Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now

365 replies

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 20:14

He's always been a chubby misogynist with questionable.comments to make about his wife but now he has compared a woman's afro hair to the fur on an alpaca. Has the world gone completely bloody mad? How come he still has that job? And, no, the 'I have old fashioned northern Irish charm' act doesn't make up for it. I for one am certainly not feeling charmed! I have no idea how Ruth puts up with him tbh.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MostlyNormalSometimesOdd · 13/08/2021 06:57

@Sparklingbrook

This is what he posted on Twitter

Hey everyone out there. if my attempt at being humorous with my friend
@DrZoeWilliams
was misjudged I am mortified and humbly apologise to anyone who was offended

Oh come on, he was joking, can’t anyone take a joke nowadays.

I’m pretty sure Eamon will see the funny side when I joke that he’s a first class prick

BatshitCrazyWoman · 13/08/2021 06:07

Can't stand the man. Ruth is lovely, no idea what she sees in him.

polkadotpjs · 13/08/2021 05:49

@Clocktopus

It’s a scary world we’re living in now, frightened to do or say anything.

Don't do or say racist things and you'll be fine.

Yup. Don't be racist. Simple
Heiferr · 13/08/2021 04:00

@Snoozer11 In America, she's generally deemed as black.

Heiferr · 13/08/2021 03:55

Some of you are so committed to your refusal to acknowledge that racism is more than just the N word that it's actually laughable.

Are people forgetting that in the wake of the absolute shit show that was 2020, we had every single company under the sun posting black squares and/or pledging their commitment to eradicating racism in their organisation? Did this not include ITV? Is ITV not his employer?

It is utter infantilising bullshit to suggest that he didn't know any better or it wasn't intentional or just "banter". He is a grown man in a professional setting who knows better. The "educate him" argument is crap too. For a start, nobody is obligated to educate anyone but here on this very thread we have multiple people literally spelling out in the clearest possible way why his comments have been rooted in racism yet there is post after post pushing back on what's being said. We are in the age of information and Google is free. At this point, much of this lack of understanding about what's racist is just wilful ignorance as far as I'm concerned. The "education" people claim to be so desperate for is literally everywhere.

Heiferr · 13/08/2021 03:41

Those defending his use of the word Uppity as not having racist connotations because of the difference between the UK and the USA seem to be forgetting that the woman he was describing is from the USA.

He knew exactly what he was doing.

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 13/08/2021 02:35

Interesting, why

I only learned last year that watermelons and fried chickens can be racist. I had no idea. None.

Just as my American neighbours had no idea about sectarianism. They grew up in a place steeped in racism, we kicked the shit out of each other over religion.

They don't see the flute or orange as oppressive tools in the way I do. And I was oblivious about their discomfort over my KFC and vodka filled watermelon.

What that combo showed was I was common, not racist.

whythooo · 13/08/2021 02:16

@Doublestar but who is suggesting that? Confused

It's not about religiously checking online every morning at 7am to see if there are any new words with racist connotations.

At best it's about being aware and at the least it's about 'I didn't know but now I know'.

Last year there were hundreds of articles online about all of this after the massive drive to 'educate yourself' about every day racism, systemic or structural racism and becoming anti-racist. You'd basically have to only ever use the internet for Mumsnet to have missed it. (Because MN is this strange bubble of the internet where apparently none of that happened and even if it did it doesn't apply to us Brits because didn't you know we're not America and we don't have a racism problem?).

I had no idea that in eenie meanie, it wasn't always Tiggers they were catching. And now I do. Do I know if it's offensive over in the UK when we apparently used Tiger before it was replaced with a racist word and then replaced again with a bouncy disney character? Not really. And I'm not going to spend time trawling the internet over it because I don't even use it so it's a waste of time (for me).

But if I did use it, and someone said it had negative connotations and could offend people then I'd apologise, and I'd stop.

Just like I wouldn't call a gay man a fag even though a fag in the UK is a cigarette because I know it's an American slur.

Fag and uppity are probably good examples to compare. The difference is that "fag" went from Britain to America (and eventually became a cigarette here while eventually becoming a gay slur there) whereas "uppity" came from America to Britain and eventually became associated with a racial slur there.

And to like, hammer home the point, I don't think anyone expects everyone to be an expert on every single word. But I don't think it's a bad thing to stop doing or saying something completely inconsequential to you if it hurts or offends or negatively impacts a minority group? It's not chopping of your own arm or losing half your wages - it's basic respect to another human being and it boggles my mind why some people are so completely against wanting to do this?

stripedbananas · 13/08/2021 01:51

He lost a really well paid job on morning tv because he demanded more money.

The vain, greedy, entitled man was already on £450K a year but he decided he deserved more.

Oh how we all laughed when they called his
Bluff and didn't renew his contract. Grin

stripedbananas · 13/08/2021 01:47

I agree he really needs to go.

He's a liability and an embarrassment.

I don't mind him as a presenter but you just can't make silly slip ups like this.

It just means he's not properly prepared or aware of how things are in the current climate.

It's unacceptable to say things like this to someone. If he doesn't realise this then he can not be on live tv anymore

Doublestar · 13/08/2021 01:34

Do people not know that the same word can be used differently (and sometimes even have a different meaning) in different countries? Can you not for once show a little respect and stop the navel gazing for a minute? The 'educating' brigade is intrusive and massively overbearing

Yes, maybe there should just be a list of words posted on billboards for everyone to read which a certain group of people (no one knows who these people are or why they are elected but we must obey if they say this list of words is offensive. Coz someone, somewhere is offended by it) No one can question or refute this otherwise you are a (insert word of their choice) the list is added to daily and we must check it at intervals to ensure nobody offends anybody, anywhere, ever.

I think it's best we just wear gags at all times, then there's nothing to worry about.

That is until they devise a mind-reading device....

FrenchCovidInfo · 13/08/2021 01:30

Do people not know that the same word can be used differently (and sometimes even have a different meaning) in different countries? Can you not for once show a little respect and stop the navel gazing for a minute? The 'educating' brigade is intrusive and massively overbearing

If someone told me that something I said was considered to be racist, I'd listen. That's it. I wouldn't hang on to my God-given right to use a word, regardless of its impact and/or associations. I'd just use a different word, one that wasn't considered to be racist by millions of people, even if those people weren't the ones that I live alongside every day.

And with that, I'm off to bed!

RobynNora · 13/08/2021 01:27

@mustlovegin who knows what Eamonn Holmes meant. None of us are in his mind (thankfully haha)

But ok, assuming he had no idea of the collocation, it’s not a great thing for a white man to describe a black woman as ‘above her station’ or someone with airs. Even without the n word to follow it, it doesn’t look great.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 01:26

And this is the salient point - to learn something and move on

Who has the global ownership of words and dictionaries? Who can dictate what words can and can't mean?

Snoozer11 · 13/08/2021 01:23

[quote RobynNora]@EnidSpyton Maybe it was a super unfortunate coincidence that he chose this unusual word to describe a black American woman and he had no idea of the massively racist collocation, but it raised a red flag because a hell of a lot of us do know what it means and he has form for making dodgy comments![/quote]
Meghan Markle is mixed race, not black.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 01:20

But it's not intrinsically associated with segregation in Britain, because segregation never existed here. Why would this word be widely used in this context in Britain, when, as I have said before, the specific circumstances that gave rise to the connotation never existed in this country? Expecting people in one country to know the culturally specific connotations of a word in a different country is a little unreasonable

^This, a zillion times

Do people not know that the same word can be used differently (and sometimes even have a different meaning) in different countries? Can you not for once show a little respect and stop the navel gazing for a minute? The 'educating' brigade is intrusive and massively overbearing

FrenchCovidInfo · 13/08/2021 01:17

Snowflakes I tell you. Fucking woke brigade. Ruining things for racists everywhere since the day the first tweeter tweeted

I need a like button ^

whythooo · 13/08/2021 01:10

I'm white as can be and even I have amassed the skills to play bingo on this thread, particularly with a certain posters comments.

no way was he trying to intentionally be racist

it was another silly comment, that he doesn’t stop to think about

no malice behind it.

Here we have: he's not racist he's just stupid. Because a grown man, with all the money and resources he has, is apparently incapable of reading a couple of articles online, or a book, or using google.

Typically leads to...

He needs to be educated

Or he could, you know, recognise he's a grown adult and educate himself?

If he's so stupid why is he in a job like that? Surely in a country of 60+ million people, there must be at least someone who is just as talented and yet not quite as stupid.

I'm sure we could even find one with an accent.

You can truly, hand on heart, believe he was intentionally being racist?

The idea that any sort of racism is only racism if it's intentional.

Does that apply to everything else, yes?

Truly Judge, hand on heart, I didn't intend to kill her when I got in my car drunk, drove through a red light and knocked her over.

Please.

I didn’t even see the racist element, does that make me racist too?

My absolute fave! I love these Grin shoving in a plank in your own eye to prove your own ignorance because you somehow believe it will save the racist from removing a splinter from their own.

"But I don't get offended when people insult my long, thick, shiny, balayage blonde hair!"

It’s a scary world we’re living in now, frightened to do or say anything.

Will somebody, somewhere, please think of the children and their right to grow up in a world where they can be offensive to anyone they choose?!

Next thing you know, they'll be coming for baba black sheep and our SKIN TONE plasters.

Snowflakes I tell you. Fucking woke brigade. Ruining things for racists everywhere since the day the first tweeter tweeted.

RobynNora · 13/08/2021 01:10

@EnidSpyton Maybe it was a super unfortunate coincidence that he chose this unusual word to describe a black American woman and he had no idea of the massively racist collocation, but it raised a red flag because a hell of a lot of us do know what it means and he has form for making dodgy comments!

FrenchCovidInfo · 13/08/2021 01:04

Of course, now I know the connotation, I will be very cautious in my usage of it and am grateful for the education. But I don't agree that it's commonly known to be a racist slur in the UK, and just as I have been educated this evening, I would hope those who have immediately taken offence at the use of the word would pause for a moment to likewise be educated by the comments of those on this thread who have genuinely not known the connotation before

I agree to a point. And this is the salient point - to learn something and move on. It's the people who announce that they will continue to knowingly use a racist term/word that are the problem.

EnidSpyton · 13/08/2021 00:58

@FrenchCovidInfo

Don't think this was meant to be deemed as racist

Irrelevant though, since it was, in fact, racist. It's not the first time, as detailed upthread.

*People use the word uppity to describe someone stuck up or who thinks themselves better than others"

Specifically, black people, for millions of racists, for many, many years.

So I personally will continue to use it as I see fit, thanks. Its pretty entitled to tell people they can't use a descriptive word from the English dictionary to describe someone who is, you know, uppity, as it offends them personally

Knowing that a word is intrinsically associated with segregation, and has been used for decades as a word specifically referring to black people 'getting above their station,' and yet you are determined to carry on using it, speaks volumes.

If you're happy for some people to think that you're chucking around a racist reference, crack on. But some people will then think that you're racist, because some words carry the weight of history with them.

But that doesn't bother you. So there we are.

But it's not intrinsically associated with segregation in Britain, because segregation never existed here. Why would this word be widely used in this context in Britain, when, as I have said before, the specific circumstances that gave rise to the connotation never existed in this country? Expecting people in one country to know the culturally specific connotations of a word in a different country is a little unreasonable.

I'm 35 years old and very well read. I had never been aware of uppity as having racist connotations before this evening. I've just checked my dictionary and it makes no reference to this connotation in the definition.

Of course, now I know the connotation, I will be very cautious in my usage of it and am grateful for the education. But I don't agree that it's commonly known to be a racist slur in the UK, and just as I have been educated this evening, I would hope those who have immediately taken offence at the use of the word would pause for a moment to likewise be educated by the comments of those on this thread who have genuinely not known the connotation before. Rather than jumping straight to accusations of racism, let's have some awareness that the word's racist connotations are not as obvious to everyone as some people may have previously thought.

RobynNora · 13/08/2021 00:56

@Doublestar since I’m quoted here, I’ll respond. No frothing here. I remember asking my other half at the time and he was unsure of the racist connotations so I can accept plenty of people don’t know. Never said otherwise.

Still think Eamonn is a racist though and I won’t turn a blind eye to racist behaviour because that makes me complicit. Check out his rant about Meghan Markle. He’s the one you’d describe as frothing - he’s seething with rage and it’s unsettling to watch. That, coupled with numerous other comments detailed here tells me all I need to know.

lollipoprainbow · 13/08/2021 00:55

I can imagine Ruth gave him a good talking to after the show, I sometimes wonder what she really thinks of his behavior. He cuts across her a lot and interrupts her, she grins and bears it but she she doesn't seem the sort of woman to put up with that to be honest. That said, I love them and wish they would present full time, I sense he might have burned his bridges there though, bet Ruth is fuming!!

IncessantNameChanger · 13/08/2021 00:52

I'm not sure anyone would enjoy bring told on live TV that their hair resembles a alpaca would be great banter.

It's just plain rude. If it wasnt in live national TV and she retorted with "at least I have still have all my hair" and they both fell about laughing then maybe he could say it's just banter between friends. It's like your boss making sexist comments and you laughing whilst thinking what a dick as the boss has the upper hand.

It doesnt matter. If its offensive then its offensive.

It's not about how the giver feels. It's about the receiver feels.

It's not ok to override those feelings because you feel you know better.

But generally who says someone looks like a animal on live TV? Who would enjoy being told that? Honestly? You pick holes in people and say it's a just a laugh as it amuses you. It's not ever about how the other person might feel.

Hey Sue! Your long hair looks like a horses tail! And then we all cracked up.......

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 13/08/2021 00:51

Err uppity absolutely does have racist connotations, it does not just mean posh! You really should take this information on board, its ok to not know something, but when someone tells you that something is racist, you really should listen to them. Otherwise you risk looking foolish at best, or racist. But if you don't care about that, well that says a lot about you.