Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housemate who secretly recorded us has been made a lecturer at UK university

334 replies

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 12:15

I cannot be unreasonable here. I wrote on here about two yrs ago about my housemate who hid a camera in our kitchen. He is now a lecturer at a London uni.

The police were not interested neither was landlady- I didn’t contact university and am now wondering should I?

OP posts:
HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 12/08/2021 13:12

Hallelujah, the other thread has an answer after five pages of evasive responses from the OP!

He is working on a project sequencing film scenes through machine learning. I presume he will say he wanted to track motion in front of a lense, etc, etc. When I found the camera I said no recording bt then found he had moved camera to front room and started recorded front of house. Then set up a different thing (not sure what it is) to automate watering plants that works from his computer It doesn't have a camera on it (that I can see) or recording device.

The university is not going to be interested.

JudgeJ · 12/08/2021 13:12

@bongsuhan

"12 years later I found out he was a teacher in a secondary school! I wrote to the Head but he wasn't interested and very much turned it on me to look like a bitter vengeful hag hmm on the upside he applied to the school I currently teach at a couple of years ago and when I told my (amazing) Head what he'd done he believed me and bumped him off the interview list and told him exactly why. Ex denied it and made noises about legal action but as suspected it came to nothing."

This is completely insane, almost as wild as the OP. 12 years later! I can imagine the posters trying to rationalise this behaviour as some sort of safekeeping, but it belongs on one of those petty revenge threads.

Nothing 'petty' about the revenge, totally barmy! If we look back to our days as students etc how many of us cringe at things we did that, now, as responsible adults, some even in 'positions of trust', we wouldn't dream of doing? That's not referring to anything illegal, just stupid.
HeronLanyon · 12/08/2021 13:11

You cannot ‘censure’ someone for ethics for something alleged to have been done by someone off the street. Come on folks.what op describes sounds odd but there is no conviction no police caution even seemingly no offence etc etc. Leave him be before you are the one getting into difficulty and acting inappropriately.
If this were me and someone contacted my employer in these circumstances I would take action against them. Civil action for repetitional damage and losses.

user16395699 · 12/08/2021 13:10

Right, so if a woman is abused or assaulted or raped, unless she reports it immediately and is one of the tiny number of victims who see their assailant convicted, then she is never allowed to speak of it again or raise concerns through safeguarding channels if that person is later appointed to a position of trust or authority?

A lot of people chatting misogynistic shit on this thread. Organisations have safeguarding policies to deal with situations like this, because actually it is important and does matter.

An employer does not require criminal convictions to take action against employees under their own policies about conduct. They do not have to meet a criminal burden of proof to take disciplinary action. They do not have to have a criminal conviction to follow safeguarding policies.

When somebody displays "low level" abusive behaviour like this man, you are a fool to ignore it. People leaping to so vigorously defend his right to get away with it are why abusers are able to stay in positions of power escalating their abuse.

Defending his so-called right to get away with this without consequences is no different to defending his actions.

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 13:10

Yes @DappledThings. That’s it

OP posts:
MurielSpriggs · 12/08/2021 13:08

@DappledThings

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3672606-Housemate-set-camera-up-in-house-without-our-knowledge?pg=4

This one? A lot of people there suggested you contact his supervisor for his PhD. Did you do that? They might have been more interested in the ethical side of it and censured him than the police would have been.

But it's really not up to a university to censure or discipline people for behaviour which is not connected to the university of their studies there. That's what the police are for.
bongsuhan · 12/08/2021 13:07

"Wow. Ok then. Of course some teachers are not going to be great people....but there’s ‘not great people’ and sex criminals. I’m comfortable with making a distinction, personally!"

My point is exactly that - some extremes aside - you can't tell if someone is "great" or "not great" from one episode in their past.

Vanishun · 12/08/2021 13:06

No, I don't think HR keep notes from random people with grievances against staff. Or I bloody hope they don't.

Not that you're in the wrong, or to defend his behaviour mind you.

CalishataFolkart · 12/08/2021 13:05

@Smurfsarethefuture

I didn’t get past the desk clerk at the station who said it was the landlady’s responsibility.

This is shocking to me but clearly not to others. I haven’t contacted his university (also where he did his PhD) as I can see without evidence it all looks strange and as someone has said, rules exist to protect us all from malicious allegations. Just feel there must be a legitimate course of action to take in a situation like this and frustrated that there isn’t.

Sorry, missed this. The police never spoke to him? So there is no record to establish a pattern of behaviour?

He sounds like a grade A dickhead and an awful lack of support from your landlady/police.

It does leave you a bit in the wind now though.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 12/08/2021 13:04

@bongsuhan

"It’s completely different to the OP. You really think a man who distributed covert videos of his teenage girlfriend having sex should be teaching in a secondary school? If he’s done it shortly after when it rightly became a crime he would be on some kind of register with a criminal record! You’d honestly be fine with this ‘man’ teaching your teenagers? That’s worrying."

It happened 12 years ago. Probably before the children he's teaching were even born. I have no idea how you make a connection between his - and I completely agree that that it was hideous and should be penalised - behaviour and his teaching activities.

I am fully aware that the people teaching my children have likely done vile things at some point in their life (as we probably all have somewhere) but unless it is very specifically to do with teaching children I don't really think it is any of my business.

Wow. Ok then. Of course some teachers are not going to be great people....but there’s ‘not great people’ and sex criminals. I’m comfortable with making a distinction, personally!
DappledThings · 12/08/2021 13:02

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3672606-Housemate-set-camera-up-in-house-without-our-knowledge?pg=4

This one? A lot of people there suggested you contact his supervisor for his PhD. Did you do that? They might have been more interested in the ethical side of it and censured him than the police would have been.

Smurfsarethefuture · 12/08/2021 13:01

I understand that the university cannot do anything now. I didn’t think it worked like that. I thought that if something like this was reported and then later there was a separate incident and a pattern starts to emerge there is a record - I thought that was what we were being advised to do across all sorts of crimes. I know that the police can’t act on everything but I thought records were being kept?

@Womaninthemirror1

This is really unnecessary- and there is no personal vendetta. I ‘m in a safe guarding role and the easy thing is for me personally to let it go but professionally I was trying to figure out the right thing to do.

OP posts:
therearenogoodusernamesleft · 12/08/2021 13:01

What do you perceive as the risk to his students? Why did he say he'd put the camera up when challenged?

HeronLanyon · 12/08/2021 13:01

It’s not necessarily fine and does sound odd but so what ? The police cos can only investigate where there is an offence alleged - not entirely sure there was an offence here. Then even if there were they can only charge where the cos charging standards are met - is there sufficient evidence that a conviction is likely and is it in the public interest to proceed.
Clearly at the time you reported this op these would all have informed the police decision not to proceed. So that was that.
Loads of people are walking amongst us right now who have done odd or creepy things but we can’t approach their employer with what amounts to uncorroborated tales of you reporting something which the pice took no further. !
You’re not wrong to have noticed and had a thought. There really is nothing for you to do now. If you were to you might well be committing an offence !

bongsuhan · 12/08/2021 13:01

"It’s completely different to the OP. You really think a man who distributed covert videos of his teenage girlfriend having sex should be teaching in a secondary school? If he’s done it shortly after when it rightly became a crime he would be on some kind of register with a criminal record! You’d honestly be fine with this ‘man’ teaching your teenagers? That’s worrying."

It happened 12 years ago. Probably before the children he's teaching were even born. I have no idea how you make a connection between his - and I completely agree that that it was hideous and should be penalised - behaviour and his teaching activities.

I am fully aware that the people teaching my children have likely done vile things at some point in their life (as we probably all have somewhere) but unless it is very specifically to do with teaching children I don't really think it is any of my business.

user16395699 · 12/08/2021 13:01

@PurpleDaisies

Nobody is saying he was right to do this.
I dunno, you seem pretty invested in defending him.
canigooutyet · 12/08/2021 13:00

I would have been disturbed if I came home and found my housemate walking around naked tbh.

What outcome do you want if you reported him to the uni @Smurfsarethefuture?

MurielSpriggs · 12/08/2021 13:00

[quote Smurfsarethefuture]@PurpleDaisies

Not random. Were housemates.

Bit shocked at the responses, guys. Very passive, no?[/quote]
They're realistic. You're posting a lot but providing very vague information. It doesn't sound like he committed any offence. And in any event the employer will not be remotely interested (not should they be) without an actual conviction.

Vanishun · 12/08/2021 12:59

I don't think people here are saying it's fine. But I can't see an employer caring or responding to something like this.

Even if they asked him (which I don't think they would), he could just say "oh god, it's my old creepy flatmate again who makes up weird lies about me".

Unsure33 · 12/08/2021 12:59

As the police did not do anything then they must think there was not a case . It was a kitchen not a bedroom or bathroom ?

So I dont think you should contact his employers .

He has no convictions so what are you going to say ?

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 12:59

what did you do about it at the time?

ExpressDelivery · 12/08/2021 12:59

Why did he put a camera in the kitchen? Presumably it was something to do with pilfered food rather than on the hope of seeing people undressed?

Of course he shouldn't have done it, but it seems like the sort of thing that might seem reasonable to a very young person feeling that his housemates were stealing. It might even be the sort of thing that gets recommended on MN!

No reason at all for him to be paying for it years later in my view.

TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius · 12/08/2021 12:59

I think being as it wasn't dealt with at the time you gave to let it go. If you do anything now you are exposing yourself to litigation from him.

SkinnyMirror · 12/08/2021 12:58

I am surprised people think it's fine and nothing odd about it.

Nobody has said it's fine. Literally everyone has said it isn't fine.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 12/08/2021 12:58

I don’t know why

Okay but you said he freely admitted it, so what reason did he give?

Swipe left for the next trending thread