Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband throwing tantrum about cars..

292 replies

MouseDeMuir · 13/08/2021 08:19

Hello lovely people of mumsnet.

I need some help.
My husband and I have been together 10 years.
We have a 3 year old and I'm currently 8 weeks pregnant.
We both work, me part time very close to home and him full time, but his commute is 280 miles a week.
We have 2 cars. One very small 2 door car, that's very economical and does 80mpg, and one bigger estate car that can fit car seats and dogs and is much newer but only does around 40mpg.
My husband had a hard up bringing, and on the whole is a very kind and caring person, but he's very materialistic. He worries about what people think if he drives a small or old car. I honestly couldn't care less about how things look, as long as they work!
Until now, he has used the 'new ' big car to commute to work, while I take our son and dogs to my mother's house every day in the little old car. It's fine but it does mean I struggle to put everyone in and It would be easier in a 5 door car..

Anyway.. at the end of every month my husband has no money left. He claims it all goes on fuel.
We pay equally into our mortgage and bills, and I pay for the food shopping, despite earning around £500 a month less than him as I work part time, but he still ends up borrowing money from me to get by until the end of the month.

So.. I suggested we swap cars..

To me this makes sense because:

  1. We bought the car half and half each.
  2. The little car would be cheaper to run him Commute.
  3. It would put less miles on a newer car, hence preserving the value better.
  4. I have the children and dogs to take and collect daily, so wouldn't it make more sense for me to use the 'family' car.

But he just says he hates the other car, it's too slow and looks shit.
He says I'll make the other car dirty with the dogs and the kids, and won't treat it with respect..
Since this conversation he hasn't spoken to me.. won't look at me. Just sulks.

I honestly don't know where to go from here..
It sounds daft to consider breaking up over a car, but honestly this is how he is with anything materialistic.. he's all about image and I really can't live like this anymore..

Am I being a hormonal crazy lady ?

OP posts:
CreamPantsuit · 13/08/2021 11:37

Having said that, I wouldn't want to drive a small 2 door car either so I think you both need to compromise. Can you sell both cars and buy 2 4-door hatchbacks?

CreamPantsuit · 13/08/2021 11:34

I drive 300+ miles a week, car does about 60mpg and I spend maybe 120-140 per month on fuel so how is it costing him that much?
I'd find it hard to respect some an adult who sulked in this way.

Backwaterjunction · 13/08/2021 11:34

Whoever said 280 is not a lot divided by 10 obviously never tried to do that across a busy place that has no direct public transportation (so takes longer) for a decade averaging between 14 and 18 miles an hour

MaybeMaybeNotJ · 13/08/2021 11:30

So
My husband is the same, so far as to him his car is the only “luxury” he has and if he ever has to take my car to work he hates it.
However, I have an old Citroen Berlingo multi space so don’t have to compromise on practicality. He has an estate but a sporty type that I’d hate to have with the kids.
Can you sell and buy a family friendly new old car?

Backwaterjunction · 13/08/2021 11:29

Speaking as someone that used to commute, 300 miles a week, traffic jams, congestion etc is a hell of a long time in a car you find uncomfortable and don’t like, 60 miles a day he must be in the car 3 hours a day? If he works in a city (going on my own crawling average speed) so your proposing swap to a horrible car that will lengthen that journey errr thanks a lot!!! Not surprised he’s grumpy

RedToothBrush · 13/08/2021 11:28

@Coogee

Oh and btw, Dh is 6ft 2.

Height isn’t the full story. My husband is 6’4’ and has a friend who is the same height. They don’t find the same cars comfortable as one is long in the leg and shorter in the body and the other is the opposite.

Dh is longer in the body than leg.

It means he cant drive astras as his eyeline is about the level of the window.

But he is fine with most small cars (he's driven a lot of rentals). He doesn't have the seat back to the full extent either so there is definitely room for those with longer legs.

We also find people get in the back of our city car and find they have more leg room than their bigger car, much to their surprise.

It has the top rating for safety too, so we aren't compromising on that.

I do think that if size is the thing then looking at more unfashionable brands is the way to go. You just cant beat Dacia. And many of the other brands like Kia, Seat, Hyudani etc compare very well.

It doesn't make sense to be paying out for mercs, audis and vws on extortionate finance plans.

riceuten · 13/08/2021 11:27

Stop making excuses for him. What you propose is totally reasonable. And read him the riot act. If he goes into a sulk rather than rationally discuss things, then that - for me anyway - sets alarm bells ringing. Tell him in no uncertain terms that this behaviour is unacceptable.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 13/08/2021 11:25

We swapped cars when DH had a big commute and have swapped back now he is on the train again. No dramas. Tbh it sounds like the smaller car isn’t right for the family full stop, can you look to change it?

DGFB · 13/08/2021 11:25

Why are you paying more than him for a start?

RB68 · 13/08/2021 11:23

280 is not alot in a week - divide by 10 for am and pm drive. Seems to me there are a range of issues

  1. smaller car is just not suitable for either of you. He needs a small more fuel efficient (electric?) suitable for an average less than 30 mile in and 30 mile back commute.
  2. the newer car is more the fam car and you should have this and use protective mats and regular cleaning to keep it clean etc.
  3. Newer car should be famility car for safety reasons if nothing else
  4. Mardy arse is not communicating well and I would say he needs to look at his spending and how his salary is "disappearing" so for e.g. is he heavily paying into a pension pot - if so wheres yours?? In family situation such as this all money should be going into a pot other than an agreed personal spend amount. Any other way when money is tight is not going to work and lead to inequalities.

Have you thought about a lease style car purchase? Then you could lump for an electric car - likely to have chargers at work for this - then reduction in costs for the family etc

Fizzogg · 13/08/2021 11:23

I'm not sure why posters are suggesting the OP should LTB 🤨 that's obviously not what she's asking.

No OP you are not BU to ask to swap cars, it makes total logical and economical sense.

Naunet · 13/08/2021 11:22

@DrSbaitso

And even to the extent it is about appearence, how many women criticising him would be willing to wear shit ugly clothes because they "do the job" and looking good is just stupid vanity that family money shouldn't be wasted on? Women often claim that they dress nicely for themselves, not other people.

When you need to wear specific clothes to cart the family kids and dogs around on your daily business, and there is an added cost and environmental impact as well, this might become a suitable analogy.

Exactly. Add to that the expectation that your partner pays 50/50 towards the cost of these clothes and is continuing to subsides you despite being the lower earner so that you can keep spending on yourself…
Coogee · 13/08/2021 11:19

Oh and btw, Dh is 6ft 2.

Height isn’t the full story. My husband is 6’4’ and has a friend who is the same height. They don’t find the same cars comfortable as one is long in the leg and shorter in the body and the other is the opposite.

DrSbaitso · 13/08/2021 11:18

And even to the extent it is about appearence, how many women criticising him would be willing to wear shit ugly clothes because they "do the job" and looking good is just stupid vanity that family money shouldn't be wasted on? Women often claim that they dress nicely for themselves, not other people.

When you need to wear specific clothes to cart the family kids and dogs around on your daily business, and there is an added cost and environmental impact as well, this might become a suitable analogy.

MargosKaftan · 13/08/2021 11:16

So he earns more than you. You spent equal amounts on the household bills. He doesn't pay for food, you do. He spends extra on petrol. Even if his petrol costs were the same as the food costs, where is his money going that you have left over cash at the end of thr month but he doesn't.

Forget the car. You need a serious conversation about his spending habits.

IME, men you can't trust with money you can't trust about anything. (Or "few dickheads are only dickheads in a limited fashion")

HermioneKipper · 13/08/2021 11:13

What? He’s letting his pregnant wife and child with all the paraphernalia that comes with it plus dogs go around in a tiny 2 door car while he spends a fortune running the bigger one. What a prince if his “image” is so much more important than your comfort and actual practicality.

So when you’re on mat leave he’d be happy for you to struggle to get a baby into the backseat with the seat pulled forward on a two door. Will you even be able to fit the pram in the boot?

It shouldn’t even be a discussion. He should’ve swapped immediately without being asked.

Show him this thread

RedToothBrush · 13/08/2021 11:13

Oh and btw, Dh is 6ft 2.

He has no problem with fitting in my car and driving it comfortably

MrsBumm · 13/08/2021 11:13

Yeah "car as status" is one notch up from a massive wide screen telly as status, which is one notch up from, I dunno, designer trainers. Ironically it probably makes your husband's background of poverty more obvious. Which is shit to go through- and understandably would leave its mark.

MacmillanMO · 13/08/2021 11:10

He’s taking the piss. Stop giving him money, and insist he pays for half of the food shop.
As for sulking about the car … how very unattractive. I wouldn’t put up with it personally.

RedToothBrush · 13/08/2021 11:09

My little city car does 60mpg even with my driving in start stop town traffic.

Dh likes to play 'see how high i can get fuel efficiency' when driving my car...

Its fab.

MaMelon · 13/08/2021 11:09

I understand where he’s coming from - in normal times I do a similar number of miles each week, often more, and wouldn’t want to do it in a very small car. I love my big car, it feels safer and it’s more powerful (although definitely not huge, and it’s a very sensible Karoq) so I can overtake lorries and tractors trundling along on the A road so my journey doesn’t become too long.

Given that you both can’t agree I think you need to compromise - sell them and buy 2 medium sized ones, or take it week about.

Pipsquiggle · 13/08/2021 11:07

Your DH needs to get over himself.

I remember this scenario about 8 years ago. I had the small car, my husband had an alfa romeo (which he loved). He got this car pre-children so I didn't mind.

We were talking about our car situation - we needed 2; 1 needed to be bigger than the other. It was literally a 2 minute conversation, I told my DH that I should have the bigger car due to prams, car seats, food shops etc. He tried to argue his case but even he realised he didn't have a leg to stand on. We now have a 2nd hand SUV and a 2nd hand fiesta.

My husband is a director at a big firm - all the other senior managers / directors have mercs, BMWs, Jags etc. My husband rolls up in his fiesta and he couldn't give 2 hoots (he also had a fairly poor upbringing) - we pay no tax on it and it is super cheap to run, great for parking as well. He did choose the make and model though as he did want specific features e.g. blue tooth for business calls etc

Like PPs I would question his outgoings, 280 miles isn't that long a commute - where is his money going?

RedToothBrush · 13/08/2021 11:06

He worries about what people think if he drives a small or old car.

www.autoexpress.co.uk/opinion/355731/people-have-decided-mercedes-bmw-and-audi-are-no-longer-top-10-car-brands
'The people have decided that Mercedes, BMW and Audi are no longer top-10 car brands'
Mike Rutherford thinks the 2021 Driver Power survey shows changing attitudes towards premium cars

Your DH isn't up and with the times.

The way people view cars and status is fundamentally changing.

Cars are losing their status symbolism and people don't care what others drive.

The thing here is that 1) you can't afford to run the status symbol he wants 2) his attitude towards you on this is appalling and unacceptable.

The funniest thing is that what you find is in the most affluent areas you often see less status symbol cars than in more average areas because people prioritise housing over cars and using a car as a status symbol can be viewed as trying to make up for a lack of status! The penis extension if you want to put it into crude terms (but the same principle applies to women too though to a lesser extent).

Ask him why he feels so insecure be needs a car to 'prove' his status to the rest of the world.

You will get a pretty hostile reaction, but the point remains that his reasoning is about signalling to others a certain status and he feels the need to do this or he will get laughed at. Thats insecurity.

As it goes DH would love a flash car but he cant justify either the cost nor the trade off in practicality (he drives a car bought new but bottom spec unfashionable brand). He doesn't have to worry about it getting dirty from his sports gear and he doesn't worry about potential damage to it. Its an estate.

If we go out as a family we usually go out in my city car. Its so much more practical for parking etc. Its new as my previous car (bought new) was starting to need multiple repairs. Again unfashionable brand but its mid spec. Dh loves driving it cos its nippy and fun.

He gets the whole status symbol stuff and can be wistful about it, but keeps coming back to practicality, reliability and wanting money for other things.

This is a mature response. Its also one thats being shared by an increasing number of people who dont want to be slaves to marketing and the insecure.

Dh certainly wouldn't judge your husband for driving something entirely sensible. Because he doesn't bloody care what anyone else drives as long as they don't drive like a dickhead as the model of car doesn't have impact on him.

Skyla2005 · 13/08/2021 11:03

He sounds like a twat

BungleandGeorge · 13/08/2021 11:02

@Christmasfairy2020

My dh does 60 miles per day. He has recently got an automatic diesel car its a Mercedes and diesel. Only puts 20 quid per week init
Unless my maths is wrong you’d need to be doing around 92mpg to get that figure. What car is this??