Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ethnic minorities...

118 replies

PatricksRum · 13/08/2021 03:22

Do you answer monitoring questions e.g. What is your ethnicity?

It still makes me feel very uncomfortable and I refuse to provide an answer as I probably will be treated differently.

YABU - I answer
YANBU - I also refuse

OP posts:
Nivealove · 13/08/2021 11:00

It's good for data collection

ATowelAndAPotato · 13/08/2021 10:57

It makes me so angry that people are still worried about being treated differently once they’ve disclosed their ethnicity. I’m not going to sit here and say it never happens, because we all know in some circumstances it does, and it’s shit.

I know that most organisations are asking because they want to understand their client base, who to aim services at, which groups funding is being spent on, etc. All seem reasonable enough reasons to ask, and at an organisational level, maybe that information is used for the purpose for which it was collected, but unfortunately between the client and the organisation there is sometimes a total racist arsehole.
Until society grows up, many people will never feel comfortable disclosing.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 13/08/2021 10:50

if we want them to continue to fund us we need to gather the statistics they want.

ClaudiaWankleman · 13/08/2021 10:45

I answer the ethnicity but refuse the gender if it has anything other than male or female.

Don't hijack a thread where people are discussing potential racism for other issues.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 13/08/2021 10:30

I answer the ethnicity but refuse the gender if it has anything other than male or female.

NurseButtercup · 13/08/2021 10:27

@PatricksRum

Do you answer monitoring questions e.g. What is your ethnicity?

It still makes me feel very uncomfortable and I refuse to provide an answer as I probably will be treated differently.

YABU - I answer
YANBU - I also refuse

I don't disclose anything in the monitoring questions, I always select the "prefer not to say" option.

I had to challenge a HCP on this recently, when I went for my 2nd covid19 vaccine u had selected the "prefer not to say" option, the HCP crossed it out and ticked my ethnicity in front of me. Her reason, "oh they keep reporting that there's a low vaccine take up in your ethnic group, but I want to show this isn't true", I made her get another firm and start again.

SweetCharityBeginsAtHome · 13/08/2021 10:23

I used to volunteer for a charity in inner London where we had to monitor the ethnicity of service users. It was difficult because I did understand why a lot of Black British participants didn’t want to be monitored and labelled in that way, and it was difficult to enable non-English speakers to fill in forms (tiny charity and a lot of different languages locally so translating was quite a big challenge), but OTOH the people funding us had a legitimate reason to want to check that it wasn’t being run by the white middle class volunteers solely for the benefit of them and their mates. It genuinely wasn’t - by eye you could tell that it had a completely mixed intake but proving it was a nightmare.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/08/2021 10:22

In which case, why does it need to ask?

Because charitable and third sector organisations need to compile statistics so that commissioners know who the service is being provided to, and so that they can be sure the organisation is fulfilling it's obligations regarding inclusivity etc.

@DeflatedGinDrinker pretty much already explained this?

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/08/2021 10:18

Today 10:15 DeflatedGinDrinker

Theres absolutely no way you would be treated differently by my organisation OP. Why would you be?!“

In which case, why does it need to ask?

Muddydoor · 13/08/2021 10:17

Last time I was asked I said human “oh, so you don’t want to answer?”

DeflatedGinDrinker · 13/08/2021 10:15

Theres absolutely no way you would be treated differently by my organisation OP. Why would you be?!

DeflatedGinDrinker · 13/08/2021 10:14

I hate asking the question at work. We are charity funded though and our funders ask us to get this information so they know what kind of people we help. So we have to ask.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/08/2021 03:43

So your issue is with the handler's potential subconscious bias then, rather than the fact that diversity monitoring exists for completely innocuous reasons.

That's fair enough I suppose. Disabled people often feel the same way about disclosing their disabilities, even though there are significant practical reasons for doing so.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/08/2021 03:39

An accent covers everything.

It's true.

All monitoring needs to be entirely double blind and externally done.

PatricksRum · 13/08/2021 03:35

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

Diversity monitoring forms are completely anonymous and not used for filtering candidates etc anyway, so I'm honestly unsure how you would believe that you might be 'treated differently' upon completing them?
Where did I mention candidates?

I call 111, 119. They ask. If I answer correctly I fear being treated differently.

OP posts:
PatricksRum · 13/08/2021 03:34

@MrsNeilGaiman

I do, even though I know I won't be.

I'm an immigrant and Polish ancestry but a 'perfect' accent so no one knows. Which means people say a lot about Polish people in front of me Sad

I know what you mean about the accent.

An accent covers everything.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/08/2021 03:32

Diversity monitoring forms are completely anonymous and not used for filtering candidates etc anyway, so I'm honestly unsure how you would believe that you might be 'treated differently' upon completing them?

MrsNeilGaiman · 13/08/2021 03:25

I do, even though I know I won't be.

I'm an immigrant and Polish ancestry but a 'perfect' accent so no one knows. Which means people say a lot about Polish people in front of me Sad

Swipe left for the next trending thread