made for your DD2 in a trust fund.

ChavDiningHalls · 13/08/2021 11:37

Sorry - our posts crossed, tea!

ChavDiningHalls · 13/08/2021 11:36

@fortifiedwithtea I did search for your previous posts (only because you suggested it - I don't make a habit of this). In one of them, you talk about DD1's hatred of DD2. If there's already a problem, I wouldn't make it worse by in effect cutting DD1 out.

As PP have said, you need a really good solicitor to draw up wills for you and your husband which ensure that DD2's additional needs (which you describe as 'mild' in another post) are covered without her losing any benefits. You and your husband would normally have 'mirror' wills, unless there is some particular reason not to (such as him having children from a previous marriage or you having some pressing reason to leave something to someone else).

I really would not delay.

Shedbuilder · 13/08/2021 11:31

I feel the need to say this again because so many people don't seem to understand. Leaving your child with bipolar disorder a property won't ensure that she is never homeless. If she racks up debt, if she sets light to the place when she's in the manic stage of bi-polar, if she is persuaded to take out loans by an unscrupulous partner or fails to pay her bills during the depressive stage of the illness — any of these things could result in debt, bankruptcy and the house needing to be sold in a hurry. Perhaps she'll end up with enough funds to buy somewhere smaller. And then, because of the cyclical nature of bpd, the whole thing could happen again. I have known several people with BPD over the years and although it seems to be better-controlled these days all those I've known with that diagnosis have had roller-coaster lives. Flying high one minute, down on the ground the next.

We created a trust for my learning-disabled cousin (not BPD) because he is terrible at managing money and property and has lost thousands over the years. If he'd had access to the £350,000 his home was sold for it would all have gone down the drain in five years. As it is the money is invested, he gets a basic income from it (which he supplements with work) and he is guaranteed stability for the rest of his life.

fortifiedwithtea · 13/08/2021 11:28

Ok I’ve heard you all loud and clear. Leaving a house to DD2 is a terrible idea.

Neither ours or DM is a big house. We are talking 3 bed semi’s but because of the locations of both close to London they are worth a lot. In fact DM house is worth more than ours. DF was in finance. He took out investments when each grandchild was born. Dd2 also benefitted from a government scheme. To make it fair we opened an investment for DD1 so each child had 2 investments. Safe to say they BOTH have a nice nest egg.

This thread has brought up another issue that had not even occurred to me. DD2 might have too much already in savings to qualify for full benefits. So something else that needs professional help .

Dd1 has never had a good relationship with DD2. They are too different in personality. They have never been company for each other. Nearly 5 years age gap. I was so desperate to give DD1 a sibling as I hated being an only child I never considered that DD1 might actually enjoy being the only one or that DD2 could be born different. Dd1 never wanted her sister to be at her sporting events and we never forced DD1 to support DD2 in her sport either. With hindsight maybe that was a mistake. Or if I’d forced them to be together maybe the resentment would be worse. I don’t know.

OP posts:
Doubledoorsontogarden · 13/08/2021 11:27

Equal is on the only way not to cause issues.

MeridianB · 13/08/2021 11:24

@fortifiedwithtea Try STEP
www.step.org/

It’s a professional standards body for specialists in this field.
You can search for an estate planning specialist in your area.

Backwaterjunction · 13/08/2021 11:22

No completely not alright, no no no, I can’t think of anything you could do to make your daughters not have anything but no relationship when you are gone, not cool

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 13/08/2021 11:22

I have bipolar disorder and C-PTSD, and unfortunately my parents have helped me out a lot financially over the years - it's not something I ever asked for or demanded, btw. I've always held down jobs to the best of my ability, and have always done my very best to stay in work.

My sister is 15 years older than me (she's my dad's stepdaughter), and fully understands the difficulties I've had. For the most part, she's remained in stable financial situations throughout life and has no significant health issues, and harbours no resentment towards me or my/our parents.

My parents have split everything between us equally in their joint wills, including their house - my dad insists that my sister is just as much his daughter as I am.

This gives me a lot of comfort. It's not my sister's fault that I have mental health issues. It's likely the house will be sold before my parents' death anyway, in order to pay for their care (my dad's care home fees are already extortionate).

This does look like favouritism I'm afraid, OP. If I'd been left the house in the will due to my illness, I'd feel deeply uncomfortable with that. As PPs have recommended, speak to a solicitor experienced in these matters, because your daughters may well need to rely on each other once you're gone. A rift over finances could cause untold damage to their relationship.

Greystray · 13/08/2021 11:14

and again what about the Op's husband...the father of both these children?

Husbands in my opinion are one of the main reasons women should get a will sorted.

I've lived to see - sadly - friends pass away without wills, naturally assuming their husbands will pass everything down to the children, another case of assuming that everything will be preserved in aspic exactly as it always was, then a year later a new woman is in his life and in the home and then married and a beneficiary. And there's nothing wrong with that except that I know my friends would have safeguarded their assets for their children if they'd have known.

Crowtooyo · 13/08/2021 11:08

YABU. Massively actually. Your DD1 needs your support not the cold shoulder because she's s difficult character. Please split it equally.

cutebutscary · 13/08/2021 11:07

I think what you are doing to dd1 is unforgivable . If dd2 has disability , she will be able to be cared for by the state in the event of your not being around . It's really cruel

MaMelon · 13/08/2021 11:01

You’re being beyond unreasonable.

Greystray · 13/08/2021 11:00

Not everyone is as greedy as the posters on this thread.

In her own words the older daughter feels bitter about her mother's plan and thinks that it's unfair. Where did you read that she actively supports the decision?

And she suffers from anxiety and is at uni, she's not happily established in a career. Her DM is just assuming she will do well, perhaps in comparison to her sister. I think OP is failing to see that things could change for both women.

Oblomov21 · 13/08/2021 11:00

I too feel sorry for your dd1. There has got to be a better way round this, surely?
Clearly you need to consider lots of things, as other posters have said.
And then, make a will, ASAP.