Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think phone appointments aren't always convenient?

108 replies

TheGenealogist · 12/08/2021 15:03

I need to speak to the GP, menopause related. They do not run a specific menopause clinic, cannot see the nurse as she is unable to prescribe, should it be decided I try HRT.

Phone surgery, telephone appointments only. They can offer me Wednesday morning, any time between 9 and 1. Have already arranged to see a friend on Wednesday for coffee. They can offer me Thursday morning, when I volunteer in a charity shop.

Now I know I am very much not being U by not wanting to discuss my hot flushes, recurrent UTIs and other symptoms in front of my volunteer colleagues, or all of the customers in the cafe.

If phone appointments are here to stay, why are they not being offered in slots? Even half an hour? Because yes I could do after 11am on Wednesday, but no.

Must be a nightmare for people in open plan offices or other roles where you can't just step away to take a call in private.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MercyBooth · 13/08/2021 20:33

8 to 6 or between 9 and 1 is not an appointment, is a time window at best. It is misusing English to call that an appointment, and if at all possible should be challenged

Which is exactly what i do with my HA because this is what they do with the gas safety check "appointments"

WouldBeGood · 13/08/2021 20:03

But how does one know if something is non urgent without being “seen” by a doctor?

It could push back significantly things like the two week urgent referral to a consultant, if that still even exists.

It’s precisely because of this nonsense that there is such pressure on emergency medical services.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/08/2021 19:52

fucking hell. Three weeks
Maybe should have fitted in the first appointment offered around the coffee morning?

privateandnhsgp · 13/08/2021 15:36

Well your wait is commensurate with the amount of your tax that goes to primary care (£150 per year regardless of how much you consult or should we say are able to consult) and the prevailing conditions in healthcare.

Personally I think they should scrap free at the point of (ab)use primary care and have either a co-pay French type system or alternatively something similar to Australia. But it will end up costing more than now, for sure.

TheGenealogist · 13/08/2021 15:24

Non-urgent as in not serious enough that i'm in my bed. Or likely to deteriorate to the state that I need A&E. That doesn't mean it's some wee minor thing that can wait THREE WEEKS.

We all know GPs are working hard. Well, most of of them. But it's not OK to expect patients to be grateful for getting appointments three weeks in the future! It's not good enough.

No idea where the blame lies, probably with everyone who thinks the NHS is a sacred cow never to be criticised.

OP posts:
privateandnhsgp · 13/08/2021 12:52

So a consult for a non-urgent issue is in just under 3 weeks in the middle of a pandemic when it is widely publicised that services are under significant pressures both in terms of staffing (pinging, a chronic doctor shortage etc) and in terms of demand (with most practices reporting a 15-30pc bump in demand since the beginning of the year). And in a narrow time slot like you wanted.

You seem really outraged by this. What were you expecting.

TheGenealogist · 13/08/2021 10:09

Just phoned back as instructed by the woman on the phone yesterday.

The FIRST appointment for a call they can give me is 1ST SEPTEMBER. 3 weeks away. Narrower window of between 9am and 10am but fucking hell. Three weeks.

Agree with others who posted that it seems like the NHS is just not fit for purpose.

OP posts:
Heatherjayne1972 · 13/08/2021 09:18

I wouldn’t be able to take a call between 8-2pm on a weekday

And no I’m not discussing my private medical problems while I’ve got a patient sat in my dental chair with my hands in their mouth listening
I’d get in a lot of trouble for that

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 13/08/2021 09:13

If you had a F2F appt, presumably you'd have to take the time off work to go, OP, so I don't see any reason why you shouldn't take the time off to have a phone consult

With a F2F appointment you have a fixed time. I can take that time off. I cannot take the whole day off to wait fir them.,

Stoolpigeon21 · 13/08/2021 09:11

If you had a F2F appt, presumably you'd have to take the time off work to go, OP, so I don't see any reason why you shouldn't take the time off to have a phone consult

I am a teacher - in normal times, I would make an appointment for first thing in the morning or as late as possible to minimise the inconvenience to my school. My GP offer a call ‘at some point today” .To have to take whole day off for a 10 minute appointment is ludicrous.

In addition, I have elderly parents and telephone appointments are a nightmare. Both parents are very deaf and do not always hear what is being said on the phone, although neither of them will admit to this. I was at their house recently with my father, who has Parkinsons, had a telephone call with his Greek consultant. The combination of my father’s poor hearing and very poor processing of language combined with the consultant’s strong accent made the conversation almost impossible. Had I not been present, the consultant would have been given completely incorrect information as my father did not understand what he was being asked.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 13/08/2021 09:11

That’s only convenient for them. I’m working from home, I cannot sit and wait fur a call that can come at any time.

ZenNudist · 13/08/2021 09:08

I Don't mind phone appointments but not instead of being seen if it really needs to be looked at.

I had this with ds. I work and can be in a call which several people will have coordinated diaries to speak to me so I can't just drop out. A slot even a 2 hour window can be blocked out but I can't just hold the whole day.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 13/08/2021 08:53

Abraxan the "European model" isn't that - in Germany it's 15.5% of your income for state health insurance, and the state pays if you're unemployed, and children and stay at home spouses are insured with the main earner at no extra cost. So its effectively from each according to their ability to each according to their needs.

There used to be a 10€ fee for the first appointment of the quarter (so never more than 40€ per year whether you had four appointments per year or fourty) but the charge was scrapped years ago as the administration was more expensive than the amount gathered in charges, and it was considered unfair.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 13/08/2021 08:49

Halloaten I wonder why its only so difficult for the NHS. In Germany we have face to face appointments which are pretty much on time, give or take half an hour sometimes, and never wait more than a day or two unless we want a very specific time (a non urgent appointment for a child, avoiding school hours and their sports training times, might be booked for late afternoon in three weeks time but that's ok - an appointment important enough to miss school for is same day almost always).

Abraxan · 13/08/2021 08:42

@FrippEnos

OverByYer The whole NHS needs a complete overhaul and cross party review. I’d suggest nominal fees to see a GP for a start like the European model.

So if we went with the "nominal fees to see a GP" would you also be happy for the GP to pay a penalty for late or cancelled appointments?

So people with long term health issues end up paying a ton of money to maintain their health?

This only works surely if there is a special rate for ongoing health issues or affordable health insurance including for those with long term disabilities or health conditions.

I'm fortunate that I could afford it as I have to see someone at the surgery at least 4 or 5 times a year, sometimes much more, for ongoing health conditions.

But if someone didn't have the money are they then left to suffer???

MaryBoBary · 13/08/2021 08:39

I completely agree, there should be set appointment times. It's very inconvenient to have a call any time in a 4 hour window. It's also unprofessional to need to keep your phone on you all morning in case of a call from the dr. IMO they all need to pull their fingers out and organise themselves. It's embarrassing what a shambles getting a dr appointment is now.

Abraxan · 13/08/2021 08:35

If you had a F2F appt, presumably you'd have to take the time off work to go, OP, so I don't see any reason why you shouldn't take the time off to have a phone consult.

Yes, but no more than an hour usually. And I have some say over times so always had them either:

  • first thing in the morning at 8:30am - less likely to be as late and can usually still be at work by 9
  • after 3:30/4 when I can then leave early or just as school finishes
  • linked to a free lesson, my PPA time or next to a break/lunch time so time missed was minimal.

With f2f I never need to take a full day, ir even a full half day off to attend a doctors appointment unless I was ill enough to be off on sick leave.

Shellfishblastard · 13/08/2021 08:33

I quite like the telephone triage appointments - my GP is excellent and I’ve spoken to her about anxiety over the phone during the pandemic and I felt quite comfortable.

However, agree it should be an appointment time. We are given an appointment time and told it will be as close to this as possible, just as it would be if you were physically in the surgery.

Tablow · 13/08/2021 08:31

We have an online form and then you get a call back at a random time. I've had to do a few of these for DC and they ALWAYS phone when I'm driving. By the time I've parked up safely to take the call they've stopped calling and won't take a call back.

The whole thing is set up to prove we don't need primary care and can manage with apps, an algorithm and a call centre.

Abraxan · 13/08/2021 08:25

Whilst I find phone appointments a good idea for some issues and could work great, I don't agree with the current system we have in place here. If they are to stay we need proper time slots, not a vague anytime between 9am and 6pm, or if pushed any time in morning/afternoon.
Our GPS will call twice, but within about 10 minutes if each call. But if you miss it you can't call back etc. You have to start all over again the next day.

I teach and can't have my phone on me. I can't leave class to answer a call. Not all medical appointments warrant me taking a day off work as sick leave.

Like with in person appointments I need a time slot.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/08/2021 08:22

How do we know its "non urgent?"
Because the OP prioritises going for a coffee FFS
currently going through an e-consult process for a gynae problem - when calls come through I excuse myself from the office and take them.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/08/2021 08:18

you've been offered two slots - if you want to prioritise coffee, and are not able to say at the start of your volunteering shift that you'll need to take a call from your GP somewhere quiet, then maybe you'll have to wait a bit longer - down to you to decide priorities.
Breaking a coffee meetup or 10 minutes out of your volunteering shift sounds a lot more convenient than a trip to the surgery

TheGenealogist · 13/08/2021 08:17

@fatvegan

You're going for coffee - cancel it. You volunteer - then ask someone to cover you for a few mins while you take the call.

How lucky for you that you have time to volunteer and float about meeting friends for coffee. Try fitting in the phone appointments when you work full-time.

And that's just bloody rude.

Not going to start justifying myself, and my working patterns to anyone.

There are a million and one reasons why someone can't be available from 9am to 1pm on the offchance a call comes through. All are valid. Work is just one reason.

And besides, for someone working from home, taking a call at any point during the day might not be an issue.

OP posts:
cloudyrain · 13/08/2021 08:10

I had a phone appointment last week, after having filled in a long online form for why I wanted to 'see' a Dr. First I had a text saying I would be called at 9.15 so I cancelled my meeting to be ready (no call) I didn't ring the surgery as that would take at least half an hour. After lunch I got another text saying I would be called at 2.15, so again I cleared my diary, the call finally came in at just after 5, and the first thing the Dr ask was for me to tell him what my problem and symptoms were, I did ask if he had read all the information I had to submit for him to call me, he said yes but still wanted me to tell him, OK that was a way to waste 5 minutes, he then had no solution or plan just decided that I needed to get blood tests before they could think about what may be wrong and told me to google our local hospital that does them to find out how o book one, and that he was on holiday for 2 weeks but to book an appointment with one of his colleagues when I got the results.
So a day of skipped meetings, a wasteful call which fortunately I was at home for, then I had to work out how to book an appointment and then call the surgery to tell them I had done that and ask them what to do next.
I have now been given another telephone appointment in 2 weeks to discuss the results

Theunamedcat · 13/08/2021 08:06

@234Pepperplant

Slots would be easier, for you. Presumably not for the GP.

But in the current circumstances in healthcare and for a non urgent issue, I think the onus is on you to be a bit flexible and keep a morning free - you clearly do have spare daytime time if you’re meeting friends etc so you’re not in the circumstances of a full time teacher or something.

How do we know its "non urgent?" Most people are not doctors that is why they consult one there have been many times when I have been out and about functioning as normal and been a few points away from a thyroid storm one time the lab called my doctors to ask which hospital I was in as it only had the doctors details on it the doctor duly informed them I was actually at work I was seriously ill and didn't know
Swipe left for the next trending thread