Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now

365 replies

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 20:14

He's always been a chubby misogynist with questionable.comments to make about his wife but now he has compared a woman's afro hair to the fur on an alpaca. Has the world gone completely bloody mad? How come he still has that job? And, no, the 'I have old fashioned northern Irish charm' act doesn't make up for it. I for one am certainly not feeling charmed! I have no idea how Ruth puts up with him tbh.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SaharaFlower · 12/08/2021 23:55

@Clocktopus : This is a bit biased. Let me suggest that you have straight hair.

Me to you: your hair looks like an animal... not racist
You to me: your hair looks like an animal... racist

Therein lies the problem.

RobynNora · 12/08/2021 23:55

That’s genuinely interesting @EnidSpyton - someone should do a Twitter poll on this.

I found it incredible that anyone wouldn’t know the historical racial connotations of uppity and I’m British born and bred.

Christinayangtwistedsister · 12/08/2021 23:55

I had no idea of the connotations behind uppity but now that I do it's a learning point, no?

Catlover77 · 12/08/2021 23:53

Agreed, Enid. I have a good command of the English language and I have also just looked at the first five dictionary definitions of uppity - no reference to racism.

EnidSpyton · 12/08/2021 23:48

@ttcsucks

Here is why uppity is considered a racist term for anyone struggling to understand the history behind it;
I'm sorry, but this is absolute nonsense in a UK context. While we may share a language with the US, we don't share a history or culture, and as such, the connotations certain words have due to historical or cultural events and experiences in one country, are not necessarily shared by the other.

I'm sure in the US the term 'uppity' can legitimately be said to have racial connotations due to the specific context of the Jim Crow era. In the UK, however, this connotation of the word is entirely foreign, as we didn't have enforced racial segregation in this country. Why on earth would the word uppity have the same connotation in a country that didn't experience the same events that gave rise to the connotation in the first place?!

I have a BA and an MA in English. I teach English Literature. As such, I like to think I have a wide vocabulary - more so than the average person on the street. I have never read or heard the word uppity used in a racist context in this country, ever. I cannot agree or accept that uppity in the UK is a racially charged word. In British English, it simply means arrogant and can be applied to anybody seeming to be so.

I'm not commenting on Eamonn Holmes' behaviour in general, as I don't watch him enough to make a judgement, but I don't think it's fair or right to suggest that he used the word uppity as a racial slur for all of the reasons I have explained above. It's very damaging to throw claims about like this. I think you'll find most British English speakers would have no idea of the American context behind the word.

BrozTito · 12/08/2021 23:47

Oh i see we've even got in a 'my daughter has lovely long aryan blonde hair miles long' comment. Beyond fucking parody.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:47

After that should say utter twat

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:46

Regarding Boris Johnson's hair, I have seen animal comparisons.

Ah yes, the well known racist - Boris Johnson. Comments about his hair are in no way related to his race and are instead focused on him being an atter that who hasn't even got the decency to comb his hair when representing the country because he thinks looking like an unkempt bank manager makes him more relatable as part of his "my mate Bozza" persona.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:44

It’s a scary world we’re living in now, frightened to do or say anything.

Don't do or say racist things and you'll be fine.

mustlovegin · 12/08/2021 23:42

Eammon has had his day, week, year and decade and now seems really out of touch

Incredibly ageist and offensive comment

PicsInRed · 12/08/2021 23:42

I didn’t even see the racist element, does that make me racist too?
It’s a scary world we’re living in now, frightened to do or say anything.

This actually sums up the issue perfectly - turning the issue of racist language used on live tv, into the fears of white people. Classic DARVO. It isn't black people with the thin skin here.

The fragility lies elsewhere.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:42

Someone makes a mistake, apologises for it properly with none of this "I'm sorry if..." half-heartedness, and then learns from it? Great. Let them crack on, learning and growing is part of being a decent person.

Someone issues a "sorry, not sorry, it's your fault for being offended" style apology, learns nothing from the incident, and then carries on making repeated incidents? They shouldn't have a public platform such as a regular TV slot and their employers should be sending the message that once is a mistake, more than once (several more than onces) is intentional and will not be tolerated.

If I was at work in my old job and an employee made a racist comment, the first offence they'd have been sent for a meeting with HR where it would be clearly spelled out to them why it was not acceptable. They would also be booked in for some equality and diversity training. It would be made clear that this was a learning opportunity so that the same mistake was not repeated. Further instances? Disciplinary process comes into play with dismissal as the result. Zero tolerance.

BustyDusty · 12/08/2021 23:42

@toocold54

I don’t watch this morning very often but I’ve seen Dr Zoe with her natural heir several times on the show and he’s never commented on it so he obviously doesn’t think she normally looks like a llama. Similar to if someone had a mohawk you could say they looked like a peacock.

Black people have to deal with subliminal racism all the time regarding their hair so it is ok if someone is offended by his comment and he has rightly apologised.
But I don’t think it was malicious and I don’t think he should be sacked over it. I was unaware that ‘uppity’ was racist too, so I think there’s a big difference between intentionally being racist or deeming and saying words maliciously.

Stop thinking. Just stop.
SaharaFlower · 12/08/2021 23:42

@RobynNora : I think most are bored of Meghan and Harry now.

RobynNora · 12/08/2021 23:40

@Whatnext2018 I do truly believe he’s racist and I was actually telling someone this at the weekend. His rant about Meghan Markle made me feel unsettled and upset and I’m not even much of a Meghan fan.

It was the vitriol in the words he reserved for her and the way he excused Harry.

SaharaFlower · 12/08/2021 23:39

@hugolugo : Regarding Boris Johnson's hair, I have seen animal comparisons.

Whatnext2018 · 12/08/2021 23:37

I watched it and found it awkward, but didn’t even think of it in a racist way, just that he was being awkward like he is a fair amount about someone’s appearance. I didn’t even see the racist element, does that make me racist too?
It’s a scary world we’re living in now, frightened to do or say anything.

Christinayangtwistedsister · 12/08/2021 23:37

@workshy44

Whatever way you look at it what he said was outrageous, it was deeply offensive. Whether he should lose his job and be “cancelled” is another matter really. To take away someone’s livelihood is a big deal and shouldn’t be done lightly imo.
Making racists comments on prime time tv is the big deal and shouldn't be taken lightly
PicsInRed · 12/08/2021 23:37

@mustlovegin

He has apologised. These constant requests for cancelling people are worrying, frankly
Sure, a real apology, with some insight and a commitment to learn, for a one off incident of true ignorance, maybe.

But he's a repeat offender with a bullshit apology, remorseful only at being called out, and this isn't cancel culture, this is an employee long overdue for being fired for misconduct in the office and bringing his employer into disrepute.

BrozTito · 12/08/2021 23:35

Ew. "BANTER''.

Sparklingbrook · 12/08/2021 23:35

@workshy44

Whatever way you look at it what he said was outrageous, it was deeply offensive. Whether he should lose his job and be “cancelled” is another matter really. To take away someone’s livelihood is a big deal and shouldn’t be done lightly imo.
He has other sources of income like the awful adverts. He’s only covering TM for a few weeks. It’s not his livelihood.
BrozTito · 12/08/2021 23:35

People are still trying to say this isnt racist? Its basic stuff which we did training on in my minimum wage job. The racist shit on here just gets worse. Eammon has always been a moron. See also his 5G comments.

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 23:34

Unaware you are saying racist and offensive things = smacks of institutionalised racism.

Eammon has had his day, week, year and decade and now seems really out of touch.

OP posts:
Whatnext2018 · 12/08/2021 23:33

@RobynNora What malicious comments has he made? You can truly, hand on heart, believe he was intentionally being racist?
Wow.

workshy44 · 12/08/2021 23:33

Whatever way you look at it what he said was outrageous, it was deeply offensive. Whether he should lose his job and be “cancelled” is another matter really. To take away someone’s livelihood is a big deal and shouldn’t be done lightly imo.

Swipe left for the next trending thread