Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable for wanting to tell you about being Caucasian?

115 replies

DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 18:47

Inspired by another thread I just responded to, I thought I would start this one.

So, do you think I'm being unreasonable for wanting to tell you about what it means to be Caucasian?

The reason I want to tell you about it is because when most people hear the term 'Caucasian' their thoughts most often go to a dark place. White supremacy. Racism. But reality is, Caucasians are not "white". "White" being someone of, say, Germanic, Scandinavian or Anglo-Saxon heritage. For those that might know this, there is a rather large region in Central Asia called the Caucasus. It consists of countries like Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan, but also lots of regions in what we know as Russia. People that originate from the Caucasus - such as myself - we are called Caucasians. The reason why I want to tell people about the Caucasus and Caucasian people is because I feel like our name is being misused so much, and almost always in negative contexts. I shouldn't have to be worried about offending someone by telling them I'm Caucasian. Just because, in their mind, a Caucasian must be a white supremacist.

I really hope that even one person might read this thread might think twice about their reaction next time they meet someone that tells them they are Caucasian. Because some of us genuinely are Caucasians, and very proud of our ancient heritage, our culture and our history. We do not want to be associated with racism, superiority of any kind, or anything else that's negative and so far away from us / who we are.

Thank you for reading...

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 12/08/2021 21:16

@dreamingbohemian

I know quite a few people from the Caucasus and I've never heard any of them call themselves Caucasian.

They say I'm Georgian, Armenian, Chechen, etc.

Caucasian is not very specific, why wouldn't you just say where you're from? Especially because the word does have a twisted meaning here.

Same here.

I’ve never heard someone describe themselves as Caucasian, and I’ve never heard anyone use the term to mean white people outside of police dramas.

Where are you that this is a big issue OP? In what circumstances is it arising as a problem?

brokenbiscuitsx · 12/08/2021 21:11

@Lovinghannah

Also I would never associate the term Caucasian with white supremacy.
Nor would I. I just associate it with police identification if anything Blush
DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 21:11

@znaika

I am Russian. I know what you mean as I come from a minority nationality and not technically a slav, normally I just say russian as that it what is in my passport (but not my passport iykwim😅)
See, so you get it =D It's the same reason I just say I'm Caucasian. I'm quite mixed so it's easier to just say Caucasian than to say my exact ethnicty. To then have to explain exactly where it is and what we are. I don't mind doing that in certain settings, but in most contexts it's just tideous for every party involved.
OP posts:
DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 21:09

@StColumbofNavron

Good thread OP. I am Turkish so have grown up knowing about the Caucasus and Cherkez (amongst other ethnicities). In the UK I would probably say I am Cherkez from Turkey/Armenia/Azerbaijan or wherever. I think in a English it’s Circassian that might be more recognisable that Cherkez.
Thanks for your input and for your advice =D As a Turk I can imagine you must indeed have a quite vast knowledge of Caucasus. After all, Caucasians and Turks have a lot in common and are to some extent neighbours =)
OP posts:
znaika · 12/08/2021 21:07

I am Russian. I know what you mean as I come from a minority nationality and not technically a slav, normally I just say russian as that it what is in my passport (but not my passport iykwim😅)

DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 21:06

@GlutenFreeGingerCake

This is why the White Russian cocktail of Vodka, Kahlua and cream is also known as a Caucasian. Someone on a Facebook thread about cocktails actually got a ban warning for saying they hated White Russians, which we thought was funny.
That made me laugh =D People can be so ridiculous...
OP posts:
DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 21:05

@eurochick

You say you are not in the uk so maybe the white supremacy baggage is particular to the place where you are, rather than a general thing.
It seems like it at this point, yes =D
OP posts:
DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 21:04

@znaika

I echo what Dreaming says. You are right to say that the term Causcasian is frequently misused in N America. But I jave never once heard someone call themselves a Caucasian. It would be like saying Balkanite or Alpine, people normally use their nationality
Sure, I agree. But some of don't have a nationality and ethnicty that match...
OP posts:
55378OO8 · 12/08/2021 21:01

Thanks for this thread, I have always been confused about why the term 'Caucasian' is used as a synonym for white. I don't think the term is commonly used in the UK though, I have only heard it on American police drama TV shows. I didn't know it had connotations of white supremacy either.

StColumbofNavron · 12/08/2021 20:49

Good thread OP. I am Turkish so have grown up knowing about the Caucasus and Cherkez (amongst other ethnicities). In the UK I would probably say I am Cherkez from Turkey/Armenia/Azerbaijan or wherever. I think in a English it’s Circassian that might be more recognisable that Cherkez.

GlutenFreeGingerCake · 12/08/2021 20:47

This is why the White Russian cocktail of Vodka, Kahlua and cream is also known as a Caucasian. Someone on a Facebook thread about cocktails actually got a ban warning for saying they hated White Russians, which we thought was funny.

eurochick · 12/08/2021 20:47

You say you are not in the uk so maybe the white supremacy baggage is particular to the place where you are, rather than a general thing.

DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 20:43

@onelittlefrog

I also don't link the term "Caucasian" with white supremacy. This is a very odd thread.
Did you read it? I was essentially trying to explain and clarify what a Caucasian is, because the term gets used too often in wrong contexts, and to describe the wrong groups of people. That's all =)
OP posts:
DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 20:41

Also glad to hear so many of you haven't heard term Caucasian being used in racist contexts as much as I sadly have. Gives me hope =)

OP posts:
onelittlefrog · 12/08/2021 20:39

I also don't link the term "Caucasian" with white supremacy. This is a very odd thread.

DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 20:39

@RandomLondoner

All I can say that those that associate Caucasianess with pale skin, blue eyes and blonde hair are in the wrong.

I recently watched something that claimed ancient Greeks recognised three races, White, Black and Yellow, where by "Yellow" they meant nordic European types with blonde hair and blue eyes.

Also, the first European explorers to go to the Far East considered Chinese and Japanese people to be "white", the word "yellow" to describe them was a historically recent racist invention. (I tend to agree with those explorers, most of the Chinese people I've met, and I've had reason to meet a few, are as pale or paler than many white Europeans.)

So I guess I agree that "white" is not that well-defined.

Thanks a lot for sharing, I had no idea about this. But glad to hear the term "white" is as undefined to me as it is to other. Even those from the past =)
OP posts:
znaika · 12/08/2021 20:39

I echo what Dreaming says. You are right to say that the term Causcasian is frequently misused in N America. But I jave never once heard someone call themselves a Caucasian. It would be like saying Balkanite or Alpine, people normally use their nationality

Needapoodle · 12/08/2021 20:33

I thought caucasian meant white/pale skinned european descent so interesting thread thanks! I've learnt something.

eurochick · 12/08/2021 20:27

I'm a bit puzzled by this thread. I've never heard of Caucasian being used in relation to white supremacy (Aryan, yes). In fact I've only heard it used in American film and TV as a synonym for "white". Which might be inaccurate but doesn't come with the baggage the OP is suggesting.

Like others on this thread I've always wondered why Americans use the name of one region for all white people, most of whole won't be from that region. 🤷‍♀️

RandomLondoner · 12/08/2021 20:25

All I can say that those that associate Caucasianess with pale skin, blue eyes and blonde hair are in the wrong.

I recently watched something that claimed ancient Greeks recognised three races, White, Black and Yellow, where by "Yellow" they meant nordic European types with blonde hair and blue eyes.

Also, the first European explorers to go to the Far East considered Chinese and Japanese people to be "white", the word "yellow" to describe them was a historically recent racist invention. (I tend to agree with those explorers, most of the Chinese people I've met, and I've had reason to meet a few, are as pale or paler than many white Europeans.)

So I guess I agree that "white" is not that well-defined.

PicsInRed · 12/08/2021 20:20

ConfusedHmmGrin

DelphineMarineaux · 12/08/2021 20:18

@dreamingbohemian

I see what you mean but then I would just say I'm from the Caucasus (instead of I'm Caucasian)

You would be Cherkessian from the Caucasus (instead of Caucasian)

It's a small change but it makes a huge difference, especially in the US. I would not advise going to the US and saying you're Caucasian.

Thanks for the tip. I'm not a native English speaker and in the country I live in it's very common to say what one's ethnicity is rather than where one is from. But I'll definitely keep your suggestion in mind for when I travel to the US and if people there ask me what I am =D I'll just say I'm from Caucasus instead of saying I'm Caucasian. But I still think it's sad that I should have to 'hide' or not speak of being Caucasian...
OP posts:
rottd · 12/08/2021 20:16

I understand your point, caucasian is often used as a catch all term for white as opposed to where some people come from.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 12/08/2021 20:13

I first heard it in a very simplistic kids' textbook as a synonym for white. Another here who has never heard it used in any kind of white supremacy context.

I'm never really sure about the lines drawn around groups of people anyway. The 2010 US census ended up trialing a box for white, black and Latino/Hispanic with "check all that apply", and the option Hispanic people ticked varied (many living in the US near the Mexican border ticked white as a "strategy"). But you will never hear cops in the US describe someone who looks like they may be from Mexico as white, or an Afro-Latin American person as anything but black.

TinyTroubleMaker · 12/08/2021 20:11

*expect not exist
Bloody spellcheck tonight

Swipe left for the next trending thread