Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think piercing a child's ears with a gun should be banned?

138 replies

lovesthosebeeps · 12/08/2021 11:39

Okay, people must insist it's done because xyz

Mine was done with a needle as a tiny baby. However, it appears most tattoo places that do piercings won't touch a baby/small child.

But I've always known guns are worse. A tattoo/piercing artist I know personally just posted this image on FB

She says the gun isn't a clean go, and can cause damage to surrounding tissue etc.

AIBU to wonder why this is still allowed, with a gun, because it can cause so many issues later on?

Obviously it would be best if people didn't bother getting small children done at all but at least abolish bloody guns?!

To think piercing a child's ears with a gun should be banned?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheGonnagle · 18/08/2021 19:59

Dd had hers done yesterday (she’s 11) at the local tattoo shop. Implant grade titanium and flat backed (no butterfly) stems with internal threaded fronts were my reasoning. And the studs are slightly longer to allow for any swelling which reduces the chance of the ear swallowing the back of the piercing. A strong focus on hygiene and aftercare made me very happy with my choice, he also took the time to have a proper chat with dd about what he would do and talked to her all the way through the procedure. She’s chuffed to bits with them.

kernow3043 · 18/08/2021 19:42

Everyone I know has had their ears done with a gun and never had issues (me included). But I would probably go to a place which uses needles if I ever had anymore done - had my lobes down twice at around aged 7 and 10.

I think piercings should be banned in babies and small children until they can make their own decision (say 5+)

My daughter is 6 and just had hers done a month or so ago - most of her friends had it done ages ado. I tried to find somewhere that do it with a needle but couldn't find any for her age. She had it done with a gun but a proper piercing shop that did them from age 5 . Avoided Claire's at all costs. Healing just fine!

Cryalot2 · 13/08/2021 09:06

I am another who hates to see babies with it done.
Would like to see it left to at least 12 or older.
Seems wrong to inflict pain on babies who do not choose this, all for no good reason.
Dd had hers done when she was about 10 ( a relative took her as a birthday present) . They got infected despite the bathing and turning and they were uneven. We had to let them close and later as an adult had them redone at a reputable place and had no bother. I think her first were done with a needle .

Enko · 13/08/2021 08:53

I had mine done age 7 with a gun
It hurt.

I had a 2nd piercing done with a gun age 14.. it hurt

I have had 2 further piercings done as an adult. With needles. Hurt but not as I recall the gun hurting.

The piercings done with the gun I still get regular infections in (I am 50) the 2nd I've let heal up. You can still feel a small bump where it was.

The needle piercings ive never had any infections in what so ever

When my dd wanted their done (age 12 and 14) we went to a piercing studio. Dd1 said it hurt a lot dd2 said it didn't really hurt.

I think the pain is objective to each persons pain threshold.

Personally I would never again pierce with a gun
I've learned the damage and experienced it myself. I agree piercings on young babies however at age 7 I knew I wanted them done and I have never regretted them pierced but I do hate how easily they get infected.

Also the tattoo studio was more private than the places I had a gun done. Tattooist had private rooms the guns were just done on a chair in their shop

pinkyredrose · 12/08/2021 17:10

YABU. The gun is much better. Quicker, cleaner, easier, more direct for piercing ears. Why on earth anyone would choose a needle for it just baffles me

Quicker? Cleaner? More direct?

Lol! Grin

Sceptre86 · 12/08/2021 17:07

I can't get worked up about when or if other people choose to get their kids ears pierced. My dd is 5 and has started asking, I would like to wait until next summer holidays and see if she is still keen. If not we can hold off till she wants them.

Cheeseplantboots · 12/08/2021 17:05

Disagree. When I was a kid we all had our ears pierced with a gun with no issues. I’ve got 3 piercings in each ear. My kids had theirs done at Claires with a gun, no issues at all.

MrsMonkeyBear · 12/08/2021 16:53

My DD age 6 has just has hers done with
needles at a tattoo studio. She barely flinched when it happened. Initially, she was more than willing to wait until she was 12 but when I was recently getting a new piercing, I was informed of the local law on them

"As long as the person who is getting pierced is aware of what is happening and consents to getting it done (along with appropriate parental consent) there is no lower age limit on ear piercing."

So for 2 weeks we watched videos of people getting their ears pierced. We went for a wee visit to the shop to have a look at the equipment that will be used and watched the piercer work on another client (with permission.)

The main reason we chose needle over guns though is the type of jewellery available. "Gun" jewellery is often not long enough to allow for swelling, which in turn can cause the ear to "eat" the butterfly back. We also chose Implant Grade Titanium, which has an extremely low allergy risk, unlike Stainless Steel, Gold Plated Rhodium and 18ct Gold.

sbhydrogen · 12/08/2021 16:43

I used to think guns were bad due to sterilisation issues and tissue damage. I've had a lot of piercings in my life with both a needle and a gun, and I've never had any issues with either. I've had my gunned ears done for about 20 years, and there's no damaged skin as far as I can see. Same for everyone else I know who had a gun piercing 🤷‍♀️

RedMarauder · 12/08/2021 16:41

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss if you banned it there would be loads more young teenagers like me piercing their own ears or piercing their 9+ year old siblings ears. This would cause more problems for the NHS as unlike Claires, jewellers and tattoo parlours a lot of teens wouldn't bother to sterilise their needles and earrings.

NumberTheory · 12/08/2021 16:34

I don’t think we should ban ear piercing guns to appease tattoo artists (and increase their revenue at others’ expense).

The degree of injury from ear guns is nothing like serious enough to take away the consumer choice (and lower prices) that having them provides.

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/08/2021 16:26

I agree. DD had hers done at 10, after we'd had a proper talk about care.

But 10 is a very arbitrary age, isn’t it? It’s not the legal age of majority and it’s not an age generally considered to be valid for Gillick Competence. What it is, is an individual parent’s assessment of whether their child has adequate maturity and understanding of what’s involved with a piercing and how to take care of it. For some parents, that could be as old as 16; or as young as 4.

Hence why there’s no legal lower age for a piercing, and why the law is content for parents to make their own decisions.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 12/08/2021 16:22

One thing about ear piercing is that there's very little risk if the person later decided they didn't want the piercings. The holes are barely visible and even in a worst case scenario, if there was scarring, say, ears are easy to cover with hair.

TurquoiseDragon · 12/08/2021 16:01

@ChampagneWorries

I think piercing children's ears under the age of 10 should be banned full stop
I agree. DD had hers done at 10, after we'd had a proper talk about care.

She's got other piercings now, we both go to a tattoo parlour if we want any more done.

dottydodah · 12/08/2021 15:56

I didnt realise children under 10 were allowed ear piercings like this. Obv not up on these things! DM said I had to wait until I was 17 to get them done!

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 12/08/2021 15:54

@Martianworld

I'd ban all piercings til children are 16. I'd be happy to say 18 but that's hard to justify when it's legal to have a baby.
I’d like it to be banned until 18 but would be happy with 16 too.
paddlingon · 12/08/2021 15:39

I had a gun as an adult.
Dd a needle as a teen.

She had a lot more issues than I did.
Obviously this is just one anecdote but I'm
not that convinced there is a lot of merit to using a needle.

Vitallyli · 12/08/2021 15:36

The benefit of the gun is that you don't need to fiddle with freshly pierced ear, it's done much quicker. I'd let parents decide which one they prefer. I had my ears pierced with a gun and second holes with a needle later. Both were fine.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 12/08/2021 15:35

There's a notice up in Claires that they wont pierce a child who is distressed but many times I've witnessed a crying , resistant child being almost pinned down by the parent .
They always seem to site the chair in the window so we can all have a gawp . Sad

My DD was leaving Yr 6 when she had hers done , so old ennough ( IMO) to choose . She knew about keeoing them clean and aftercare .

She's had gun (lobes) and needle ( tragus , helix, belly)
Tattoo parlour is as far away from Claires as you can imagine !

DD is not a fan of needles (understatement) bu said you only hear a crunch , worse bit i the fiddly fastening of the stud .

PattyPan · 12/08/2021 15:34

I had my ears pierced with a gun at 11 (after begging my mum) and my seconds also with a gun at 15. It barely hurt and I’ve had no problems with the piercings at all - this is the first I’ve heard of it not being a ‘clean go’. Mine were done at a local beauty parlour.
I agree parents shouldn’t get their child’s ears pierced before they are old enough to consent though.

lovesthosebeeps · 12/08/2021 15:32

@sallievp

If it's ok to make a hole in a baby or child's ears without their consent....why stop there!? How about piercing their belly button too and also nose and eyebrow?

I think piercing children's ears under a certain age should be banned, but this type of comment is OTT

Piercing a simple, classic lobe piercing on each ear is completely different to giving them a belly button piercing! Or nose piercing!

Most women I know have a simple ear piercing

OP posts:
ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 12/08/2021 15:18

I had my ears done with a gun when I was 10. I asked for it so my mum agreed.
it was nothing.
I would've run a mile if they'd tried it with a needle.

my DD is 9. she hasn't asked yet so I've not thought about this until now.

Brefugee · 12/08/2021 15:12

Urghh to PP who had a needle piercing but was sure nothing was sterile. Why?

DCs both had needle piercings at out tattoo studio (by the resident piercer) everything completely sterile and very well done.

I've had gun piercings (OK) and a kind of weird needle thing on a stick (can't describe it) done in a cheap grimy jewelery shop on a Saturday morning for 50p.you had to provide your own self-sterilised earring (which they would inspect, many rejected). This was about 1978 and the queues were right down the street.

Have also got some "needle into cork" self piercings. "pain relief" (mitigation) was either snow or Waspeeze. All OK but more due to luck 😁

gogohm · 12/08/2021 15:10

Had mine done at Claire's many moons ago, it was just fine. Dd has recently had her done too (at 18)

iwannabelikeyouhoohoo · 12/08/2021 14:58

I’ve got to say, the photo in your OP seems purposely emotive and I’d be interested in a fact check. It looks like someone who would ban guns has been commissioned to do a sketch and doesn’t look particularly accurate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread