Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to count DDs savings in the emergency savings fund

256 replies

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 13:37

We have an account for DD where money from her grandparents has gone into. As she is only 1, although it's in her name, we have full access to it. It's a separate account though with entirely her money and we don't touch it. I'm celebrating 'loosely' as after years of being in debt, we're not only debt free (apart from mortgage), but actually have some savings. I returned to work after mat leave 'full time' in February but used annual leave to complete a phased return until a few weeks ago and I was able to save on the nursery days we didn't need but obviously now we will be paying full time childcare and the bill will increase so I can still save, but a much lesser amount each month.
I'm very open with my sister and we've been supporting each other through our debt - savings journeys so I excitedly told her that after my pay day this month I will have officially reached my emergency savings goal so I can then focus what little savings I can now make for gradual upgrades to the house that I've been desperate to do but have ignored to focus on savings. I told her what the emergency savings was and she said she didn't think that was quite enough and I explained that if we had to, as a very last resort, we would have access to DDs savings too. She then told me that it was wrong to count her money towards my emergency savings goal because it was essentially stealing from her which I really don't agree with.
To be clear, we have sinking funds for birthdays, Christmas, annual expenses such as insurance, MOT, expected car repairs etc. So our savings are for genuine emergencies only and we would need to exhaust our own savings (which are literally 3 times larger than DDs) before we'd touch hers so we are talking some really significant emergency having happened here before we dip into them. Also, we're now paying nearly £900 a month in DDs childcare bill; we'll be able to save a lot more once we no longer have that to pay for and it is our intention to top both our emergency savings up as well as DDs savings up when we no longer have that to pay anyway so if we absolutely had to borrow the money from her, I'm certain we could repay it long before she turns 18 and will be getting it anyway. Is it really so wrong to say that in a genuine emergency I might borrow some of my daughter's money?

OP posts:
Soberanne · 12/08/2021 16:05

People on here are actually saying that a family struggling due to financial hardship should get into debt and potentially end up in a worst situation rather than borrow some money already available with no interest and no risk. Seriously .

Soberanne · 12/08/2021 16:01

@TeanupFlutter the OP never once said she would dip into it, shes using it as a last resort back up plan if her own income and savings dry up for whatever reasons.

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 12/08/2021 16:00

Take it if you need it, she’s one for goodness sake. Ignore the people on here saying otherwise.

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 15:58

@godmum56
I think it would be more honest to say. "If we got really totally stuck I would take the money and use it and consider it part of the family resource and tell her GP's that" which would still be wrong but more honest to them and to yourself....and yes I think you should take out a formal loan in preference to taking her money BECASUSE IT IS NOT YOURS

How is this different to what I've said? Did I ever say I wouldn't speak to my parents about it? Do you know if I have already? My parents know the money is in an account I can access. If they didn't trust me to keep it safe for her they wouldn't have given it to me for safe keeping in the first place and kept it aside for her. And FYI, if and when I have grandchildren and I was lucky enough to give my daughter a sum of money for them to safeguard for 18 years I absolutely would not be upset if she borrowed from it in the space of those 18 years providing it was for a genuine emergency. I am assuming every single one of you who would not be okay with touching a penny of DCs money no matter how destitute you are would feel the same way when the time came for you to be grandparents?

OP posts:
Soberanne · 12/08/2021 15:58

I cannot believe that people are suggesting that someone facing a crisis, getS into debt and take out loans with interest leading possibly to lead to further money issues rather than using money that is in a childs saving account. I really trully wish my life Had been as blessed as some of the posters on here.

TeanupFlutter · 12/08/2021 15:55

Your sister is right, it's not your money. Other people have given her that money and it's not yours to take. If you feel you may be tempted to dip into it when times are tight I would ask the grandparent to open an account for her and transfer it all there so that you don't have access.and then it's never in your mindset that it could be used in emergencies.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 12/08/2021 15:53

@AnonymousCheerleader

If borrowing money from your daughter was going to save you from homelessness, then use it. Otherwise, it shouldn't be counted as your savings, emergency or otherwise.

I never consider my son's money as ours.

My thoughts exactly. But I think if you touch it for lesser things it will become far too tempting, and you'll end up not replenishing it properly.
FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 12/08/2021 15:52

I used £2k of my kids savings to flee a deeply unhappy marriage with their dad. I'm not sorry and I am paying it back.

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 15:51

@user16395699
If that were true, why would it even be possible for me to take money out of the account in the first place? This is my DDs account in her name but I have the legal right to access it as I see fit as her legal guardian.
Not to mention all of the posters who have also pointed out that during a universal credit claim, DDs money would be counted and we would be expected to use it (which I didn't know and is a very interesting point so thank you to those that explained that). I'm not buying for one second that this is stealing and this is where Mumsnet turns particularly toxic at times. You can have a different opinion to someone and you can choose to make different decisions but it's not okay to accuse someone of committing a crime against their child with no proof to back that up. So get off that high horse there. I am in an extremely privileged position here and I know that! If you honestly cannot imagine a scenario where you would be so desperate for money that you needed to take money out of your child's account because you have explored every other option and there isn't one, then you really do need to check your privilege.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 12/08/2021 15:49
  1. You didn't put the money there
  2. Its not intended for you
therefore 3. Its not yours to use.

I am unconvinced, from experience, nothing personal, that it would get paid back....after all you are specifying a dire emergency and that you have zero funds yourself...its fatally easy to think "oh well shes 3/4/5 I have got 13/12/11 years to pay it back I don't need to start yet"

I think it would be more honest to say. "If we got really totally stuck I would take the money and use it and consider it part of the family resource and tell her GP's that" which would still be wrong but more honest to them and to yourself....and yes I think you should take out a formal loan in preference to taking her money BECASUSE IT IS NOT YOURS

Bellringer · 12/08/2021 15:49

You can borrow against your house

Bellringer · 12/08/2021 15:48

What basis was it given on, what do gp expect, what will dc think when older. Is it spending money or for uni, a car at 18, whatever?

Terhou · 12/08/2021 15:45

You can't claim to have reached your emergency savings goal if it includes your daughter's money. Keep saving so that the issue of using it doesn't arise.

Blackberrybunnet · 12/08/2021 15:44

"Emergency" is the key word here. You wouldn't be using the money unless it was really needed. What would the alternative be, and wouldn't that be putting your daughter at a disadvantage? You are the parents, and you get to decide what the money is used for until she is older. I'm with Sarahlou63 here.

user16395699 · 12/08/2021 15:43

You are holding that money in a bare trust for your daughter. If you take the money you are depriving her of assets and breaking the law.

So actually it does matter what other people think, because what you feel entitled to do is unlawful.

Loki01 · 12/08/2021 15:41

@Gettingmoretoast

I get the point a lot of people are making regarding I shouldn't even be thinking about it. (though I disagree strongly with the rational being because otherwise I might randomly decide that that new lamp is worth dipping into DDs savings for. That's down to the individual and I know myself and DH well enough to know that that would not happen. When we say it would only be for an emergency, we mean it would only be for an emergency.) But can you help what you think about? Doesn't it just happen.... My sister said she doesn't think I have enough and I should keep saving which I immediately know I'm not going to do. She says 'what if...' and my brain goes to, well if we had to, if we absolutely had to, we do have access to DDs money. I can't help that, that's where my brain went, it just happened. How do you force yourself to not even think something? And now that I have thought about it, it's up to me and DH to decide how we feel about this and whether we would actually do it or not in the very worst case scenario and I believe yes, we could and I feel okay about that. Many of you disagree and would not in your scenario. That's fine. It's interesting to see where everyone sits.
It's all just talk. Of course, they would dip into their savings rather than losing the house, etc. As long you are only using it when there is no other way, I don't see a problem.
Loki01 · 12/08/2021 15:38

@mam0918
F... off. When money is needed for an emergency is for the whole family. It is not stealing.
Some people.....

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 15:36

I get the point a lot of people are making regarding I shouldn't even be thinking about it. (though I disagree strongly with the rational being because otherwise I might randomly decide that that new lamp is worth dipping into DDs savings for. That's down to the individual and I know myself and DH well enough to know that that would not happen. When we say it would only be for an emergency, we mean it would only be for an emergency.)
But can you help what you think about? Doesn't it just happen....
My sister said she doesn't think I have enough and I should keep saving which I immediately know I'm not going to do. She says 'what if...' and my brain goes to, well if we had to, if we absolutely had to, we do have access to DDs money. I can't help that, that's where my brain went, it just happened. How do you force yourself to not even think something? And now that I have thought about it, it's up to me and DH to decide how we feel about this and whether we would actually do it or not in the very worst case scenario and I believe yes, we could and I feel okay about that. Many of you disagree and would not in your scenario. That's fine. It's interesting to see where everyone sits.

OP posts:
Loki01 · 12/08/2021 15:36

@Blossomtoes

You are bearing the costs of bringing her up and paying for everything

That’s kind of the definition of parenthood.

Yes, it is. I still don't see why she shouldn't be able to use the money if needed. Dont really get your point.
RainingChampions · 12/08/2021 15:31

If it was an absolute emergency, then yes I would use it. Sometimes things happen in life that you can't control/plan for.

conxray · 12/08/2021 15:31

I think it shouldn't count as the emergency savings funds.
So say you have 2K savings for emergencies and DD has 1K, your emergency fund is 2K not 3K.
It shouldn't be entering your head when totting up your savings.
Even considering it increases the likelihood of you using it.

Katela18 · 12/08/2021 15:28

My parents did do this with savings that were put aside for me and my brothers from an inheritance. The full amount was never paid back and we also lost out on a lot of interest which would have accrued, as they gave us the amount left in the account when we turned 18 and then topped up a bit from their current account. If the money had been sat in the savings account the whole time it would have accrued a reasonable amount of interest.

Though I (sort of) get your rationale, the money is not yours. You shouldn't even be thinking about it. It's a lot easier said than done to say you would just pay it back, more important things will always crop up.

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 15:27

@HoppingPavlova Happy to accept the nomination 🍆
Who knew that using 'DDs childcare bill' instead of 'my childcare bill' would lead to such an honour. I'm touched, truly.

OP posts:
mam0918 · 12/08/2021 15:26

@Loki01

YANBU. You are bearing the costs of bringing her up and paying for everything. If you need the money in an emergency, it is an emergency that includes your DD. My DS doesn't have any savings. I never got a penny for him from anyone, my parents never helped me with any money towards the wedding, house etc. I would love to save for him but can't as we bought a house and are making improvements. He is a capable person and will make his own money.
You are bearing the costs of bringing her up and paying for everything.

That is litrally your legal responsability as a parent, if you're too selfish to do that without thinking it entitles you to steal or finacially abuse others then you shouldnt have had kids.

ifonly4 · 12/08/2021 15:23

To my mind money put aside for your DD is totally for her benefit, so unless say needed a change to the house was because she had a disability, a more expensive holiday would be because it was specifically geared to her enjoyment, or you were struggling to feed/cloth her, needed it to support her education, then it shouldn't be touched.

Swipe left for the next trending thread