Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think piercing a child's ears with a gun should be banned?

138 replies

lovesthosebeeps · 12/08/2021 11:39

Okay, people must insist it's done because xyz

Mine was done with a needle as a tiny baby. However, it appears most tattoo places that do piercings won't touch a baby/small child.

But I've always known guns are worse. A tattoo/piercing artist I know personally just posted this image on FB

She says the gun isn't a clean go, and can cause damage to surrounding tissue etc.

AIBU to wonder why this is still allowed, with a gun, because it can cause so many issues later on?

Obviously it would be best if people didn't bother getting small children done at all but at least abolish bloody guns?!

To think piercing a child's ears with a gun should be banned?
OP posts:
thereisonlyoneofme · 12/08/2021 14:56

You are not allowed to slap a child but allowed to pierce its ears. I know they have injections etc, but thats not a vanity thing

sashh · 12/08/2021 14:55

Horrified at the people having their noses done with a gun... it's cartilage, should absolutely be done with a needle!

Nose piercing guns are a thing, they are fairly new but they have been developed.

iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 12/08/2021 14:54

I had my ears pierced at Claire’s when I was 15, and it didn’t hurt at all - just a pinch (and I’m a total wuss). No issues, although I do realise that doesn’t mean everyone has the same experience. Agreed that ear piercing should be banned to a minimum age of 12.

lazymare · 12/08/2021 14:53

*gun, obvs

lazymare · 12/08/2021 14:53

Mine were done with a dun 40 years ago. My daughter's were done with a gun at Claire's (two staff members so both ears done at once). Both absolutely fine.

sashh · 12/08/2021 14:53

Article comparing both

www.truthorfiction.com/say-no-to-piercing-guns-viral-facebook-post/

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/08/2021 14:50

@sallievp

If it's ok to make a hole in a baby or child's ears without their consent....why stop there!? How about piercing their belly button too and also nose and eyebrow?
I don’t believe there’s a legal lower age limit for any kind of piercing except genital piercing. And since we don’t see babies with eyebrow and bellybutton piercings, would suggest there’s no risk that baby ear piercing is a gateway.
therocinante · 12/08/2021 14:48

Horrified at the people having their noses done with a gun... it's cartilage, should absolutely be done with a needle!

sallievp · 12/08/2021 14:46

If it's ok to make a hole in a baby or child's ears without their consent....why stop there!? How about piercing their belly button too and also nose and eyebrow?

TedHastingsweeDonkey · 12/08/2021 14:44

@Nivealove

I will Pierce my child's ears no matter the age. When some of these posters allow some of their children to do drive/ drink at a young age. The British culture is odd.
You must not be entirely familiar with the meaning of "culture" - what a silly, silly comment! Confused
lovesthosebeeps · 12/08/2021 14:43

[quote bobdidit]@lovesthosebeeps think what you want! No one should tell you what to think.
So please don't try and tell others that ear piercing guns should be banned! My daughter is 6 and has chosen to have hers done. Single use, perfectly safe and she's had no infection. Get a real worry!! [/quote]

It was just a discussion. You will see from my previous posts that I agreed with a poster about something regarding gun use and said she had a good point

OP posts:
Bumblenums1234 · 12/08/2021 14:42

@BungleandGeorge

I’m confused, they don’t use a normal earring in the gun and just jab it through? They have a pointed end just like a needle. I can quite believe a skilled person can be more accurate and gentle but the two things are not so different?
They use a hollow needle when they peirce, they aren't just shoving through a solid bit of metal. Plus they are single use so MUCH more hygienic than the grot stuck in the Claires equipment.
MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 12/08/2021 14:41

I did my own, numbed my lobes with an ice pop from the freezer and shoved a pair of earrings through. I vaguely remember using surgical spirit but I do remember the earrings weren't even real silver. I had no problems at all unlike the ones I had done professionally and was told to turn them 6x a day and got a big infection.

Ericaceae · 12/08/2021 14:41

That diagram isn't the basis for any informed discussion though, since it doesn't show the tiny sliver of flesh that's removed with a needle. Both methods cause 'damage', which is being shown selectively by someone who uses the first method.
Correlation isn't causation, and stories about children with infected ear piercings from guns are relatively more common because the vast, vast majority of lobe piercings are done with guns. Aftercare and decent jewellery is key. I've got 5 "gun" lobe piercings, and have never had a single infection or issue with them. I've had needle piercings elsewhere, which suit different areas of the body.
Inforned consent is a whole other topic, though I understand why it's been wrapped round this discussion.

bobdidit · 12/08/2021 14:40

@lovesthosebeeps think what you want! No one should tell you what to think.
So please don't try and tell others that ear piercing guns should be banned! My daughter is 6 and has chosen to have hers done. Single use, perfectly safe and she's had no infection. Get a real worry!!

Kanaloa · 12/08/2021 14:40

@Nivealove

Do you mean you would pierce your kids ears whenever they asked? I don’t think it’s culturally British to let your unpierced ear having children drink and drive.

dementedpixie · 12/08/2021 14:36

Piercing the ears of a baby is odd tbh

Nivealove · 12/08/2021 14:35

I will Pierce my child's ears no matter the age. When some of these posters allow some of their children to do drive/ drink at a young age. The British culture is odd.

TedHastingsweeDonkey · 12/08/2021 14:33

*hole - obviously!

sashh · 12/08/2021 14:33

@Dixiechickonhols

I’m always confused by reference to gun. I had mine pierced for first time age 45 at a jewellers. It wasn’t a gun it was a tiny stapler sort of thing that pressed the earring through. I barely felt it, - nothing like a flu injection, eyebrows threaded or nettle sting you actually feel. I didn’t have mine done as a child as my Mum thought it was common.
That is what the modern 'guns' look like. They are also single use.

This is one thing I can never get my head around, a device specifically designed to pierce ear lobes is evil but using a needle designed for medical procedures is fine.

I've had my ears done with guns and my nose done a couple of times with a needle (I had to remove the stud for work and it sealed up).

The needle was i a sterile container but the piercers did not wear sterile gloves, just ordinary latex and the jewelry certainlky wasn't sterile.

Guns are not 'blunt force trauma because they are not blunt and a piercing by definition is a piercing.

The arguments about not bein able to sterilise them, well if they are single use there is no need to sterilise them.

The older guns could not be sterilised, but all the parts that came in touch with your ear were sterile.

TedHastingsweeDonkey · 12/08/2021 14:32

I had my ears pierced as a new born, even before my mother left the hospital! Not UK, and it's still standard practice. I just don't get it, I would absolutely never do this to a baby / child, unless they were old enough to decide for themselves. Guess what though, when I was around 13 / 14, I desperately wanted a second whole pierced in one ear (as it was soooooo cooooool!) but somehow that was deemed inappropriate and my parents wouldn't let me??!! 🤣

YANBU. It should be banned.

Deadringer · 12/08/2021 14:31

I have had my ears done several times with a gun and had no issues, as have all of my 4dds. (Not as babies, age 9 or 10), so no i don't think they should be banned. People have a choice, and that's as it should be imo.

3womeninaboat · 12/08/2021 14:26

I don’t think small children should be allowed to have ear piercing however it’s done but I can’t join in with the hysteria about guns. I had six done myself with a gun, four of them at Claire’s, and it didn’t hurt. I can feel the tissue damage around the piercings that another poster talked about but it’s an earlobe, it has zero impact on my life. Children get them infected by getting hairs around the earrings, however you put them in.

lljkk · 12/08/2021 14:23

I'm convinced there's some kind of Luddite factory-made gadget=bad but primitive human operated needle=good bias at work here.

AngryWhompingWillow · 12/08/2021 14:22

@lovesthosebeeps

YABU. The gun is much better. Quicker, cleaner, easier, more direct for piercing ears. Why on earth anyone would choose a needle for it just baffles me. Confused

That said, no child should be allowed to have pierced ears until they are 13 or older.

@RedHelenB

My kids had theirs done with a gun aged 7 and have been fine. like nearly everyone else they know. Seems like it's a real mumsnet bee in the bonnet to have to go to a ratio parlour to get them done with a needle.

This. In the real world, I don't know a single person who has an issue with piercing ears with a 'gun.' Only on mumsnet does this seem to be a bugbear for people. Use a needle for other piercings yeah maybe... but there is nothing^ wrong with using guns for earlobes.

And yeah, saying 'mumsnet has a bee in their bonnet about this' DOES make sense. No idea what @GhostCurry is on about, saying you clearly don't know what 'bee in your bonnet' means! I think ghostcurry is the one who doesn't know the meaning! Confused

Shame the OP hadn't enable voting on here. Would have been a close call I bet, as quite a number of posters disagree with her.

Also, I agree with the attitude towards tattoo parlours. As a pp said, they are not sex dungeons! The people there are lovely, talented people!