Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housemate who secretly recorded us has been made a lecturer at UK university

334 replies

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 12:15

I cannot be unreasonable here. I wrote on here about two yrs ago about my housemate who hid a camera in our kitchen. He is now a lecturer at a London uni.

The police were not interested neither was landlady- I didn’t contact university and am now wondering should I?

OP posts:
SkinnyMirror · 12/08/2021 14:23

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

OP: "A man I lived with crossed a personal boundary, filmed us without consent and bow he's in a position of power with young people"

MN: "Stop trying to ruin his life you should be arrested" Hmm

I think you're projecting now. This is VERY different to what happened to you.
Hemingwaycat · 12/08/2021 14:23

Don’t really get this. Read your posts on the previous thread and still don’t get it. He set a camera up in the kitchen, why is that an issue? Were any of you naked or having sex in the kitchen? He must have had a reason to do this but I don’t think I could get worked up about it because nobody does anything remotely interesting in the kitchen. Did he think people were stealing his food or something? If he’d set one up in the bathroom or your bedroom then I’d get it but the kitchen? Nah.

CarlaH · 12/08/2021 14:23

Afraid not Flowers. Maybe it's my computer.

Kanaloa · 12/08/2021 14:20

I’m sorry, he filmed you while in the kitchen? Hmm I’m not sure. I think coupled with some of the other stuff you’ve said (wouldn’t pay the license, doesn’t clean up) it could come across that you just disliked him and you are using this as a sort of way to get back at him.

If I lived with a horrible roommate who refused to do any cleaning and wouldn’t pay relevant bills I wouldn’t stay ‘because he should be the one to move out.’ I’d leave and tell the landlord why, and explain he will lose more paying tenants if the house is dirty and people aren’t doing their share.

To sum up, I don’t think you can get someone sacked for filming you in the kitchen and being generally unpleasant.

Crazycrazylady · 12/08/2021 14:17

Honestly Im uncomfortable with the notion that stupid actions should follow you forever. I dont agree with what he did and think it was stupid but not sinister, having said that I have a real problem with people threating to tell peoples employers about their totally unrelated poor behaviour years later.
Who among us hasn't behaved poorly or stupidly at some point in our lives and would we want our employer written to with our past deeds like a old report card. It seems so incredibly spiteful to be me.
He will no doubt tell his employers ( assuming that they just dont bin) it that you're a bonkers paranoid roommate he lived with once and that will be the end of it.

Flowers500 · 12/08/2021 14:16

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

OP: "A man I lived with crossed a personal boundary, filmed us without consent and bow he's in a position of power with young people"

MN: "Stop trying to ruin his life you should be arrested" Hmm

Have you actually READ what happened? It's on the other thread, which is pretty short and totally unrecognisable from the picture OP is trying to portray here
Flowers500 · 12/08/2021 14:13

@CarlaH

How are others able to read the earlier thread. I get an oops not found message.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3672606-Housemate-set-camera-up-in-house-without-our-knowledge?pg=4

Does this link work for you? Works on my phone?

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 12/08/2021 14:12

OP: "A man I lived with crossed a personal boundary, filmed us without consent and bow he's in a position of power with young people"

MN: "Stop trying to ruin his life you should be arrested" Hmm

lljkk · 12/08/2021 14:11

I would have been like OPs original housemates & unbothered about original recording. Not sure what OP wants to achieve now. Will she object forever if the fellow gets into any job that has a safeguarding element to it?

CarlaH · 12/08/2021 14:09

How are others able to read the earlier thread. I get an oops not found message.

VorpalSword · 12/08/2021 14:04

The time to complain would have been 2 years ago to his PhD supervisor about the ethics of his research (capturing motion).

If his PhD is in this field then it is hard to say there was voyeristic or malicious reasoning behind it. If his PhD was something completely unrelated the it would be more concerning.

Unless there is a lot more to it that has been said on here, there are no major safeguarding concerns that you need to be flagging.

Flowers500 · 12/08/2021 14:04

I just read your full other thread. If you try to create job issues for him now then frankly I think he should report you to the police for harassment. You don't have any "safeguarding concerns" and you intentionally didn't tell the full story as you KNEW you were not in the right to try to make this a career-ending thing.

He was a shitty housemate. As anyone who has been to uni will tell you, at least 10-20% of the population fall into this category then go on to be completely normal, boring employees.

Grow up and get a new hobby! You're weirdly obsessed with him.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 12/08/2021 14:03

@bongsuhan

"Wow. Ok then. Of course some teachers are not going to be great people....but there’s ‘not great people’ and sex criminals. I’m comfortable with making a distinction, personally!"

My point is exactly that - some extremes aside - you can't tell if someone is "great" or "not great" from one episode in their past.

Well we will have to agree to disagree then because I am convinced that anyone who has made and distributed sex videos of his unwitting teenage girlfriend is not a great person and never will be. There is a minuscule chance they have changed entirely and fundamentally as a person but it’s too great a risk to have someone who has shown such perverted and evil tendencies teaching teenage children. You are far too quick to give people in a position of trust over children the benefit of the doubt and it’s scary to me that there might be others like you working in school management.
TheGenealogist · 12/08/2021 14:03

OP I have some experience of this. An ex boyfriend from when I was 18 had secretly filmed us having sex and distributed it to his mates.

Horrendous.

But also completely different from what happened to the OP. She did go to the police. Fair to assume that the police have all the details about what happened. The police chose not to take it further. 2 years later, she wants to go to his employer about it?

parietal · 12/08/2021 14:02

He was filming movements as part of a research project.

your only sensible recourse is to the ethics committee that approved the research project, and also possibly to the data protection dept of the university. the project should have had an ethics approval and a data protection approval to be covered by GDPR. if it did not, the university he was at during his PhD could sanction him (including withdrawing published papers).

But you should have done all this 2 years ago. There is no point in continuing to worry about this now.

SixesAndEights · 12/08/2021 14:00

Have read the last replies - I see there was nothing in particular to report about the filming.

MissyB1 · 12/08/2021 13:59

@Flowers500

If you're going to be purposefully unhelpful, obtuse and evasive then you can't expect others to give you the benefit of the doubt. And as others have uncovered from your previous posts, you are intentionally not representing the situation correctly.
This. 👆

Your previous thread has been found and doesn’t substantiate your insistence of a “safeguarding concern”. And you were deliberately vague at the start of this thread. Now we appear to know why.

I think you should drop this before you get into trouble for stalking or harassment.

SixesAndEights · 12/08/2021 13:58

OP: He did cause a lot of stress in the house, he also left without paying bills, etc.

OP: I didn't contact the university

OP: Very passive, no?

Yes, OP, you were very passive. Not anyone on here. Why didn't you go after the non payment of bills? Why didn't you contact the university?

It's a bit late now.

conxray · 12/08/2021 13:54

There is something wrong when people are so defensive of behaviour like this. Some posters have written very thoughtful replies, which I appreciate but the antagonistic ones? I don’t think they serve a purpose. I’m not deranged, unbalanced, petty or anything like that - I didn’t report him and left the house

What's wrong and off about the thread is that you did not explain what his reasons were for filming in the kitchen, nor that he stopped doing this and filmed out of a window.
There's a link to your original thread and several pages down on that thread you explain that he said he was filming movement as part of his research.
Why did you not include this information in this thread?

I've said above that I would have been furious if someone was filming movements in the kitchen for research but that this was not sinister in the way you are implying. You asked him to stop so he moved the camera so it was not filming the kitchen.

Now you're claiming there's something "off" about the thread because you are not getting the replies you wanted.

CalishataFolkart · 12/08/2021 13:50

[quote Smurfsarethefuture]@DappledThings

No, police first.[/quote]
You said you didn’t get past the desk clerk. Did you make a police report?

You then said you “didn’t report it and left the house.”

It’s just that if you are hoping notes have been made to evidence a pattern of behaviour but you haven’t actually managed to make a report with the police or his PhD supervisor at the time, what is there to add to?

I mean this kindly - are you feeling a bit guilty that you didn’t report it to his supervisor at the time and now feel you have to make amends? You said in your previous thread you had a lot going on. His behaviour is not your responsibility. There really doesn’t seem to be much you can do now and if he does commit a crime in the future there is nothing you can do right now that would prevent that. Not your fault.

Notanotherusernamenow · 12/08/2021 13:46

I would raise this with the university if you have evidence. It breached rights to privacy and GDPR, two things that lecturers should really understand. If you don’t have evidence, then much as you are right to be angered by the lack of consequences, unfortunately it will just be seen as malicious.

As someone who fought hard to get into academia, it upsets me when men like this get through.

DappledThings · 12/08/2021 13:45

[quote Smurfsarethefuture]@DappledThings

No, police first.[/quote]
So you went to the university second 2 years ago as well? What did they say then?

randomlyLostInWales · 12/08/2021 13:45

The difficulty for the university or any employer is that he hasn't been charged or convicted of any crime. Legally they can't do anything. I appreciate that it must have been a deeply upsetting exprerience but as the police didn't take it forward at the time his / her employer can't take action about the allegation now.

^This.

I'd have an expectation of not being filmed even in shared areas of a multi occupided house - but my privacy expectation would be lower in kichen than bedroom/bathroom were I would expect police to be interested.

If it was research - I would have expect a headsup and complaining around ethical guidelines of his research was good previous advice.

I'm not surpised you still shaken by experience but I don't think there's much you can do about him.

RedMarauder · 12/08/2021 13:44

You are telling people half the story and refusing to clarify your original post, hence the responses you are getting.

Anyway I agreed with another poster that you should have contacted his university at the time.

If he was just recording you for research reasons, hadn't got your expressed permission then they would have told him off and threatened to kick him of his PhD and out of the university if he didn't stop.

I've helped masters and PhD students with their research plus done my own uni research with people and you have to obey the ethics standards of your university. This includes getting people's express permission.

However if you don't get people's consent it doesn't mean your actions are a criminal offence.

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 13:43

Thank you @Take and @surfer

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread