Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling to reconnect with DH

37 replies

fightingbadfeelingoff · 12/08/2021 11:57

NC for this as I don't want it found by my MIL who's also on mumsnet.

DH and I have been together 10y, married 8. We have 1 DC who is 20m old. He is a very loving, loyal and caring person who adores DC and has taken time out of work to stay at home as I went back to work quickly after their birth.

The problem is... he is very... impractical. No matter where we live (and we lived in 4 countries - including US and the UK), I'm always the one making all decisions, organizing everything - from house hunting to car repairs (and I don't even drive). He will 'execute' what I ask him to, but in most cases I will have to double-check that he doesn't miss deadlines (he once almost missed his own visa deadline) as he tends to leave things to the very last moment. However, he will never, ever notice something needs doing. In the house, in the garden, admin...etc.

If we go on a holiday, he won't even try to organize day-trips, book restaurants etc - he'll leave it all to me. He'll get me a purse or a book for my birthday but won't try to do anything special. This has been an issue which would go dormant and flare up on occasion - depending on how exhausted I got.

After working PT for the last year (to do childcare for DC), he now decided to go back FT. Great, I support that! However, his job requires us to move from living close to my parents to living close to his parents (a few hours trip). I have reluctantly agreed but after 10y of being responsible for everything I asked him to take the lead.

This didn't happen - at all! I'm the one talking to movers, I'm the one who ended up talking to agents, etc. And I didn't even want to move!

As a result I've noticed I have zero feelings towards him and towards this move now. I can't see literally anything to look forward to and am going through the motions, ticking off the things from the 'to do' list and accepting my 'fate'. I have very bad experiences from living near his parents (MIL is very dominant and interfering) and am dreading that it will only get worse as we now have DC.

On top of that, we don't really need his salary at all. I'm a high-earner and have been making at least 2x his salary since we've been together (3x with bonuses nowadays). In my mind, I'm leaving behind my parents, my friends, comfortable home I love, to live in a place I don't like as much, near his parents, away from any support network of my own, for the sake of him feeling good about himself when I haven't had the luxury of feeling like that in years. There are some objective reasons why the move may be good for DC (better schools, etc.) that I am trying to use to rationalize stuff, but those are going only so far.

So, to summarize - for a couple of weeks now my resentment has bubbled and I have zero interest in any physical intimacy with him... furthermore, I've noticed that my desire to talk to him is almost non-existent (and communication has always been our strong suit as a couple) and after a period of sadness - I now have no feelings whatsoever about the move, our life together, or my life for that matter. I'm just blank.

How do I move forward? How do I reconnect with him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Summerrain123 · 28/08/2021 09:19

The fact you say you are feeling 'nothing' indicated maybe the stress has caused some depression. I have no doubt that the situation and inequality of responsibility annoys you and the current situation has highlighted it even more. However, it sounds like usually the benefits out weigh this negative until recently when you have ended up taking responsibility for something you don't even want to do. The resentment and stress is understandable.

In moments of depression, it is normal to lose feelings, it sounds like the basis of a good friendship is there. Don't make any rash decisions. Extend the lease, give it a year - 18 months and if you are still feeling very unhappy, move back. Taking this pressure off will certainly help you to feel less stressed and hopefully less depressed.

Howshouldibehave · 13/08/2021 09:13

Will you have to sort out childcare single-handedly as well if you’re both full time?!

I think you were mad to agree a move!

Maray1967 · 13/08/2021 09:06

OP, I recognise done of what you have posted although I mostly don’t work full time so accept that I need to do more to even things up. My DH had never planned or booked a holiday ever - in 30 years of being together. I made it clear this year that I wanted a weekend break for my birthday. And for the first time he delivered, booking the accommodation, reserving restaurant tables and booked one activity. I don’t know what made the difference, perhaps telling him this was the only thing I wanted.
I recognise that I have taken over in the past, just getting on with it as he doesn’t. I’m not sure I can advise you very well but for what it’s worth I’d give very specific instructions (I think in my case it’s at least partly his fear of getting it wrong as much as not bothering) and he needs to be stepping up now to help, whatever you decide to do. My DH was great with the failed ivf and 3 MCs and is a great dad, and was, right from the start, sharing night duties etc. He coped better with the colic than I did. So as far as I’m concerned, having to book holidays and sort out almost every activity we do is something I can live with - mostly.
With regards to your MIL I would address this with him beforehand if you do go ahead with the move. Make it clear what is not acceptable from her and make sure he will deal with any issues. I’ve been firm here as well although mine is not overbearing.
I wish you well.

Meatshake · 13/08/2021 08:54

Can he not buy a crash pad near where he works and do a weekly commute/home for the weekends?

Sounds like a bit of space for you and self reliance for him might do you both the world of good.

fightingbadfeelingoff · 13/08/2021 07:05

@SoundBar - my parents had a very unhappy marriage - there were a lot of arguments and shouting and it was always made very clear to me that they stayed together 'for the kids'. Finally, they divorced after 30y of marriage and are on non-speaking terms now.

It may be a bit cultural too, I guess - I am not British (as you probably can tell) and my husband is. There is a definite 'collective before individual' trait in my culture where individual happiness is valued less than family life - even if that family life is not functional.

I do think that I have a proneness to feeling guilty and doing things out of 'duty' in general, not just in my marriage and I will seek counseling to try to unpack this a little. But in terms of our marriage - I think that what we went through together - the trauma of many pregnancy losses and infertility as well as moving around, starting from scratch so many times created an additional bond with DH which makes me more hesitant to break things off than I possibly would have been otherwise.

OP posts:
SoundBar · 13/08/2021 01:20

I am so confused as to why on earth you are moving OP. It just doesn't make any sense at all. It sounds an awful situation to be in. Why do you feel so guilty towards him? What was your parents relationship like growing up?

fightingbadfeelingoff · 12/08/2021 19:07

Not sure if I can tag everyone, but I'll try to respond as best as I can.

Yes, I think that the way forward for us may be a 'probation' - pulling out of the purchase, extending the lease for a period of time and counseling. I am wondering if I put deadline on it - would it undermine our effort with counseling or make us take it more seriously?

I don't want to divorce him as I think he is a lovely person and I do think and see how much he loves DC. He really is a devoted father and he never says no when it comes to DC - he may not organize things or notice things need doing, but he is very patient, creative and loving parent. I also still respect him as a person - maybe I don't think he's a great husband and I struggle to respect some of his decisions (or lack thereof) but I respect his mind, his morale, and his love and loyalty to our family.

On the other hand - yes, we failed each other badly. He by not taking action and me by enabling it by taking too much of it. I don't want to blame it all on him as I am sure that my personality is not the easiest one to co-exist with, and that my behavior made it easier for him to give in to his weakness.

I guess that if I was sure that I can never again be happy with him, I'd consider divorce more seriously... but I am not. I get very angry and think 'to hell with it all' but then I also remember being in love with him, I remember him holding my hand in hospitals after many MCs, being there for every doctor's appointment, giving me injections even though he is afraid of needles, leaving the house at 11pm to get me wasabi peas when I was finally pregnant... and then stepping up and handling quite a few nights at newborn stage to give me time to recover from a life-threatening delivery.

Those things still tell me that there may be hope. And I don't want to give up on him and us, because we didn't give up on becoming parents when it looked just as hopeless as this does. He needs to do a lot of work - and we won't make it if he doesn't - but there may be things I can do to help us get there too. I just don't see them right now.

OP posts:
AllTheSingleLadiess · 12/08/2021 15:41

If you move to be near his parents and you split up, there's going to have to be a legal battle for you to get permission to move back to where you live now. You're not forbidden to move away if you separate but if your son is settled and in school, the distance you'll be able to move will be seriously curtailed if your h wants 50/50. Your h could use the legal system yo prevent you moving away (I know the irony here would be that he'd found a solicitor and instructed them to carry out the paperwork but you never know what he might do if things are this important)

Vitallyli · 12/08/2021 15:22

Maybe he has adhd? Talk to him about how you feel and come up with a plan. Let him manage some things and let him miss deadlines. Is he good at helping around the house? It's a crisis moment for you, moving is always stressful. Give yourself time to feel better about the move, maybe look for local groups to make new friends. Talk to him about how you feel and try to think about things you like about him.

Crimeismymiddlename · 12/08/2021 15:20

I think that your feelings have deadened towards him because frankly being the one that does everything, notices everything and actions/drives everything is exhausting esp with a big job. If the roles were reversed and you had taken time out with the children it would be taken for granted the parent with more time would do the life admin/work, but he hasn’t now you are sacrificing a lot and making a move you don’t want to do and the only thing you asked of him was that he deals with it all, and he could not be bothered. That is going to cause ructions in your relationship, of course you are indifferent to him, rather than being in a team in which you feel supported you now feel taken for granted and even more over worked than normal. I work with a man like this in a job were noticing and fixing things is at the core, I only feel apathy and annoyance towards him, and I only see him at work so god knows how you must be feeling right now.

Feedingthebirds1 · 12/08/2021 15:01

It's not ideal but I'd pull out of the rental and rent somewhere where you're living now. You'd be mad to move away from your support network, to be nearer to a domineering MIL. Tell him that if he wants to move he's going on his own. You have to get past this before you do anything as you are going to be utterly miserable. Put your needs first.

I just don't know what I can do to help this as I literally don't feel anything about anything anymore - I am not angry, sad, excited, worried... nothing.

That nothingness is a key symptom of depression. I suspect that it's been a Chinese water torture effect of carrying him for so long and over so much. You've maybe got used to it so that you haven't really noticed until this has come along and thrown it into sharp relief. Another reason not to do something that will leave you even more isolated and depressed.

AtticusHoysAnus · 12/08/2021 14:57

Tell him exactly what you've written here.

Catawaul · 12/08/2021 14:54

I wouldn't move, what if it doesn't work out and you want to move back closer to your family, but can't if he won't agree to the DC moving?

CarolinaWeeper · 12/08/2021 14:51

I think you feel nothing for him because he is acting like your child and not your partner. Which isn’t very sexy in a grown man.

This is it in a nutshell. I think it's time for a really honest conversation and couple's counselling. It doesn't sound like it's doomed but he needs to understand that things must change to save the relationship. To be honest it sounds like you need to understand that too.

MostlyHappyMummy · 12/08/2021 14:48

What @IndigoHexagon said

IndigoHexagon · 12/08/2021 14:41

I wouldn’t move, and I’d cancel the house purchase, and rent somewhere near your support network until you are able to make a clear decision. Maybe a trial separation where he goes to the new rental and you see if you actually want to move with him or not?

gannett · 12/08/2021 14:40

I am 100% he knows I don't enjoy it but I also think he thinks I can't 'help myself but take charge' (which is probably true to an extent). He definitely thinks I'm better at it - he has a history of shying away from any confrontation so naturally all problems always used to come to me. However how this turned into everything comes to me (not just problems) is something I am not sure about... I guess we pushed each other into extremes - he pushed me into 'taking charge' extreme and I pushed him into 'back seat'.

I think this level of awareness/insight is a positive sign for reconnection. Have you had this meta conversation with him? Not about the specific house move or anything specific in fact, but the larger pattern and roles you find yourself falling into. And how you want to get out of those roles.

I think in most couples, each partner ends up in default roles, often the ones they're best at. I'm horrendously impractical and indecisive, so DP does pretty much all the heavy lifting when something needs to happen without getting into a tizzy. I end up leaving stuff like that to him because it will definitely be done better by him than me. On the other hand I'm better at long-term research, finding out information, coming up with a range of options and pushing us out of our comfort zone. So the dynamic is often, for example if we're planning a holiday, I'll research a range of options, present them to him and we decide together, then he does the nuts and bolts of organisation.

You sound extremely capable, frighteningly so to a chronically disorganised person like me. From our perspective it's often just better to let capable people crack on with being capable rather than attempting and failing to match them.

MissSueFlay · 12/08/2021 13:45

"I guess we pushed each other into extremes - he pushed me into 'taking charge' extreme and I pushed him into 'back seat'."

I think this is a really honest insight, and it's a place that lots of people find themselves in, especially after children have arrived.
Would relationship counselling help to get things back on track in regards to the division of the mental load? It would mean him stepping outside his comfort zone, and you allowing things to get screwed up.

When both parties are pulling their weight and working as a team again, you may feel differently about things. Putting the purchase of the new house off for 1-2 years might make him realise that the time to change, and maintain the changes, really is now.

He doesn't sound like a nasty man, and you sound quite impressive, but it does sound like the two of you don't communicate terribly well.

IS0D0RA · 12/08/2021 13:33

I am 100% he knows I don't enjoy it but I also think he thinks I can't 'help myself but take charge' (which is probably true to an extent). He definitely thinks I'm better at it - he has a history of shying away from any confrontation so naturally all problems always used to come to me. However how this turned into everything comes to me (not just problems) is something I am not sure about... I guess we pushed each other into extremes - he pushed me into 'taking charge' extreme and I pushed him into 'back seat'

But he just left it for you to do as he’s too lazy, so you had to step up. You said so upthread.

I think you feel nothing for him because he is acting like your child and not your partner. Which isn’t very sexy in a grown man.

Or because you are just plain exhausted at doing everything.

If I were you I would be SEETHING with anger and resentment, underneath a veneer of being nice and understanding.

I think you have internalised all his pathetic excuses for being so lazy and selfish. I’m surprised you aren’t posting asking for help for his syndrome / condition Hmm.

Like the women posting here asking for help with their husbands “ anger problems “ - when he only loses his temper at home.

Or the ADHD that only manifests itself with housework or childcare.

pjani · 12/08/2021 13:29

My guess is you have years of buried resentment and anger to work through. You can’t access warm feelings because ‘blocking’ bad feelings has been your way of coping. But now you have to push down so much it’s blocking positive feelings too.

I think get to therapy! Could be so helpful! And also couples therapy. Maybe you have a parent (you)/child (him) dynamic that needs breaking.

I personally wouldn’t give up yet.

IS0D0RA · 12/08/2021 13:21

This makes no sense.

You are making a move which you don’t want and will make your life harder , with a lazy and selfish man you are not in love with.

Why? Because it’s “ his turn”. Because you have kids now and it seems unfair.

When it is his turn to be an adult? And when is it your turn to put your needs first?

No wonder you are dreading this. And you can stop it if you want to. Yes it will cause a lot of trouble and yes it will cost money. But isn’t that easier than being unhappy and resentful for years?

And no it won’t be the same as a single mum. You will be much less angry . You will hire help who will take instruction better and won’t need reminded all the time. If they don’t, you will fire them.

And you will get time to yourself when the kids are with their useless father.

But you need to do this now, before you move to a new area and upset your kids schooling. Also you don’t want to end up stuck in a new area.

fightingbadfeelingoff · 12/08/2021 13:19

@Gertie75 I did tell him. We have a very open relationship in that sense - I have been warning him about possible consequences of this issue for years now. I also told him how I feel. He is very worried and promised to do everything to change and make things better for me/us. I want to believe this will be the case. I want to believe it is possible for us to reconnect - I just don't know what I can do to help this as I literally don't feel anything about anything anymore - I am not angry, sad, excited, worried... nothing.

The sale of our house is completed. We're supposed to move into a rental for the first 6m while waiting for the purchase to complete as well. I guess we could pull out and just extend the lease after the initial 6m to give it more time.

I am 100% he knows I don't enjoy it but I also think he thinks I can't 'help myself but take charge' (which is probably true to an extent). He definitely thinks I'm better at it - he has a history of shying away from any confrontation so naturally all problems always used to come to me. However how this turned into everything comes to me (not just problems) is something I am not sure about... I guess we pushed each other into extremes - he pushed me into 'taking charge' extreme and I pushed him into 'back seat'.

OP posts:
IdblowJonSnow · 12/08/2021 13:11

Don't move and don't reconnect!!

It's not too late.

He sounds fucking useless. Just stop doing everything that isn't for you and your child.

KatherineSiena · 12/08/2021 13:09

It sounds very worrying that you will be leaving your support network and moving closer to in-laws who you don’t sound close to. This would bother me as much as all the marital issues you raise. Is there any way you can stall the house purchase, even if you sell and maybe rent to buy some time? Or has the purchase completed? Otherwise I’d view the purchase as a stop gap and maybe try it for 18 months but in good time for you to move back before your DC starts school.

You are clearly a resourceful and independent woman and having a partner who just allows you to fill the organisational space would really grind my gears too. Does he think you enjoy it or are just better at these things or is he simply lazy?

Gertie75 · 12/08/2021 13:05

It's not very fair to him though if you have zero feelings towards him now, it'd be an awful conversation to have but at least of he knew how you were, or weren't, feeling then he can be part of the decision about whether to try and save the marriage.

You both sound like decent people but could be happier apart.

Years ago I called off an engagement and house move with my then fiancé, he was a lovely guy but I'd fallen out of love with him, the day he left was awful and we were both in tears. We've both now met other people and are much happier than we were together, still friends too.
We could've stayed together and had an OK life but I couldn't bear the thought of getting to my old age and looking back knowing I'd wasted the best years of my life with the wrong person.