Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housemate who secretly recorded us has been made a lecturer at UK university

334 replies

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 12:15

I cannot be unreasonable here. I wrote on here about two yrs ago about my housemate who hid a camera in our kitchen. He is now a lecturer at a London uni.

The police were not interested neither was landlady- I didn’t contact university and am now wondering should I?

OP posts:
Flowers500 · 12/08/2021 19:41

@VestaTilley

YANBU. I’d write to his head of department and dean of the faculty, cc’ing the uni head of HR so they’re at least aware and can’t brush it under the carpet.

Was the intent to see if anyone was stealing his food? Or more sinister? Either way, it’s odd and will escalate if not confronted.

I’d also suggest reporting to a different police force and see if they take a different view. It’s definitely more than odd behaviour.

Have you read the thread—either this one or the previous one? You’ll see that OP has so misrepresented the situation as to essentially be lying. It sounds like he’s being borderline harassed by an ex roommate
VestaTilley · 12/08/2021 19:33

YANBU. I’d write to his head of department and dean of the faculty, cc’ing the uni head of HR so they’re at least aware and can’t brush it under the carpet.

Was the intent to see if anyone was stealing his food? Or more sinister? Either way, it’s odd and will escalate if not confronted.

I’d also suggest reporting to a different police force and see if they take a different view. It’s definitely more than odd behaviour.

MurielSpriggs · 12/08/2021 19:30

It's so annoying when an OP is so evasive like this. Why not explain this at the beginning of this thread too?

Clearly to conceal any facts which are likely to result in her being labelled unreasonable. Which she said in her very first sentence is not an acceptable answer!

(And even then it didn't work.)

LadyJJ · 12/08/2021 19:22

I've lectured at a university and they don't do a PBS because you're not working with vulnerable adults or children.
I was surprised at the time.
So I doubt passing on what is in reality hearsay will do anything.
He's bound to say its malicious , but agree he sounds awful.

LittleLadyCece · 12/08/2021 19:17

OP having read the original post I think it's time you let this go and stop festering on the past. He was completely wrong in not asking permission but I can't see why you think this needs to be dragged up again with his employer. Especially as the police, other housemates and landlady didn't think it was worth taking further at the time.

I'm baffled as to what your concerns from a safeguarding point of view are now that he's a lecturer??

Notthemessiah · 12/08/2021 19:01

What a weird thread. OP could not be more obtuse or put together a worse case if she tried.

All I can think is that I'm very glad I didn't share a house with either her or the bloke with the camera.

plodalong12 · 12/08/2021 18:54

@Bluntness100
What was the reason, I can’t access the other thread. The ops comments just feel malicious and spiteful. Likes she’s envious this guy is a success and wants to ruin it for him

This is what the OP wrote:

He is working on a project sequencing film scenes through machine learning. I presume he will say he wanted to track motion in front of a lense, etc, etc. When I found the camera I said no recording bt then found he had moved camera to front room and started recorded front of house. Then set up a different thing (not sure what it is) to automate watering plants that works from his computer It doesn't have a camera on it (that I can see) or recording device.

This, coupled with the nasty posts about the housemate (to be fair, who does sound like he acted horrendously as a housemate) seems like a bitter act to take someone down, someone, who the OP admits works in the same field as her, and who she has just learned got a promotion as a lecturer whilst she hasn’t.

conxray · 12/08/2021 18:37

You finally (sort of) explain in the other thread that he’s doing some sort of tech/robotics/engineering research project where when the camera senses movement or noise, it causes something like the plants to be watered or a switch to be turned on. Hardly sinister and creepy behaviour

Exactly. It's so annoying when an OP is so evasive like this. Why not explain this at the beginning of this thread too?
The OP also said in the other thread that when she complained about the camera in the kitchen the housemate then moved it so it was pointing out of the front window and was no longer pointing at any of the housemates inside the house.
So yes, he shouldn't have done what he did. When he was challenged about it he moved it. Yes, I'd have been fucking furious/really pissed off too.
But no, it's not sinister and creepy and is not something that warrants him losing his job/career over.

Bluntness100 · 12/08/2021 18:19

Eh? How was it innocent and how did OP know this?

Um read the thread or the last one, you’re confused on how forums work, we aren’t here to save you the effort and summarise for you, 😂

therearenogoodusernamesleft · 12/08/2021 17:57

@Smurfsarethefuture

Thank you *@PlainJaneSuperbrainthe2nd*

I’m not wrong then that there are protocols to follow for this kind of thing.

But that doesn't mean he is a danger to his students now - can you see that?
MolyHolyGuacamole · 12/08/2021 17:13

He was a shitty housemate. As anyone who has been to uni will tell you, at least 10-20% of the population fall into this category then go on to be completely normal, boring employees.

My experiences put it more at 50% 😳

Morgoth · 12/08/2021 16:42

@Flowers500

If you're going to be purposefully unhelpful, obtuse and evasive then you can't expect others to give you the benefit of the doubt. And as others have uncovered from your previous posts, you are intentionally not representing the situation correctly.
This

Why do you just never answer simple questions that would clarify things?

When you discovered the camera, what did he say when you or your housemates asked him about it? What reason did he give? I assume at some point when you found it one of you said to him “Bob is this your camera?” How come it’s in the kitchen?”

You finally (sort of) explain in the other thread that he’s doing some sort of tech/robotics/engineering research project where when the camera senses movement or noise, it causes something like the plants to be watered or a switch to be turned on. Hardly sinister and creepy behaviour.

He should have asked you all before setting up the project but the worst he’s been is annoying - hardly a pervert or a serial killer worth having his career ruined. Why are you giving so much headspace to this? What reason did he give you when you spoke to him that makes you think he was being sinister and this was traumatic?

This whole thread is bizzare

Flowers500 · 12/08/2021 16:38

@phishy

I would tell the university. The twat should be shamed.
Have you read the other thread?
phishy · 12/08/2021 16:32

@Bluntness100

Op the more information that unfolds the more this looks like it was innocent and you knew this, and it was resolved. It does look like you want to make a malicious report.

What is the issue here? Do you hold a grudge, dislike him, did he knock you back, bad break up? What? Are you envious of his success?

Very clearly something is driving you and it’s not safeguarding.

You don’t need to explain here and irs highly unlikely you will but it’s no ok to make malicious reports to people’s employees, no.

Eh? How was it innocent and how did OP know this?
phishy · 12/08/2021 16:30

I would tell the university. The twat should be shamed.

Bluntness100 · 12/08/2021 15:53

Op the more information that unfolds the more this looks like it was innocent and you knew this, and it was resolved. It does look like you want to make a malicious report.

What is the issue here? Do you hold a grudge, dislike him, did he knock you back, bad break up? What? Are you envious of his success?

Very clearly something is driving you and it’s not safeguarding.

You don’t need to explain here and irs highly unlikely you will but it’s no ok to make malicious reports to people’s employees, no.

Butterfly44 · 12/08/2021 15:39

Well you went to the police and they didn't think a crime was committed.
And now you want to cause malice and ruin his career? Because he had a camera in the shared kitchen space?
You also sound jealous he's got a good job. So up until now you didn't bother going to his former employer or landlady to raise anything.

Pebblo · 12/08/2021 15:27

Really weird behaviour, I always felt quite vulnerable when I've been in houseshares with people that aren't friends, if I'd have found out someone was recording a communal area I'd feel really weird about it. Even for a project he should have asked, presumably the outcome wasn't affected by what was actually recorded so it would have made no odds to him letting you know.

That said, I'm not sure why it'd be necessary to tell his employer now, although hopefully he teaches his students about ethics.

jimmyhill · 12/08/2021 15:20

@oldwhyno

To put a post on AIBU and kick off with "I cannot be unreasonable here." is borderline psychotic to begin with, not to mention asking MNHQ to "look into this thread or take it down".

What's surprising is that despite the overwhelming opposition in the comments, 49% of people that voted apparently do think OP is not being unreasonable and ought to contact the university now. Madness!

Quite a lot of people also think the police are (or should be) a Stasi like organisation which - in the absence of any clearly defined criminal offence - collects and preserves information about personal grudges and poor manners, to be used later to block people from employment

Maybe OP grew up in East Germany or China

HarebrightCedarmoon · 12/08/2021 15:03

@bongsuhan

"It’s completely different to the OP. You really think a man who distributed covert videos of his teenage girlfriend having sex should be teaching in a secondary school? If he’s done it shortly after when it rightly became a crime he would be on some kind of register with a criminal record! You’d honestly be fine with this ‘man’ teaching your teenagers? That’s worrying."

It happened 12 years ago. Probably before the children he's teaching were even born. I have no idea how you make a connection between his - and I completely agree that that it was hideous and should be penalised - behaviour and his teaching activities.

I am fully aware that the people teaching my children have likely done vile things at some point in their life (as we probably all have somewhere) but unless it is very specifically to do with teaching children I don't really think it is any of my business.

I imagine people have done "vile things" like laughing at a cruel joke, but making a sex video of your girlfriend and distributing it to your mates is on another level - and a crime now. I don't think most people teaching your children would have done this level of "vile thing" in their lives, or at least I bloody hope not.

Stop being an apologist for sex offenders.

oldwhyno · 12/08/2021 15:01

To put a post on AIBU and kick off with "I cannot be unreasonable here." is borderline psychotic to begin with, not to mention asking MNHQ to "look into this thread or take it down".

What's surprising is that despite the overwhelming opposition in the comments, 49% of people that voted apparently do think OP is not being unreasonable and ought to contact the university now. Madness!

CarlaH · 12/08/2021 14:51

Thanks Hirples that has worked.

TheGenealogist · 12/08/2021 14:31

@Hemingwaycat

Don’t really get this. Read your posts on the previous thread and still don’t get it. He set a camera up in the kitchen, why is that an issue? Were any of you naked or having sex in the kitchen? He must have had a reason to do this but I don’t think I could get worked up about it because nobody does anything remotely interesting in the kitchen. Did he think people were stealing his food or something? If he’d set one up in the bathroom or your bedroom then I’d get it but the kitchen? Nah.
His reason was study-connected. A computer science thing looking at motion sensitive cameras.

Yes he should have got consent but didn't. Had the OP gone to his PhD supervisor at the time. I'm assuming they would have brought that up with him and talked again about ethics.

But OP is being deliberately vague about whether she actually did go to the Uni at the time or not. Or whether she went to the police and formally reported it, or not.

Being a shitty housemate is not a crime, and just as well as we've all come across a shitty housemate and probably most of us have done things our housemate objected to.

But really OP, you need to LET IT GO.

HirplesWithHaggis · 12/08/2021 14:26

@CarlaH

Afraid not Flowers. Maybe it's my computer.
Delete the "pg=4" at the end of the link - that worked for me.
MsHedgehog · 12/08/2021 14:23

I’ve read your previous post and at no point do you raise any safeguarding concerns, so it is odd that 2 years later you are suddenly concerned.

Maybe have a think about why this bothers you so much, but ruining his career is a petty move, especially if there was no ill intent on his side.

Swipe left for the next trending thread