Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now

365 replies

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 20:14

He's always been a chubby misogynist with questionable.comments to make about his wife but now he has compared a woman's afro hair to the fur on an alpaca. Has the world gone completely bloody mad? How come he still has that job? And, no, the 'I have old fashioned northern Irish charm' act doesn't make up for it. I for one am certainly not feeling charmed! I have no idea how Ruth puts up with him tbh.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ttcsucks · 13/08/2021 18:42

Anyone STILL struggling to understand this situation and the issues with it, Dr Zoe has personally responded on her Instagram in the most beautifully worded piece.

I will take the time to post because she sums up the point I think many posters have been trying to make including myself throughout the thread very well, perfectly in fact;

To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now
To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now
To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now
Sparklingbrook · 13/08/2021 16:33

@littlebilliie

He always seems bored and truculent
Yes! Like he's just doing you a favour even being there, as if it's all a bit below him really.
littlebilliie · 13/08/2021 16:26

He always seems bored and truculent

itsallaboutschmoo · 13/08/2021 16:18

@Clocktopus

Black people: "This was really offensive and racist"

White people: "Ah, it's just bantz"

Black people: "Look, this is the explanation of why it is racist"

White people: "That's not racist, it's just a joke"

Little hint - if Black people are telling you that certain comments/phrases/actions are racist, maybe listen to them seeing as they're the ones on the receiving end of it!?

It's like short sighted racist bingo isn't it:
  • oh but he's really nice. Check
  • he didn't mean it- banter! Check
  • how is [insert term I could've googled] even racist? Check
  • the world's too PC/cancel culture Check
  • Example of how they (a white person) experienced someone commenting on their hair and didn't find it offensive. Check.

Can't believe people don't hear themselves. DP is mixed and deals with comments on her hair ALL the time. Most are innocuous but it's exhausting for her. She doesn't want to discuss how often she washes it, whether she's ever straightened it, what it looked like when she was a baby all the damn time.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 15:45

Ruth is stunning, articulate, polished, well-mannered, poised and a good presenter. She should definitely be on TV

Christinayangtwistedsister · 13/08/2021 15:33

[quote Whatnext2018]@Christinayangtwistedsister Are you implying I’m racist too?!

I honestly believe it was his clumsy, thoughtless humour and had no malice behind it and definitely not of a racist nature.

Don’t forget, if they take them off air, which would be a shame imo, we’d be stuck with P & H, both awful people, not nice at all, R & E are genuine, good people, seems unfair.[/quote]
How do you know that they are genuine, good people???

MeadowBrown · 13/08/2021 14:38

I have been educated, never fear. So I don't really understand why you're taking issue with me over this. I never use the word uppity in general parlance anyway!

I wasn't taking issue with you, I promise EnidSpyton I was putting forward a different pov.

And fwiw, I think it is splitting hairs when people say that people living off the profits of slavery isn't as bad as actually having slaves as there was suffering involved in both. But I am no expert.

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 13/08/2021 14:37

He is clumsy and thoughtless but he’s also arrogant and speaks over people, he is quite an entitled man and I don’t think any of those are excuses for what he said. There was no need to mention her hair let alone call it what he did. There is no defence. Certainly not banter, too many people cover their racist remarks with ‘banter’ and ‘jokes’ because they are too thick to actually have a laugh without it being at other peoples expense. He should go, allowing him to stay is basically saying it’s ok to make thoughtless racist comments because it’s banter or a joke.

Sparklingbrook · 13/08/2021 14:36

I don't see how H&P are any more awful than E&R TBH. But I don't know any of them personally.

Whatnext2018 · 13/08/2021 14:25

@Christinayangtwistedsister Are you implying I’m racist too?!

I honestly believe it was his clumsy, thoughtless humour and had no malice behind it and definitely not of a racist nature.

Don’t forget, if they take them off air, which would be a shame imo, we’d be stuck with P & H, both awful people, not nice at all, R & E are genuine, good people, seems unfair.

debbrianna · 13/08/2021 14:16

@Nicolastuffedone

What’s Dr Zoe saying about it?
Her comment about "don't touch my hair" should have indicated to you exactly how she felt. Perfect response. Those who understood her knew what she meant. Those who didn't, I font think they should bother if they can't Google why she would say that. She meant it either metaphorically or physically or politically. All apply. Don't touch a black woman's hair. I
PollyPepper · 13/08/2021 14:15

@PercyPigAndMe

Not aware of these comments or the context but just to add another view .. I met Eamonn some years ago at a specific award ceremony. And he was absolutely lovely. Genuinely interested in the people receiving the awards, wanting to know the ins and outs of it all and staying well over his allotted time as he wanted to talk to everyone. And nope, this wasn't something he was paid for and wasn't televised or anything

So I can only speak as I found him. And I found him genuinely nice.

Well I worked with him for three years and he was an absolute prick scuttles off
LimitIsUp · 13/08/2021 14:07

[quote ttcsucks]@Cam2020 it is a word that was used in slavery times by white southerners in US to describe a black person being above their station.
[/quote]
I think the vast majority of people would not be aware of the origins of that word ('uppity') but thank you for sharing that - it's good to learn

LimitIsUp · 13/08/2021 14:02

He may not have intended racism, but it was nevertheless racism - unwitting or otherwise. He has made other ill considered remarks (as referenced on this thread) If he can't get to grips with current socially mores and opinions, he needs to retire

AdelindSchade · 13/08/2021 13:30

Google suggests that uppity is originally from American English. So any use in British English would apoear to have been appropriated from Americans if this is correct. It is a strange old fashioned word to use. I think until this thread I could count on one hand the times I have heard it used.

mustlovegin · 13/08/2021 13:23

A word's meaning and its connotation are entirely different things

The English language was created in England by the English. It's extremely brazen, out of line, and downright offensive to suggest that we are no longer allowed to use a word because it was appropriated by someone else.

EnidSpyton is making a lot of sense

Felix125 · 13/08/2021 13:05

The pair of them (Aamon & Ruth) are like a real life Alan Patridge. So glad they were replaced by Rylan & Alison on the show.

He made a comment to a guest once (I think she was an author) "If your book doesn't do well you should be able to get a job as a model with your looks"

Madness

Deadringer · 13/08/2021 12:46

I have only watched this programme a few times and while his manner with Ruth is a bit cringey i always thought it was just banter, i know couples like this irl and they get on great. But i saw them on Catchphrase and i thought he was awful, criticising Ruth and scoring points off her the whole time. I didn't see the show in question and am white Irish so i don't feel qualified to comment on it, but i do want to say that Holmes didn't say to a rape victim 'i hope you learned your lesson', he actually said 'i hope you get a taxi next time'. which was disgraceful, and he was rightly castigated for it afterwards. I am not a fan but i think its unfair to misquote him.

EnidSpyton · 13/08/2021 12:44

@NoNotMeNoSiree

I simply don't agree that the word uppity is intrinsically seen as having racist connotations in British English. This thread is proof of the fact that many British people had no idea it had racist connotations at all.

Yes, but just because a lot of people have no idea it has racist connotations, doesn't mean it isn;t.
In fact it shows us up as being woefully uneducated!
There's a difference in yourself, who upon knowng it does have racist connotations, says that now you know of course you wouldn't use it towards someone who is black, and others on the thread who have been like "nope, it's still not, or nope, it hasn't been "explained" , and it's not racist, it's just bantz," or that they'll keep using it as they still don't see a problem,

Absolutely. Once you know there's no excuse.

I'm a bit embarrassed that I didn't know, to be honest. I even lived in the US in my youth for a long period of time and had genuinely never come across it.

NoNotMeNoSiree · 13/08/2021 12:40

I simply don't agree that the word uppity is intrinsically seen as having racist connotations in British English. This thread is proof of the fact that many British people had no idea it had racist connotations at all.

Yes, but just because a lot of people have no idea it has racist connotations, doesn't mean it isn;t.
In fact it shows us up as being woefully uneducated!
There's a difference in yourself, who upon knowng it does have racist connotations, says that now you know of course you wouldn't use it towards someone who is black, and others on the thread who have been like "nope, it's still not, or nope, it hasn't been "explained" , and it's not racist, it's just bantz," or that they'll keep using it as they still don't see a problem,

EnidSpyton · 13/08/2021 12:34

@MeadowBrown

EnidSpyton I am white so hesitating to comment , but I do work with words and know that some words that once were seen as acceptable no longer are once their connations and origins become known. Surely you understand that?

And I don't think you can so easily separate the UK and US experience of slavery when many of our historic buildings are constructed on its profits. Ever been to Lancaster? All of the major civic stone buildings there were built on the profits of cotton and gold, gleaned off the back of hideous suffering. Have a look at the English Heritage document "Slavery and the British Country House". Yes, some stately homes are linked to abolition, but many are linked to slavery itself or the profits of slavery.

Yes of course I do understand that. I simply don't agree that the word uppity is intrinsically seen as having racist connotations in British English. This thread is proof of the fact that many British people had no idea it had racist connotations at all. I have already stated repeatedly that I would - now I know the US connotation - never use the word to describe a person of colour. I have been educated, never fear. So I don't really understand why you're taking issue with me over this. I never use the word uppity in general parlance anyway!

I am fully aware of the legacy of slavery in the UK and its evidence in our built environment, thanks. I have read the English Heritage document with some interest, several months ago. I have taught whole units on the legacy of slavery within English Literature to my students. I work next door to a building with a blue plaque to a slave trader on it! I do get this. However I don't see that slavery being a state in which Black American people lived for generations and that was experienced by most Black American people's immediate ancestors in the same country in which they currently live is comparable to the experience of living alongside buildings being built from the proceeds of slavery.

I think it's important to respect the different historical experiences of Black people and not bandy about generalisations that all Black people live under a traumatic legacy of slavery. It perpetuates a narrative of Black = victim which is surely something we should be fighting against rather than continually reinforcing.

I'm not saying, and nor do I believe that Britain had no role in the slave trade and that racism is not an issue in our country. I am not ignorant. What I am saying is that US and UK lived experience of slavery is very different and as such cultural references to slavery and Blackness do not transfer as easily between our two countries as many posters seem to claim.

NoNotMeNoSiree · 13/08/2021 12:32

They ‘already explained’ it, at the time I was asking the question. Do you really think I would ask the question if it had been answered?
I call people uppity, I am unaware of any racial connotations

Oh right, I see.
In that case I apologise for taking your comment in good faith.
I thought you actually were asking for an explanation, but your use of quotation marks and the rest of your comment says it all.
As you were then.

ChequerBoard · 13/08/2021 12:24

[quote Summerbreeze4]@Hugolugo I think it’s his style of humour, yes it would be rude to say he looks like a hairy wombat, yes it’s rude saying someone’s hair looks like an alpaca, a poster above said a colleague had said she looked like a poodle because she had left her hair curly. If someone said to a black person with curly hair that they looked like a poodle would that be racist or just rude?. Blurring rudeness to a black person with racism isn’t helpful. I think he has different ‘banter’ towards women and doubt he would have said that to a man but I think we need to be careful to always default to racism to explain inappropriate behaviour.[/quote]

I'm at loss to understand what it is about E that make so people excuse his frankly abhorrent behaviour.

Come on, it's not funny it's just rude, obnoxious and yes it is plainly racist. If you can't see it, perhaps you need to check your own prejudices.

Roussette · 13/08/2021 12:21

I wouldn't even say to my best friend of 50 years that her hair looks like an alpaca. And we continually josh with each other.

He's rude. He's not funny.

NoNotMeNoSiree · 13/08/2021 12:21

If someone said to a black person with curly hair that they looked like a poodle would that be racist or just rude

Racist and rude.
Even if you were to say it and not think it as racist, doesn't mean it isn't.
It just means you're ignorant/naive/privileged as well.
Seeing as you've never had to think about it too much before, whereas black people have.
Upon which I'd be looking at educating myself, instead of doubling down and saying something like "but it's not, it was just bantz" or whatever (not aimed at anyone in particular, just those with that attitude in general)

Swipe left for the next trending thread