Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ethnic minorities...

118 replies

PatricksRum · 13/08/2021 03:22

Do you answer monitoring questions e.g. What is your ethnicity?

It still makes me feel very uncomfortable and I refuse to provide an answer as I probably will be treated differently.

YABU - I answer
YANBU - I also refuse

OP posts:
LadyMaid · 13/08/2021 14:47

I answer the question.

My 10 year old is of the opinion that its none of their business.

JingsMahBucket · 13/08/2021 14:45

@emuloc please don’t invite anymore malarkey onto this thread :)

emuloc · 13/08/2021 14:38

@mustlovegin

I agree that positive discrimination can be concerning as was mentioned upthread.
Why do you find it concerning?
mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 13:42

I agree that positive discrimination can be concerning as was mentioned upthread.

Zarene · 13/08/2021 13:40

I'd feel quite uncomfortable with hearing some off that @SometimesRavenSometimesParrot.

The 'people who have paid for today...' stuff would make me feel patronised and as if I'm supposed to be grateful.

The 'I can signpost you to the local Arabic Center' thing would get my back up because it assumes that with an Arabic background I want support that focuses on my ethnicity not anything else about me.

I do totally get that you have good intentions. But it may not be heard that way, which is why people are sometimes wary of disclosing.

SometimesRavenSometimesParrot · 13/08/2021 13:32

To give another view, I work in widening participation in HE and collect this data about the students on my programmes. I just explain it as the people who’ve paid for today would love to know more about what we’re doing and who we’re helping, and who we haven’t reached so we can help them too. Most students disclose their ethnicity.

But also having that data means I can promote appropriate opportunities for them - so where a local Arabic centre is offering mentoring, or a scholarship for BAME students. I apply the same logic to students who declare disabilities, care status etc. So it can have some clear benefits to disclose.

StarDrawers · 13/08/2021 13:28

@Flaunch

I answer but I refuse to engage in any form that asks for gender. If it’s a paper form I scribble out the word gender and write ‘you mean sex’ next to it 😬
Ok but we're talking about ethnic minorities.
StarDrawers · 13/08/2021 13:27

@NurseButtercup that is awful. I'd have asked who to complain to.

OhWhyNot · 13/08/2021 13:25

I do if medical as it can be usual

Otherwise I leave it blank

Starseeking · 13/08/2021 13:22

Working in finance, I believe in the power of data even if it puts me at a disadvantages, so I always tick the relevant box for me.

It's amusing when certain results around diversity are published and people do the faux big eyes and exclaim "oh that can't be right" IT'S ALL IN THE DATA!!!

Inthesameboatatmo · 13/08/2021 12:42

I answer.
I am an ethnic minority I'm not ashamed of that at all.if I'm judged or treated differently in a bad way because if it then that's in them ,I'm proud of who I am .

AgentJohnson · 13/08/2021 12:34

I refuse to answer if possible. I’m white and I’m aware that positive discrimination is permitted, and it disadvantages me. Lots of opportunities will reject me for being white because I don’t “tick the diversity box”.

Good for you, the amount of times where I have been the only person of colour in a room is a testament to how endemic these positive discrimination are Confused.

AgentJohnson · 13/08/2021 12:23

I work in a sector that is subsidised and these forms are used for reporting purposes. It allows us and our donors to know who we are reaching and if there are any groups which are under represented. Which then allows us to develop strategies to reach the under represented groups.

I suspect Google knows more about you, than can be determined from one of these forms. Is there a particular reason that you think you would be treated differently.

I live in the Netherlands and because diversity monitoring is not really a thing here, under representation of groups are rarely acknowledged or challenged. Report after report has shown that people are routinely filtered out during the recruitment stage because of surnames and or photos, with the most common ‘explanation’ given, that people from diverse backgrounds don’t apply. Diversity monitoring would expose the lie behind that ‘explanation’.

JingsMahBucket · 13/08/2021 12:18

@Flaunch

I answer but I refuse to engage in any form that asks for gender. If it’s a paper form I scribble out the word gender and write ‘you mean sex’ next to it 😬
To quote PP @ClaudiaWankleman

Don't hijack a thread where people are discussing potential racism for other issues.

Flaunch · 13/08/2021 12:12

I answer but I refuse to engage in any form that asks for gender. If it’s a paper form I scribble out the word gender and write ‘you mean sex’ next to it 😬

Paulinna · 13/08/2021 12:06

I refuse to answer if possible. I’m white and I’m aware that positive discrimination is permitted, and it disadvantages me. Lots of opportunities will reject me for being white because I don’t “tick the diversity box”.

Faithless12 · 13/08/2021 12:00

@DeflatedGinDrinker

Theres absolutely no way you would be treated differently by my organisation OP. Why would you be?!
This isn’t necessarily true. OP may be concerned because she has an English sounding name and is not white so people treat her one way on the phone and completely differently in person. It happens. Don’t be so dismissive.
BiBabbles · 13/08/2021 11:57

I'm fine ticking Mixed most of the time (my accent gives my not Britishness away anyways) but I have noticed my DDs both use 'prefer not to say' more often than they tick any ethnicity options.

DD1 particularly, occasionally she also ticks mixed, but generally prefers not to say and I do think that is in part because she's had the most shite out of my four kids from her peers saying shite like she's 'not really British'.

My DSs on the other hand always pick an ethnicity. DS1 has also had some shite like DD1, if not to the same extent, but he never selects Mixed. He always picks White British, which his father is and I have always given as option for them. I think this might also be a reaction, just in a different way, though how this impacts data collection when mixed kids pick one ethnicity has been discussed by far smarter minds than me.

Brainwave89 · 13/08/2021 11:56

Yes I fill in the form. Most serious organisations are interested in reaching all areas of society be that by gender, race, class or sexuality. Collecting appropriate data demonstrates issues which need addressing. For example, black and asian people generally are not using national parks- work is ongoing to address this. Women do not cycle as much as men- a strategy to address issues for women are being developed. It is the accountant in me I know, but without data, these issues cannot be identified and addressed.

DeeCeeCherry · 13/08/2021 11:51

XDownwiththissortofthingX

This is baseless nonsense

That's a stupid opening line.

Organisations such as 'Charity So White' exist precisely because if what I've said, and the bias of charities who gatekeep diversity funding for gain, getting their hands on funds so that Black people/organisations don't.

Then aim to patronise, as you've just done,vwith the usual 'we know best what's good for Black people' attitude.

I look forward to the day when gatekeepers are forced out of the way and real work gets done.

In the meantime I'm ever more determined not to tick a box, particularly for fat cat charity monetary gain.

Stay there with your 'baseless nonsense' attitude. It's not all about you.

JingsMahBucket · 13/08/2021 11:49

@ClaudiaWankleman

I answer the ethnicity but refuse the gender if it has anything other than male or female.

Don't hijack a thread where people are discussing potential racism for other issues.

Thank you @ClaudiaWankleman :)
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 13/08/2021 11:38

DH has a noticeable ethnic accent (he is Algerian) even after living in the UK since his 20's. He sometimes puts me on the phone to deal with services and companies as he is convinced I get a better response with a standard native British accent. His English is perfectly good but it is clear he is not a native speaker.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/08/2021 11:35

As for charities needing info to collect stats - it's blatant that it's jobs for Whites at the top and normally White board members only - accessing funding by 'helping' non-White people just so charity can keep themselves in a job/money, get Diversity kudos and of course keep clawing in those funds. All very useful for them

This is baseless nonsense.

The funding for many organisations is not predicated on precisely who the service is provided to. You have the cart ahead of the horse there. And nor is it relevant in any way to who the organisation hires, or who sits on the board/committee.

Organisations that cater exclusively to ethnic minorities, and that are staffed exclusively by ethnic minorities still carry out the exact same diversity monitoring.

DeeCeeCherry · 13/08/2021 11:25

I don't fill it in.

As for charities needing info to collect stats - it's blatant that it's jobs for Whites at the top and normally White board members only - accessing funding by 'helping' non-White people just so charity can keep themselves in a job/money, get Diversity kudos and of course keep clawing in those funds. All very useful for them.

Aside from that I don't believe there is no bias in monitoring. There are still companies who do the monitoring yet still manage to have either no Black staff, or just a few in lower grade positions.

Anyway thankfully it's not compulsory to complete race questions

Auntienumber8 · 13/08/2021 11:07

I have never minded ticking the box but to be honest my name gives away I’m not white European anyway. When it comes to accent I was born here and speak with a RP accent. I have had people say you don’t sound Chinese to me on the phone.

They use data to make sure they are reaching all people or to find out if they aren’t reaching some groups. It can also be used for funding and grant applications.

Swipe left for the next trending thread