Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to count DDs savings in the emergency savings fund

256 replies

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 13:37

We have an account for DD where money from her grandparents has gone into. As she is only 1, although it's in her name, we have full access to it. It's a separate account though with entirely her money and we don't touch it. I'm celebrating 'loosely' as after years of being in debt, we're not only debt free (apart from mortgage), but actually have some savings. I returned to work after mat leave 'full time' in February but used annual leave to complete a phased return until a few weeks ago and I was able to save on the nursery days we didn't need but obviously now we will be paying full time childcare and the bill will increase so I can still save, but a much lesser amount each month.
I'm very open with my sister and we've been supporting each other through our debt - savings journeys so I excitedly told her that after my pay day this month I will have officially reached my emergency savings goal so I can then focus what little savings I can now make for gradual upgrades to the house that I've been desperate to do but have ignored to focus on savings. I told her what the emergency savings was and she said she didn't think that was quite enough and I explained that if we had to, as a very last resort, we would have access to DDs savings too. She then told me that it was wrong to count her money towards my emergency savings goal because it was essentially stealing from her which I really don't agree with.
To be clear, we have sinking funds for birthdays, Christmas, annual expenses such as insurance, MOT, expected car repairs etc. So our savings are for genuine emergencies only and we would need to exhaust our own savings (which are literally 3 times larger than DDs) before we'd touch hers so we are talking some really significant emergency having happened here before we dip into them. Also, we're now paying nearly £900 a month in DDs childcare bill; we'll be able to save a lot more once we no longer have that to pay for and it is our intention to top both our emergency savings up as well as DDs savings up when we no longer have that to pay anyway so if we absolutely had to borrow the money from her, I'm certain we could repay it long before she turns 18 and will be getting it anyway. Is it really so wrong to say that in a genuine emergency I might borrow some of my daughter's money?

OP posts:
topwings · 12/08/2021 18:36

YANBU.

To use a term that MN loves, all our money is "family money". Nobody has separate accounts; money is used for the good of the whole family as and when it is needed.

ChloeCrocodile · 12/08/2021 18:36

OP, I think this is one of those things where different people have different definition of “emergency”. Of course you would be right to use DDs money if the alternative is homelessness, inadequate food or no heating in winter etc. The fact that so many posters don’t seem to grasp what a real emergency is (ie one of these) simply demonstrates that many people on MN are far more financially secure that the average UK citizen. I just do not believe that any reasonable person would leave their child without proper food rather than use the DC’s money.

Well done on reaching debt free status and hitting your savings goals.

conxray · 12/08/2021 18:30

Yeah.... Probably. But that also kind of proved my point doesn't it. On one hand you want to say that it's the OP who has the issue because all it is is people give their 'reasoned' arguments.... But then perhaps if I wanted a 'reasonable' discussion I should have gone to a different page. So clearly AIBU is not a place to have a reasonable discussion then is it?! So I am indeed in the wrong place.

That was exactly my point. Buy you implied Mumsnet was the wrong place. It isn't. There are loads of boards which are really helpful and supportive.
You are in the wrong place on AIBU. But you are not in the wrong place on Mumsnet.

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 18:27

@conxray
You would have been better off posting in the money section if you wanted a reasonable discussion with others about this.

Yeah.... Probably. But that also kind of proved my point doesn't it. On one hand you want to say that it's the OP who has the issue because all it is is people give their 'reasoned' arguments.... But then perhaps if I wanted a 'reasonable' discussion I should have gone to a different page. So clearly AIBU is not a place to have a reasonable discussion then is it?! So I am indeed in the wrong place.

I assure you, I'm not flouncing off upset. I'm just bored of this now. I've heard enough of the reasonable posts with no new ones coming through but still plenty of people who want to take joy in telling someone how inferior they are because they make decisions that are different to them. And that's not just aimed at me as the OP; there are others on this thread who both would and have had to borrow savings from their DC and they don't deserve to be called thieves either by people who only want to view things from their point of view. And as soon as you do try to discuss from your point of view people will just accuse you of not liking how the thread has gone and make no further points to actually continue a discussion, just point out that they are clearly right, you're clearly wrong and you disagreeing is just you not liking being told that, as though it's fact and not just one opinion versus another!! 😂 Honestly, I've been a lurker long enough on Mumsnet, don't know why I thought it'd be possible to get people to engage any differently.

OP posts:
MurielSpriggs · 12/08/2021 18:20

You would have been better off posting in the money section if you wanted a reasonable discussion with others about this.

I'm not sure that would go any differently! From a purely "money" point of view there's not a shred of doubt that the money belongs to the child. The point of AIBU in that sort of situation is that sometimes people say: OK, maybe technically you're in the wrong, but from a "reasonableness" point of view you're ok. In this case the OP is wrong in both senses!

conxray · 12/08/2021 18:09

I don't think I'm in the right place

It's not all of Mumsnet which is like this.
You posted in AIBU.
A lot of the time posters get their ass handed to them on a plate. I would say the majority of AIBU OP's don't think they are being unreasonable. When they are told they are but don't want to accept this, the whole thing rapidly turns into a bunfight.
Pages and pages of people saying that the OP is unreasonable and giving reasoned arguments why this is a case but no, the OP doesn't accept this, accuses the whole of MUmsnet of being some kind of witches' coven and then flounces off.

That's not to say there aren't some really mean posters on AIBU who really want to stick the boot in because they are.

You would have been better off posting in the money section if you wanted a reasonable discussion with others about this.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 12/08/2021 18:06

“Really? So if the roof of your house caved in and you needed to use all of your savings to fix it but were a a bit shy, you'd rather take out a loan to cover that rather than borrow from your child's account with a view to repay plus interest somewhere in the next 16+ years before they are ever going to see that money anyway? Does that really not seem unnecessary to people?”

That’s what insurance is for!

HealthKick2021 · 12/08/2021 17:57

Yabu.

SunshineCake · 12/08/2021 17:55

My children are 16, 18 and 20 and I still have access to all their savings accounts. No way would I take a penny and we've put a lot of it in there!

user1493494961 · 12/08/2021 17:51

OP flounces off. (I don't think this thread has gone the way you expected it to).

Gettingmoretoast · 12/08/2021 17:41

I'm losing patience with Mumsnet to be honest. You try and have a genuinely nice discussion with people and actually do enjoy hearing the different options of other people but that is clearly not what a lot of people use this forum for. I respect other people's opinions; I don't respect people attacking others or essentially calling them bad parents or thieves based on a hypothetical situation where there cannot possibly be a definite right and wrong answer. I don't think I'm in the right place. Thank you to the nicer posts (and no, not just the posts that agree.... This will come as a shock to many of you but it is actually possible to disagree without being rude but I'm losing interest in hearing from you). Night all 👋

OP posts:
Ozanj · 12/08/2021 17:33

your focus should be on building up your emergency fund instead of focussing on whether you can steal your daughter’s money.

MrsMiddleMother · 12/08/2021 17:32

Of course you are being unreasonable. That's money gifted to your daughter, for your daughter. Most parents have savings accounts for their children that neither can withdraw from until they're 18 so wouldn't ever consider dipping into it. That's what savings are for, a 'hole in the roof' or a new boiler etc it's for emergency. If your daughters grandparents wanted to give you money for emergencies then they would, but they're not.

MyMummyHasGotABigBottom · 12/08/2021 17:28

I this is all v subjective anyway. This is on the basis that your sister doesn’t think your emergency fund is enough? If you do, then that’s all that matters.

We don’t count DDs savings in witb our main household pots, and generally wouldn’t touch them. But if it were to keep a roof over our heads in a dire emergency then of course they would be used and paid back in due course.

Soontobe60 · 12/08/2021 17:28

@Gettingmoretoast

Really? So if the roof of your house caved in and you needed to use all of your savings to fix it but were a a bit shy, you'd rather take out a loan to cover that rather than borrow from your child's account with a view to repay plus interest somewhere in the next 16+ years before they are ever going to see that money anyway? Does that really not seem unnecessary to people?
By spending your child’s savings, you’re depriving her of interest. My DDs had savings that grandparents contributed to. Even when we were struggling, we didn’t steal their money.
SealHouse · 12/08/2021 17:23

OP you started this thread and are getting some answers that you don't like, so now you're getting a bit narky and sarcastic. Maybe don't seek opinions from others if all you really want is people to tell you you're right.

nancydroo · 12/08/2021 17:14

Don't include your daughter's savings in your emergency fund. The risk is you'd be dipping in and out of it and mess up her interest etc.
We have savings for children and glad I can't touch them

Crabsy · 12/08/2021 17:11

I also love how many people are saying “I wouldn’t touch her savings in an emergency, I’d get a loan from the bank”.
It may come as a surprise to some people to learn that banks are only interested in lending you money when you already have money. When you’ve got nothing, and no income, they won’t touch you. And even if they will lend it to you, it can take weeks to arrange by which point you might be freezing/starving. Why do you think pawn shops and loan sharks exist?
I guess it depends on your definition of “an emergency”.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 12/08/2021 17:10

No way would I touch it and I have no savings at all. My dc gave around £4000 altogether from a family member. I put it in junior isas so couldn't touch it even if i wanted to

INeedNewShoes · 12/08/2021 17:09

You've done amazingly to pay off all your debt.

Things weren't great financially for me a couple of years ago but are much more comfortable now.

It has never once occurred to me to 'borrow' money from DD's savings, not even to buy stuff for her. I have an agreement with the people who are paying into it as to what they would like it to be spent on and I will stick to that.

If you'd get into the situation where you would need your DC's money that means your finances aren't predictable enough that you can be sure that you'd be able to pay the money back.

BiBabbles · 12/08/2021 17:09

I don't count any of my kids' savings or other accounts in our emergency pot. I track them separately in my finance sheet from all our other savings.

I get why you want to - it means you can save for other things sooner and still feel safe, but maybe it would be better to divide any savings between the two and grow both slower rather than counting on your child's savings as the ultimate back-up. It's easy to say you can repay when she's 1, but what if that emergency roof collapse happens at 10 or 15 when there is a likely a significantly bigger amount that could help and far less time to pay it back? If your goal is security, it's not really reasonable to rely on something that you know will eventually not be available to you.

I can't access my kids' savings, beyond what's in their little blue money boxes or otherwise in the house. They're all in accounts that don't allow that (and have never been counted in anything). Most kids' accounts I've seen either don't allow it or have a penalty for withdraws or after X number of withdraws, especially if it's a cash account with extra interest compared to an adult account so I'd double check the fine print on the account before counting it at all.

TractorsAndHeadphones · 12/08/2021 17:09

It’s rare to see a poster with as much grace and humour as you OP fending off the obsessives - well done!
Too many people getting het up over a stranger’s affairs. Or have never been poor before.

Absolutely - if it’s an emergency you’d be entitled to use it. As pp have mentioned it’s the counting it as part of the savings goal that has got people’s backs up but if you could survive on cutbacks for 6 months I’d consider it alright.

In any case - income protection insurance is a better idea than just relying on savings…

TeachesOfPeaches · 12/08/2021 17:06

What type of account is it that you have full access? Lots of parents get stung by opening accounts in their children's names and then finding out years later that only the child can access it.

Knittingupastorm · 12/08/2021 17:02

If I, as an adult, found out that my parents had dipped into savings for me in a dire emergency when I was a child, I really would not be able to be angry about that.
This is with the caveat that I know my parents are good with money, and therefore it would have been a serious emergency for them to need to - parents who spent all the money on crap and then couldn’t pay rent so took my money I’d be more annoyed at.

OaxacaChihuahua · 12/08/2021 17:02

If the account is in her name and it’s money which has come from someone else then it is stealing. That said, your baby needs a roof over her head so if those were the stakes it would be in her interest to use the money to provide for her basic care.

Swipe left for the next trending thread