Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ethnic minorities...

118 replies

PatricksRum · 13/08/2021 03:22

Do you answer monitoring questions e.g. What is your ethnicity?

It still makes me feel very uncomfortable and I refuse to provide an answer as I probably will be treated differently.

YABU - I answer
YANBU - I also refuse

OP posts:
ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 13/08/2021 17:23

I'm Hungarian but have a British passport and because DH is British I always tick "White British" for me & kids.
I'm pretty sure it is my legal right to do so but mainly I just can't be bothered with nitpicking.

Also I don't even know if "Hungarian" counts as ethnicity.

jcyclops · 13/08/2021 16:59

I always answer monitoring questions on ethnicity, age, income, education level, house type etc. but I rarely answer truthfully. If the data collected is used in a non-discriminatory way then it doesn't matter. If it is used for discrimination (positive or negative) or for self-congratulation then I am happy to contribute to the errors in your data.

Namenic · 13/08/2021 16:53

I think it is helpful for organisations to know what the spread of their applicants and employees are. It’s helpful to be able to see if ethnic minorities are being fairly rewarded/promoted/hired. How will organisations be able to do this if they can’t collect the data?

I am part of an ethnic minority and always fill in this part.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 13/08/2021 16:48

I always put Mixed - other, as I have a small amount of Romany ancestry. If there is an option to mention Romany, then I do. Nobody would ever know unless I told them, to anyone looking at me I'm just a middle age white female, but I am not completely White British and I don't want to say that I am.

My DP is never completely sure what to put. He is Indo-Jamaican, so often puts Caribbean as he is Caribbean, but that comes under the Black or Black British section and he isn't black so it doesn't seem completely correct. On the other hand, he doesn't feel overly comfortable ticking Indian as he doesn't feel particularly Indian or Asian.

Peanutsandchilli · 13/08/2021 16:47

I do answer but then I'm white British so know I'm not going to be discriminated against.

I understand it's difficult for you, but equally, if people of other ethnicities refuse to answer monitoring questions, how do companies know what needs to change for them to feel equal?

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 16:43

Discrimination is not ok

I agree, discrimination in either direction is not ok, and hence many people prefer not to tick any boxes

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 16:41

Schrodingers what would happen also if there were two equally capable candidates but there was a quota to be filled?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/08/2021 16:38

@mustlovegin

That's just a pure and simple discrimination and she should be saying no

How can you say no to your manager who is adamant to meet certain quotas? It's not realistic at all

Would you say the same if they said "no ethnic minorities"? Discrimination is not ok no matter what skin colour/sex/disability and people should be challenging it or reporting it.
mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 16:34

That's just a pure and simple discrimination and she should be saying no

How can you say no to your manager who is adamant to meet certain quotas? It's not realistic at all

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/08/2021 16:15

@Paulinna

That's really not how this wprks amd positive discriminate is NOT permitted outside of specific circumstances such as genuine occupational requirement My SIL recently conducted interviews at work and her boss told her “don’t hire a white person even if they’re the best candidate, we need more ethnic minorities to hit our targets”. And I was once turned down for a job because “you’re too local and it doesn’t fit with the multicultural image we want to project going forward”. Another interviewer told me “we already employ enough people who look like you”. So regardless of whether it’s legal, it does happen.
That's just a pure and simple discrimination and she should be saying no. IF they can really show they have big imbalance and get equal candidates they can apply s158. But no, you can't just "not hire the white one even if they are best" and unless people start reporting shit like this, discrimination won't get any better. I hope you rrported the interviewer
Paulinna · 13/08/2021 16:11

That's really not how this wprks amd positive discriminate is NOT permitted outside of specific circumstances such as genuine occupational requirement
My SIL recently conducted interviews at work and her boss told her “don’t hire a white person even if they’re the best candidate, we need more ethnic minorities to hit our targets”. And I was once turned down for a job because “you’re too local and it doesn’t fit with the multicultural image we want to project going forward”. Another interviewer told me “we already employ enough people who look like you”. So regardless of whether it’s legal, it does happen.

SometimesRavenSometimesParrot · 13/08/2021 16:04

@Zarene

I'd feel quite uncomfortable with hearing some off that *@SometimesRavenSometimesParrot*.

The 'people who have paid for today...' stuff would make me feel patronised and as if I'm supposed to be grateful.

The 'I can signpost you to the local Arabic Center' thing would get my back up because it assumes that with an Arabic background I want support that focuses on my ethnicity not anything else about me.

I do totally get that you have good intentions. But it may not be heard that way, which is why people are sometimes wary of disclosing.

It’s obviously said in a nicer, more appropriate way @Zarene. ‘The people who’ve helped us to provide you with the event today’ or ‘as you know today was part of national X day and the people at national X would love to know a bit more about the people they’ve helped today’

I can assure you the support we provide is NOT wholly focused on ethnicity, but where there are supplementary, high quality activities we’re made aware of, having data the data to send them out as a supplementary activity is a fantastic opportunity for the students I work with. The take up rates tell us that broadly students are happy to have that additional tailored support - who can often provide things that aren’t in my remit. For example the Arabic centre mentoring I’ve picked as an example, that’s strong community leaders offering young people support with their employability and enterprise activities. This isn’t something I can offer within my programmes.

Ultimately we help about 35k young people a year, both in terms of activity, 1-2-1 support and financial support. If we don’t get the data to evidence what we do, this will be pulled back and less people will benefit. I imagine this is the case with anything charity based or NGO too.

I understand the worry some people might have about being discriminated against (my family is Irish and my grandfather tried to find work in England during the no dogs, no blacks, no Irish period…) but equally if we don’t have data, we can’t understand underrepresentation or the impacts or that and it will continue to happen.

The vaccine example above thread is a good example…vital resources could be going on trying to sort vaccine take up in an ethnic group, when actually this group has good take up but there is a trend within the group not to disclose.

Charley50 · 13/08/2021 15:53

Flibberty - don't we only know those stats (so can only act on them) because data on ethnicity is collected? I'm not clear on your point?

Badgertadger · 13/08/2021 15:51

Please please please answer the monitoring questions. They're the only way for organisations to be able to measure whether they're systematically discriminating against people on the basis of protected characteristics in hiring, promotional or performance decisions. If you don't answer the questions there's no data, so no evidenced problem.

DroopyClematis · 13/08/2021 15:48

@MrsNeilGaiman

I do, even though I know I won't be.

I'm an immigrant and Polish ancestry but a 'perfect' accent so no one knows. Which means people say a lot about Polish people in front of me Sad

I get this too.
FlibbertyGiblets · 13/08/2021 15:38

Wary is understandable if you know that Black women are 4 times more likely to die in childbirth, and Asian ethnic women are 2 times more likely to die in childbirth compared to white women, stats from the MBRRACE report here
www.rcog.org.uk/en/news/mbrrace-uk-report-response/

It doesn't take a genius to draw a line between maternal deaths disparity and the over representation of deaths in the same groups from covid.

Patrick I hear you.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 15:21

OFRS is an Oh Fuck Rucksack

Smile
PattyPan · 13/08/2021 15:18

I always answer diversity questions. It’s much harder to tackle a problem if you don’t have data on it existing.

NeverTalkToStrangers · 13/08/2021 15:15

OFRS is an Oh Fuck Rucksack. It’s what you have packed full of essentials and irreplaceables by the door ready to grab and go when the Cossacks/Nazis/zombies are coming.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 15:11

I want time to grab my OFRS

What's an OFRS?

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/08/2021 14:59

My last organisation changed three things about these forms.

  1. Asked at the end of the service not the beginning. We did lose data about people who dropped out, which was concerning because maybe we were losing people because of discrimination. But many more people were happy to fill the forms when they knew and trusted us. Anecdotally we thought drop out was not an issue but it was concerning.
  2. We made the forms much more 'tell us about you' rather than 'tick this box we've defined'. That helped.
  3. We had a script which explained why we asked, why certain questions and that they were the fewest we could. Most importantly, proper informed consent.

If we provided a good service, people filled them in more and wrote more on ALL the forms, feedback, monitoring and all. Shit service, shit forms.

NannyOggsward · 13/08/2021 14:52

I’m not but my children are and no I don’t answer on anything.

I want time to grab my OFRS and be gone when all the wokeness leads to the rise of the far right.

Not actually joking.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/08/2021 14:51

@Paulinna

I refuse to answer if possible. I’m white and I’m aware that positive discrimination is permitted, and it disadvantages me. Lots of opportunities will reject me for being white because I don’t “tick the diversity box”.
That's really not how this wprks amd positive discriminate is NOT permitted outside of specific circumstances such as genuine occupational requirement Confused
JingsMahBucket · 13/08/2021 14:49

@emuloc no worries, I know it’s tempting. 😉

emuloc · 13/08/2021 14:48

Sorry Jings, I know I should just ignore that type of nonsense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread