Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Eammon Holmes needs to go now

365 replies

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 20:14

He's always been a chubby misogynist with questionable.comments to make about his wife but now he has compared a woman's afro hair to the fur on an alpaca. Has the world gone completely bloody mad? How come he still has that job? And, no, the 'I have old fashioned northern Irish charm' act doesn't make up for it. I for one am certainly not feeling charmed! I have no idea how Ruth puts up with him tbh.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Sparklingbrook · 12/08/2021 23:33

@mustlovegin

He has apologised. These constant requests for cancelling people are worrying, frankly
He’s apologised but he doesn’t seem to learn from his mistakes. So he’ll be apologising about something else soon.
Christinayangtwistedsister · 12/08/2021 23:32

How could he have possibly have thought this was acceptable?

RobynNora · 12/08/2021 23:32

@Whatnext2018 I’d like to believe that but there have now been too many malicious comments about black women. Why does he keep attacking black women? Racism.

Banter is a poor excuse and if he’s not aware of the power dynamics of an extremely wealthy white man criticising a black woman’s hair (to the point where she’s so uncomfortable she must tell him) then I don’t believe he’s a good man in any case, If he’s unaware of the politics surrounding black women’s hair, he must be living under a rock or extremely stupid.

mustlovegin · 12/08/2021 23:31

He has apologised. These constant requests for cancelling people are worrying, frankly

Sweetchocolatecandy · 12/08/2021 23:30

I think his comments were completely unacceptable and it is just me or is he ALWAYS interrupting Ruth? He also comes across as quite judgemental whenever they are interviewing people on the show. I think he has had his day and it’s time he steps down.

Cocopogo · 12/08/2021 23:30

Agree he should have been sacked ages ago. It’s irrelevant whether there was internet or not as someone in his position/power to reach so many should not be so inept. If I was so crap at my job, despite my good intentions, I’d be fired and rightly so.

PicsInRed · 12/08/2021 23:29

Phil & Holly are a very different story.
I feel sorry for them as they’re likely upset by this tonight

I feel sorry for the professional woman who suffered racist "bantz" on live tv with a direct comparison of her appearance to an alpaca.

Isn't it instructive how people are empathising with Eamon, Ruth, even peripheral figures such as Phil and Holly, but not at all for the Dr who was the actual victim today? 🤔

Themeparklover · 12/08/2021 23:25

I have to agree I always find him quite awkward to watch and Ruth is far more engaging , I think he should probably step down soon and Ruth move to loose women or similar

toocold54 · 12/08/2021 23:25

I don’t watch this morning very often but I’ve seen Dr Zoe with her natural heir several times on the show and he’s never commented on it so he obviously doesn’t think she normally looks like a llama.
Similar to if someone had a mohawk you could say they looked like a peacock.

Black people have to deal with subliminal racism all the time regarding their hair so it is ok if someone is offended by his comment and he has rightly apologised.
But I don’t think it was malicious and I don’t think he should be sacked over it. I was unaware that ‘uppity’ was racist too, so I think there’s a big difference between intentionally being racist or deeming and saying words maliciously.

Whatnext2018 · 12/08/2021 23:20

Can’t believe some of the comments on this thread, no way was he trying to intentionally be racist, it was another silly comment, that he doesn’t stop to think about, no malice behind it.
I personally really like both of them and talk of him having to lose his job is just mean, if there was intent behind the things he said, then yes, I really don’t believe there is.
I know several friends of friends who have met/worked with them and say they are both such lovely, genuine people.
Phil & Holly are a very different story.
I feel sorry for them as they’re likely upset by this tonight

TowandaForever · 12/08/2021 23:20

I thought he'd been separated from his first wife for ages before he met Ruth?

Thought he hadn't got divorced because of his Catholicism?

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:20

Black people: "This was really offensive and racist"

White people: "Ah, it's just bantz"

Black people: "Look, this is the explanation of why it is racist"

White people: "That's not racist, it's just a joke"

Little hint - if Black people are telling you that certain comments/phrases/actions are racist, maybe listen to them seeing as they're the ones on the receiving end of it!?

Hugolugo · 12/08/2021 23:14

I mentioned the northern Irish accent because I know that some people find regional accents around the uk charming and the n irish accent is seen to be charming and calming and friendly etc. My initial point was that the charming accent doesn't distract me, or many others, from the fact that he says offensive things that someone in his position, with his reach and the opportunities that come with that, on his money etc should just not be saying.

I also later made a point that Eammon seems to be very personal with his comments to guests so would make a comment to someone, say from n Ireland, about n ireland and possibly it would be offensive, such is his very 'playful' and 'hilarious' and 'non-bullying' 'sorry if you misunderstood my humour, old chum' banter. If he were to read this thread, I hope he would find the bowling ball comment equally as 'funny' as it was meant in the same spirit of 'banter' and if he were to misunderstand me and take it as offensive, I'm sure he would realise I just meant he was a fat old man. Basically.

OP posts:
DaisyWaldron · 12/08/2021 23:11

I'm Northern Irish and there are plenty of things that English people say about us that are pretty offensive (jokes about bombs and terrorism, jokes about being stupid, jokes about being alcoholic, jokes about potatoes/the potato famine, comments about glib charm, comments about how strange/horrible/"naughty boy" common Irish names are etc) but commenting that people like Eammon Holmes' accent doesn't fall into that category.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/08/2021 23:09

They are both vile. But powerful... for now.

Powerful?Confused Are we talking about the same Eamon and Ruth @BustyDusty?GrinGrinGrin

PicsInRed · 12/08/2021 23:06

He left his wife and three kids for Langsford.

Of course he did. Of course.

Well, they sound lovely. What's going on with that show anyway? Bit of a low empathy zone isn't it, across the board?

Dontwatchfootball · 12/08/2021 23:06

@Catlover77 - Uppity was commonly used in the southern US to describe people not being subservient enough to the white population. Usually followed by racist epithets. So now you cannot claim to be unaware of the racist connotations of this term.

VladmirsPoutine · 12/08/2021 23:05

Eamon is a very good demonstration of apparent benign whiteness at work. Except it's not actually benign is it. It's harmful and abusive.

ttcsucks · 12/08/2021 23:04

@QueenB5

Calling someone northern Irish is fact, comparing someone to an alpaca is not a fact it's an offensive nasty thing to say - and racially insensitive.

How is referring to someone's nationality the same thing?

QueenB5 · 12/08/2021 23:00

The fact he is Northern Irish has been mentioned a few times. Is that offensive? I’m asking honestly as it seems certain things are racist and other things aren’t. Also for reference one of my daughters has long golden blonde hair that flows past her bottom, elderly people and more people who do not have her hair colour naturally in their cultures love to touch it. I just assumed it was because they found it unusual.

ttcsucks · 12/08/2021 22:57

@Hugolugo

Unsure33 Boris's hair needs brushing and cutting. No one compares Boris to a wild animal in a live interview but if they have it would still be a different issue. White privilege...
Exactly this. Boris purely has 'messy hair' that's it - he's not told he looks like an animal. Ever. In fact I don't think I've ever heard a white person compared to an animal.

Only black people seem to get these comparisons.

It's as if history lessons never existed for some people.

Winter2020 · 12/08/2021 22:57

I was watching today and thought "oh god no" when Eammon made his comment. It was unacceptable/rude/awkward for everybody - and of course for the lady his comment was directed at. Yes he should be given a warning by his channel, he should apologise to the lady concerned (privately in my opinion) and apologise to his wife and his general apology to the public should be sincere but I don't agree we should be sacking people, or bullying people "cancelling people" for saying something stupid that they immediately regret.

Catlover77 · 12/08/2021 22:56

[quote NoNotMeNoSiree]@catlover77 someone on the thread has already explained how it is racist to call somebody black uppity.
I usually quite like Eammon, but Shock at the hair comment, really no need.[/quote]
They ‘already explained’ it, at the time I was asking the question. Do you really think I would ask the question if it had been answered?

I call people uppity, I am unaware of any racial connotations

Dontwatchfootball · 12/08/2021 22:56

@QueenB5

If he said I had frizzy hair, what would that make him? A bit too honest for his own good but not racist. Instead tarring him with the ‘racist’ brush, perhaps educate him that his remarks are insensitive but without wanting him sacked for a flippant comment.

He can be a bit cheeky to Ruth but she keeps him in line, I’d rather watch them than everything being so PC in case anyone finds offence that the show becomes scripted and the funny live moments are a thing of the past due to someone being offended 🤷🏼‍♀️

Do you really not think people can be funny without being misogynistic and racist?
WellTidy · 12/08/2021 22:55

@Chocolatier9 thanks - it is a shame that it wasn’t picked up on. Maybe it would be now? So many comments have (rightly), but a fuller picture is always best.