Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying for GCSE results

110 replies

Lilyargin · 12/08/2021 16:47

Some of my DD's (16) friends' parents are giving their children £50 for each 9 they get, £20 for each 8, £10 for each 7 and £5 for each 6.
Am I alone in feeling that you shouldn't put monetary value on academic success; that it de-values the real joy which is in the pride of the achievement by reducing it to a pay per grade transaction?
Or am I just mean? Grin

OP posts:
noangel1811 · 12/08/2021 23:31

I just read this to my 15 year old ds he said if Im willing but match these he will work harder to get better scores 😂 my son has suffered with his mental health for the last 18 months, self harming and refusing to go to school. He is on counselling to and has been much better for the last 3 months so in our circumstances I don’t think I would mind offering him these incentives to get better grades as it will probably encourage him to go into school more too. But I can definitely see it from both sides. A year ago I wouldn’t have been in a position financially to be able to do this

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 12/08/2021 23:21

I did not offer any incentive to my child. Just a whole lot of nagging about how important it was.
She got a 4, a 6 and a load of 5’s…which for her was an excellent result. I had to go out after we’d picked her results up this morning. I returned with a brand new laptop as a present for her - to help her a level studies.

We rewarded the effort she’d put in off her own back (after my nagging Grin )

LEMtheoriginal · 12/08/2021 23:15

Got DDs results today. She smashed it and i couldn't be more proud. Her reward was an impromptu day out and oh, the small matter of a place in 6th form doing her chosen subjects. Oh and i went on a roller coaster with her despite being terrified Grin she said laughing at my shreiking and swearing all the way round was her best reward! Bugger Grin

therocinante · 12/08/2021 23:09

I was a lazy bastard who got all 9 A*s and 3 As. My sister, who worked her arse off, got Cs, Ds, and one B.

That system would just have rewarded me for being good at exams and clever, while she would have been (comparatively) penalised for being less academic, while being MUCH harder working.

Seems like a stupid system to me. But maybe I'm just bitter I didn't get £450...

hernamewas · 12/08/2021 22:59

I was offered a LOT more than this and still got failed them all. It doesn't change anything just do what works for your family and don't worry about others.

AlexaShutUp · 12/08/2021 22:56

I’m guessing you haven’t had problems with her motivation! It’s easy when you don’t have the issue in the first place.

No, but I have been mindful of the importance of intrinsic motivation since she was tiny. Never did rewards or punishments of any sort.

Bagamoyo1 · 12/08/2021 22:53

@AlexaShutUp

No, I wouldn't ever do this. I think it's better for kids to find their own motivation.

DD got straight 9s today. The reward is in how happy she feels. That's enough.

I’m guessing you haven’t had problems with her motivation! It’s easy when you don’t have the issue in the first place.
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 12/08/2021 22:17

I think it depends on why they're not performing to potential. If they're lazy but capable or capable but scared to try a cash incentive might help. Some people will never be motivated by intrinsics of getting a good grade, so extrinsic motivation might be best. As an adult at work they're are sometimes extrinsic motivation to work harder like, praise, bonuses, promotions.

If DC are hard working, but are only ever going to get so so grades or not pass due to cognitive delays or SEN then rewarding outcomes would be unfair and demotivating. Id prefer to reward effort if anything, but if my DC needed an extrinsic reward to achieve their potential I'd consider it.

EIRA3 · 12/08/2021 22:07

18 years ago when I did my GCSEs my uncle did this for me. My parents were low earners we didn't have much. I started to withdraw from school and couldn't b bothered really!
He said if I put my head down and worked hard he would pay me £100 A* £80A and so on. So I started year 11 went to every lesson, did extra too (best attendance ever) and ended up doing really well, to the shock of everyone! But he paid me and I was so happy that I achieved the results I had, and the financial incentive really pushed me and I am so grateful Smile
My son is 13 I will do the same for him come yr11 just to help in anyway I can.

AlexaShutUp · 12/08/2021 22:05

No, I wouldn't ever do this. I think it's better for kids to find their own motivation.

DD got straight 9s today. The reward is in how happy she feels. That's enough.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 12/08/2021 22:00

@CluelessAt50

I hope this isn't happening everywhere. A lot of parents (especially lone mothers) can't afford it & it'll have a big affect on the self worth of those parents & children. On the bright side though, I'd happily put money on which group (the financially rewarded/motivated vs not) will be the happiest adults.
Upto individual parents. No different than bonuses from work.
Still1nLove · 12/08/2021 21:54

What a great idea. My dd is going into year 10 and has no drive to work towards her academic success. Dancing, that’s a different matter, she will work day and night for the perfect performance. I have explained the importance of her grades, emphasising how important it will be for future decisions on college and career. She has taken this on board and has upped her maths and been moved into the ‘higher’ class (it helped her understand how applying herself, just a little bit more, makes a difference).

Now I’ve read this thread, I’m going to offer financial incentives for higher gcse results. It can’t hurt, so why not? I have a little time to save, and I’ll give her the money (in a savings account to be used sensibly), regardless of what she achieves, as long as she has worked hard.

Thanks @Lilyargin

Rumplestrumpet · 12/08/2021 21:54

(to be clear, I would never do it for my kids!)

Rumplestrumpet · 12/08/2021 21:54

My dad did this for my older brother as he wasn't working at all and my dad was terrified he wouldn't get any GCSEs. I don't know if it incentivised him but he passed them all so maybe it did?

Problem was I came a few years behind and expected the same - but was a straight A student ! When I told him my GCSE results I started off with "Sorry dad, you can pay me in installments" Grin

Titsywoo · 12/08/2021 21:49

No I haven't done it for my DD. She did very well today and got a nice takeaway of her choice this evening. She is happy enough with the results there was no need to bribe her. Saying that my lazy DS would probably do better if I paid him (he does his in 2 years) so I won't say never!

CasparBloomberg · 12/08/2021 21:39

When DS told us his friends were going to get loads of money for their GCSE results, we told him he could have £1 for every grade (so £9 for a 9 etc). He wasn’t impressed but accepted that it meant he’d be able to have a little to mark the occasion.

We didn’t want it to matter that much what the grade was, as there was only a few pounds in it.

He has worked hard anyway and got great results today so we’ve upped that a bit as a reward, but the extra money is to be used to open a savings account that he will start putting some of his pt job money into. He’s really happy with that bonus.

I see nothing wrong with wanting to reward and celebrate their successes and it’s down to parents to decide what they think will motivate or help their child most.

thelastgoldeneagle · 12/08/2021 21:37

We have our dd a gift for the amount of effort she put in, not her results!

Imapotato · 12/08/2021 21:31

There’s no way ever I would reward grade with differing cash amounts.

Dd1 has just got her results and down very well. Dd2 is able enough, but not as academic as dd1. She already feels like she is living a bit in her shadow going to the same school, so to add monetary value to grade would be awful for her.

Dd1 got some news trainers she’d been eyeing up before results came out, just for working hard and we went out for dinner this evening. I think that’s more than enough tbh.

mne13 · 12/08/2021 21:26

I transferred my DS £50 this morning before we collected his results it didn't matter to me what his grades were, I've literally dragged him through every year of school since nursery as he hated it!
The results were great but the reward was more for his determination for the last couple of months!
Some of his mates have had £100's of pounds!

minionsrule · 12/08/2021 21:25

My ds got his results today.
We never promised or suggested money per grade but we will be giving him a cash bonus for doing so well. I think promising cash for grades can go the wrong way, if they don't get the grades its a double whammy.
Ds doesn't know about any bonus yet so hopefully will be a nice added surprise for him

bonbonours · 12/08/2021 21:20

Totally agree with rewarding the effort not the achievement. If you have one child who is naturally academic but lazy, and one who is not particularly academic but hard working the latter might put in more work but get less high grades.

Maybe some sort of incentive based on achieving or exceeding their predicted grades would be fairer.

burnoutbabe · 12/08/2021 21:16

My parents did this for me 30 years ago!

And I reminded mum if it 3 years ago when I did another gcse and scored another £20 then.

Happy days!

lazylinguist · 12/08/2021 21:14

YANBU. We bought dd a present for doing well in her GCSEs but she wasn't expecting a present, so it wasn't a bribe!

Disrespected · 12/08/2021 21:13

My ds isn't acedemic hates all learning he's predicted 3s and 4s for next year. His mocks he had 2 failed. Even though he tried his best. One he missed by 1 mark!
Hell still get a meal out and maybe a small gift either way next year. Because I know he tries!

iloverunningslow · 12/08/2021 21:11

My parents did this for GCSEs. All of us kids went on to get good a-levels, degrees and professional careers. We have four postgraduate qualifications between three of us. I wouldn't agree it's demotivating if done right - the reward needs to be a celebration of success which is already expected rather than simply a bribe.
I also had an employer who paid £250 bonus every time you passed an exam they wanted you to take. Everyone taking that course was doing it to further their career and make more money, not just for the love of learning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread