Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Arguement about car seat safety

90 replies

PloddingAlongLikeABean · 12/08/2021 12:44

Sorry I didn't really know where to put this, but I would like to know who others think is being unreasonable. Because I really don't think I am.

I'm going back to work next week after mat leave. My mother has kindly offered to have LO couple days a week and that is absolutely wonderful.

But we've had a bit of a disagreement over car seats last night. She informed me that they had bought a car seat for their car so we don't have to be faffing with it in the mornings. Thought, wonderful that's a great idea. She showed it to me and I had to explain it wasn't a rear facing one and was pretty sure it was the law to have them in a rear facing? (Correct me if I'm wrong here but that's what I was told by HV). Needless to say, whether or not its the law, I said that LO is far too young to be facing forward if there is a accident etc.
She went on to say that it is from 9months of age and cost a lot of money and it is obviously safe or they wouldn't sell it.

Baby is 8 months old, is a small baby for age.

I tried to show her the guidelines but she wouldn't hear it and ended up quite awkward and upsetting.

This morning I have tried to broach the subject and say that we could perhaps look for one suitable in the meantime and then use the one they bought when LO gets to the recommended weight as opposed to recommended age.

She can't understand it from my point of view and I was hoping that if I asked on here and showed her what other people's views were that she may see it from the safety point of view?

OP posts:
Youcanchangeyournamebut · 12/08/2021 14:15

Honestly if she can't listen to you on safety issues, I wouldn't be leaving DC with her. It's pretty black and white: legally baby should not yet be forward facing, and from a safety point of view rear facing is considerably safer. It's nothing personal or ungrateful at all. If she can't see that on something this serious I think you're going to be having a lot of issues in future.

PloddingAlongLikeABean · 12/08/2021 14:13

It's nice to see that some of your LOs are still in rear facing at much older ages and bigger centiles. Im just wondering how their legs are positioned (ie crossed) I'm going to have a look online now to see if I can get a good car seat that will last but I can't figure out where LOs leg's will go? Blush

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 12/08/2021 14:12

An 8 month old shouldn’t be forward facing under any circumstances.

Take the seat back.

girlmama32 · 12/08/2021 14:10

We had this exact argument with my in-laws, they wouldn't listen even after I'd showed them all the evidence about why it was so dangerous and insisted on keeping the FF seat they had bought.
I told them she wouldn't be going in their car until she was old enough to FF in that case. Myself or DH drop her off and pick her up at theirs if they are having her now.
Car seat safety isn't something to take lightly and I don't understand why when the evidence is right in front of you someone would still choose to ignore it so you are 100% right to raise it with your mum.

Pythonesque · 12/08/2021 14:08

Double check it's not a seat that has two modes? The seat ours used from 1-3 did IIRC have a rear-facing mode although I didn't use it - mine are now late teens so extended rear-facing hadn't really become a thing when they were small. Also, they were never that small, grew out of that seat well and truly by 3.5 or so.

Hope you can come to a reasonable compromise, agree with everyone that a small 8 month old has to be rear-facing one way or another for at the very least several more months.

smashionaltreasure · 12/08/2021 13:57

Don't let her read the thread though, it's quite harsh

8dpwoah · 12/08/2021 13:53

The law depends on which seat she's bought too, there's twos ETA of safety standards running concurrently so 9 months might well not be possible if it's a newer seat (I think). If you can get the exact model and post on the equipment forum there are some incredibly knowledgeable people on there that will be able to tell you what you need to tell your mother.

Stick to your guns, it'll be her pride causing the difficulties and she'll get over it. It's too important to compromise on like we do with other grandparent things like that extra biscuit or slightly late bedtime.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 12/08/2021 13:51

If she's doing some childcare for you then I think it's worthwhile for you to buy a seat that your happy with, after all it will only a few weeks to have saved enough on childcare to cover the cost of the seat. She's frustrated because she thought she was doing the right thing, and it's not totally her fault, any capable shop assistant should have steered her in the direction of the safest possible seat.

If possible get her one of the rear-facing seats that spin, I have a Joie i-spin 360 for my granddaughter to save my back from pain. It stays rear-facing for quite a long time and then will last up to 19kg in the forward-facing mode.

Hercisback · 12/08/2021 13:50

Front facing at 8months isn't safe. Some parents choose to do it, but all the research shows RF is much safer in an accident.

I would absolutely say no car journeys.

My mum uses a FF with my big 18mo but she only does local short journeys on slow roads and it saves the hassle of getting the car seat in and out 6x per week.

EmbarrassingMama · 12/08/2021 13:50

No way. My 3 yo is still rear facing and I won't be turning him any time soon. YANBU.

To save it getting heated, could she return her seat and you buy a new one for her car?

2pinkginsplease · 12/08/2021 13:50

I’m a stickler for car seat safety and would rather find alternative childcare than put my child in danger.

My Inlaws weren’t very good with car seat safety and regularly took my nieces out in unsafe car seats or no car seat. Safe to say neither of mine were ever in their car!

ThousandCows · 12/08/2021 13:46

I believe the 'official' (govt? NHS?) advice is to rear-face until age 4 now. My 5 and 3yo are both rear-facing and will be until they exceed 25kg or get too tall for the seat. Ita a subject I feel very strongly about and can't really understand why anyone wouldn't RF their children after doing even the smallest bit of research internal decapitation, anyone?... But I'll get off my soapbox. I think ultimately your mum needs to respect your wishes on this.

Wjevtvha · 12/08/2021 13:45

At 8 months it’d be unsafe to be front facing and quite honestly ridiculous before they’re the right weight. Also if you want her rear facing for longer then they should go with that; I changed my older DD round at 18 months as I didn’t really know about extended rear facing and now with my son my in laws and DH are acting like it’s some silly thing that I’m insisting on as he’s 1 and I’ve bought an extended rear facing seat. It makes me slightly rage filled how they disregard the evidence but they’re keeping to it

bloodywhitecat · 12/08/2021 13:40

Will this article from the In Car Safety Centre help?

Hemingwaycat · 12/08/2021 13:40

My DS is almost 3 and he’s still rear facing, I’m keeping him that way until he’s at least 4 if I can.

Car safety isn’t something to fuck about with so I just wouldn’t let her drive your DC around unless she’s willing to change the car seat.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 12/08/2021 13:37

This is something I would fight on for sure!! We still rear face out almost 3 year old, and he's on the 95th centile!!

bloodywhitecat · 12/08/2021 13:35

I worked with a child who is now in a wheelchair and is tracheostomy dependant for breathing as a result of being a forward facing toddler in a single car RTC, no way would I forward face such a young child.

MonkeyPuddle · 12/08/2021 13:28

I would be questioning her as to why her hurt feelings are more important than her grandchild’s safety?

Because at the end of the day the thing that matter is the child’s safety, she needs to suck it up and move on like the adult she is.

This is absolutely a hill I would die on, no compromised at all.

stripesandyellow · 12/08/2021 13:27

We had no isofix and used a maxicosi Pebble until DC was too big (maybe 18m?), then got another RF seat that she used until she was gone five (she's nearly six and still not too heavy for it).

Can you buy a new one for the next few years and give DM the one you use now?

Just reiterate that guidance has changed - our DC was the only one RF that late and in-laws thought it odd, but respected what we said and DC knew no different.

modgepodge · 12/08/2021 13:27

Alternatively, if your mum won’t return the car seat she’s bought, to avoid switching seats around all the time you could buy whatever car seat you’re planning to buy next (presumably still rear facing), and use it straight away in your car, and give her the infant carrier to use. Then when your child outgrows the carrier they can use her one, by which point it will be a bit safer for them. The next stage seats are often advertised as being suitable from newborn, and whilst I wouldn’t use them with a newborn, they’ll be fine for an 8 month old. I’ve got the nuna rebl basq for example, which is a spinning seat, or the joie 360 is very similar.

Would still be better for your mum to get a rear facing toddler seat though, and she absolutely can’t use the FF one with a small 8 month old.

JustLyra · 12/08/2021 13:24

I’d stick to simple facts.

Rear-facing is considerably safer. It’s more likely that an accident will happen close to home or on a short journey (“we won’t be going far” is often used as an excuse/reason for not using car seats). Your daughter isn’t big enough for that seat.

Knowing those things why would your mother want to put your DD in it?

Habber · 12/08/2021 13:17

I had my kids donkeys years ago and RF them until they were about 2- 2.5as they were very small and only when their legs got too long did I turn them

PloddingAlongLikeABean · 12/08/2021 13:17

@memememe

Yes we still use the carrier one.

Might just be worth moving the car seats from car to car for a few months, it has an isofix with it so not that difficult to transfer.
Just feel a little bad because I understand she was just helping but car safety is just so important and I'm having difficulty letting anybody else drive LO around as it is.

@FluffMagnet
Ye she could return it, I think that's what upset her further and why she said I was ungrateful.

But got other people's views who don't know us so it wont put any family members in awkward situations now.

Thank you to everyone and I'm glad to see others have been in similar situation

OP posts:
Whatnexttoday · 12/08/2021 13:16

As your mum will be reading - my 3 year old is still rear facing and loves her seat. It spins and she is very comfy in it. She has regular appointments at a large children's hospital and her consultant there was really pleased she still rear faces.

GigantosaurusRex · 12/08/2021 13:14

My son rear faded until he was 5. Times have changed, cars have more powerful engines, there are a lot more of them on the road and we have more scientific data to show how much safer rear facing is. I consider good car seats (and childhood vaccinations for that matter) as an insurance policy. You can be fine every day without them but never know when you are going to need them.